Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout7.1(Attachments #4-11) \L»~, \lD3 ~-) Proposal Components not included in Council Packet Complete proposals available upon request Amador Valley Industries Signed Addenda Bid Bond Form M - Transfer Station Facility Form N - Non-Collusion Declaration Form 0 - Performance Bond - Collection Form P - Performance Bond - Disposal Form Q - Secretary's Certification Staff Resumes (Duplicate) Audited Financials of Affiliated Companies Truck Delivery Guarantee Letter Cart and Vehic1e Brochures Republic Services Signed Addenda Bid Bond Copy of Submittal Fee Check Form M - Transfer Station Facility Form N - Non-Collusion Declaration Form 0 - Performance Bond - Collection Form P - Performance Bond - Disposal Form Q - Secretary's Certification Staff Resumes (Duplicate) Appendix A - Compliance Program Guide Appendix B -2003 Annual Report Appendix C - Labor Union Agreements Appendix F - Cart and Vehicle Brochures Appendix G - Vehic1e Delivery Guarantee Appendix H - Solid Waste Facilities Permit Appendix I - Notices of Violation (Duplicate) Waste Management Inc. Environmental Review Brochure Signed Addenda Bid Bond Labor Union Agreement 2003 Annual Report Form M - Transfer Station Facility Form N - Non-Collusion Declaration Form 0 - Performance Bond - Collection Form P - Performance Bond - Disposal Form Q - Secretary's Certification Permit Review Report Cart and Vehic1e Brochures ATTACHMENT 4 1-- --- -- U) (þ ... ëõ s:: s:: o :¡:; U) (þ :s a (þ CJ s:: (þ ... ~ (þ c::: ~ o ~ ns E E :s (J) ~ ~~lJ I men en ~'IO~ 11"'."0 "II '" " W W _ lJo ~ ~ 1I¡.u",J. Jo 8 _ r-..- SlI.t9IQOJd'ì;;.. lJ!le~ l/eJ9i\O .Q'fA I -----' ...i//eldll.to 111 ~-'U -0111 :> 01 9S(¡0c1;;;:;~ r----.-- - ÆJ..,I.O J. ~ O!ll}q~(¡!ellJo:> ~ ~ (¡~Q ·oJ~81111 [ ------ 1 "'¡I9.ld '1ftA ~ ·lc19Q 9:)1i\J9 - -. ··"bo~ JJoIS Æ ' _ S J.",Oj.,,:> ,;;¡ r---.:' 'IU"O:>IÆ¡¡~ _ ~ ----- .... °19i\IS'. JJel -, "'0c1S9~ '8 ~S Æ¡u"o:>.IO Æ¡,:> ,_~ ~ , I.. rt¡Y'UOIIOI.~ 'I>'II I/ r--. ..... --ø ---- SlI.teJfJ - ... (I 0 oJd loou ._ m 0 Q) Z "':)8 "3111 ..., è z >- _ UO¡I"<iÞ¡I.tOd 10 - I/ rn rn 0 0 !:)J91.l¡1.l¡0:> " = __ è z z r-----.- 0111 "CI ~ _ UO/IOrtl~IÙO - C rn 0 0 ~ I ""'80Jrt u, ·I°rt ' , _ dO"", ':>111 _ " ~ Z Z I _ - ---' ¡~¡I.tOrt Æ¡,U"... _ >- 0 0 0 " ...,lI.tO:) S9 Q) m Q) Q) Q) ~ ·"''''Bo.,rt 'PUO 00 '111\1 _ " >- >- >- ~ - ¡...·PU" Æ¡¡u"",... - iii = ~ = = --- _-0:> "IIJ > >- ~I>- >- _ r-- 'IU..~ ----.:: ~ '_ _ _ _ - ~ UOll:>ol/o:> 0 -... '¡;; mr rn ~ - I !:)9c1S "tflll 0 è è 5. ~ _ ~ SI(¡/f!/c1l1.t ___ " r- _ ' 0:> J·"UO .Irt/l/"", 'r;; C'IIe] ~ ~ ~ _ ....UI"1Uo 0- '" ' :> "·./~¡Y·II '.;¡; <C ::¡ '" ::¡ w _ >- ¡--- ----- Sl.Ioc19ù J - 1- m ·u --" ° Æ¡I/O"b 'J' ~ W '" '" _ O¡IOPU.",,,, J' .= 0 0:)9~ lI.teJ80 __ 0 0 0 Q) ''''OJ80Jd U 'd ".tv 'ill Z Z Z ~ _'- 0/SJ9i\/Q le,:) _ _ ~ _ '-- '''''''8 , '."''''0:> '01 '" '" '" ~ '- oJd UO¡....., ---..:: _ '- ;;; I r-----.- '''''''80Jd Uo ·0 -{/¡"'O""¡I/"" ':>1 ~ '" w '" I r-----.-.-, 1.....¡0 101lU _ _ '" '" t./9__ ~ ---:e;j en en w w - O:>UO""OJJ. _ '" d UO!SJ9i\IQ (f) (f) w (f) . l/eJ9i\O 'tfl - - ,... .EP.menm c _ "roenmen èw - menmm èww ~_ ~ men cmww _ m.EP.enen _ C I-- ~:ß:ß:ß .:.>->->- - m menenw - r-- '- -- - r--- -- L ~ (¡OIl:)!PSIJ"r . I -;:NMV I I I I I ...., - - - - ~ o - (,) J! (I ~ ~ ? ~ ~ - 0 Q) J!üe !!! J! ~ !i .!!! )( w-w c: nI II =r.Wæ 1 J=» m d D \10:) nI 'C Q) E nI :;: C o - c: nI (I nI Q) a: e 'C c: nI Q) ..J c: nI en Q) 1ii s:. c c ::s m 'C Q) ~ Q) .~ ~ c (I c o ~ 'C (I ';:: ::s ""') ATTACHMENT 5 :3 Db1 La -5 Client Reference Comments ATTACHMENT 5 Amador Valley Industries fA VI) References (Note - A VI is a new company and has never orovided Collection Services. The references for A VI are municipalities that are serviced bv collection comoanies owned and operated bv the owners of A VI. Amador Valley Industries - Client Reference #1 Very successful diversion programs - organics and commingled over 50% diversion. AVI provides one annual special pick-up of 2 CY, 1 e- waste and no special events. A VI is very responsive to customer requests. Amador Valley Industries - Client Reference #2 Successful City programs - Implementation good. City uses dual stream collection w/split carts, plus motor oil & filters and batteries. Driver complaints - I've seen worse but AVI could do better. Bulky item pick-up twice per year, no e-waste. No school recycling education programs provided. Hauler does not resolve complaints very quickly. Overall, City is much happier than with last company. Amador Valley Industries - Client Reference #3 A VI is not very proactive - it