HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 4.01 Draft Minutes 03-16-1999
.'-
~
.
REGULAR MEETING - March 16, 1999
A regular meeting of the Dublin City Council was held on Tuesday, March 16,
1999, in the Council Chambers of the Dublin Civic Center. The meeting was
called to order at 7:04 p.m., by Mayor Houston.
...
ROLL CALL
PRESENT: Councilmembers Howard, Lockhart, McCormick, Zika and Mayor
Houston.
ABSENT: None.
..
PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
Mayor Houston led the Council, Staff and those present in the pledge of
allegiance to the flag.
-.
~
INTRODUCTION OF NEW EMPLOYEE
7:04 p.m. 3.1 (700-10)
New Dublin Police Services Sergeant Larry Perea was introduced by Chief
_ Thuman. He has prior experience working in Dublin about 6 years ago as a
Deputy. He has an extensive background and has been an officer for over 20
years.
Sgt. Perea stated he was here about 6 months and because of budget problems,
he was demoted. He stated he appreciates this opportunity.
~
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 118
4~1
PRESENTATION OF DPIE AWARDS
.
7:06 p.m. 3.2 (515-60)
Rhonda Goldstone with Dublin Partners in Education gave a brief update on the
accomplishments of the DPIE program. 175 students went to 90 businesses
and participated in the job shadowing program. She quoted an 8th grader who
shadowed at Club Sport and wrote of the many things he learned. She thanked
everyone who supported the program.
Mayor Houston then presented awards on behalf of DPIE to: Robert O'Gorman .
representing OPUS West, Craig Champlain representing Summerhill Homes
Craig Champlain, Annette Borges representing Livermore-Dublin Disposal and
Roz Perazzo representing Chevron.
Mayor Houston stated there has been quite a growth for DPIE in the last couple
of years. It's really a great program.
~
PROCLAMATION
.
7: 11 p.m. 3.3 (610-50)
Mayor Houston read and presented a proclamation recognizing and
congratulating the U12 Girls High Energy Soccer Team for their outstanding
season and participation in the California Youth Soccer Association State Cup
Championship. Coaches were Mark King, Richard Lee and Dan Phillips. Players
were: Nicole Briones, Megan Bundy, Brittany Cameron, Donna Clark, Whitney
Feller, Kasey Gillmore, Nicole Irwin, Jori King, Mallory Lee, Kristine Maige, -
Shannon McFerrin, Amanda Phillips, Amanda Pinkston, Brianna Tsui, J acquie
V oznik and Katie V oznik.
..
Recess
Mayor Houston called for a short recess at 7:20 p.m. The meeting reconvened at
7:23 p.m., with all Councilmembers present.
...
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 119
e'
.
Farmers' Markets Issues (470-50)
Tom Benigno stated he does Citizen's Voice and he has been doing some things
regarding farmers' markets. He has been going to some 150 meetings
throughout California regarding farmers' markets and at this particular time
they are moving forward with what they said they would do. People are able to
go into communities and not pay taxes and they're not living up to their
agreements. Downtown business associations are allowing City Managers to
generate this business for their own agenda. If the money goes to the
businesses through a reduction of rents it should go on record that they are in
violation of federal rules.
~
Fireworks (650-60)
Tammie Lund stated she has been a Dublin resident for 8 years, has 4 children
and they participate in lots of activities. She discussed fireworks. She is in
favor as they are a great fundraiser. She is on the Dublin United Soccer Board
as member at large. She did a fIreworks stand last year. She was concerned
. that fIreworks is on lottery basis which is fme. There is also a draw of when you
pick up your fireworks. Her concern is the placement of the booths. Don Hewell
through American Promotional does not do a lottery draw for locations. This is
not always beneficial to the organization. There are prime locations with little
competition. Depending upon your location, your profits are determined. She
requested that the locations be by draw.
Mayor Houston asked for a report as to how this all works. Policies could be
discussed.
~
SPCA Event (500-10)
Linda Jeffery-Sailors representing SPCA stated she wanted to let the City
Council know that the East Bay SPCA now includes the Tri- Valley SPCA and
they are starting to process plans to build out here. They are working with the
other animal organizations to basically fulfill our goal 2007. Their mission is to
put an end to over population by adoption. They will be doing over 8,000
. CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
j'l-f arc h 1 6 J 1 '7 9 9
PAGE 120
surgeries per year. It is making a big difference. They want to open a center in .
2000 and will put in an education center to strengthen the human/ animal bond
and teach people how to properly care for pets. They hope to not have to
euthanize any animal that can be adopted. Their first activity will be this
coming Saturday; a pet adoption from 1 to 4 p.m., at the Hacienda Crossing
Shopping Center. They will have over 20 animals there for adoption. Mike
Sadak will be there with his dog, and she will bring McDuff who is having his
10th birthday. .
...
Freewav Overpasses (800-30)
Dan Rodriguez, a resident of Dublin stated he is concemed about overpasses
over Amador Valley Boulevard and over Dublin Boulevard. When you drive
under them your radio goes blank. He asked if there is any plans to add an
antenna there.
City Manager Ambrose stated not to his knowledge.
Mr. Thompson stated the State has done some on the tunnel on Highway 24 .
and it does work. As far as he knew they have not proposed any for these
underpasses. They are very short.
Mr. Rodriguez stated he felt this should have been picked up under the
environmental impact report.
Mayor Houston asked Mr. Thompson to investigate this.
..
CONSENT CALENDAR
7:35 p.m. Items 4.1 through 4.19
Cm. Lockhart pulled Items 4.6,4.7,4.8 and 4.10.
Cm. McCormick pulled Item 4.3.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 121
.
. On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Zika, and by unanimous vote, the
Council took the following actions:
Approved (4.1) Minutes of Regular Meeting of March 2, 1999;
Awarded (4.2 350-20) Purchase Order for Street Light Pole Painting to St.
Francis Electric ($14,950);
Adopted (4.4 670-40)
RESOLUTION NO. 34 - 99
ACCEPTING A STORM DRAIN EASEMENT
LOCATED ON PORTIONS OF PARCELS K, L & 0 OF TRACT 6925
(STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE CHAPTER 4)
and
RESOLUTION NO. 35 - 99
.
