HomeMy WebLinkAboutReso 231-06 Purchase 6401 Dublin Blvd
RESOLUTION NO. 231 - 06
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
*********
APPROVING SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
WITH ANGELO GASP ARE, PROPERTY OWNER, AND
CONOCOPHILLIPS COMPANY AND KAYO OIL, LESSEES,
FOR THE PURCHASE OF A PORTION OF PROPERTY IN FEE
LOCATED AT 6401 DUBLIN BOULEVARD
WHEREAS, it is necessary for the City of Dublin to widen and improve the intersection of
Dublin Boulevard and Dougherty Road as part of Capital Improvement Program Project No. 96852,
Dougherty Road Improvements - Houston Place to 1-580; and
WHEREAS, in order to accomplish this goal, it is necessary for the City to acquire a portion of
property in fee located at 6401 Dublin Boulevard; and
WHEREAS, along with the Grant Deed for the subject portion of 6401 Dublin Boulevard, the
City must procure a Temporary Construction Easement in order to facilitate construction of the Project;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Dublin approves
the Settlement Agreement with the property owner, Angelo Gaspare, Trustee of the "A&O Gaspare Trust"
Dated February 10, 1993, and lessees ConocoPhillips Company and Kayo Oil Company.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Mayor is authorized to execute the agreement, attached
hereto as Exhibit "A".
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 19th day of December, 2006, by the following
vote:
AYES: Councilmembers Hildenbrand, Oravetz, Sbranti and Scholz, and Mayor Lockhart
NOES: None
ABSENT: None
ABSTAIN: None
ATTEST: ~ ~
, City Clerk
Reso No. 231-06, Adopted 12/19/06, Item 4.8
Page 1 of 1
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
This Settlement Agreement and General Release of All Claims (the "Agreement")
is made as of the 19th day of December, 2006, by and between plaintiff City of Dublin
(the "City"), a public body, corporate and politic, and defendants Angelo Gaspare,
Trustee of the "A&O Gaspare Trust" Dated February 10, 1993 (hereinafter "Gaspare")
and ConocoPhillips Comp any and Kayo Oil Company (hereinafter jointly "Conoco
Defendants"), with reference to the following facts and purposes:
RECITALS
WHEREAS, the City is vested with the power of eminent domain to acquire real
property by virtue of Article I, Section 19 of the Constitution of the State of California,
Section 37350.5 of the Government Code of the State of California, and Sections
1240.010 and 1240.110 of the Code of Civil Procedure of the State of California.
WHEREAS, on July 15, 2005, the City commenced the action entitled City of
Dublin v. Angelo Gaspare, Trustee of the {~&O Gaspare Trust" Dated February 10,
1993, et al., Alameda County Superior Court, Action No. VG 05-222845 (the "Action"),
to acquire a portion of the real property and real property interests located at 6401
Dublin Boulevard, Dublin, California, identified as APN 941-0205-010-03 (the "Subject
Property") as set forth in the Complaint on file in this Action and attached hereto as
Exhibits A, A-1 and B, and B-1;
WHEREAS, as of the commencement of the Action, the Subject Property
consisted of one parcel with a gas station, convenience store and car wash on it;
WHEREAS, Angelo Gaspare, Trustee of the "A&O Gaspare Trust" Dated
February 10, 1993, is the fee owner of the Subject Property as set forth in the Litigation
Guarantee Title Report of Chicago Title Insurance Company dated January 4,2005;
WHEREAS, ConcoPhillips Company and Kayo Oil Company have a lease
interest in the Subject Property;
WHEREAS, Defendants Gaspare, ConocoPhillips Company and Kayo Oil
Company, and each of them, have agreed to accept the consideration, terms, and
conditions as set forth in this Agreement, as compensation for their claims and interests
in the Subject Property and the claims they could have in this Action;
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
1
WHEREAS, the City, and the above named Defendants, and each of them, wish
to settle any and all claims against each other that were or could have been raised in
this litigation;
The parties hereby agree as follows:
AGREEMENT
1. As payment in settlement of the claims from or otherwise relating to the
Action, as described herein, the City hereby agrees to pay a total of
FOURTY-NINE THOUSAND NINE HUNDRED FIFTY-EIGHT DOLLARS
($49,958), to Defendants ConocoPhillips Company and Kayo Oil
Company as just compensation for their real property interests at issue in
this Action (the "Conoco Settlement Amount").
2. As payment in settlement of the claims from or otherwise relating to the
Action, as described herein, the City hereby agrees to pay a total of ONE
HUNDRED AND SIX THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED AND NINETEEN
DOLLARS ($106,219), to Defendant Gaspare as just compensation for its
real property interests at issue in this Action (the "Gaspare Settlement
Amount").