is up to City to recommend programs. Apartments pay for recycling service. For reporting requjirements, AVI is very open in giving information. Problem with some of the union drivers - their incentive is to finish early - Lot of leave benefits. AVI provides annual neighborhood clean-up. No quarterly newsletter - annual calendar shows recycling schedule. Limited success in business recycling programs. School recycling programs provided through seperate contract. Hauler is fairly responsive to requests from City staff. Customer Service Department - supervisors good but staff spotty. Few complaints regarding delivery of new containers. Overall - Corporate & Management staff are good - drivers are the biggest problem. Amador Valley Industries - Client Reference #4 Some success w/diversion programs - could be more aggressive with strategies by the company. Required reports are marginal - not a lot of details - PGS is thin on admin side - operations are fine. Very few complaints regarding drivers. Bob (Owner) is very hands on - benefit of a small company. Annual e-waste collection well organized. Food Waste participation is 27%-30%. Hauler provides free cardboard & office paper recycling. City had to do a lot of the work on the transition process. U) (1) .... I .......... --- ~ B(¡l ., I ------ ------ 6(¡!le~ IleJ9;10 'tfll I --;;;;;::::~!:!!fS¡';OI¡1 - -----= villi ,~. SUeJJ. Jo fJ __------=--" SlI.t91q Ulle~ /JeJ --- ..!!! m ..!!! m ..!!!c ~ r---:.::'qOJdlSjU¡OI<l'("O' ."0 'OIJ¡ ~ w c ..... :> 01 9S~ .!! .!! ~ J(¡ S9~ ':>1/1 ~ en CI) en c C ··¡I"a J.UIOIUO ----.: ~ '" 1¥ 1¥ 1¥ ~ ~ u';¡¡"q¡.q.¡, ' :> '81J¡ ern" ~ - - ~ ~"'!I"'~ 1¥ "'11¥ '" " '2 -- 1<1.0 O:>I~ ~II\ I J '·"bo~"O - , .S J."'OI'''?;':;:;- '" ::> ['" '" '" '" r---..:"" 's Æ¡u"o - "II 0 :>IÆ¡¡:> 01.., ---...:.: 0 0 0 = = m JJoIS Æ¡u"o - "UOcI..~ '111\ ~ ~ ~ >- >- >- -...:::.::" :> JO Æ¡,:> I.. d ----.:::.: ., ----- - ':. ~Ol.~ 'It.. '" ::¡ '" ::¡ '" ~ - ~ ~ f-~ I ------ ~"'Bo. ,. ------ - "õi ., ., = = = L ------.~ 'd 100y~S 'iiJ¡1 ~ ~ ~ >- >- >::: -- UO¡¡"<i¡~¡I.tOd l.þJ.",,,, ---..:::.::. :¡ = = = ~',j! "-- ~:> '0111 >- >- >- >- _ 4, UO¡IOdlO!l.to ---..:::.: U.. rn rn = ~I~ ~~"'BOJ<I U¡ ·IOdl~ -' dO"" ':>1\} == ~ '2 " >- ~ _ . /ÙO<l Æ¡¡u"",,,, _ .c "õiUi 0 = 0 = ~~SlI.teJfJOJct Sp 0:) S900 08111 :s .:..:..:. >- z >: U"1....Pu ~ Q, _ 0., 0 0 I ----- ~.." " Æ¡¡U"",,,,o~ , CD ~ = m ~ Z Z L ----- --- ~ 1>'1\},., ~ >- >- _ --- ·IU..~ ..::::---- ------..:.::: .... ~ _ - ~ U°i!.~.I/O:> ,.-::----. - ¡",ro; 0 0 .. :; - - :> le!:)9cts "tflll .:. .:. ~ ~ ~ >- ------ SllJ!elctll.to'\ '''''1\1 __ _ ..:.- v..~ JQ 9 ~ - - 0 0 0 0 :J r--- , ¡"'Illn"" " Zo z Z Z _z _ '- ---- ....UI"1U .;;;:-::..!!.I/ _ '" '" I------=:::::::-, 0:> " ·./~¡Y.II 'WI '" ::¡ '" '" W ~ :;,,,.~~ ~ '" ~ '" ~;;; - S(¡O!l~1.l¡0:)9)' ,~b ":/1 m w c "'''''.~ "''''8 0 0 0 = = ~ ~ I ~BOJd <;;;¡;;¡-:. !:Jd ".tv 'ill z z z >- >- 5' !--...- ·ru. ~,··¡O 1·/0..·"''''0 --- '" '" '" '" ~ '" 13 r---.-. '''''''BoJd U _:> 'C11 ~ 0/SJ91\10 r - co m u r-..- SIhe' 'B " ~'I!lI.teJ.h'''''A'' en .!! m m c: _ ' --- -. oJd UO¡ J '".... :>1 c _ ~ ~ ~e~~SJ91\!Q lelllJ9'þ --- ,ft en m m ~ m .s ~ ~ !'.~ '81.. J! 0 m r-----.- ·~UO""O.. 0 13 E - ""9d (¡OlS.< U) m en m ~ J! ~ : "91\!Q II~ < m en W (I 'tí - ..9;10 °tfl m ~ úJ --- Moo:tLt)U)~~1I ~N iíll~ ......!!.OII:)!PSIJnrl I I I I I I ):J m - en "' m(/)mLl¡lmì: m cu s:: s:: o :¡:; U) (1) ::::J a (þ (,) s:: ~ (1) ..... (þ c::: ..... o ~ n:s E E :s (J) "'---- -- --- '? 4 Dl") llo ~ - C Q) E Q) 0) "' c "' :E ~ co ~ l;' C ~ o U ~ o U ~ - c o u 1ñ ~ i o E "0 Q) ë: l;' c ~ o U o C "' Õ en ~ ~ o u "' 1ñ o u ~ ë 0"0 (.)- Q) 'Ö'E Q) .- ~ "' Q) u.. .- (I i:: Q) Q)- - ~ c Co) - ... (I Q) C:J: o . .- l;' tL_ .- ... "00 (I .c .- - ... ~ ~< S-cs \LD:, !) Republic References Republic - Client Reference #1 Republic management staff are generally cooperative, but it can depend upon who you are dealing with. Republic could do a much better job of promoting commercial recycling programs. Republic - Client Reference #2 Residential diversion programs have been very successful. Commercial waste diversion program has room to improve. Quartely & Annual reports are typically on time. Very few complaints against the drivers. Bulky Waste Program run very well, organized, clean, etc. 2xJyear bulk waste collection. Customer Service Department had problems during transition, but is doing better now. Container delivery went smoother than expected. Republic-Client Reference #3 Republic needs to do a better job of promoting recycling to small businesses. Annual clean-up program run very well. There have been