HomeMy WebLinkAbout8.2 Radisson Hotel GP and SP Study
K-"'- Of DOll
6~K4
1Il~I~~\~
19~ ~82
~~~
()I,Iro"Q~~
CITY CLERK
File # D~[z]~{3][Q]
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: April 18, 2006
SUBJECT:
ATTACHMENTS:
RECOMMENDATION: 1
&o/!.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT:
Initiation of a General Plan and West Dublin BART Specific Plan
Amendment Study for the site of the existing Radlsson Hotel located at
6680 RegIOnal Street.
Report Prepared bv Jeff Baker, 4ssociate Planner
1.
Resolution denymg Iml1al1on of a General Plan and West Dublin
BART Specific Plan Amendment Study
ResolutIon approvmg Imtiation of a General Plan and West Dublin
BART Specific Plan I\.mendment Study
Letter from Applicant dated January 31,2006
West Dublin BART Specific Plan Table 5 - MaXimum Economic
Development Potential
West Dublin BART Specific Plan Land Use Plan Map
General Plan Land Use Map
2.
3
4
5
6
5
Receive Staff presentation;
Receive presentation from Applicant;
Receive public comment; and
Adopt Resolution denying the General Plan and West Dubhn BART
Specific Plan Amendment Study request; ill:
Adopt Resolu\lOn approving the General Plan and West Dublin
BART SpecIfic Plan Amendment Study request.
The costs of prepanng the General Plan and Specific Plan
Amendment shall be borne by the affected property owner who has
requested this amendment.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION:
The 5.57-acre project site is located at 6680 Regional Street. This sIte IS located at the northeast comer of
the I-SSO/San Ramon Road interchange. The site has Planned Development Zoning (PD 02-0l4). The
current General Plan Land Use designation is Retail/Office and the current Specific Plan deSIgnation is
Hotel. The 234-room Radisson Hotel IS currently operating at this location.
COPIES TO:
Applicant
Property Owner
Page 1 of 4
ITEM NO. ~ . 2.
Ci:\AgeruJa!i\2U06\cc!ir 4. Ht06 Rll.ui!ison Reust: GPA SPA. dot;
The development of the Radlsson Hotel began under Alameda Counly's Junsdietion in 1972 with
approval of the first site development review The hotel was ongmally approved as a 93-room hotel and
restaurant (Howard Jolmson Motor Lodge). Over time, various Condll1onal Use Permils were approved
to expand the hotel use to what is now in place today, a 234-room hotel, With nleetmg facilil1es and dilllng
space.
Charles Clark, on behalf of Dubhn Continuum, LLC., has submitted a request tu initiate a General Plan
and West Dublin BART Specific Plan Amendment Study for the proJect site. The Applicant proposes to
change the use of the sIte Irom the existing Radisson Hotel to senior housing consisting of independent
hvmg, aSSIsted hvmg, and an Alzhelmer/demenl1a facility, as well as possibly maintaining the existing
COlllmulllty meetmg space and puhlic restaurant (Attachment 3).
West Dublin BART Specific Plan
The West Dublin BART Specific Plan, adopted by the City Council on December II.), 2000, contains a
development program that ontlincs the maximum development potential for the various land uses in the
plan area. The Specific Plan allows lor a maximum of 396 hotel rooms and 541 residential units within
the plan area (Allachment4).
All of the hotel rooms are antIcIpated to he developed on two siles which inclnde 6680 Regional Street
teXIstmg Radisson Hotel), and 6600 Golden Gate Dnve (I\.ttachment5). The City Conneil has approved a
Stage 1 Development Plan for a limited service hotel at 6600 Golden Gate Dnve; however, the Apphcant
still must process a Stage 2 Development Plan and Site Development Review, and obtam Buildmg
Permits in order to eonstmet the facility Table I provides a breakdown of the existing and proposed
hotel rooms in the Speei fie Plan area.