3. Defendants Gaspare, ConocoPhillips Company and Kayo Oil Company,
and each of them, agree that payment of the Settlement Amount
constitutes just compensation and full satisfaction for each and every
claim, cause of action or liability, known or unknown, now or in the future,
against the City, its agents, employees, or authorizing authorities or public
entities, which is asserted or might have been asserted by Defendants,
and each of them, in the Action, including but not limited to, specific
apportionment of the Conoco Settlement Amount, severance, loss of
goodwill, relocation assistance and benefits, compensation for
improvements, personal property inventory, furniture, fixtures, machinery,
equipment, inverse condemnation, pre-condemnation damages, interest
and any damages of any nature and for any causes.
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
2
4. Payment of just compensation to the Conoco Defendants in the amount of
$49,958 shall be made payable to Kayo Oil Company and forwarded to
ConocoPhillips and Kayo Oil Company c/o Dawn Ceizler, Glynn & Finley,
LLP, One Walnut Creek Center, 100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500 Walnut
Creek, California 94596, for disbursement to Conoco Defendants.
5. Payment of just compensation to Gaspare in the amount of $106,219 shall
be made payable to Angelo Gaspare, Trustee of the "A&O Gaspare Trust"
Dated February 10, 1993, and forwarded to Mr. Gaspare c/o Tom Nagle,
Erickson, Beasley, Hewitt & Wilson, 482 Ninth Street, Suite 200, Oakland,
California, 94607.
6. The Agreement shall be placed on the Agenda of the earliest regularly
scheduled Closed Session of the City Council that it can be put on with
adequate notice for discussion and approval, but no more than thirty (30)
days after execution of the Agreement by all Defendants.
7. This Agreement does not apportion the amounts of the Conoco
Defendants settlement ($49,958) or the Gaspare settlement ($106,219)
between any of the defendants. All funds being distributed to each party
represent the settlement amount between the plaintiff and that
defendant(s). Nothing in this Agreement shall make the City liable to any
individual defendant for the apportionment of any amount of compensation
paid to any defendant.
8. This Agreement does not include nor address the respective rights of the
individual Conoco Defendants in and to the amount of $49,958 paid to
said defendants. Any and all claims or rights regarding the apportionment
of this amount of compensation shall be determined separately and
without the involvement of the City.
9. As further settlement of this Action, the parties agree that the Conoco
Defendants, and each of them, are responsible for the installation of a new
planter in the existing signage island, including concrete curbs,
landscaping and irrigation; relocating signage; payment of the cost of the
closure of monitoring wells; and payment of their professional fees, the
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
3
costs of all of which are included, without limitation, in the Settlement
Amount. As more fully described below, the Conoco Defendants'
obligation to install new concrete curbs shall be limited to new concrete
curbs and landscaping around the existing sign island.
10. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
widen two driveways: (a) Dougherty Road (south driveway) - increasing
the width from the existing 34 feet at the street to 48 feet at the street (40'
at the back of the sidewalk); and (b) Easterly Dublin Blvd driveway -
increasing the width from the existing 24 feet at the street to 40 feet at the
street (34' at the back of the sidewalk). In light of the widening of the
existing driveways by and at the cost of the City, the parties agree that
there will be no need to relocate the fuel filler caps.
11 . . As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
signing and striping the carwash exit to a right turn only and the northerly
Dougherty driveway to entrance only; the City will install signs to
supplement the arrows.
12. Attached as Exhibit "C," hereto and incorporated herein by this reference,
is a "sketch" which generally shows the revisions for the proposed future
improvements as set forth in this Agreement, including without limitation:
lay-out of the reconfigured driveways; relocated lights, bollards; painted
arrows; relocated backflow devices; new sign location; relocated parking
stall.
13. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
adjust the carwash manhole to grade; the carwash driveway will not be
exiting straight out onto Dougherty Road, accordingly, only one manhole
will require adjustment to grade. The parties further agree that should the
adjustment take longer than seven (7) calendar days, the City agrees to
pay liquidated damages in the amount of $525 per day as lost revenue for
each day in excess of seven days.
14. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
install two bollards, as shown on the sketch attached hereto, one on either
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
4
side of the existing tank vents near the carwash exit (NOTE: The vents
are actually closer to the south curb than shown on Exhibit C - the 76
base map).
15. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
relocate a total of three yard lights as follows: (a) Two lights (one near the
car wash and one at the northerly corner of the identification sign planter),
shall be moved and the circuitry installed by and at the cost to the City,
with no underground splicing of electrical conductors/wires, and the name
of the subcontractor performing the work provided to the Conoco
Defendants a reasonable time prior to construction; and, (b) A third light at
the westerly Dublin Blvd driveway will be removed by the City's
underground utility contractor as the light is in the center of the trench. It
is believed that the adjoining development will be placing a light on the
westerly side of the driveway which will serve to replace the 76 Station
light being removed.
16. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
pay the cost of relocating the back flow devices currently located in a
landscaped area behind the public right of way along Dublin Boulevard.
Dublin San Ramon Services District has verified that the back flow devices
may be placed in tandem. Conoco Defendants have agreed that the drive
isle parallel and nearest Dublin Blvd. can be narrowed by the City at the
City's cost by six (6) inches. The City will allow a long term
encroachment, in the form attached hereto as Exhibit "0," into the back of
the sidewalk for the remainder of the required space for the backflow
devices.
17. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
pay $9,308 (already included in the Conoco Settlement Amount set forth
above) as subcontractor costs and consultant oversight fees for three
replacement well drilling and complete installation to replace abandoned
monitoring wells MW-2, MW-4, MW-6, and MW-7.
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
5
18. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
give Mr. Bill Borgh, agent for the Conoco Defendants, a minimum of one
week notice of the commencement of construction work on the site.
19. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, defendant
ConocoPhillips Company agrees that it will not rely upon the
condemnation as a basis for early termination of the lease associated with
the property at issue in the Action.
20. Should any term, clause, provision or attachment of this Agreement be
found to be invalid, the validity of the remaining terms, clauses and
provisions shall not be affected.
21. This Agreement is subject to ratification by the City Council of the City of
Dublin and has no effect until it is approved by said body.
22. Upon receipt of the amount of $25,677 (the difference between the
amount the Conoco Defendants will receive from the funds on deposit with
the State ($24,281) and the amount of the settlement ($49,958)), the
parties will execute a Stipulation for Entry of Judgment, in the form
attached hereto as Exhibit "E," approved by counsel for all parties, which
conforms to this settlement agreement.
DATED: \)e.-~~ ~2006
CITY OF DUBLIN
(/~, , \ '" C_/~l'Al /,'
B \.1> '5/(4 -" '/. /;.:rr #/ ,~i ,(,,1',. l ,(,
y:."f6''';;' "?i::'/f; .;:;/c;,J(:~',~ r 'h/'l(.,&'/; /1
/ . .
JA~ETLOCKHART,MAYOR
l'
j\; tU:'>I-; ~o.w.-.. ~
'f&uJV\ ~\~I ~ ~
DATED: September
,2006
ANGELO GASPARE, Trustee of the
"A&O Gaspare Trust" Dated February 10, 1993
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
6
18. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, the City agrees to
give Mr. Bill Borgh, agent for the Conoco Defendants, a minimum of one
week notice of the commencement of construction work on the site.
19. As further consideration for the settlement of this Action, defendant
ConocoPhillips Company agrees that it will not rely upon the
condemnation as a basis for early termination of the lease associated with
the property at issue in the Action.
20. Should any term, clause, provision or attachment of this Agreement be
found to be invalid, the validity of the remaining terms, clauses and
provisions shall not be affected.
21. This Agreement is subject to ratification by the City Council of the City of
Dublin and has no effect until it is approved by said body.
22. Upon receipt of the amount of $25,677 (the difference between the
amount the Conoco Defendants will receive from the funds on deposit with
the State ($24,281) and the amount of the settlement ($49,958)), the
parties will execute a Stipulation for Entry of Judgment, in the form
attached hereto as Exhibit "E," approved by counsel for all parties, which
conforms to this settlement agreement.
DATED:
, 2006
CITY OF DUBLIN
By:
JANET LOCKHART, MAYOR
r(;) <t--ioh~r
DATED: $.Ql3tcr'l.6er 1,17 , 2006
ANGELO GASPARE, Trustee of the
"A&O Gaspare Trust" Dated February 10, 1993
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
6
DATED: September
DATED: September
Approved as to form:
DATED:~'2006
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
,2006
B(~do h~~
Angel Gas~re, .