some very difficult discussions with Republic management. Be very careful in negotiating contract language. Republic - Client Reference #4 67% Diversion - City very pleased - Primarily due to green waste program. Very demanding population, with backyard service. Republic drivers have been great. Republic administers E-waste dropoff program - Very well run and popular. Very good relationship between City staff and Republic. Very cooperative There were some problems during transition, but going very well now. Overall service is very good. Republic· Client Reference #5 Republic has tried hard to be involved in the community. Public education programs have been very poor. CSR's are knowledgable, but have been unpolite with residents. Republic· Client Reference #6 New Base Year for 2002 - 42% diversion. Public Education programs are not run well, could be much better. Interaction with Republic staff and drivers is good, however Republic management are more difficult. - t/) (þ ~ ëã s:: s:: o :¡:; t/) (þ :s a CI) CJ s:: CI) ... CI) 'to- CI) c::: 'to- o ~ ns E E :s (J) Î Î -I I ~ BUllo~ 1, J '" '" '" "' '- ~ --- .:." 1/0J··o '1r¡£I '" '" w _ - - ---~- - 1¡Ou",J. Jo BUIIO ~ _ _ '- rn SlI.t9IQOJ..vs . ~ /JeJ9,,0 "alA m ~ m (J) m c _ - ~, 1U101d",0 - "- rn ' ~ :> 01 .0UOrto.~ 7;:;-' '" ~ "'_ m_ ~ ~t _ '--- ÆJ -- v£l _ rn rn ~ ··¡/·O J.U¡OIUO:> ' '" ~ '" '" "" _ UO/lllqµ¡SlO ' 8£1 ~ -= _ _ rn rn T r------. ~ , °JUI ·"'¡I9.ld 'ÞÌ1 '" ~ '" '" " ": = r---. d _ __ ~ '- _ '- ...... 1~~ __",,,,~,,, '.IIb.~ ~ . , S J·"'OIOll:> ':>;; '" '" w w _ r--. JJoIS Æ¡UIIO:>I.fI/:> 01 "'---' _ 0 0 0 0 = 9,,/S(¡0c1s9ù , >-:ß >-Q) .;? .;? .;? >- >- JJoIS Æ¡Ullo __" 111\ _ '-- ~ :> JO Æ¡¡:>~ d¡YOUO¡IOI.~ ~ '" '" '" '" '" '" = - ..... -~---I--ëñ slI.t __ I- 01 (I Q) OJB""d looy~s 'iiJ¡1 ë ~ ~ ~ ~.Ë~_,- 1______. UOII"<iI~11.t _ III __ 0 0 0 0 œ ---- " " ed le/:JJ9l1.tll.to"lo " Eo Q) >-Q) .;? .;? >- v 0111 z >- ---1--1- - ~ UOIIOdl _ 1II"i; 0 0 = 0 = "''''Bo.l</ U/.IOrt -- '~¡ÙOd 0"" ':>111 èj ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ '- 1"'------- 1~II.t.rt Æ¡¡UII"".. __ C'II"i;.. 0 = ~ œ -- -O~O.o, C œ œ~>->->- _ O"''''Bo.,rt 0 111\1 C'II >- >- _ _ 0 - OPU"1oJ.PUII Æ - "'" Ui 0 = = ~ œ '-- I/UII"'",o:>,~ '"" œ ~ >- >- >- ---- vitI ~ __ __ OIU··ii ~ III 0 0 UOII~I/o:> I.¡~.rt --- ûi ....1. = ':¡ ~ ~ -- 8 °tflll ns ~ >- >- >- SI(¡lelc1l1.t - == _ lñ 0 0 ' 0:> J·""o .'dl - ros "f 0 œ Z Z ~ , · ,1111" '0.. œ >- z >- ....UI"1U "" ~ ~ _"- '" '--- , ~ "O./~¡Y·II 'tfìi '" '" ::¡ '" '" w + - - '- -- I Sl.I0c19~ _ I- - m m m Jo .(lllel1b 0::/1 æ en m w _ ~UO/IOPU·",,,,o~.~ ~ 0-1 0 (I 0 0 ~ " "''''80 0 0 œ Z Z ~. o"'OJBo, 'd "·tv ?II z z z >- _ 0 l-----..::.::.:.eJB d UO¡OJ··¡O I·ÞJ.",,,, _ _ '" ~ '" '" ~ _ Ü O"''''BoJ 0:> 'C11 ~ "I .¡¡: ì--..- · d UO¡...·.IO -{II",O ---.::: rn ~ '" "'I'" ~ ï:i '-- o"''''B"" ' '¡-¡IIII" ':>1 '" " _ _~. '" d UO¡....., _ - '" ü ~ ~ ,0 10¡IU·p¡0.~ '81 '" '" '" '" '" _ J! 0 œ - (l t)E r-----.- .~uo""oJJ _ '" '" '" .¡¡: ~ ·d UO¡...··¡'!¿t"'..o 1ft '" '" (J '" '- _ ~ ï:i W ~ ;=N........... T.''I1::¡ (¡O!l:)IPSMnq I I I I I I I U::J m - I "--- ----- r--- L - D'~. \\.Q:> l.U r \ ',_~ .....1 ¡:. c3 c o '2 ::J e o E ... Q) > ::¡ 1i e o LI. ~ j ,5 :is :3 C 't' r::: cu :;: C'CI o 'E C'CI ~ ::E: .. 't' J Q) .~ Q) ~ (I r::: o tj :a (I '¡: :3 ., Waste ManaQement References Waste Management - Client Reference #1 The recycling coordinator has done a good job, and made an effort in the community. Commercial recycling programs could be better. Food waste program off to slow start. There have been a few minor incidents between property owners and drivers. Very successful HHW, bulky waste and xmas tree programs. School programs OK, but could be better. Relationship between WMI and City Staff is good, but it used to be better. Current management can be very hard-line with Contract language. There have been some problems with CSR's giving wrong information to residents. Waste Management - Client Reference #2 WMI complies with contract - nothing more, nothing less. Special collection events (hhw, e-waste) run very well. Waste Management - Client Reference #3 Commercial and multi-family programs not going well. Very low participation. WMI reports are good quality but often late to City. WMI management has been prompt in responding to problems. WMI are good corporate citizens. Negotiations of Franchise Agreement were difficult. CSR's very helpful and polite. Waste Management· Client Reference #4 New regional manager is great - very responsive and easy to work with. Problems are always addressed immediately. WMI very good at following