Table I - Hotel Rooms in the West Dublin BART Specific Plan Area
-~---~'.~'" ."."~,,
Exi"ting Ho_tel!~0Illsat._66~() Regiona!S,!reet___ 234 rooms full-serVICe hotel)
Pro nsed Hotel rooms alli600 Golden Gate Dnve 150 rooms limited service hotel)
Total ExistiugJ'Pro osed Hotel Rooms 384 rooms
1I~~!!~Q...,!,~ allo~_e_~~e,r"S,p~!:.ific Pll!n 396 rooms
The SpecIfic Plan also allows for a maximum of 541 residential unIts on two SItes (6600 and 6700 Golden
Gate Drive) (Attaclmlent 5), A Stage I Development Plan has been approved for 210 umts at 6600
Golden Gate Drive. A Stage 2 Development Plan and Site Development Review have been approved for
the development of 304 residential units at 6700 Golden Gate Drive, Table 2 provides information
regarding the development potential of these two sites,
Table 2 - Anticipated Residential Uses in the West Dublin BART Specific Plan Area
Residential Units allowed
Units Pro osed er S ecific Plan Unit Surplus
210 210
304 331
514 541
6600 Golden Gate Drive
6700 Golden Gate Drive
Total
o
27
27
Transient Occupancy Tax
The City of Dublin collects a Trans,,)nt Occupancy Tax (TOT) on all hotel rooms within the City The
TOT equals 8% of the nightly room rate and IS General Fund revenue for the City. The proposed rense of
the Radisson Hotel as senior housing would not be subject to the TOT and would thus ehmlllate a source
of General Fund Revenue for the City
Page 2 of 4
Hotel and Meeting Rooms
The existing Radisson Hotcl currently provides meeting space to Dublin busll1esses and residents. The
Apphcant has lI1dleated that they will "attempt" to mall1tam this meeting space along with the dining
facilities for public use (Attachment 3). As previously stated, the City Council has approved a Slage 1
Devclopment Plan that includes a I 50-room, limited service hotel at 6600 Golden Gate Dnve. As
currently proposed, this limited service hotcl docs not include regional meeting space.
ANALYSIS:
The existing General Plan land use designation for the project site is Retail/Office, which permits a range
of office and retail uses, lIlcluding hotels and ancillary uses such as restaurants and meeting space. The
existing West Dublin BART Specific Plan land use designation IS Lodgmg, which also permJ/s hotels and
ancillary uses (Attachments Sand 6). In order to allow the proposed senior housing and possibly a
restaurant and meeting space on Ihe site, an amendment to the General Plan and West Dublin BART
Specific Plan IS reqLLJred that would contain the following components:
General Plan Amendment to change the land use designation Irom Retail/Office to either High
Density Resldenllal or Mixed Use if the proJect meludes public meeting and dining facilities,
2. Specific Plan Amendment to change the land use designation from Lodgmg to either Resldenl1al or
Mixed Use if the project includes meeting and dining facilities.
City policy requires that the City CounCil approve the 1Illhalion of any General Plan and/or Specific Plan
Amendment Study pnor to Staff accephng a development apphcation that would include a General Plan
and Specific Plan Amendment for a project.
CONCLUSION:
If the City Council authonzes a General Plan and West Duhlin BART Specific Plan Amendment Study
for the property located at 6680 Regional Street, Staff will:
" Examllle the proposed land uses and densihes to detenmne if they are appropriate based on City
policies and standards.
);> Evaluate the impact of eliminating 234 hotel rooms and meeting facilities from the West Dublin
BART Specific Plan area.
" Study the land use plan, clTculahon routes, and the interrelationship and compatibility of the proposed
combination of uses.
" Study the Impact on parkland.
);> Study the fiscal impacts of the proposal, including the loss of the TranSient Occupancy Tax and the
cost of providing City services to the proposed use.
The City Council is only considering the initiation of a General Plan and West Dublin BART SpecIfic
Plan Amendment study at this time, Initiating or not initiating a General Plan Amendment Study IS
totally wltlun the discretion of the City Council. If the City Conncil initiates the General Plan and
Specific Plan Amendment Study, the project will come before the Plannmg CommissIOn and the City
Council for a General Plan and Speclfic Plan Amendment, PD - Planned Development Rezone with Stage
I and Stage 2 Development Plan and other entitlements as needed.
At t11is point, the City Council needs to detennine whether a General Plan and Specific Plan Amendment
Study should be authorized for the Applicant's proposaL Both denial and approval resoluhons have heen
included for City Council consideration (Attachments 1 and 2).
Page 3 of 4
RECOMMENDATION:
Staff n;eolllmends that the Cily Council I} Receive Staff presentation; 2) Receive presentation frolll
Apphcant, 3) Receive pubhc comment; and, 4) Adopt a ResolutHln denying the General Plan and West
Dublin BART Specific Plan Amendment Study (Attachment I); ill:.51 Adopt a Resolution approving the
General Plan and West Dubhn BART Specific Plan Amendment Study (Attaclnnent 2).