CONOCOPHILLlPS COMPANY
By:
NAME
TITLE:
, 2006 KAYO OIL COMPANY
By:
NAME
TITLE:
MEYERS, NAVE, RIBACK, SILVER & WILSON
B
Claudia J. Gor m
Attorneys for Plaintiff
City of Dublin
7
By:
Angelo Gaspare,
DATED: September ~ , 2006
DATED: September
Approved as to form:
DATED:
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
JCf
,2006
NAME 1=>\A~\ 8~~tll'o"
TITLE: l\ HantL{ -[ () - 'kU::J-
,2006
NAME ?\O\~\ ~;WI.~
/" TITLE: A-nor rif JJ -- (VI - ~(J-,
I
MEYERS, NAVE, RIBACK, SILVER & WILSON
By
Claudia J. Gorham
Attorneys for Plaintiff
City of Dublin
7
DATED: September
DATED: September
Approved as to form:
DATED:~' 2006
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
,2006
By:
Angelo Gaspare,
CONOCOPHILLlPS COMPANY
By:
NAME
TITLE:
, 2006 KAYO OIL COMPANY
By:
NAME
TITLE:
MEYERS, NAVE, RIBACK, SILVER & WILSON
B
Claudia J. Gor m
Attorneys for Plaintiff
City of Dublin
7
DATED: (0 (r~ , 2006
DATED:
859262
,2006
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
GLYNN & FINLEY, LLP
By (JCl.uM ~
Dawn Ceizler
Attorneys for Defendants
ConocoPhillips Company and
Kayo Oil Company
ERICKSON, BEASLEY, HEWITT & WILSON, LLP
By
Thomas Nagle
Attorneys for Defendant
Angelo Gaspare, Trustee of the
"A&O Gaspare Trust" Dated February 10, 1993
8
DATED:
,2006
DATE~~2006
859262
Settlement Agreement
City of Dublin v. Gaspare
GLYNN & FINLEY, LLP
By
Dawn Ceizler
Attorneys for Defendants
,ConocoPhillips Company and
Kayo Oil Compa ny
ERICKSON, BEASLEY, HEWITT & WILSON, LLP
~
By "
omas agle
A~~:n:~~ fa - efendant
Angelo Gaspare, Trustee of the
"A&O Gaspare Trust" Dated February 10,1993
8
EXHIBIT A
to the SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
. .
"
-'
rt
(
FEE ACQUlSITION
APN No. 941-0205-010-03
Exhibit "A"
All that real property situate in the City of Dublin, County of Alameda, State of California,described as
follows:
Being a portion of Parcels 1 and 2 described in that certain document recorded on February 16, 1993 in
Document No. 93052324, Alameda County Records, .
Also being a portion of P ARCEL-D as shown on that certain map entitled "PARCEL MAP 756", filed
for record on October 8, 1971 in Book 72 of Parcel Maps at Page 13, Alameda County Records, more
parti~ular1y described as follows:' . .
BEGINNING at the most northerly corner of the parcel described in that certain "Public Right of Way,
Grant Deed", recorded on October 9,1996 in Document No. 96259547, said county records, said corner
also being a point on the southwesterly right of way of Dougherty Road, a varying width right of way, as
shown on said map;
Thence along the northwesterly line of last said parcel, also being the northwesterly line of said
PARCEL -D, South 55016'51" West 8.10 feet to the general southwesterly line of said parcel described
in Document No. 96259547, said point being the beginning of a non-tangent curve to the left, having a
radius of 863.08 feet, to which point a radial line bears South 64016'05" West, the TRUE POINT OF
BEGINNING;
(
Thence leaving last said lines and along the general southwesterly, westerly and northwesterly line of
said parcel described in Document No. 96259547, the following three (3) courses:
1) Along said curve, through a central angle of 6046'56", an arc length of 102.16 feet to the
beginning of a reverse curve having a radius of 42.00 feet;
2) Along said reverse curve, through a central angle of 87047' 40", an arc length of 64.36 feet;
3) South 55016'51" West 109.70 feet to the southwesterly line of said Parcel 2;
Thence leaving last said northwesterly line and along last said line, North 34043'09" West 3.85 feet;
Thence leaving last said line and across said Parcels 1 and 2, the following three (3) courseS:
1) North 57008'06" East, 100.83 feet to the beginning of a curve to the left, having a radius of
37.00 feet;
(
Exhibit "A"
Page 1 of 2
..:'~
I
2) Along said curve, through a central angle of 87042'04", an arc length of 56.63 feet to reverse
( curve having a radius of 945 .00 feet;
3) Along last said reverse curve, through a central angle of 6033' 11", an arc length of 108.08 feet
to said northwesterly line of said.Parcell;
Thence along last said line, North 55016'51" East, 8.78 feet to the TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING of
this description.
Containing an area of 1,740 square feet, 0.04 acres more or less.
A plat showing the above described parcel is attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit "B".
This descripti.on was prepared by me or under my direction in conformance with the Professional Land
Surveyors Act.