SUMMARILY VACATING A STORM DRAIN EASEMENT
LOCATED ON PORTIONS OF PARCELS K, L & 0 OF TRACT 6925
(STREETS AND HIGHWAYS CODE CHAPTER 4)
Adopted (4.9 1060-90)
RESOLUTION NO. 36 - 99
SUPPORTING THE CITY OF PLEASANTON'S APPLICATIONS FOR
TEA 21 25% FUNDING ALAMO CANAL TRAIL GAP CLOSURE AND
1-580 CORRIDOR MANAGEMENT-SIGNAL INTERCONNECT/CONNECTION
TO TRAFFIC OPERATIONS SYSTEM
Adopted (4.11 360-20)
RESOLUTION NO. 37 - 99
INITIATING PROCEEDINGS FOR LIGHTING & LANDSCAPE
MAINTENANCE ASSESSMENT DISTRICT NO. 99-1
(STREET LIGHTING MAINTENANCE - DUBLIN RANCH PHASE 1)
.
CITY COUN elL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
7'-IJich 16J 1999
PAGE 122
Adopted (4.12 350-20)
RESOLUTION NO. 38 - 99
.
WAIVING THE COMPETITIVE BID PROCESS AND
AUTHORIZING STAFF TO NEGOTIATE THE PURCHASE OF
TWO (2) POLICE PATROL VEHICLES
Adopted (4.13 350-40)
RESOLUTION NO. 39 - 99
DECLARING SURPLUS PROPERTY
(POLICE VEHICLES)
Adopted (4.14 600-60)
RESOLUTION NO. 40 - 99
APPROVING FINAL MAP FOR TRACT 6960
(DUBLIN RANCH - NEIGHBORHOOD L-5)
AND OFFSITE IMPROVEMENTS
Adopted (4.15 410-40)
.
RESOLUTION NO. 41 - 99
ACCEPTING IMPROVEMENTS CONSTRUCTED IN
PARCEL MAP 7042 (PORTION OF SANTA RITA DEVELOPMENT AREA)
OPUS CREEKSIDE BUSINESS PARK
and authorized Staff to accept $967,925 maintenance bond;
Adopted (4.16 700-20)
RESOLUTION NO. 42 - 99
AMENDING THE CLASSIFICATION PLAN
(INFORMATION SYSTEMS MANAGER)
and
RESOLUTION NO. 43 - 99
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 123
.
.
AMENDING THE MANAGEMENT POSITIONS EXEMPT
FROM COMPETITIVE SERVICE RESOLUTION
(INFORMATION SYSTEMS MANAGER)
and
RESOLUTION NO. 44 - 99
AMENDING THE SALARY PLAN
(INFORMATION SYSTEMS MANAGER)
Approved (4.17 600-30) an Agreement with Pacific Program Management, Inc.,
for Construction Management Services for the Civic Center Remodel ($38,964)
and Emerald Glen Park, Phase 1 ($140,786);
Approved (4.18 300-40) the Warrant Register in the amount of $688,338.33;
Directed (4.19 660-40) Staff to send letters of support for SB 3, 1999 Library
. Bond Bill.
em. McCormick pulled Item 4.3 related to the Final Map for the Gleason 17-Lot
subdivision and stated she would simply like to symbolically vote against this.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Zika, and by majority vote, the
Council adopted (4.3 410-50/600-60)
RESOLUTION NO. 45 - 99
,
APPROVING FINAL MAP FOR TRACT 7067
(CLlFDEN PARK)
and
RESOLUTION NO. 46 - 99
ACCEPTANCE OF PARKLAND DEDICATION IN LIEU FEES
FOR FINAL TRACT MAP 7067
Cm. McCormick voted against the motion.
",,",
.......,
.
CITY COUN ell MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
jv1arch 16,1999
PAGE 124
em. Lockhart pulled Item 4.6 (820-60) related to street names for Tract 6979. She .
stated the main concern was having names people could spell and pronounce}
especially children. Some of the names came back that they didn}t particularly care
for and others are even more difficult to pronounce. She asked if there is any
opportunity to go a different direction with names other than Spanish explorers.
Mr. Thompson stated some of the names came back and they}ve already been used
in the area so we can}t use them.
Cm. McCormick asked why Office of Emergency Seroices would have authority to
select names.
Mr. Thompson stated they are one of the emergency organizations that provide
comments.
Mayor Houston stated he understood if you have another one in your city} but if
there is a street name in Livermore} we should be able to use the name.
Mr. Thompson stated the problem is both fire and emergency seroices cover a bigger
area and there could be a mix up.
.
Cm. Lockhart stated she hates to throw out the baby with the bath water, but she
would just as soon not have Spanish explorer names.
Cm. Zika agreed and stated he felt they will have the same issues on Item 4. 7.
Connie Goldade with McKay & Somps commented that originally the Spanish
names were suggested by City Staff, They agree that some of them are difficult to
pronounce. They have been trying to work with the City and this is the fourth time
they've been here to get the names approved. If these are denied} it will take
another two weeks to go through the agencies for review.
Cm. Lockhart stated she understood that this is a pain} but the people will live on
these streets for a long time. She is not comfortable with these names.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Zika, and by unanimous vote, the
Council deleted 3 street names "Viscaino Court, Urdeneta Court and Lagazpi
Court" and replaced them with "Damphier, Doak and Guerrero", and adopted
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
}1a r c h 1 6, 1 '1? 9
PAGE 125
.
.
RESOLUTION NO. 47 - 99
APPROVAL OF NEW STREET NAMES
FOR STREETS IN TRACT 6979
Cm. McConnick asked for reconsideration of Item 4.5 which already approved,
(820-60) the street name list for Dublin Ranch Phase 1.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Zika, and by unanimous vote, the
Council agreed to reconsider and discuss this item.
Cm. McConnick stated she felt that Cranbrook Place sounded too similar to
Cranford, a street which we already have. On the alternate choices for L-1 through
L-6, Sugar Hill is listed and she would like to see Sugarloaf Hill replace one of the
names. This is a hill in Bray, Ireland which overlooks the City. She stated she
would like to throw out the name Cliffside Court because there are no cliffs there
(Area L-1) and insert Sugarloaf Court.
.
Mr. Ambrose stated Staff will have to come back because we have to route these
through the Post Office and other agencies.
City Attorney Silver stated they could suggest this name as a backup.
Mayor Houston directed that the name Sugarloaf be added to the alternate choices.
Mr. Thompson stated all the ones on the alternate list have been reviewed.
On motion of Cm. McCormick, secohded by Cm. Howard, and by unanimous
vote, the City Council added the name "Sugarloaf" to the altemate list
Cm. Lockhart pulled Item 4.7 (820-60) related to street names for Tassajara
Meadows Unit II.
The Council discussed the spelling of Preciado vs. Precado. The Council
detennined that the names "DeFuca and Zalvidea" should be removed from the
primary selection list and the names "Gallaup and SalvatierraJ] from the alternates
list be inserted in their place.