contract requirements. Managers are very honest with City staff - high degree of trust. Waste Management· Client Reference #5 WMI is responsive to staff, unless increased costs are involved - very tough negotiators. Customer Service department needs much improvement. Waste Management - Client Reference #6 WMI told businesses they had exclusive right to recyclables - not true. Negotiations with WMI for new programs is very tough. School recycling programs could be much better. l I5?') \ LD ~ £2, Db ) If);';;';;) Year 1 Cost Comparison of Recommended Agreement Scenarios ATTACHMENT 6 Franchise Notes Collection Disposal (1) Carts Fee (2) Total )ptlon 1: Republic Collection and WMI Disposal (Altamont) 3 $ 4,017,773 $ 760,375 $ 192,000 $ 942,604 $ 5,912,752 Option 2: AVI Collection and Republic Disposal (Vasco) 4 $ 5,681,747 $ 952,185 $ 193,654 $ 942,604 $ 7,770,190 Option 3: WMI Collection and WMI Disposal (Altamont) 5 $ 5,677,141 $ 897,518 $ 285,501 $ 942,604 $ 7,802,764 (1) Please note that the proposers were required to submit Contract Year 1 tonnage amounts. The Disposal costs represent the product of the Year 1 tonnage and the proposed tip-fee. (2) The Franchise Fee represents the amount estimated to be collected in Fiscal Year 2004-2005 , and is used in this analysis for purposes of comparison. (3) Republic proposed a 4.02% increase in the Collection Compensation if the Vasco Road Landfill is not used for disposal. Year 1 Collection Compensation = ($3,862,500) .. (1.0402) = $4,017,773. Year 1 Disposal Compensation = (27,650 tons) .. ($27.50Iton) = $760,375. (4) A VI submitted a proposal for collection services only. Year 1 Disposal Compenation = (31,107 tons) .. ($30.61Iton) = $952,185. (5) WMI did not offer a "multi~service" discount. Year 1 Disposal Compensation = (32,637 tons) .. ($27.50Iton) = $897,518. 1 ATTACHMENT 6 c¡ r)j \ lD :.:> Year 1 Cost Comparison of Non..Recommeded Agreement Scenarios Franchise Notes Collection Disposal (1) Carts Fee (2) Total Option 4: Republic Collection and Republic Disposal (Vasco) 6 $ 3,862,500 $ 827,288 $ 192,000 $ 942,604 $ 5,824,392 Option 5: AVI Collection and WMI Disposal (Altamont) 7 $ 5,902,199 $ 855,443 $ 193,654 $ 942,604 $ 7,893,900 Jption 6: WMI Collection and Republic Disposal (Vasco) 8 $ 5,677,141 $ 999,019 $ 285,501 $ 942,604 $ 7,904,265 (1) Please note that the proposers were required to submit Contract Year 1 tonnage amounts. The Disposal costs represent the product of the Year 1 tonnage and the proposed tip-fee. (2) The Franchise Fee represents the amount estimated to be collected in Fiscal Year 2005-2006 , and is used in this analysis for purposes of comparison. (6) Republic offered a 4% "multi-service" discount on the landfill tip-fee if awarded both Contracts. Year 1 Disposal Compensation = (27,650 ton) * ($29.92/ton) = $827,288. (7) A VI proposed a 3.88% increase in the Collection Compensation if the City elects to use the Altamont Landfill for disposal. Year 1 Collection Compensation = ($5,681,747) ." (1.0388) = $5,902,199. Year 1 Disposal Compensation = (31,107 tons) ." ($27.50Iton) = $855,443. (8) WMI did not propose an increase in the Collection Compensation if the Altamont Landfill is not used for disposal. Year 1 Disposal Compensation = (32,637 tons) * ($30. 611ton) = $999,019. 2 ATTACHMENT 6 \ 0 ()-..: \ \..0 ~ n.'.''/ ..... I- Z w :E ::z: u < I- ~ ; *~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ð ~ ~ 0 0 ,...... ~ ~ '1""'"...... "I""" .- ~ ~ ~ .- "'''' 0 0 It)I.{)LOI.OLOtn "''''''' '" '" Q) '# '7 '7 g¡1f) - Q) 0 c: ~O '-' N 111 E~ - E 'Co <O~ Õ 0 <0 N<O <0'<1"0 ¡;; g~ 0 <0 Q)O ... If) 0 <0 "I""'"M-.::tVWa) M (I) 111 "' N ..ria; :t , e. N",r.ocricriN ~gj:ß en 0 C) 0 ... N"""tD~CO~ (I) M ctI a. "",""'N M 0 c: d. ctI ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... :E 'C'" M<O N'<I" <0<0 <00 000 0 '" 111 Q) 0 M~ <ON<OO'<l"M NM'<I" M ~ :g ~ LOa:) , . ~~m~~; ~;;;¡8 N ,.... - (I .... N ~ (I) a. If) "I""'""I""""'I;f'"C\l1.n M"'... ctI 00 ... ~ ~o D..N ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... Q) ~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ g¡~ 00 0 0 000000 000 0 0 '# If) '" 0 0 If) "'''' "''''''' "''''''' '" '" Eo '7 '7 '-'N .E~ 'Co ~<O Õ Õ :g~~g~:;:j ¡;; g~ 0 M Q)~ ,.... M 0 <0 (I) '" :g ~ ..ria; :t , e. "':~.nu)......:o ¡;;äi~ ..; 0 ~ a.Q) ... ~...s-(Q~co~ (I) M 2 ð ,....,....N M D.. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... 'C1f) <OM ~C1i¡ß~(!i ~ 000 0 M Q) 0 No "1M '<I" (I) to! :g ~ tria) :ß~gjgu;~ &i¡8;i cD a; a.~ ~N ... 