(
-?'-C~
Billy Martin, LS 5797
License Expires 6/3012006
K:'Main\2001\20016002-10IlEGAlIGi'SPI\RE_ B.doc
-
/ff~ /, 20ds
,
Dated:
(
Exhi bit "A"
Page 2 of 2
EXHIBIT A-l
to the SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
(
TKMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT
APN No. 941-:0205-01O~03
Exhibit "A"
All that real property situate in the City of Dublin, County of Alameda, State of California,
described as follows:
Being a portion of Parcels 1 and 2 described in that certain document recorded on February 16,
1993 in Document No. 93052324, Alameda County Records,
Also being a portion of P ARCEL-D as shown on that certain map entitled "PARCEL MAP
756", filed for record on October 8, 1971 in Book 72 of Parcel Maps at Page 13, Alameda
County Records, m?re particularly desoribed as follows:
BEGlNNING at the most riortherly corner of the parcel described in that certain "Public Right
of Way, Grant Deed", recorded on October 9, 1996 in Document No. 96259547, said county
records, said corner also being a -point on the southwesterly right of way of Dougherty Road,. a
varying width right of way, as shown on said map;
(
Thence along the northwesterly line of last said parcel, and continuing along the northwesterly
line of said Parcell, South 55016'51" West 16.88feet to the beginning of a non~tangent curve
to the left, having a radius of 945.00 feet,' to which point a radial line bears
South 65059' 13" West, the TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING;
Thence leaving said lines and southwesterly along said curve, through a central angle of
6033' 11", an arc length of 108.08 feet to the beginning of a reverse curve having a radius of
37.00 feet;
Thence along said reverse curve, through a central angle of 87042'04", an arc length of 56.63
feet;
Thence South 57008'06" West 100.83 feet to the southwesterly line of said Parcel 2;
Thence along last said line, North 34043'09" West 5.00 feet;
Thence leaving said line, North 57008'06" East 101.00 feet to the beginning of a curve to the
left, having a radius of 32.00 feet;
Thence along saidcurve, through a central angle of 87042'04", an arc length of 48.98 feet to
the beginning of a reverse curve having a radius of 950.00 feet;
Thence along last said reverse curve, through a central angle of 3010'18", an arc length of
52.59 feet;
(
Exhibit "A"
Page 1 of 2
,
.
(
Thence South 62036' 19" West 26.00 feet to the beginning of a non~tangent curve to the right,
having aradius of 976.00 feet, to which point a radial line bears South 62036' 19" West;
Thence northwesterly alol1g said curve, through a central angle of 3002'16", an arc length of
51.74 feet to said northwesterly line of Pal-cell;
Thence along said line North 55016'51" East 31.53 feet to the TRUE POINT OF
BEGINNING.
Containing an area of 2,697 square feet, 0.06 acres more or less.
The Temporary Construction Easement, to terminate upon completion of construction, for the
purposes and incidents thereto over, under, across and upon the above described parcel.
A plat showing the above described parcel is attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit
(tB" .
This description was prepared by me or under my direction m conformance with the
Professional Land Surveyors Act.
(
____~ A'_~'
Billy M in: LS 5797 t,
License Expires 6/30/2006 ~,
K:\Maln\2001\20016002-10\LEGAL\GASPARE_B_ TeE. doc '
/1411~ '7 -ze,dr
;-
Dated:
(
Exhibit "Alf
Page 2 of 2
EXHIBIT B
to the SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
.',
\\
FEE ACQUISITION
. \
LENGTH
B.l0'
3.85'
8.78'
PARcEL - D
72 M J3
\
LEGEND
APN - ASSESSOR PARCEl,NUMBER
DOC. NO - DOCUMENT NUMBER
\ P.O.B. - POINT OF BEGINNING
(R) - RADlAl .
\ sq. ft. - SQUARE FEET
\ T.P.O.B. - TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING
, \ l~) \6 ~
\ P.O.B," ~ >- "-'\0
'O? /\~ l:>
\ s~3-\~/ 10~ !
/".A\~
. DO' '9- OJ. (:): r..
'-& ""').....
00 ~Q.-:i '\ I
(I ~~ \ ~
1c>~.~~ \
\ . (1~,.AO \
"p. <9 1"-2 ~
~ ~ ~ ~~q..~<t
~ 0\ q;. L00" 1:- 't- \
~->~~.~/~ "7..L \
<5'. 6'"
\
\
\
\
\
~
~\ "\ ~
-> .'&
'B> ~.'O:
'0 -;. o.
ij). ..
BASIS 'OF BEARINGS
THE BEARING N 32"48'00" WEST, THE MONUMENT
UNE ON DOUGHERTY ROAD, BETWEEN FOUND
MONUMENTS AS SHOWN ON THE MAP ENTITLED
"PARGEl MAP 1043" FILED FOR REOORD ON
SEPTEMBER 28, 1973 AND RECORDED IN BOOK 80
OF PARCEL MAPS AT PAGE 29, IS USED AS THE
BASIS OF BEARINGS FOR THIS PLAT.
LINE
L1
l2
L3
LINE TABLE
BEARING
S 55"16'51" W
N 34"43'09" W
N 55'16'51" E
/
~I
INGRESS/EGRESS EASE. .' .
DOC. NO. 9352324
PARCEL 4 /
DOC NO. 91009057 /
PARCEL 2
PARcEL - c
12 M J3
FEE ACQUISITION
1,740 sq. ft. :l:
\ 0,04 acres :t
\
R=42.00'
b78T47'40"
L=64.36'
I
/
/
/
/
.58'
DOC. NO. 02598974
. APN: 941-0205-009-08
I
IK
lit"');".