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
t'13ic:1 16) 1999
PAGE 126
Cm. Zika suggested they name the bigger streets the more common names, and that .
the smaller courts be given the more difficult names.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. McCormick, and by unanimous
vote, the Council agreed that the two names "DeFuca and Zalvidea" would be
replaced with "Gallaup and Salvatierra" in Tassajara Meadows Unit II
Cm. Lockhart pulled 4.8 (1060-90) related to the grant for traffic signals on Village
Parkway, at Tamarack Drive, at Brighton Drive and at Davona Drive. She had a
concern that this is something that's been on the books for a long time, and
questioned ifit is really necessary to have stop lights there. She travels this area a
lot and traffic seems to flow beautifully there.
Mr. Thompson stated we updated the studies and they do meet the warrants. The
real problem is when the high school kids come down through there.
Cm. Lockhart expressed concern with 3 stop lights in a row. Someone may get
green through the first one and then speed up to get to the second. With stop signs
we are not encouraging speed on that street. We may be biting off something we .
don't want to get into.
Cm. McCormick questioned if and why the money has to be used for these stop
lights.
Mr. Thompson explained that we submitted these locations a couple of months ago.
Each city tried to get projects that would meet the requirements of the funding. We
went back into our ClP and this has been partially funded for a number of years.
We've been getting traffic impact fees for this for a number of years.
Cm. McCormick stated she was more concerned with the area near the Library.
Cm. Lockhart's daughter was struck by a car in the crosswalk there recently. The
Librarian herself said she is afraid to crosS that street, as are many senior citizens.
Mr. Thompson stated it is so close to Donohue he wasn't sure we could put another
lig ht there.
Cm. Lockhart stated her main concern is people trying to get through a series of
lights.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
'M an~jl i /:;, 1 999
PAGE 127
.
.
Mr. Thompson stated they will be tied together. It is very likely that we will get the
money for these.
Cm. Zika stated we could put them in, but we don't have to turn them on.
Cm. Lockhart stated she wanted to do what's bestfor the neighborhood. If we feel
the safest thing is to have 3 in a row, then we could put them in. She stated she
doesn't understand why the Tamarack signal is needed.
Cm. Howard stated parents want a light.
The situation of trying to make a left turn out of Wineberry was discussed.
Mr. Ambrose clarified that they seemed to be mainly concerned with the signal at
Tamarack. We could probably withdraw from a portion of it. We could take a look
at the impacts after putting them in at Davona and Brighton. We could go ahead
and apply for the grant but have our traffic engineers look at the impacts of just
putting in the two.
. On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. McCormick, and by unanimous
vote, the Council adopted (4.8 l060-90)
RESOLUTION NO. 48 - 99
AUTHORIZATION FOR GRANT APPLICATION
FOR THE SURFACE TRANSPORTATION PROGRAM AND
CONGESTION MITIGATION AND AIR QUALITY IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM
FOR NEW SIGNAL INSTAllATIONS
The Council also asked Staff to report back on the consequences of not putting
in the signal at Tamarack.
Cm. Lockhart pulled Item 4.10 (1060-90) related to the STIP grantfor the Road
Resurfacing Program and asked if Amador Valley Boulevard falls under this for
resurfacing.
.
CITY COUN CIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
iYL3rcl1 16,1999
?AGE 128
Mr. Thompson stated we have a Pavement Management Program, which quantifies .
how bad each of the streets are. We started out with all the major arterials that
were really bad and then did some of the collectors. With the new garbage trucks,
some of the courts are now really bad.
Mr. Ambrose explained that there are 3 levels of maintenance; sluny seal, overlay
and reconstruction. We want to use the less expensive at the appropriate time so
we don't have to reconstruct the streets. We try not to get to level 3.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Howard, and by unanimous vote,
the Council adopted (4.10 1060-90)
RESOLUTION NO. 49 - 99
AUTHORIZATION FOR GRANT APPLICATION FOR THE
STATE TRANSPORTATION IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM (STIP)
FOR THE ROAD RESURFACING PROGRAM
PUBLIC HEARING - PA 98-063
TOLL BROTHERS - EMERALD GLEN #4 PLANNED DEVELOPMENT
.
8: 15 p.m. 6.1 (450-30)
Mayor Houston opened the public hearing.
Planning Consultant Mike Porto presented the Staff Report and advised that this
request is for a PD Rezone from a PD Medium Density Residential to PD
Residential to allow development of 295 single family homes consisting of 3
product types to be developed on 28.9 acres located in the Eastern Dublin
Specific Plan Area. The first product is 100 single family detached homes
ranging in size from 2,030 square feet to 2,840 square feet on approximately
4,000 square foot lots. The second product is a zero lot line patio homes
product of 43 homes of between 1,633 to 2,009 square feet on individual lots of
approximately 3,000 square feet. The [mal product is a series of single family
attached townhomes in twenty-four 5,6 or 7 unit buildings and an associated
recreation complex with floor plans ranging in size between 1,305 to 1,828
square feet.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 129
.
. On February 9, 1999, the Planning Commission adopted resolutions
recommending that the City Council approve the requested rezone and establish
findings, general provisions and development standards and approve the
Tentative Map and the Site Development Review for the proposed project, along
with conditions of approval.
The Development Agreement is under preparation at ~s time and is expected to
be presented to the Planning Commission and City Council for consideration in
April, 1999.
The proposed residential project is exempt from further environmental review
according to Section 15182 of the State CEQA Guidelines because it is within
the scope of the Final Environmental Impact Report for the Eastern Dublin GPA
certified by the City Council in 1993 and the Addenda in 1993 and 1994. As
conditioned, the project will comply and conform to all of the Action Programs
and Policies of the Eastem Dublin Specific Plan.
Cm. Zika asked about the non standard streets in the lower portion, and asked
what is the difference?
. Mr. Porto stated the streets will be constructed to City standards. The one area
that is private will have a homeowners association and have a landscaped lot
with play equipment. One of the streets will only be 30' wide with parking
allowed on one side only.
Cm. Zika expressed concern that people buying homes will not notice that their
street is somewhat different from the others. They will then learn that the City
,
won't maintain it. People don't read CC&R's. Can we enforce all traffic laws on
these streets?
Mr. Thompson stated on a private street we need to do a special ordinance to
enforce the vehicle code. There will be a different type of pavement treatment
and a sign that says private street.
Mayor Houston asked if parking ratios conform to our guidelines.
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 161 1999
PAGE 130
Mr. Porto stated each of the homes has a 2-car garage and an 18' driveway + an
outside parking spot which is the City's criteria. Other parking issues were .
discussed.
Mayor Houston asked about the location of Zone 7's access..
Cm. Lockhart asked if Zone 7 will maintain the trail.
Mr. Thompson stated the trail is in a landscaping and lighting maintenance
assessment district. Zone 7 will maintain the channels.