00 ~""''<I"N'" M"'''' '"': ~o ,.... D.."I ... ... ... ... ",,"EA-WWWM- ... ... ... ... ... ¡ ~~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~ ~~~ ~ ~ ~ '<1"'<1" 0 0 ;!::!:;!:~:!:! '<1"'<1"'<1" '<I" ~ ~ ~ 0 0 ,....,.... ,.... ,.... .. "$. '7 '7 "'If) .. 0 ~O '-' N ¡;:~ - - .2 -0 N"'" 0 0 co <0'<1" (I) "I'" 000 0 0 'Co '<1"'" 0 <0 0"1""'" NO) M:'I""" <0(1)"1 '" '" .. N ~N :t , e. cPNcri¡"':",ro .o",r..; a; a:i :c "' 0 .... "I""" "I"""('t)",tn M"'''' 0 :::I a. ,.... c.. e ~ D.. ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... '" '<1"<0"1"'<0'" 000 ~ 0 'C'" ~to! ~C!CJ.l~"",,:(t! <0'<1""1 "I Q) 0 ::N (I) (I) <0 0> CO CO """:wtO &i a; ",0 '<1"(1)'<1"0(1)0 (1)'<1"(1) <0 &.~ "I"""('t)....'V "1'<1"'" co 00 ~ 0 D..N ... ... ... ... .................. ... ... ... ... ... "'''' 0 0 ~~~~~~ 000 0 0 ~~ 0 <0 0"'0 0 ... 'E 0<0 ",r c::i M<oO.-M<O "':~N ..; 0 Q) '<I"<oM......'" <0(1)"1 <0 <0 E 1í .... ... '1""""1'1""'"(1') "1M'" ... ;;¡" CJ ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... ... en o æ < Z W U en I- Z W :E..... WI- WZ a:::W C):E <::z: u.~ 01- ZI- 0< en æ < a.. :E o u w ~ "õ * <0 0> ~ ¡: '" ..Q e ",ãi g. .! C) 10.." to - '" a::: ~ .~ ~ -_0<1> :c:æ..¡gg>E 1:~¡ii;~ ~~:2~i3 '8 :ß-- ma:::OCæ,¡g ~E.§!~ 'CEmE'- ;¡; ï: (') ~ ~ &1~ìb i:: .. CJ C> .5 U ~= <II ¡: ~ g ~ 8- ~ ¡: äi ~ :!? ¡ (')a. <; ¡: ,g :¡; 'C « ..... ï: ::J ¡ ð 0> .5 U >. o Q) OC ~ 'Ë ~ 3 ::¡; "õ * .... r-. ~ '" :ß ~ 1í e a::: .:g ~ ¡;; <I> - "" 0 E ~~iiii~-ª'~ ~-..----;;-;:ß~a , Ë Q) Q) <II E E <I> - - EEE.-""j¡;·~ .!~~~+:i"""'N~E ~""''''''''I''''"N''I'''''" I -! (þ Q) , , , , , '" Q, E E"O"O"O"O"O"OEE E m ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 0>->->->->->-1'/)<.) U.-N MM '<I" '<I" ~ ~ .s .! <.) <.) ~ ~ ~ 8 8 5i 8 g <'> ¡ - c: g OC ~ 2 '" ~ '" ° In ~.ª £~~ ~ '0% 'õ.ê-~ D.. £,-,ij ~<.)== .! ~2ü~~~ OJ <II <II '" to '" « " :3 ~ '" :3 I'/) E"!J CI) ¡ :"oog:¡¡~üo:¡¡~3 n...J...J...J"'1I1 "'OJ'" ~"E"E"E ~~"E ~~=;, o-:'-:'-:'~CI-:'a::CI-g c~~~ ~ ~ ~ to; = '" rJJ <:> =- =eoo 01:1. "~ ... ~ a. ,- Z c.s :is r~" ~=- 8 e-~ o¡:t:= U5U ~~-< c.s=~ ¡::z::~~ QJ '¡: -< ~~ ~~ a. <:> c.su Co:) ~ Q Q N IJ"> <1)0 ",0 03N bg ..s~ <fi? ~ ;;. o <fi?'$. ~o "",-i ...... .--... E ~ B ::I '" U~ IJ"> IJ"> .--... 1,0 000 Vt Vt "2 b/j '$. '$. ~>,.......,....... g.< 00 .... S <:';I Q., 0 <fi?~ "0 U t- 1,0 <1) ..... IJ"> ~ ~ .s :ë ......: g.:ëŠ,.--...N Q'::o~VtVt 00 "'" o~ d)....¿~ b/j......N 03 ~ ';:VtVt ¡::= ~ê:S~ ~Nr--: § U) Vt Vt § g §~ '" 03 <1) ¡S::;Vt "'" .--... ~"""""t,(") o--i 5......N ;;. ~VtVt .s :g Q ~ o ~ IJ"> - Jg <II 7ä "" V'> 0 ...... ..... N "'" CoB ë;ë; .;:: .;:: ..... 0:: 0:: ..S ~ v ....~~ "'=i~~~ B:5!o::o:: ¡::= '" '" '" æ~u~ g o N ¡:::: C'! o ..... <fi? 1,0 0'1 §" u * 03 ~ 5 ~ .§ 0; ...: bJj~ i t >'0.. ~ '" ~ §' ~ 6 ." 03 Q:;.£ ::I u ~~ u ..... ·6. ~~ ~ u <1)_ <1) 03 ~ 'õ '-' <1) § ~ u...... ~-g 03 03 ~ bJj§ u .§ bJj .5 ~õ .A ~ ...... e .g~ ::I '¡¡; õ.J::J ,S ~ ;,; u ~~.§ Z .$:! 0; '" bJj '" ' IÏI;:;!; >. ::;;¡ <1) <1) ;:::: ¡,; <1) .¡:: o l U ~ <1) p... § U) >. IÏI "'d e <1) ;;. o U ¡:: <1) S B '" ::I U .5 :g Q <fi? ~ ...... = Q,I .S "I:I:æ¡ -5 :: =Q ¡g- u <1) ~ ~ = <1) ~ .§ 0; b/j .,J. 1,0 >. ~ <1) ;:::: . ;..::~ §'>. , ... ~ <1) u 0.. .~ en >.0.. ::;;¡ 7 ~ § ~..2 '-'u §'; u 'f ~§ ]"'" a"'d b/j§ = ,. :@ § 03 U bJjbJj aA .5 t') - '" ~ ~ u :;:I e g~ .- .- <1) '" ......-e ~ :;:I u u 'm § c:¡= ~ t.¢ 01,0 Ë5 Q,I <1) ... <1) ~;:::: ~ § ~ U >. .J::J "0 .S:! p.. §' '" § u <1) ~ 5 ~ ::: .9 0; bJj -.c 0'1 >. ::;;¡ <1) <1) ;:::: ~ ~aJ §'>. 1; R 15.. '" >.§' ~ § <1) <1) ¿õ =0; B .~ ~~ "'...... ~"O bJj§ = . .9 § 0; u bJjb/j , = IJ"> '.... ......õ ~ ~ -g e ü~ .S "Ú; ~-e .... G .~ s:: ~..9 ~o; = b/j o.,J. 51,0 ~ >. =~ = <1) J':!a: IJ"> o <1)0 ~C'! e"'" uO .5~ '$. ~ > o '$.<fi?<fi?<fi?'$.<fi? 000000 -i-i-i-i-i"", .--... .-. - I,ONoooo"",O ..... "<!:O'I......"''''!IJ"> ¡:¡ .........00 ......00 t:<1)"<t00......t-t-'" cqVtVt-N-...... 80::; VtVtVtVt "2 bJj<fi?<fi?<fi?<fi?'$.<fi? ~>1,00'It--0'I0t"! 0..< Nor--: N"';- SE~~~~~~ Q., 0 <fi?~ N t- ~""! 00 0'1 ""'0 .-. ...... Vt Vt 1,0 IJ"> 1,0 0000 0'10 - "<t Vt Vt 0'10'11,01,01,0 "<1:"<1:1"-: 00 ......"'--ioô "",001,0- ......N"<tN'" N '" v ...... b/jt-- þ~ ..... v U>VtVtVtVtVtVt ......< § FOOOOOO ¡¡¡IJ">IJ">OO~O ~.........oo.;OÔ"",N t--......oot--......I,O ~Vt~~~~~ :::O'IIJ"> BI,ON §~g; '" ..... 03 <1) ¡:¡::; ~~g~ OONoo t- 0 IJ"> IJ"> N '" ...... 1,0 VtVtVtVtVtVt<fi? ..... t-- \ \ VO \~-;;¡~ <fi?'<f('$.'$. ooo~ -i-i-i"<t ......--... ...... 0000 ~,,"!O~ N...... I,OO'INOO N ...... IJ"> t-- Vt Vt Vt EFt '<f('<f('$.'$. ~~~t-- --'I..............,¡M . , I 1""""'1 , 0000 I,O"<I:~'" r--:I,OIJ">N 0'1 "'" 0'1 0'1 N "'" IJ"> 00 Vt Vt Vt EFt IJ">......01,O "'",!-t-- N.......,.;-i 0"'0...... t') .". 