PARCEL 3
DOC. NO. 9352324-
INGRESS/EGRESS EASE.
d<::)
~~~
~V0 /
~ ~O*'~~/
<'J., V n
-.,\>V ,,\J
V/
/
,.-
/
,/
/
REFERENCES
(D- 107 M 51
,/
/
/'
/
,/
/
BkF
4780 CHABOT DRIVE
SUITE 104
PLEASANTON. CA 94588
925-396':" 7700
925-396-7799 (FAX)
Sub ject EXHIBIT "Bit .
DUBLIN BLVD"-DOUGHERTY RD. WIDENING
Job No. 20016002
By BL Dote 03/07 /05 ChkdRlH
SHEET _ 1 OF 1
EII&ED I 8uImIlIIl 'PIMB'BI
Kf\l;ur01\Dr~oop\n;,n\nl.'t..\C;Al;PARf,d"" P/?71POU,<; 1I.4?100 AM Pl;T
EXHIBIT B-1
to the SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
.,
TEMPOR. ~YCONSTRUCT10N
\
,
. ,
1~SEMENT
. LEGEND
APN - ASSESSOR PARCEL NUMBER
DOC. NO. - DOCUMENT NUMBER.
. \ P.O.B. - POINT OF BEGINNING
(R) - RADIAL
\ sq. ft. - SQUARE FEET
\ T.P.O.B. - TRUE POINT OF BEGINNING
T.C.E. - TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION
\ . EASEMENT -9, t
\ 'f>~o
\ P.O.B. r~) ~\Gl-, !
,. ~'9 O~~
V ~,~t:~ ,/ ~ '\'1>
S c/ \~ ...
\~
\
\
BASIS OF BEARINGS
THE' BEARING N 32~4B'OO" WEST, THE MONUMENT
/. UNE ON DOUGHERTY ROAD, BETWEEN FOUND
vlONUMENTS AS SHOWN ON THE MAP ENTln.ED
"PARCEL MAP 1043" ~LED FOR RECORD ON
SEPTEMBER 28. 1973 AND RECORDED IN BOOK 80
OF PARCEL MAPS AT PAGE 29, IS USED AS THE
BASIS OF BEARINGS FOR THIS PLAT.
CURVE, TABLE
CURVE DELTA RADIUS LENGTH
C1 6'33'11" 945.00' 108.08'
C2 8T4-2'04" 37.00' 56.63'
C3 8T4-2'04" 32.00' 48.98'
C4- 3"10'18" 950.00' 52:59'
C5 ~, 3'O2~16" 976.00' 51.74'
LINE
L1
12
L3
L4
LINE TABLE
BEARING
S 55,6'51" W
N 34"43,'09" W
S 62'36'19" W
N 55"16'51" E
.PARcEL ~ c
12 M J3
('
DOC. NO. 02598974
APN: 941-0205-009-08
LENGTH
16.8S'
5.00'
26.00'
31.53'
\
INGRESS/EGRESS EASE. I
DOC. NO. 9352324
PARCEL 4 ~
DOC NO. 91009057 ---./j ,
PARCEL 2 /
I
\ ~.OO' -<>
\ ,&c5'.
<'0 ~ 9-A
\ 000,,,-
\ '-1-;~%~
\ \' 9 0~.AO'
\ <9 7~ ~
(1\ \ ~ 9t-'*'~
is' \ (l 1.5'.... /;;. '/f--
l:) \ A/'. ""1.5' ".
~\,;/~'/~y\)y( \\ j'S .J-
s c"i-J. :/ 5.00' \ \ \
/ c;..\ \
\\~ \
~L \
C31
{, I
/; / /
PARcEL,-D ~ /
12 .M J3 , ~ ,/
19~ \ \a\~~ /. TEMPORARY
~~ "s.'l/~:s// CONSTRUCTION
~ll" \ ,ar"o 'l. ~ fjrp EASEMENT
<:,'r~ 'l' ",;~ ~ '/ .2.69, 7 sq. ft. :l: /
\ ~ ~ -r", ~arb / . 0.06 acres ::J:/
r , ~ 1"\'0 / ..-
~ ~ ~.'V ~ /'
#' c; ~ / ~~ /'
/: / .~~..-
// 0"v0/
. -Q) ,,,s. ...-
y.~ ~ ~,v/,
~~ <::?,. /'
<V/
..-
/
LANDS OF ANGELO GASP ARE
TRUSTEE OF THE A& 0
GASPARE TRUST
PARCEL 1
DOC. NO. 93052324
APN: 94-1-0205-010-03
10' P.U.E.
DOC. NO.
, 96251701
I
PARCEL 3
DOC. NO. 93052324
INGRESS/EGRESS EASE.