Cm. Howard asked if there will be street parking allowed in the high density
areas.
Mr. Porto stated yes, there is parking allowed along the streets + a few guest lots
spread around.
John Painter, Regional Manager with Toll Brothers Homes stated they have
enjoyed working with Staff. They will provide some different housing types from
what has been offered in the East Dublin General Plan. They are a national
builder new to this area. They're on the New York Stock Exchange and operate .
in 17 or 18 states. He advised that there is a disclosure page that goes with the
sales contract about the private street.
Cm. Zika stated his only cone em is that when the developers are gone and 5 or
6 years down the road and they need some street repairs, they say no body told
them. He would like a one page sp~cified disclosure indicating these are private
streets and will be maintained by the homeowners association.
Cm. McCormick commented that no chimneys are shown on the drawings. She
stated she is very concerned that we not add to the poilu tion in the valley.
Mr. Painter stated they are on the current submission package. The only ones
with wood burning fireplaces are the larger homes. The others are all gas. They
meet whatever code is required.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 131
.
.
Mr. Peabody stated there are specific requirements in the Building Code and
these will meet the DBC. The issue of frreplaces can be discussed, but right now
our code does allow wood burning fireplaces.
Cm. McCormick stated there are some that meet EPA standards. This seems to
be a serious matter to be given a recreational designation.
Ms. Silver stated this project requires a Development Agreement and the project
will be subject to the Building Code in effect at the time of approval.
Cm. McCormick asked if this can be amended to provide that provision.
Ms. Silver stated we could say it is subject to the code in effect at the time
building permits are pulled". We can also put in notification that clarifies that
streets are private.
Mr. Peabody stated the updated codes will come before the City Council in May
and the City Council can discuss fireplaces at that time. The issue about
fireplaces is an optional discussion that the Council can deal with.
. Cm. Lockhart agreed that if there are new standards related to pollution, this
. will be a great step forward for us to take a look at this.
Mr. Painter commented he would be willing to look at more efficient fireplaces
and gas burning versus wood burning. He discussed the idea of conditioning
the Development Agreement.
,
City Manager Ambrose clarified that the Development Agreement is not before
the City Council tonight. "
Mr. Peabody stated if the project gets approved and he takes out building
permits before the new code is adopted, it will be subject to the 1994 Codes.
The 1997 Code will probably be effective in July and permits would be pulled
then, so he would be subject to the latest code.
David Bewley, 11116 Brittany Lane commented that this looks very nice. He
clarified that he was not accusing them of bait and switch, but historically it
was agreed to give medium density development in Eastern Dublin, 10 units per
. CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 132
acre. Some residents are concemed when we make changes. What is the .
fundamental purpose of increasing the density of this project and does this
improve the quality of life for Dublin residents? High density projects suffer
danger of not aging well. They just don't seem to stand the test of time. Why
are we increasing the density here?
Mr. Peabody stated the property is designated medi~m density and there is no
increase in density. The General Plan calls for 10 units per acre and this is
what this project is.
Mr. Bewley requested that the Council consider at some time discussing a
Design Review Committee to resolve some of the issues so the City Council
doesn't have to do this on the spur of the moment.
Mayor Houston closed the public hearing.
Cm. Lockhart stated she likes the variety and this brings a lot of different kinds
of people, singles, small and larger families all able to co-exist. They will all have
the advantage of the creek and the park and shopping. This is the wave of the
future.
.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Howard, and by unanimous vote,
the Council waived the reading and INTRODUCED the Ordinance amending the
Zoning Map to rezone property located east of Tassajara Creek, south of Central
Parkway, north of Dublin Boulevard and west of Park Drive (APN: 986-0001-
001-10 portion) to a Planned Development Zoning district and adopting a
Development Plan for the Toll Brotl)ers, Emerald Glen #4 (PA 98-063).
..
PUBLIC HEARING - PA 98-047
KOLL DUBLIN CORPORATE CENTER DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
8:44 p.m. 6.2 (600-60)
Mayor Houston opened the public hearing.
Staff explained that this item was a noticed public hearing item. Staff
recommended that the Council continue the public hearing to the April 6th City
Council meeting.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 133
.
. No testimony was entered by any member of the public relative to this issue.
Mayor Houston declared that the item was continued to the April 6th City
Council meeting.
..
PUBLIC HEARING - URGENCY ORDINANCE
EXTENDING MORATORIUM ON ACCEPTANCE,
PROCESSING AND APPROVAL OF GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENTS
FOR THE WESTERN EXTENDED PLANNING AREA PA 99-003
8:45 p.m. 6.3 (420-20)
Mayor Houston opened the public hearing.
Community Development Director Peabody presented the Staff Report and
advised that adopting this Ordinance will extend the 4S day moratorium on the
acceptance, processing and approval of General Plan Amendments for the
Western Extended Planning Area until February 17,2000.
. No testimony was entered by any member of the public relative to this issue.
Mayor Houston closed the public hearing.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Zika, and by unanimous vote, the
Council waived the reading and on an urgency basis, adopted
,
ORDINANCE NO.5 - 99
AN INTERIM ORDINANCE EXTENDING THE MORATORIUM ON THE
ACCEPTANCE, PROCESSING AND APPROVAL OF GENERAL PLAN
AMENDMENTS FOR THE WESTERN EXTENDED PLANNING AREA
TO FEBRUARY 17, 2000, PENDING THE COMPLETION OF A
GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY
ON ESTABLISHING AN URBAN LIMIT LINE (PA 99-003)
..
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 134
PUBLIC HEARING - ALL ABOARD MINI STORAGE
GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY PA 98-024
.
8:46 p.m. 6.4 (420-30)
Mayor Houston opened the public hearing.
Senior Planner Dennis Carrington presented the Staff Report and advised that
this G P A study analyzes altemative G P designations that could be applied to
18.37 acres of property lying east of Dougherty Road, southwest of the northeast
boundary of the Union Pacific Railioad Company property and north of Houston
Place. The alternative designations considered are Commercial (Retail/Office), a
combination Industrial Park/ Campus Office, Medium High Density Residential,
or a combination of Commercial and Residential.
All Aboard Mini Storage proposed an 85,699 sq. ft. self-storage facility on 4.21
net acres. The City Council initiated the GPA Study on May 5, 1998, to analyze
GP land use altematives for the railioad property and for two other properties
lying east of Dougherty Road, between the railioad property and Houston Place.
Frank Ridley, a representative of the Union Pacific Railioad Company, notified
the City on February 3, 1999 that All Aboard Mini Storage is no longer involved
in the project. The owners of land in the study area are the Union Pacific
Railioad Company, Edwin and Irene Omernik and Edwin and Judith Wright.