Page 4 of 4
\ ub \ 0
RESOLUTION NO. - 06
A RESOLlITION 01<' THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
DENYING THE INITIATION OF A GENERAL PLAN AND WEST DUBLIN BART
SPECIFIC PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY FOR THF PROPERTY LOCATED AT
6680 REGIONAL STREET (APN 941-1500-047)
WHEREAS, Mr Charles Clark, on behalf of Dublin Continuum LLC" has submItted a request to
con sHier a reuse of the existmg Radisson Hotel for senior housing consisting of independent living,
assisted livlIlg, and an alzhelmer/demenlla facilily on the S,S7-aere parcel located at 6680 Regional
Street; and
WHEREAS, the proposal is for different land uses and allowable denslhes than IS penmlled in the
General Plan and Wcst Dublin BART Specific Plan; and
WHEREAS, 1Il order to conSIder the project as proposed by the Applicant, amendments to the
General Plan and West Dubhn BART SpecIfic Plan would be required that contain the following
components:
Change the Gcncral Plan Land Use designation from Retail/Office to either High DenSity
ReSIdentIal or Mixed lTse if the project includes public meeting and dining faCilities;
2. Change the Specific Plan Land Use designatIOn from Lodging to either Residential or Mixed
Use ifthe project lllcludes meetlllg and dllllllg facilities; and
WHEREAS, additional entitlements including a PD Planned Development Rezonc with Stage I
and Stage 2 Dcvelopmcnt Plans, Site Development ReView, and other associated permits would need
to be processed; and
WHEREAS, the IllItiation request has been reviewed in accordance with the provisions of the
Califomla Envll'onmental Quahty I\.cl (CEQA) and was lound to bc Categorically Exempt under
SectIOn 15306, Class 6 of the Stale CEQA Gllldehneslor basic data eollcetion, research, and resource
evaluation aclivities; and
WHEREAS, a staff report was submitted outlining the Issues surrounding the request; and
WHEREAS, the City Council did hear and consider all such reports, recommendatIOns, and
teshmony hereinahove set forth, and supports the initiation of a General Plan and SpeCific Plan
Amendment.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT the City Council of the City of Duhlin does
hereby deny the IIlI11ahon ofa General Plan and West Dublin BART Specific Plan Amendment Study
for property at 6680 Regional Street.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED BY the City Council of the City of Dublin on tillS 4th
day of April 2006, by the following votes:
[,.2 4/1'3/06
ATTACHMENT I
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABST AIN:
Mayor
ATTEST
city Clerk
U:\Agcndas\CC H/;"sos R.;:IdiS50n CPA"PA' " ,
I ..... 1t1ltlatlOn.d()c
;) ac \0
RESOLUTION NO. - 116
3odO
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF TIlE CITV OF DUBLIN
APPROVING THE INITIATION OF A GENERAL PLAN AND WEST DUBLIN BART
SPECl}'IC PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY FOR THE PROPERTY LOCATED AT
6680 REGIONAL STREET (APN 941-1500-047)
WHEREAS, Mr Charles Clark, on behalf of Dublin Continuum LLC., has submitted a request to
consider a reuse of the eXlstlllg Radisson Hotel lor senior housing consisting of independent living,
assisted living, and an alzheimer/dementia faclhty on the 5.57-acre parcel located at 6680 Regional
Street; and
WHEREAS, the proposal is for different land uses and allowable denSIties than is permitted III the
General Plan and West Dublin BART Specific Plan; and
WHEREAS, 111 order to c\lIlslder the project as proposed by the Applicant, amendments to the
General Plan and West Dublin BART Specific Plan would he required that contain the following
components:
I Change the General Plan Land Use deslgJlahon from RetaillOfIiee to either High Density
Residential or Mixed Use If the proJect mcludes public m"eting and dining facilities;
2. Change the Specific Plan Land Use designation frolll Lodgmg 10 either Residcntial or Mixed
Use if the project includes meeting and dining facilities; and
WHEREAS, additional entitlements including a PD Planned Development Rezone with Stage 1
and Stage 2 Developlllenl Plans, Site Devclopment Review, and otller associated penmts would need
to be processed; and
WHEREAS, the initiation request has he-en reviewed in accordance with the provisions of the
California Environmental Quality Act (CEOAl and waS found to be Categorically Exempt under
Section lS306, Class 6 of the State CEOA Guidelines for baSIC data collection, research, and resource
evaluation activities; and
WHEREAS, a staff report was submitted outlining the issues surrounding the request; and
WHEREAS, the City Council did hear and conSIder all such reports, recommendations, and
testimony hereinabove set forth, and supports the IllIhallOn of a General Plan and Specific Plan
Amendment.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT the City Council of the City of Dublin does
hereby approve the initiation of a General Plan and West Duhlin BART Specific Plan Amendment
Study lor property at 6680 Regional Street.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Applicant shall pay for all processing costs involved
With the General Plan and Specific Plan Amendment Study
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED BV the City Council of the- ~ity of Dublin on thIS 4'h
day of April 2006, by the followmg votes:
ATTACHMENT -',
,
..;:_,- -
AYES:
NOES:
^BSENT:
ABSTAIN:
ATTEST
City Clerk
(i:\Agcnda.....\CC RC!im RadiS!iOll <iP<\SP<\ initiation.doc
Mayor
y i=-b \0
::; DblO
31 January 2006
Ms. leri Ram, Community Development Director
City of Dublin - 100 Civic Plaza
Dublin CA 94568
re: Request for Study, Adaptive Reuse of existing Radisson Hotel
for Senior Housing Continuum, 6680 Regional Street
Dear Ms. Ram:
We are hereby requesting a change in use of the Subject Property, from Hotel
to Housing and Care for Senior Citizens. Because of the anticipated new BART
Station to the East of this site, and the increasing elder population, we believe that
this proposal would result in a much more efficient use of the site.