1,0 0. EFt Vt Vt Vt 0000 0000 0000 o IJ">O 0 ...... "'" 1,0 '" Vt Vt Vt EFt 1,0 0'1 ..... "<I: 0'1 ......0...0 '" ...... 0 ...... IJ"> t- Vt EFt t- ...... o 1,0 0" ..... EFtEFt'$. "'" 00 '" <1) ~ Ü >. u e ... <.8 ~ = ..§ = o u ~ "2 .~ ~ ~ 0.. '" . 5 :ë '" '" v", 8.-::::: 5.""'0'1 "'o..o15v g7~Q~VtVt .. ã 0:.£ ::I U ~ <1) .~ ~ o...J::J ~~ ~ u <1)_ ~ .52 '-'&¡ §~ S-8 o ¡¡ u <1) >.>' .J::J ~ "2 0. :..= 0.. 8:;7 :;:I~ '" ..... ,-. 0.. ~B 03 '" ~ ; bJj' + 5 <1) gp5b ;..= ~ ~~ &¡ v .... ...... '-' ã §" u u = B :§ ~ gb~ ¿,-g "'<.8 .g] ~ ~ .S B ~~ ~ bJj u .~ § c:¡,; =! ,£1,0 = >. ¡::g ~ <1) <1J <1) ¡¡:;;:::: <1) ""''''''.N ¡,; 0000 ¡,; ¡:, N""'......<1) N"'ì""'''' <1) or--:", ...0 .¡:: -i - 00 ,...; .¡:: 5 ~~~ 6}¡ :q~~::!: 6}¡ 3VtVtVtVtEFtVtð VtVtVt~ð <1) <1) ~ ~ ~ ~ <1) v p.. p.. § § U'J U'J >. >. IÏI c:¡ "0 "0 <1) <1) ~ ~ > > o 0 ~u U ';':~~~~!t "Ot ......~......----"'S t1s ........-...C/'Jd)IU.9: tl:SO gS<1)<1)ES<1)SS", ~~~o..t; _ ... ~ ......:;:1 0 0 0 E :;:I ~ '.p '.p '.p '.p .. N U .3 0 0 0 u '~ N , ",;É ~~"O:;:;~;Ê 5"O"O"O"'d"'O"O.J::J=aaaa,J::¡ eaaaaaaoo>->->->-8 0;::";::">->-;::";::" 0 ""0000 0 U......N............""'''''';¡¡::.QN......'''''......;¡¡::. 1,0 N 00 ......t--O N-ir--: IJ"> 0 '" ..... ..... co I- Z ill ::E I Ü ~ ~ ...; ~ :: ti' ~ ~ ... .. is .. 'to ~ ~ ~ .; z: ::! t:¡ .. ~ ~ ~ '" '" '= ~ 'E ~ ~ ~ .. .s 11 '''1 ~ § .~ ~ ~ .. '" } '= § ',c '= Ë .g, .5 .. is 'to ti' :: i'! '" '= .. is ~ ::! '" '" '= ~ .; '= ¡¡; ~ .. ... '" '" .z: ~ .. ~ L>¡ Republic (Local 315)(1) Hourly Wages Side Load Driver FEL Driver Helper Recycle Driver Vacation Comparison of Employee Benefits ATTACHMENT 9 Waste Management (Local 70) (2) Hourly Wages 7/1/2004 Automated Vehicle Driver $ 25.54 FEL Driver $ 23.55 Helper $ 20.41 Recycle Driver $ 20.41 $ $ $ $ 3/1/2005 22.88 22.92 22.69 19.81 Years of Service 1 Yr 2Yr 5 Yr 10 Yr 15 Yr Holidays Solid Waste Recycle Drivers Sick Days Solid Waste Recycle Drivers Medical Ins (Hosp, Dental, Vision Drugs) Equipment Solid Waste 1 set of Rain Gear 12 pairs of gloves Uniforms Steel Toed Boots Pension Contribution (Monthly) Solid Waste Full time (160 hrs/ Mo) Recycle Drivers Medical Continuation Coverage Solid Waste Full time (160 hrs/ Mo) Recycle Drivers PEER Program Solid Waste Full time (160 hrs/ Mo) Recycle Drivers Weeks 1 2 3 4 5 Days 12 10 Days 10 12 1/1/2005 $ 952.00 Paid Yes Yes Yes Yes 3/1/2005 $ 807.91 $ 155.00 3/1/2005 $ 208.00 $ 208.00 3/1/2005 $ 48.44 $ 10.38 (1) Information provided by Republic Services Vacation 11- D(:) \ \..c.-:;> Weeks 2 2 3 4 4 Days 11 11 Days Pre 7/1/89 Hire Post 7/1/89 Hire 12 9 12 9 7/1/2004 $ 1,072.00 Years of Service 1 Yr 2 Yr 5 Yr 10 Yr 15 Yr Holidays Solid Waste Recycle Drivers Sick Days Solid Waste Recycle Drivers Medical Ins (Hasp, Dental,Vision Drugs) Equipment Solid Waste 1 set of Rain Gear 12 pairs of gloves Uniforms Steel Toed Boots Allowance $ 35.00 $ 72.00 $ 325.00 $ 125.00 Pension Contributiøn (Monthl Solid Waste Full time (160 hrs/ Mo) $ Recycle Drivers $ SABERContrit>ution (Monthly Solid Waste Full time (160 hrs/ Mo) $ Recycle Drivers $ 3/1/2005 1,081.01 1,081.01 3/1/2005 112.65 112.65 (2) Information provided by Waste Management ATTACHMENT 9 c: ¡;. 00 ëU"1::JL() o ~...- ~ :I ~ UJ !:: u.. w z w Œl9 We::: WO >0 0- ...Jm D..~ ::¡¡:z WW u..:!: 05 z« gs It: « D.. :!: o o co 1.0 r- (:) T""" NOO"lO«) ...-«)('. «)o y,:C'"i1li6oic6 ÕNoooo('. ...- u«)'<I" "'-0. {It {It {It {It Y> Q:¡'<I"(I)"'-N~ .c E :J Z N '<I" 1'-0 00 00 0"1 LO 1'-00NID (ij666"¡ ÕooCOCO(l) I- {It Y> {It (It 0000 0).... LO LO LO LO ..c(l)(I)(I)(I) Õ {It Y> Y> {It (1)0«)1'- '<I" LO('. I'- I'- I'- I'- «) ÑÑÑÑ Y> Y> Y> Y> >- (II :2 C('. IN ~ (i) 1'-'<1"«)1'- N«)O"Ioo 000"1'<1" "¡"¡riri ffl {It {It (It '<I"'<t'<t'<t NNNN '<1". '<1"_ '<1". '<1". J:T"""T"""T"""T""" C)~T"""T"""'T"'" Y>fflfflffl ,....~~tl) D::CX)COCON LULOLOLO...- LU a. Y> Y> Y> Y> ,:::1010100 00"10"10"1<0 .- <0 <0 (I) CO 0---- 0;:;0"10"10"1...- 0) a.Y>fflY>Y> 0"1<010('1) 15·~*~~g~ L...)(LO---- ~(IIIO'<I"'<I"'<I"('I) a.l-cri {It Y> (It Y> *1- g'U) >"'0 > 0) CO - Eo (II:JN ~ :z ~« O'<t 10 10 0"11'-0"10 IO<O...-N ,..:,..:,..:.-: '<1"'<1""<1""<1" {h Y> {h Y> 10 g:g~$èõ £:!NNNai ...-N('. N..... C<:¡ Y> Y> Y> Y> .~ :0 :J a. 0) D:: Q:¡ U) .?:: Q; &0 > 1O"tJQ:¡ 0 :s: :g.~ 0) >-...JQQ:¡o "I::: >- :J~...JB-o o ._ LU 0) 0) IU)LL.ID:: «) «)1'-"<1" CO NLOCOI'-(") cn...-I'-IO'<I" y,:rióoic:ñri Õl'-(")I'-IO'<I" u('f)U') 'T"'"'T"'" {It ffl ffl ffl ffl ffl Q:¡"<I"<O.....N~ .c E :J Z ...-cnl'-I'- CO 10 CO CO (ij~~:;-:;- õcnCOl'-1'- I- Y> Y> Y> Y> 1'-1'-1'-1'- 0).... 10 10 10 10 ..c1010101O Õ fflEl'¡-Y>Y> --. <II ~~ 0;:; 0 21J~ 13 § ~~ r::~;t;t ('1)...