.
Mr. Carrington stated the UP property is currently vacant but was used for
railroad purposes between 1915 and the early 1980's when the tracks were
removed. The Omernik property is the site of a truss manufacturing company
and the Wright property is used for 'automobile repair, paint sales, newspaper
distribution and a marble bullnosing company. The Omemik and Wright
properties are zoned PD allowing C- 2 and M -1 uses. The UP property is zoned
M-l. The Omernik and Wright properties are designated Business
Park/Industrial: Outdoor Storage on the General Plan. The UP property is
designated Transportation Corridor.
Mr. Carrington discussed the setting and the design characters of Dougherty
Road, Scarlett Drive, and Houston Place. He also addressed land use
altematives and defmitions of altemate GP designations.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 135
.
. Several letters were received from tenants.
With regard to the environmental review, a Mitigated Negative Declaration was
prepared for the GPA Study.
Shyam Taggarsi, Vice President of Archstone Communities Trust stated they are
national and leading real estate companies. They are a public company on the
NYSE and own about 3,000 units in the Bay Area. They are proposing 177
upscale high end units with many amenities. He addressed some of the Staff
and neighbor's concems. He displayed a slide of the study area. The trails are
the glue that hold sites together for the BART Station. If the GPA is approved
tonight, one of the first things they will do is a traffic study. Residential use
generates less traffic than an office campus use. They will also do a noise study.
They feel this area is pedestrian friendly and with the connection to the Iron
Horse Trail it forms a good network. Some are concerned about having
apartments right next to businesses. Residents are given a 30 day written
guarantee and if they aren't satisfied they will assist them to move to another
unit or another location. He proposed leaving the Wright property as
commercial and make northem portion of UP commercial retail and the other
. for residential as it makes a lot of sense for a mixed use. Commercial retail will
be surrounded by residential. He urged the City Council to consider residential
on the Omernik property.
Ed Wright stated he is the owner of the Wright parcel and has owned it since
1970. It is not for sale and he does not anticipate selling to anybody. He would
like to see the proposal on the board now because it falls within his line of
thinking. His metal building probably has only about 10 years left. It doesn't
. .
bother him to see the Omernik property go residential. The UP property is a
funny property and it will be a hard piece of property to develop. He stated he
felt his property got blown out of proportion.
Frank Ridley, with Real Estate Department of UPRR clarified that All Aboard has
no further interest in the property. They plan to place their property on the
market for sale. They own over 8 acres; 4.2 net acres would be developable.
They have not had the property appraised but they believe this area is evolving
past industrial uses and feels the community would benefit from retail with
some commercial retail. There is not yet a buyer lined up for the property. He
hoped development could occur sooner rather than later.
. CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 136
Denny Kahler, stated he OWIlS the property at 6117 Dougherty Road and has for
11 years. May 1st will be their 25th year in business. He asked that the City
Council just do something. Houston Place has never been improved. He would
like to see something happen there and the sooner the better. He has been
hearing for years that something will be happening in 6 months to a year. This
is one of the main gateways to the City. He summarized that his request was for
the City to just do something.
John Steinbuch with Colliers International Pleasanton stated he has been a
commercial real estate broker for 20 years. He helped Denny Kahler buy his
property. He has also worked with Ed Omernik over the last few years. He
spoke about the evolution of the Dublin market. Land values have gone up 4
times in the last few years. You cannot build industrial product on $20/ sq. ft.
land. The market in the last couple of years has gone up dramatically. The
prevailing industrial market is moving east to Livermore and Stockton. He
stated he does not think Dublin will see one story flex offices built anymore. .
Most everything will be multi-story, 4 or 5 stories, to justify the land values.
Sue Wilson, 6287 Dougherty Road, with the marble bullnosing company, asked
if anyone on the Council had ever been self employed. She wanted the City
Council to understand the difficulties of running a business. She asked what
and how are we going to be widening the Dougherty Road section.
Mayor Houston stated today we are talking about the zoning on these parcels.
All the improvements will be dictated by whatever happens on the properties.
All the different studies will determine what happens and when.
Ms. Wilson stated when the high t~ medium residential was brought up, she
asked if the road will be Widened first.
Mayor Houston explained that any development has a series of requirements as
part of the conditions of approval for whatever project is approved.
Ms. Wilson asked about the impacts on the school system.
Mayor Houston stated we worked very closely with DUSD and they are building
a new school. Every department in the City has an opportunity to come up with
their thoughts and ideas of how to make it an acceptable project.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 137
.
.
.
. Ms. Wilson stated she felt this does seem reasonable and was happy to hear Mr.
Wright say his property is not for sale. She thought maybe a wall could be put
around their property to deal with the impacts. The industrial area looks
terrible, however, as a small business owner, they strive to do their business
and it is very difficult to find a unit in Dublin. Leave Mr. Wright's property as is
and let them continue to do business. This looks like a good compromise.
Mr. Ambrose discussed the major improvement plans on Dougherty Road.
Mr. Thompson stated improvements to the north in part hinge on getting funds
from the Dougherty Valley people as part of their impact on Dublin. We will
have to require right-of-way.
Cm. Zika stated he was concerned that we've been negotiating for 4 years and
still haven't gotten a nickel.
Mr. Thompson stated we are actually getting close.
. Annette Wahlgren with John's European Auto Service stated they've had their
businesses for 9 years. They have over 900 customers from 52 cities. They
have installed new exit doors and ventilation systems and have been good
citizens and paid all their fees and abide by all the rules. They pay sales tax and
it increases every year. They have been challenged by people living on the
Omemik property stealing radios from their customer's cars and other things.
She stated she was not sure residential is the right thing for Dublin. Are
apartments a good idea in this area? She did not think so. It is not inviting for
pedestrians and it is a very noisy street. Smail businesses provide sales tax and
jobs for the City. They are concerned for their business, their employees and
their customers. She urged a vote against residential and to allow small
businesses to continue.
Mayor Houston felt there was confusion about what action tonight would force.
Existing uses would not go away. This is an overlay and if anything happens in
the future, those rules would apply. The mandate rests with the property
owners. We are just putting in place what we would like to see as a Council.
Time will tell what will happen. The Council cannot throw out any businesses
and the property owners are in charge.
. CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16,1999
PAGE 138
Mayor Houston closed the public hearing.
.
Mayor Houston questioned a small triangle of property that was not included
and stated he did not realize we were chopping part of it off.
Mr. Carrington explained that they want to have the 2 roads meet at a right
angle.
An unidentified audience member stated Staff wanted Houston Place to meet
Scarlett Court at a right angle. Mr. Omernik informed them of this. It was
agreed that this would be sold when Houston Place is extended. It will merge
into the Mayflower property.