The majority of the buildings would remain in their existing fonn, with a minimal
addition of a Cafe to serve the North Wing, as shown on the enclosed drawings.
This proposal would convert transient housing to more permanent residents, who
would be more involved in City programs. This conversion would require minor
changes to the existing facilities. We would attempt to maintain existing community
meeting spaces and open dining spaces to the public.
We understand that this reuse requires amendments to the General and Specific
Plans, as well as existing Zoning. Please forward this request to the Mayor and
members of the City Council for their review.
d/a-r
Charles Clark
Dublin Continuum, LLC
PO Box 1869
Pleasanton, CA 94566
(925) 846-3442
w~J\~~~hitect
Architectural Arts Unltd.
786 Solana Drive
Lafayette, CA 94549
(925) 284-7333
enc. Master Plan and Rendenng of Cafe Addition
"""''''''\''~nq;.n
FEB 2 1 2006
A'jYACH;ENT 3
.
,
~
i
.
l
,
,
!
5
1
!
i
$lIDOU<ItMT1"3P'Ot1'o<II"CI.ll<-~:
~-
\
\
, -
\ i
PROPOSED STAJlFII~.~, CES II-r---~--- --- -
/' I ~""'~'3~p.
'\/.. I ALZHElMER.DIMENTlA ! rL.- --
. 'I <IS UNITS. fi RESID~ I
L., I I I
84 UNfI'8 I ill; i tESID NTS
,
,
~
..,
..,
'"
..,
..,
\.",
.., "
~"
..,'~::---.:........... '--- ~--~~. I J
~ I
---__ ~(E) OUTBACK RESTAU iT
~-- ~ I
~,-- "
.,.. 1 '
- - ------- --
(E) A,E.BOWLING
! Ii e
PROPOSED NEW CAFE 1 ...
~ - ~ t- ~
r I I -< "
; Dc/I' ~ '\'
'IT, ~ \
, I' - 1
II' ~ \:
..~ \ \ / I
" " /;"-----
NEW LOBBY' I. ~ . 'COVERED~~/'
----c::~ MATCn (E) ;~-~,'-----
: ---~ ! I
I 0 '1
1-'_ --f-- I
! "
\
,--.----
r-
[
-L
I'
I ~
!
,
-
SENIOR INDEPENDENT LIVING
CONDOMINIUMS AND RENTALS
3/i . 40 UNITS
'---.
;
, i
LLJ
L-,
~
EXISTING iE) ADMINISTRATION
I ":o"To~""
f'bIO
1";::.40~
r--
20 0
"
,
"
----.,..,
'-
'---------
;
iEl WILLOWiTREE REST
,L, ~_lJ
" L-j (E) ~/SPA
~,
~~
;
!(E) DINING I KITe
~--
I
eo!
:
"
i I
i.,
PAF'-K\N'" 21'lCA"'$iir-
L..E.iSS -t"'t I
.,."r,.(.. 205CAr<o!
I --
,
r-
,
I
~
I
~
"-.
"
"
,~~
~ ~ .
, ,
MASTER PLAN
APN: 941.1506-047.03
SITE AREA =
EXIST, BLDG.=
NEW BLDG, =
HWY 580
2D2,S5ll SF (US ><re.)