-<0<0 ririÑÑ {h ffl ffl ffl >- (II "tJo =N ::@oö 32('1) ON i:i5 m~~~ <O('I)('. N "¡"¡riri Y>Y> Y> Y> "<I" '<I" "<I";<t æ~:gæ¡ :E N'Ñ N' Ñ C) ,- .'f""" "Ir""" 'f""'" Y> Y> {h {h D::~~~~ ~~~~~ ë15 Y> {h {h {h 5~~~~ .~ ~ ~~ ~ Q)T"""T""""t""""T""" a. Y>. Y> Y> Y> NCOOO = "';oR "<I"<X)(")(") e ~~ IO_....._«!.«!. >-(1110 "<1""<1"(")«) ~I-cri ffl ffl ffl ffl :ßI- ~U) >"'0 ;>O)CO ...;.. E.o (II:JN :J '" ê~ « ~~f313 .....0\"<1""<1" ria:ïÑÑ 1O'<t'<t'<t ffl {h Y> ffl ~ o N~ .......... 0';::: .... ¡¡ U ¿ - C CÞ i ~ c:n 'C: :! 0 :i ~ C!>(/):E .¡;¡ cþ 0) Q:¡ ::Ic:n> ;> ;=~2~ 0 ~Ëð~~ 6~ujq¡:rl I «LL.ID:: vLt)T"""T""" 1010"<1""<1" U')(")OO NNNN {h {h ffl {h I'- o '<I" iii N ...- -::; \ l.1:' ...) \~Ù)~) .2 :0 :J a. 0) D:: Q:¡ ;> o .I!J ~ c:; 0) aJ oö '" 0) g' :s: ~ ~ (ij ~ ~ £ u >- (II a. ,::: o ~ (II > ;oR o :ß "tJ :J o :s ,::: o ~ "5 o ~ ,::: o ~ (II > ~ :s: --. ,.... .... Q,I c: =-; r:n '" 8 8..Q .~ e ~ '"'¡:¡.,~ [s:z ð~æ Q,I=:u ~6< ~.~ ~ Q,I ; ~ ~c.< ~ § au ø ..,. Q o N I/") o vo ¿@~ ~"<t" vO .s~ ~ t) > o '$ '$ "" "" 00 I/") I/") ..... !3 :: :j ~ UP:: I/") I/") ......~ 000 ...... ...... .... .... -g OJ) '$ '$ r;n>~~ 8..<: gsV;>~ p., 0 '$~ "'0 v '" s:: o ..... p.:i3- o ;::3 > ¡:\::;o<: 1.0 "" C"'!~ I/") 00 ...... N .... .... 00 "<t" o~ O\Ò--'I OJ)......N '" Ii:; ~........ § <::oo¡-.- a~1/") p::s:r--: ã IZJ .... .... i~ '" '" v ¡:¡:;.... "<t" ...... v......1/") !~~ > ;J"""" .S =§ o '#: o "" .¡.; '2'"2 o 0 === cu cu C>C> '^ <::> ...., l- N .J C~ ~3 = E -,"'- .., .., .....~~ ~ == ij áj v:2~~ ;:: ~ ~ ~ æ~u;::: '<1" o o t:! ¡-.- t:! o ...... :::R o 1.0 0'1 § v .s & 5 v to ] i[ ~ ~ >'0. ;;:; '" ~ §' ~ ' .. ã 0:2 ;::3 v ~~ u ..... ..... '" p.-e ..2:;>;::3 ~ v v _ V '" ~ 'û --- v s:: p. '" '" v"" OJ "'0 ~ã ~ .. OJ)ã s:: v ..9 gf "'¡:.= t¡ð~ I/") v "" ~ ~.g "g .¡¡; 'û-e s:: ;::3 ..... u ~ ~ s:: o~B Z .~ 0; '" OJ) j!"''';' .....C::¡I.O = "' >. ~:3;:¡;a ';';;,Q ~ Q,I = ~ ¡:¡::Q;;> ¡,; v .¡: o ~ õ; u v ~ v I IZJ >. c::¡ "'0 V Ii:; > o U '" Ii:; S B '" ;::3 U .S =§ o '$ § v $:! '" '" ~ 5 ~ OJ) s:: ..9 <ã OJ) , '<1" 1.0 >. i ^8 0. OJ ;::3 >. ~ Ii:; v P. .~ r.I) >'9' ~ ã ~..!:! ---v ã~ v '1 ~§ ~'<1" a "'0 OJ)ã = .. ..9 ã <ã v OJ) OJ) if. .S ""- ~ ~ "g ~ 'û v ="'0 ..... ....... '" ~~ v v .~ § c::¡~ G.i ~ 100'<1" 01.0 ë >. ~~ ;;. v ~::;: >; ã S- o U >. ~ "'0 .~ 1: '" ã u v ~ ;¡: ß tí ] <ã OJ) J:, 0\ >. ~ v ::;: j[ ~ Ii:; u 0. ï5, '" >.§' ~ § ~..!:! ---v s::<ã '" ..... u irl ~g. 11"" a "'0 OJ)ã s:: oS g <ã v OJ) OJ) tA .5 .....'û '" >. OJ u "'0 V ;::3 ..... Õ v .S ~ .s-e '" ;::3 ..... v .~ ¡::: ~..9 ~<ã c OJ) 0";' 61.0 ~~ C V ~~ '" OJ ~ 'û >. ~ ..... <oS Ii:; s:: 'a 1: o v v ~ -g 0. ~.S II) '" p.:ë- ~ 9'£8~ s:: s:: .. '" Q;~ ;::3 v ~~ .~ "U; o.~ ..2:;>Sš ~ v ~c; ~ 'û ---v >'Ii}o ã 0 0. s:: 8 .. o a v v >.>' ,Q Ii:; -g p. ;.:::: g. 8;, =~ en .~ .-. c. ~.s '" ~ ~ ~ OJ) r= + v gftí ;..= LOU v ,þ G ~ v v ..... ...... --- ã ii v v r= v ~~ g\¡ ~ ¿,-g 0'1 0 "':e v OJ "gt; _ '" g ~ .... r= ~ ~ u s:: .~ oS c::¡<ã = ~ 0'<1" .....1.0 = >. "';:¡;a ~ OJ ==~ I/") o vo ~t:! ~"<t" uO ..$~ '$ Ii:; > o *,~"$,~"$.'$. "" "" "" "" "" "" 000000 I/") I/") I/") I/") I/") I/") ~ I:: .s ;::3 <'3 UP:: 0000"<t"0 ",,":~I/") 0......""00 "" ¡-.- ¡-.- I/") N...... "" .... .... .... 1.0 N '<1"~ MI.O ""'" 00 .... .... .... -g OJ) ~ '" ;> ...... 8.. <: ,.....; ..88'7 p., 0 '$~ "#'''¿f!.~~;ft. O~~-;OO ~"9" ~~ N'<1"l.OooooN "11.00\ C"'!oo 1/")0""'00......00 1.0 "" 0'1 0 1.0 "" ~---'VN'-f\ ........................ N 0'1 0'1 I/")"<t"""': V""MI/") OJ)¡-.-<;to ~ -N ""~........................ þ û 1.0 1.0 1.0 t-:~: o~~ ""'" N I/") c J~~â ¡-.- "" 00 ã - IZJ 000 ~~o OO,.......N ¡-.- "" 1.0 "" N '<1" .... .... .... ........ .... §~~~2~~ ¡:;."fo.;OONOO 0:j0\00¡-.-01/")1/") ~ ......NI/")""I.O OJ ¡:¡:; ........................~ ...... ¡-.- 1.0 N 00 ~""¡-.-o ON."fr--: 61/")01/") OJ ;> ;J '<1"'<1"N¡'; C"'!'<1"""OJ ¡-.- 0.; \CÎ .¡: NO"" 0 "" N '<1" OJ) ~ ........................u v ~ v I IZJ >. c::¡ '"0 ~ v ;> o ~u ~~~~~~~ ~ -- -- '" 8 ";: '";: ";:: tf) U) CL) 0 ~ ~ ~ v 8 8 t; 8 8 e e ..... ..... ;::3 ',p ''¡::: '.0 '.0 f-; ;:; U N ,s:: ~~~~..o:B aaaaa8 ><><><><><0 N""""'<1"'<1"~ -; 'C 100 Q,I 6"E 6 '" o >< u...... '$~~~ "" "" "" "" 0000 I/") I/") I/") I/") 00 ~"1 1.0 0\ N "" .... .... 00 o~ N"" N 00 I/") ¡-.- .... .... ?J?~'#.'$. 1.01.01.Ot'-: "''''''''''' N N N...... 0000 N""'<1"O'I NOO."f\CÎ 0'1 00 00 ¡-.- "" I/") ¡-.- ...... ...... ................ 1/")""01.0 I/")~"""¡-'- N""I/")."f 01/")0"" ",,-.:r 1.0 o. ...... ................ 0000 0000 0000 01/")00 ""'<1"1.00\ ................ 1.0 0'1 ...... ¡-.- ""':......0'1"" ",,0\CÎ0 I/") "" 0 1.0 "" I/") ¡-.- o. ................