Mayor Houston stated the Council should not have had to"figure this out but
should have had this information.
Mayor Houston commented that the recommendations were all over the board.
Why can't you have an overlay that would allow some commercial or some retail,
and which would allow some automotive today or coffee shop in the future and
allow this type of service in conjunction with a combination.
.
Mr. Carrington stated the City Council can apply commercial retail on the
northern part and the southern part could be designated residential.
Mayor Houston asked if the City Council could just have an overlay.
Mr. Carrington stated we should have a line.
, ,
Mayor Houston stated with regard to Mr. Taggarsi's proposal; wouldn't it be
easier to just have it overlayed and then when we get an actual proposal, we
could consider it? Staff could be directed and a policy created saying it's a
combination commercial residential and then we await a specific proposal on
exactly where the line should go.
Cm. Zika stated he is against any residential right now. He was concerned
about this 175 unit proposal being brought forward and all the additional trips
dumped onto Dougherty Road. This is an $18 million cost and we don't know
when our friends on the other side of the County Line will come through with
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 139
.
.
the money. The other thing is if we make this residential, it becomes a tax user
rather than a tax producer. Right now, it is a tax positive situation. He sees no
reason to change the designation. Dougherty Road will be a major thoroughfare
and he stated he doesn't know many people that would want to live on a 6 lane
road.
Cm. Lockhart stated yesterday and today is kind of clashing ~th tomorrow, in
trying to look at long range planning and protect businesses that do exist. She
stated she was a small business owner for quite a while and she was, from day
one, at the landlord's mercy. Everyone that leases space knows this. She
doesn't want to see anybody with an existing lease pushed out. There aren't a
lot of areas being developed within our community for light industrial. A lot of
tenants will come from people that want to be close to public transit.
Mayor Houston felt having rental units near a BART station makes sense. We
should not preclude any good ideas and should have an overlay that allows
studying options.
Mr. Ambrose suggested that this item be continued so Staff can bring back
. overlay with specifics with parameters for the overlay.
Mayor Houston asked what happens if we leave it wide open.
Mr. Ambrose stated the General Plan sets the envelope under which they can
operate.
Ms. Silver stated the designation has to be something that is listed in the GP.
That's what the City Council will be'saying is the permitted use of the property.
Mr. Peabody suggested that Staff could bring back a GPA that would allow
commercial uses that are similar to what are now allowed and change Union
Pacific's designation from transportation to the commercial and residential at 14
to 25 units per acre. Change Omernik's property and Wright's property to the
same commercial/residential and arrange appropriate findings.
Mayor Houston made a motion, which was seconded by Cm. McCormick, that
the Union Pacific property will be transferred to commercial and medium-high
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 140
density residential. The Omemik and Wright properties also go to commercial .
/residential (14.1 to 25.0 du/ac) medium-high density residential.
Mr. Carrington advised that the Council should also adopt the resolution
adopting the Mitigated Negative Declaration and Mitigation Monitoring Program.
Mr. Peabody advised that if they wanted to adopt this tonight, they should adopt
the resolutions. If they desired, they could establish a category medium high
density residential, retail/ office, commercial for the Omernik, Union Pacific and
Wright properties
Ms. Silver advised that they need to adopt the resolution and to establish a land
use category in the General Plan of residential/retail office since we don't have
retail office/residential. They could combine them or designate as either/or.
Mr. Peabody stated both currently exist
Mayor Houston amended his motion to add adoption of the Negative Declaration
and Mitigation Monitoring Program and to establish category retail office /
residential medium high residential at 14-25 units. Cm. McCormick again .
seconded the motion. The motion passed by a majority vote. Cm. Zika was
opposed.
On motion of Mayor Houston, seconded by Cm. McCormick, and by majority
vote, the Council adopted
RESOLUTION NO. 50 - 99
ADOPTING A MITIGATED NEGATIVE DECLARATION AND
MITIGATION MONITORING PROGRAM FOR PA 98-024
ALL ABOARD GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY
Cm. Zika voted in opposition to the motion.
Mr. Peabody stated the Planning Commission was concerned that looking at this
area was important and other nearby areas deserve the same consideration. We
are doing some work on redevelopment that mayor may not address this.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 141
.
. Mayor Houston felt we will be looking at this as one of our redevelopment areas.
Cm. Zika stated he was concerned about the message we are sending to
Archstone.
Mayor Houston felt the City Council was saYing they will entertain retail/
commercial/residential uses.
Mr. Ambrose clarified that the City Council did not want campus/office. It
could be added to the General Plan.
Mr. Peabody suggested that the City Council may want Staff to bring back a
clean resolution on the consent calendar at the next meeting to clarify this.
This will be brought back, not for this particular area, but for other parts of the
City.
Ms. Silver stated this General Plan Amendment does have to be adopted by a
resolution. This, however, is a straw vote and the official vote will be on the
consent calendar at the next meeting.
. +-
SELECTION OF FARMERS' MARKET LOCATION & TIME FOR 1999
10:00 p.m. 8.1 (470-50)
City Manager Ambrose presented the Staff Report and advised that last year, the
City entered into a 2-year contract with Urban Village Farmers' Market for the
start-up and management of a Farmers' Market in Dublin. In 1998, the market
was held at the Dublin Square Shopping Center on Fridays from 4:00 p.m. to
8:00 p.m. Staff contacted several property owners regarding the possibility of
moving the market to a different location this year, as well as having it on
Saturday or Sunday momings.
The City has the choice to hold the market at the Dublin Square Shopping
Center at the same time and day as last year or to change the date and time at
that location. The option is also open for the City to move the market to the
Shamrock Village Shopping Center on either Saturday or Sunday from 8:00 a.m.
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 142
to 12:00 noon. The offer to hold the event at the Shamrock Village Shopping
Center is for one year due to the potential redevelopment plans for the shopping .
center.
Mr. Ambrose advised that $5,000 was included in the FY 1998-99 Budget for
the promotion of the 1999 Dublin Farmers' Market.
In summary, Mr. Ambrose stated Staff recommended moving the Dublin
Farmers' Market to the Shamrock Village Shopping Center and to hold it on
Saturday mornings from 9:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m., June 5th through October 30th.
Cm. Zika expressed concern that if we keep moving it, what impact will this
have.
Cm. Lockhart stated she felt we learned a lot from this first year. It's fairly
simple to advertise the location, wherever it may be.
Mr. Pardini stated he felt it is negative to switch from location to location. He is
very much in favor of the weekend. More centrally located will be good for the
community and visibility as well. Being more in the core business area will help .
build additional traffic.