~5.050 SF (3 - fl.rI..) 121, (;.50 S,. TOTAc
3,610 SF (1 . otoryl
.
40
REVISIONS IV
~
3rchi tee tura l
ads
u nlimiled
(9251 2M73S3
wally holmeu
uditect <:!5-114
,.. ooIu. dri."iIl
bCa~ CA '!iI!I5fI1
--"----
nnSMlLn:K.Io\.LMhY
NOT DE COMW QK
DtSST:Mlt.'ATl::I}
wmEOlr.l'mlQ1L
\\'Rrn'E.Nl'I:IUrIlSSt<>>I
Ol'lll!:. AItCnrrt:cr
-.----------.
@ 2DD&
.. :ll
02
U;;l
'il:l.;;lfoo
Q Z~
= ..;==
1~~!;;:
.iz~~~
=~~~O
-S~~ 0 Z
~8~5::
!! O~C&:I
tZ=lIC "'
..::lIl:i5 !:l
~I!:QO'\O
t:::>-",
_",Z
'" OIl
- '"
..,.. I FEB '06
SCMJ:: llli':; .40'
0..... l.J'I~\\
.- u,(po,?
.....
n
OF . ......
,
Do\.T.uo~IH'tCDR. 100ro. :LAADOClNllil,. 1I,O,~~!l.noJ.CA.ef4O.i
I
I
!
i
,
,
,
'-
~
.J
'l
0-
o
~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~~ ~~~ i J~~ ~ <;; ~ ~
~ ~ ;
. adaptive "a_e of e.lstlng Hotel ror ~ "
1" @ ~~I~i~ I ltili Ie i" =.
-' - DUBLIN COl\lTlNUUM, LLC
I [f\~1 ... .. ~
\; '" \ .1\ Sl!:l\IlOR HOUSll\IG CONTINUUM I ~li~1! I l! .. I;;a
'l~, Z!
D '-1 \l' 6688 RIDIONAL STREI!:T ~i
'J\ DUBLIN, CA 945fi8 18:;=;3 ;;: "
" I ~z " ~ !l!
.,. ~... ~ "
~ -
80(JIO
West Dublin BART Specific Plan Table 5. Maximum Economic Development
Potential (as amended per City Council Resolution #183-01, 10/16/01 and City Council
Ordinance #8-04,3/1(104)
SP Land Use C.tegory' Acres FAR Existing Dev Max. Dev.
DUlAC (sa, ft,)"" (sa. ft.)
Commercial A (Com A) 11.20 0.30 146,826 146,826
Commercial B (C-om Bl 26.6Q 1.00 203 174 1 162620
Lodging (Ll Q.31 1.20 103,231 182,731
(246 rooms) (3% rooms)
Retail/Onlee (RIO) 18.40 1.00 38,325 801,500
Residential (Rl 3,54 58 DUlac -- 210 DII
Oflice(O) 6,98 1.00 242,385 304,050
Mixed Use (MU) 11,33 1.00 - 493,430+
331 DU
Parkine (PI 2.46 -- -- --
Rieht-of-Wav 2.11 -- -- --
Totals 91.99 -- 734,481 3,247,956
ODU 541 DU
*/vote. Pntential plazas area.'! included in acreages, land use categories rejer to those shown on Exhihit 9
** Existing 2/0744 Industrial/Warehouse ."quare tontage not induded.
JHTACtlfil1ENT y
0'\
rj~'. '~~0,% +.J
'~:~:~ .0
\Y{f.~~.;'.,:.~.;f{! ~
W
~ C
[Dill
cZl:
=u
..ot;::
:;J .-
o:rl
t;;c..
CllVJ
$:
C
III
c..
5l
::::>
-C
c
~
=
~ i ~
~~" Sl ~~ i
~~t!~fi<i~?;:::I ~ljg.t::
~~~~~~~fli~~~ ~
lID !~ ~ ~ ~ m I ~ I {(
.~
,
,
i
~
~
<1 '
~
,I, ~~ J
~ ill 8 " qttJO
~ ~!l ~
h. ~
~
~
o
~
"
o
\ \ \ \ \
, ,
"
,.
\ I,
\
\, ,
, ,
,
\ '
\ \
"
"
r"\
~
5"
!OI~/O
General Plan Land Use Designations
West Dublin BART Specific Plan
Project Site
High Density Residential Retail/Office
Mixed Use Public/Semi Puhlic
ATTACHMENT b