Bkf
REFERENCES
<D'"" 107 M 51
..-
/
,/
4780 CHABOT DRIVE
SUITE 104-
PLEASANTON. CA 94588
925-396-7700
925-396-7799 (FAX)
Subject EXHIBIT "B" , .
DUBLIN BLVD.-DOUGHERTY RD. WIDENING
Job No. 20016002
By RL Date 03/07 /05 ChkdRLH
SHEET _ 1 OF 1
1(.'..,urOI\OI6DO?\Dwn\nl.....\r.A.'>PARF rCF..,..n 1'11'7/1'005 11',17.11 PH PST
EXHIBIT C
to the SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
,
~
,I
11
'Z; u
..~i1
~
~
:1
ij
'1
H
;
(\!
......
Y""
.:-
I
1
~I
~
1
01
j
11
~j
.'
-1
:
';
.1
l
.l
;1
:1
:'j ~
a
~
ii
II
'I
~
"
\
~
'I
r
~
~
:1
'I
:'-, ;j
'j
,
,
1
~
j
4
._:)
~
'1
,
@!
~
s
~
-1
~
to
,
{
1
,
.j
u
a
i'
.1
j
I
-i
,l
~
~I
~
. . .. '_=~'_'.2~ "",.-'="'~''-' "'':'''''='-''''''''::''''-''=';'''''':''=~~''''':'~'''''''~''''';''=--'~f'-''-'''->'-''' ,.~"."",. ~,.:':'""-<=w~<,.;.,.,,",,~..;,r-:b-=-<"",=;'..:,,,,:<.,,,,,=,,,",2,",,~...:=-,,".,,...",,.,,==.~=""'..,"'.".."'.~"-'='"."~~-"-:"""" "="-'"::=/1""<''''''~':::' "'.'''''..'", ,. ..::
~
)
';.. .~
,'\'0 :.
,
:1
11
~
.i
,}
-'j
"0
!
~
U
i)
1
-- :::...-;:;y --: ...\
..r. ::t"
::E?
-::.::'
"
.::/.}'?....
""-.../J \
..~-;--
..'
'-'
6;
.-....
.1)
'..,/
0'5
,
'J
.~.
;;;
(.)
z
v
r;::
-.J.:
0..
..,,;,-:>-..-'....-~
':"~( !
~.:-..'
n
."
Ij)
t;..l
W
::--
"
-'
::L
C:j
o
0::
w
OJ
"<;
~
o
.',
_:'.:J.>
.C'....'
:',~~
;':?
~~ ....
~~
'",
.'
-- .-- -'"-- .-.
.:.-;;f
,""
;-
:~(
:j
=11
~~
00
I
!
I
I
I
.<_~. l
,.. .
'(;,.
=-
,~
\<'.
\
\~
\~
'.
\
\
\
\
<f)
.....
::r:
1.:...lW...J
~o::~
, :J. j,-
""-(/)W
wO'O'
0.::...J
.......0tJj
6ifi.t:5
---.
c..
)0-
r-
........
~
0..
0::
~
o
....l
....l
~
.......
z
.........
?
o
o
o
:\~\
\\ '
"
\\ ~\
\\ \\
..\ \,
~1, _... _ _',I, __._ ~ :~~---- _._-~""
'.
~
,::
~.>
~?
'.
L:..
'-
,
...
,
-.--..'!
"
>-
/' q
o 8
"
::'1
(0
J":
:;,)
(j)
.. .......
,) ::::
:::":;
":i;~-::~
;--::::a~y
;;...)
:0
o
:;,)
;--...
o
...~
., -
-. ~
'"
,-
.J~
'-0
.::~
::::~~ "
o
o
'J
o
,0
,)
,~
, ,
~,
..-;
------...
~ .~::;;_::;:::;;.J { .
"f ......_...:.;::<
,"_"loff~~"~"'''''''~''''''~_~ \
.:-=--.:::te:~------"'" 1 I
,
..""~~""""
....
c...:
._:;;
.."
.~J
.'
~
;<.J
<.;)
;S
:.{
c;..j
:)1
()
<:
,,-,
':C
<.
5
,)
.~
';,j
.E
'.c
<(
:.:J
0::
<(
/
- _._.._......~::-- ---- ---.---......:.;-
:. ~
(:> 1-
,) ~
..:. ~
,)) ,
'0 ~
- j
.~,{ :-
.... It..t
.>..J
n..
.~
o
({)
a
'7
S
- -- -.. ....- _..._--~..._--_..-
. .
'..-.-
''''J;
"'-
~
'.,
::.:::
<(
:2
n..
52
~
o
'-
o
.J
_\~
~.
V)
<(
::?"
--
>-
:':J
r-
ill
o
o
2
0::
tj
,~
,
-:..
.:'j
, -: "-
, . ..
=;..~"--:.,~
------
'"
,..-.: ::=:.::... ......
/,.' '.....