Mayor Houston stated he felt we should just do the best we can. With regard to
plans for that center, ideas have a way of not happening overnight, so we may
be there longer than we thought.
Mr. Pardini stated it is a better loca,tion and he would like to change it to the
weekend. They found from their surveys that our market really served only
Dublin residents. it may actually be a plus having other markets close by. We
could have better variety.
Cm. Lockhart asked about a survey we were going to do and ask the community
how they felt.
Mr. Pardini stated he remembered discussing this with Mr. Reue1, but he wasn't
sure if the survey was done by the City.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 143
.
. Mayor Houston pointed out that it is less windy in the morning hours also. It
may improve musicians' availability also.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Howard, and by unanimous vote,
the Council determined that the Dublin Farmers' Market should be held on
Saturday mornings from 9:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. at Shamrock Village, starting on
June 5th and running through Oct~ber 30th.
...
RESERVE FIRE TRUCK AGREEMENT
10:08 p.m. 8.2 (600-40)
City Manager Ambrose presented the Staff Report and advised that the City of
Dublin's existing reserve ladder truck is beyond its 20 year life expectancy and
has a likelihood of critical mechanical failures. It has been determined that this
apparatus is unsafe to operate and it has been taken out of service. This action
has created a need for a reserve truck within the City of Dublin.
. An agreement was developed and reviewed by the City Managers, Fire Chief, City
Attorneys, and County Counsel that defmes the terms of ownership,
maintenance, and use of the proposed joint reserve truck. Under the terms of
the agreement, the City of San Leandro and Alameda County Fire Department
will pay the City of Dublin a total of $407,786. The City of Dublin will need to
buy a new truck with an estimated cost of $593,889 (without equipment).
Sufficient funds have been budgeted. The City will also be responsible for 130/0
of the maintenance of the existing 1994 LT1 truck.
Cm. Lockhart asked if it is red.
The new truck will be red, but the reserve truck is not.
Cm. McCormick asked how we came up with the 130/0.
Chief McCRmmon stated the cost sharing is based on number of engine
companIes.
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 144
On motion of Cm. Zika, seconded by Cm. Howard, and by unanimous vote, the .
Council approved an agreement between the Alameda County Fire Department
and the City of San Leandro for the joint ownership and use of the existing
Dublin 1994 LTlladder fire truck.
...
AUTHORIZATION TO WAIVE COMPETITIVE BIDDING REQUIREMENTS
AND PURCHASE A FIRE TRUCK FROM LADDER TOWERS, INCORPORATED
10: 14 p.m. 8.3 (350-20)
Assistant City Manager Rankin advised that in accordance with the previous
item, a proposal has been made to have the City sell" a portion of the ownership
interest in the current front line ladder truck. The truck would be used jointly
by the Cities of San Leandro, Dublin and Alameda County as a reserve truck.
This creates the need for the City of Dublin to purchase a new front line ladder
truck, which will be partially financed from selling partial ownership of the
reserve truck to the other agencies.
Mr. Rankin reported that Ladder Towers, Incorporated has indicated that they .
will extend competitive pricing to the City of Dublin and a production slot has
been reserved allowing delivery in 6 months. The vehicle will be specified in a
standard configuration to provide conformity of ladder trucks within the area
serviced by Alameda County Fire Department personnel.
Estimated Equipment/ Outfitting Cost
GRAND TOTAL
$ 548,165.00
45.223.61
$ 593,388.61
$ 109.748.57
$ 703,137.18
$ 407.786.00
$ 295,351.18
Costs will be:
Base cost tractor drawn ladder truck
Sales Tax '
TOTAL Base Vehicle Purchased from L TI
Revenue from Reserve Truck Agreement
NET COST Fully Equipped
Mr. Rankin clarified that the cost of outfitting the Fire Truck is not part of this
bid award. Alameda County Fire Department will make these purchases which
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 145
.
. will be reimbursed by the City of Dublin at cost. The cost to outfit the truck
includes the purchase and installation of various emergency equipment, radios,
tools, generators, etc. The $109,000 is a preliminary estimate based upon the
complement of equipment carried on Fire Trucks in the Alameda County fleet.
These costs will, in all likelihood, be incurred in FY 1999/2000 after delivery of
the truck by the manufacturer.
In order to take advantage of the pricing presented, the City must confrrm the
order by Apri11st. As provided for in the Dublin Municipal Code, the waiver of a
formal sealed bid for the purchase of a vehicle requires a 4/5 approval by the
City Council to allow the negotiation of the purchase by Staff. The cost to be
negotiated will be in accordance with information provided in this report.
Chief McCammon stated this is an excellent apparatus.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. McCormick, and by unanimous
vote, the Council adopted
RESOLUTION NO. 51 - 99
.
AUTHORIZING A WAIVER OF THE COMPETITIVE BID REQUIREMENT
FOR THE PURCHASE OF FIRE APPARATUS EQUIPMENT
..
CONSIDERATION OF CALTRANS' REQUEST TO TEMPORARILY
CLOSE THE ALCOSTA BOULEVARD SOUTHBOUND ON-RAMP TO 1-680
10: 16 p.m. 8.4 (800-30)
Public Works Director Thompson presented the Staff Report and advised that
due to an increase in traffic accidents in the construction zone at the I -680/
Alcosta Boulevard southbound on-ramp, Caltrans is proposing to close the ramp
for 2 1/2 months to accelerate the work to bring the ramp merging back to a
standard configuration.
Mr. Thompson stated Staff agrees that the situation is now a safety problem and
that the 2 ~ month impact is preferable to a 9 month solution, and concurs
with Caltrans' recommendation to temporarily close the Alcosta Boulevard
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 146
southbound on-ramp to 1-680. Staff will monitor the effects to City streets and
make the necessary signal adjustments to keep traffic flowing smoothly.
.
Cm. Lockhart asked if consideration had been given to what neighborhoods
might be affected?
Mr. Thompson stated we believe they would probably try to stay on a major
street. Most of these people are coming from San Ramon.
Cm. Lockhart asked if the PG&E work will be done before this work. They are
just past Amador Valley Boulevard now, and they're moving fast. She is
concerned that we don't cut down on accidents in this one place and create
problems elsewhere.
Mayor Houston stated he felt we could monitor this.
Cm. McCormick asked if we really believe they will be finished in 2 Y2 months.
Mr. Thompson stated this will be saving them money to get in and get out
quickly. We can recommend damages if they don't complete it.
.
On motion of Mayor Houston, seconded by Cm. McCormick, and by unanimous
vote, the Council concurred with Caltrans' proposed closure and directed Staff
to respond in writing to Caltrans. Staff should urge them to let the contractor
know we want them to complete the job in the 2 Y2 months and request they
incorporate some liquidated damages if it goes beyond this time period.