~ "'<t 00 OOOO¡'; N",!""':~OJ ."f ...... 00 "" .¡: V) 00 0 '<1" 0 NMI/")...... OJ) . V ...... ..... ................ð v ~ v I IZJ >. c::¡ "'0 ~ OJ ;> o U ] ~ v e '" 0 ~~s-~ g g 0 U ""':¡""':¡Us:: "'0"'0"'0;':::: a a a ~ ><><><0 ~~~'$ v '" o ;3 0"'0 == ..... O:j 0>< 1000 QN \~C}b \{;"3 o T"" I- Z w ::2: I ~ 1= « ~ E t> t¡ ~ !i¡ 15 '" '& "" ~ ~ {: 0: ::¡ .. ::¡ '" r; ~ "2 § <:I ... <,¡ .~ 1;¡. .!:! ] .s :!1 ~ 0: '" .!:/ .. t <,¡ "'=I 0: <:I =: .~ <:I ~ .g, .5 ... 'S 1;¡. t> E ::¡ <,¡ <,¡ <:I ... 15 ~ ~ {: <:I 15 ~ ... '" <:I ~ 1:: ~ ... ~ ~ »'; Q,) '" ... &. '"' <:> ~~ = ë ~ë;::: ..... ~ '"' OJ) E-4 C':S"z c=.;~ e:; o '" Ui::I: Q,):o..U -::< ~;<;:::E-4 Q,)~E-4 ~§< ,.Q ·e '"' ., C':S =- " ë .". <:> =u = N I.(") o ¡tA0 0:I~ ~"<T 00 ,sg '$. !¡:¡ > o '$.'$. ~~ --' I.(") I.(") ~ ~ ~ U~ I.(") I.(") ~ 000 --' --' ~~ "2QJ)'$.'$. "'>t'-O'I 8.. « "f ,....; 2 S I ..... p.., 0 ~~ '"0 II) ~ ,5 0..- 2.g~ p..,O::: ..... IC "'"!--' I.(") 00 N ~~ 00 "<T o~ 11)""O~ QJ)-N ~ <~6"t ã Foot'- BO~ .....Nr- --' ...... § u¡ 6't ~ .§~ §~ ø õ:~ "<T - e.......,¡V') o "f 5 N > ;.:¡&"}~ '2"2 ~ .9 '" ';;j 00 '" 0 M r- N oJ C8 "";ë; '¡;: '¡;: - = = .:! .g .g -= '¡;j '¡;¡ '" ~ ~ '"0== -;; ~ (I;$ ~u~ :::R o IC 0'1 ii o ,2: '" os '" ß ~ QJ) I:: ° ;; ;j .+~ IC !¡:¡ >'0.. ::;;¡ '" ~ §' ~ 6 >:'"" os o:~ ~ 0 ~~ o ._ .~$ ~3 ,.;.: 0 11)- II) os '" 'õ '-' II) § ~ 0..... ~] .2 os ..... ." ß'b§ s:: QJ) .9 s:: "';:.= ~~ I.(") 0 ..... ~ ~~ '"0 ._ ~ '" ü..e ,$ g ~ ~ 1::0 o¡..¡- ~oC; tc... '¡¡; QJ) os I ¡:Q$ >. ::;;¡ II) II) ::: ;,; v '¡:: o ~ 1;j u ª v 1 (/J >. ¡:Q '"0 ~ V > o U '" ..... II) E .8 '" ~ u .5 ;g o ~ :s .... c ~ .S "0:;:; 'S = g:::Q 1;" o ~ '" os '" ß to ã ~ QJ) $ >. ::;;¡ v v ::: ~ ~v ~ >. ~ !¡:¡ o 0.. "à U) >.go ::;;¡ 6 v os ~~ ,-,0 §~ o « v I:: ~o ..J:J"<T a '"0 QJ)§ s:: ." ::ê § os 0 QJ)QJ) ~ .S .....- ~ ~ '"0 0 ~ ~ ü V 0'"0 .~ .¡¡; 1§~ o 0 .¡¡¡ ã ¡:Q- "i f~ QIC E >. .::;;¡ '" v ... v ;:¡::: ~ § e- ° U >. ..J:J ] Q. 0.. ~ '" § o II) ~ ß to .§ <;¡ QJ) ..0 0'1 >. ~ ~ !å "':-:::'0 go>. ~ [ ";:l (J) >.§' ::;;¡' II) § ~~ ,-,0 §] o ~ ~~ 0:1..... ~'"O QJ)§ o " .9 § <;¡ 0 QJ)QJ) I 0 I.(") ,_ Mü '" >. II) 0 -g ~ ü v ,13 ~ ~~ o .~ ;:: ~.9 ~<;¡ c QJ) Q.,r E\C ~ >. g:::::;;¡ = '" ~ v u¡::: '" v ;g ü >. o II) ..... . <8 !¡:¡ s:: ," § o V ~ "2 R- ~ ,13 ~ '" o.-~ ~ §'F!-§ o 6 ~ 0 ~] ~ 0 ~~ .~ "C;; 0...J:J 2:-3 ,.;.: 0 ~<;¡ '" ,- '-'~ >.0. § '" 0.0 E 0 o ii ~~ ..J:J !¡:¡ "2 0.. ;..:::: go 8;, ~,.;.: tn .~ "'"" 0. v v ~~ ~ '" QJ)6 + II) gfto ~.s >.>< ß II) ð--' § i;" o 0 .§~ - os g}¡'" ò~ 0'1 0 ~~ '"0.... .E! ~ g '" .~ ß .... II) e 51 o 0 .¡¡¡ .9 ¡:Q<;¡ =.+ .sIC ;2:- ;~ '" v s::::: I.(") o <1.>0 ~N II)~ tio .EN '$. !¡:¡ > o '$.'$.'$.~~~ ~~~~~~ 1""""'1"""" --'--I........... I.(") I.(") I.(") I.(") I.(") I.(") ~ t:: ~ ~ 0:1 uo:: IC N -.:1:0'1 .......0 "<T 00 ~~ OOOO"<TO M":~~ a-MOO ..... t'- t'- I.(") ,....... N --' ("1"1 ~~~6't "2 QJ) '$. ~ > r--: 0.« 0 F! E "7 ~ 0 '$.~ '$.'$.'$.'$.'$. ~N--'IC"'" "'?-tN<?"f N"<TIC \CI"!OO ""';,.......\0 IC M 0'1 - ...... ICooO O"<T","! ON--' _ IC "<T "<T N I.(") ~~6"t~~~ þ û ICICIC t--:"'"""'oo ~~oô ° IC""" "<TNI.(") N 0'1 0'1 1.(")-.:1:-.:1: v,....;.....I.(") QJ) t'- "<T 0 ~ -N .....<~~~~~~ !~~8 ~f2~g § ...... (/J ° ° 0 o~o oO--'N t'- M IC MN"<T ~~~ ~~~ 00'11.(") ....OICN s::"fa; 0:10'100 ~ - v õ: ~:gg~ oONoO r- ° I.(") <r) NI.(").....IC ~~~~~~'$. - t'- <I.> ;:!;~~~ o r..: a; ..0 .¡:: ~ NO..... 0 ¡:: ..... N "<T QJ) ~ ~ ;':¡~~~~~~u II) 1;j ~ <I.> 1 u¡ >. ¡:Q '"0 ~ > ° u ,.;.:,.;.:,.;.:~,.;.:~'" '" '" '" ;¡> '" ..... !¡:¡ ...... -""'---C'J)....So ...... -............... rJ'} C1) Q) II) v v ~ E E '" ":: E E e ¡:¡ ,- .:; U~ .. ''¡: ''¡: ':; ''¡: E-< N 'E N '" '" ,5 E'"O'"O"d"d'"O'"O::C ea~~aaa8 0>->->->->->-0 U......N.........."<T"<T&: ICNoo ..... t'- 0 ~~~ ...... '$."$.~~ ~~o~ ...... --' I.(") I.(") I.(") I.(") 000 ° ~":o~ ......~N("f) \C 0'1 N 00 NMI.(")r- 6"t6't~~ ~*-*'~ ..... ..... ..... ..... ooo"f ("f) ("I'") (""ì ~ 0000 I"!","!"<T","! "<T - 00 N 0'1 0'1 00 00 t"') '-rì r- 1""""'1 ~6't~~ <r)MOIC ~~......t'- N.....I.(")"f 01.(")0..... ..... "<T \C o. ~~6"tb'7 0000 0000 0000 O<r)oo M"<T\OO'I ~6't~~ IC 0'1 _ r- -.:1:""" 0'1 M .....0..00 1.(").....0\0 MI.(")t'-q, ~~~b'7'$. '<T 00 0000;'; N","!"<T~V ..,¡. ...... 00 ..... .¡:: I.(") 000 "<T ° N ..... I.(") --' QJ) v ...... .... ~~~~ð II) J2 II) 1 u¡ >. ¡:Q '"0 II) !¡:¡ > o U "d ~ ,2: v g § vvvo..t; ~~~E8 ~~~~~~~ 0>->->->-0 Qg~~~'$. )5 C)::> I Lo~ .... .... I- Z W ::2; I Ü « ~ ~ .. ç. 5 ~ ;¡¡ 'is <::0 '"ö;- ~ :¡; z: S ~ § .. ::I <::0 ~ ~ ~ 8 ... '" '" ,:,¡ § '"ö;- ~ ~ ... ~ .§ ~ § '" .~ ~ <::0 ... .". z: '" § .~ '" ë .g, .5 '" 'is '"ö;- ç. :: ~ '" '" os ~ ::I '" '" '" ~ i E 5 '" ... '" ~ 1: ~ '" E