...
TRI-VALLEY TRANSPORTATION COUNCIL
STRATEGIC EXPENDITURE PLAN (SEPt
10:25 p.m. 8.4 (1060-90)
Public Works Director Thompson advised that Mr. Kinzel would make the
presentation.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 147
.
. Chris Kinzel, with TJKM advised that this item will confirm the project priority
funding for those projects proposed to be paid for through the recently approved
Tn-Valley Transportation Development Fee. All 7 Tri-Valley jurisdictions must
agree on the priority for the funding to become effective.
This Expenditure Plan provides a blueprint for the timed funding of the top 7
regional projects in the Tri-Valley. The Fee is already being levied. Each
jurisdiction is able to use 200/0 of the Fee collected in their respective
jurisdiction toward that jurisdiction's top priority project(s).
Mr. Kinzel stated Staff was requesting that the Council approve project(s) for
Dublin's 200/0 fee set-aside monies, and approve the San Ramon Road/I-S80
interchange improvements and the West Dublin BART Station improvements as
the City's top priorities.
Cm. Lockhart clarified that anyone of the cities can blackball a project.
Mr. Kinzel stated yes, the strategic plan must be approved by all agencies.
. Cm. Lockhart stated she felt the City of Livermore would not look favorably on
the West Dublin BART Station.
Mr. Kinzel stated he wasn't sure the concern expressed by the City of Livermore
still exists.
Mayor Houston stated we are being asked to approve the expenditure plan and
then decide where our 200/0 should go. He asked how much money is estimated
for our 200/0?
Mr. Rankin stated as of February, we had about $120,000.
Mayor Houston stated in total we will be collecting about $20 million and about
$4 million will be able to be directed to our priorities. This will be our piece of
the pie. Everybody who has development has their 200/0. We do have a little bit
of latitude.
Cm. Lockhart asked if there is a preference as to where the money goes fIrst.
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 148
Mayor Houston stated we had to identify all the options .we wanted to collect .
funds for. We don't have to decide which is which and the distribution today,
but just that it will go toward those 2 projects.
On motion of Cm. Lockhart, seconded by Cm. Howard, and by unanimous vote,
the Council approved projects for Dublin's 200/0 fee set-aside monies: San
Ramon Road/I-580 interchange improvements and West Dublin BART Station
improvements as the City's top priorities.
On motion of Cm. Zika, seconded by Cm. Howard, and by unanimous vote, the
Council adopted
RESOLUTION NO. 52 - 99
APPROVING THE TRI-VALLEY TRANSPORTATION COUNCIL
STRATEGIC EXPENDITURE PLAN
..
OTHER BUSINESS
Upcoming Meetings (610-05)
.
10:34 p.m.
Mr. Ambrose advised that the Pleasanton liaison meeting had been changed to
9: 15 a.m., on Thursday, March 18th.
Mr. Ambrose reminded everyone of the Goals & Objectives meeting on Thursday,
starting at 6:00 p.m.
..
Appointment to League Committee (110-30)
Cm. McCormick announced that she has been appointed to the Community
Services Committee by the League of California Cities
....
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 149
.
.
Sister City Delegation (140-50)
Cm. McCormick complimented the Mayor on the very fine celebration and
reception for the delegation from our Sister City, Bray.
..
St. Patrick's Day Parade & Celebration (950-40)
Cm. Howard reported that she got a lot of nice compliments on the parade and
celebration this year.
Cm. Zika stated the 5K run was a great success. There were over 500 people.
He stated he is really anxious to see the evaluations of the whole event.
...
Parade (950-40)
. Cm. Lockhart thanked Staff for their participation in the parade, especially Julie
Carter, who did a wonderful job. Their float looked great. She thanked Rich
Ambrose for driving. She was very proud of the City this past weekend. She
also heard very positive responses.
...
,
Cable TV Franchise (1050-30)
Cm. Lockhart asked about the status of the cable television meetings, and asked
if anything is going on yet?
Mr. Ambrose stated he would check on the next meeting date.
..
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 150
ABAG General Assembly (140-10)
.
Cm. Lockhart asked if anybody is planning on attending the ABAG General
Assembly meeting on sustainable development. She looks forward to attending
..
Recycling Programs (810-60)
Cm. Lockhart stated she attended the Alameda County planning meeting today
and was surprised at the number of cities requiring recycling with remodel
projects. She asked if we have any program like this? Would it be helpful to get
some plans from other cities? This would be valuable in helping us reach our
goals. Cm. Lockhart stated she will get some and pass them on to Staff.
Cm. Lockhart stated they are developing waste intensity measures so people can
measure the same way throughout the County. This will go out to all the cities
and to the county.
....
.
Care Centers (595-30)
Cm. Lockhart asked with regard to unlicensed care facilities, if we are going to
participate in this study?
Mr. Ambrose stated we have not had a problem in this area.
..
Education Summit (515-60)
Mayor Houston reminded the Council of the Education Summit the fIrst week in
May. They should assemble a list of names and contacts in order to make sure
we get ours in also.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 151
.
. Mr. Ambrose indicated he thought they may try to do something just on a
Saturday. On the other dates suggested, they couldn't get facilitators.
..
St. Patrick's Day Festival (950-40)
Mayor Houston complimented and thanked Staff for putting on the festival. God
blessed us with good weather on Saturday. Sunday wasn't quite as good, but
Sunday was good weather for running. Next year we can get our race
sanctioned so this will be even better. He asked when the de briefing of the
whole festival would occur. It would be good to put comments on paper.
Mr. Ambrose stated he would get a timeframe to the Council.
..
Crosswalk (590-40)
. Cm. Lockhart stated she was stopped by a parent at Frederiksen School and
asked about crosswalks at Hibernia & Dublin Boulevard in eastern Dublin. The
neighbors are concerned because they like to walk over and look at what's
happening at the shopping center.
Mr. Thompson stated Staff will take a look at this. He stated he thought there
was a light there, so there would be a crosswalk.
+-
Parade (950-40)
Cm. McCormick mentioned the entry in the parade for Dublin Pride Week won
an award.
...-..
.
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 152
St. Patrick's Dav Luncheon (950-40)
Mayor Houston reminded everyone that tomorrow, St. Patrick's Day, is the
Chamber of Commerce's annual luncheon.
..
ADJOURNMENT
11.1
There being no further business to come before the Council, the meeting was
adjourned at 10:47 p.m.
Mayor
AITEST:
City Clerk
'I~
i;~
CITY COUNCIL MINUTES
VOLUME 18
REGULAR MEETING
March 16, 1999
PAGE 153
';. ,
.
.
.