. . '''~''
" ::.......
.. "
.......,
..... "\
\ \,
\>..
, ,
\\
,\
\\
'\ \ \..
\\ \\
\ . \
\ \ \ \.
~.~ \\
\\ \ \
\'::::.-=.:.--~-_l \
----\
....<~.::::.."':'::':=-~;
............ ........" f ~
........-:-,....-;.. ~,
..-:/~.../ !;
\..\.. .
\\
''-
,\
"
.\
\\
\, "
;I
/
I
!
<.;)
z;:::
r2::t
e::: ....-
.../'~
"'W
0..0::
..--..
.:::.,~
)
/
/
.'-.
.;
,;
;.
\\
\\ .',
. \ \ ~
\\ \\
\~ \\
~~;::;:::>-j'
.-..-..--
/:;.:?::::":==':::~1
......<-..' ~;
/,,'_.? i:
:\\( ;:
,\ :1
\\ 1i
\, :,
\ \ I,' I
\\ .1
~~ Ii
\\ .l
\\ : i
'\ .'
\\, ;!
\\ /",;
\\
\ \ : ~
\\ lj
\\ J J
'\. l
">:':::' /
w
z
.::J
w..J0::
c6~
::)z
ow
a0
iD3:
NO
-l
............J
6~
~
w
z
:i
~-
~Cl
..Jz
CLw
oZ:>
1-w
en...J
..........0
2z
.....,~
..........
Z
.........
-~
~. ...:-,.
.'
"
~'"';
o
.z
-.:!:
-1
~
Cl
w
CL
~
(/)
o
<>
;l ~.:;;~';l~
::: -;
~ ,
. / ~:'-""
, . .
0,,\ .-:.~:
.,."."
,.;
>>"
'::::....'
'-
,,-
\
\,11
\n
,
'}l
:"'1
~;:i
.,
~""J ~
....u)j
._,
.."......~
-....~
.;.:.?'"
~.,(
.~.,
:.~
~
........:'.:;t~
">
".
...:.~
"
~\..._----.....~
'<\ I
) I I I I I I I
I . .,' .! i j ; i Ii,
',' .~ c...~""'''\,,~.~\~~~\2') "-;::-~::>fC':.~ '.:-~'> ,--:::z::, ,-:>....~ .::.::::f$.... ~.~4 ~..___.(,."':O m'~ ..;r~",,"> ',.,:t.::",;{'; or..'}'~ "':",\~ c.......~l~ :.,.~ .:.....~~"'? (~
~, "', '..! : t l i 1 ! ~
I : '3'.' . r::--.:J! l ..-:-""" i'=~ _I.. ....l';.
'I . - " r'" '.' . .~. -~-......-.........-....-.~.. ......_....~..~l........'..~-.'-..........,.........'....:--.:...:..-:.:.....:.-~f,.:..=....:.:-=~l... } ~~
1----.~~- n ..~.... Ii
! ! . ~ i~\,) ! \ (I ~
I 1 ~ ig"'~f"" i Ir~1 'I
I : ij l~\..;! ; !~.tl~~; .{
1 ' !f ~ ! :! i~
J ~ \o,.;;tr~ ' I :L-s: 1:
1 .// \ ~;. ,,1 ;: i
. ; ./-~ 1 : . '\ j : : I
! :! . . ,~\ ' i :~1 i ' '. \ 0:
.. ~ \ ~~~ / 'I : \ '.'':; : i I .. ~ < :
: : '} '. -;-' 'l. t .......? ~ . ., . : I, I,
.' -.---------~_-__--I.---<:,....,,-----. . -... --... .-.. - . . 1'-' . '.'-"---' ....-. --~'---"-'----------""l ~~
;f . I ~ i i I ; .' J I :'{J-~'
I, ~ 'I ~ ' , p \. ~
II I L I I I lil;~ i 3 ~
.11 I l' a I ~ .. '" I r, ~
" W: I' ~ " , t ----18 1 ;! ~ ~
l'I:~ "':j' -(..,., \' .~/ ... ; I ~ zE-;
r ~~:" : >~,' ~;. ;A.. . :~' . ~:. 6.t : '~!",",
i,"C\:>-/ '"''''l! \' I ~ ~
'.'1 I llll I I I;' d~;>-
I B '. i I ';.l.;: .'j'\ ~ ~
;\ ~ I' .. -. 'f . . . . "(' -r "\- ~ !-l
Y ..~___...~..........lo."'''''~,'''''' ..... ......... ....~.._~..n......,,_........__......___....
I @ , l@ ;'F :
I /B I /,'~1H :
u .--,..--...-"-"i.,,,,,,...-.. '''~'-'''l'.~~~.----b 1 '
'. ~
~ <Z'= I' . ='''''1 .. .
~.-;m .;:.~ ~ 1i'.::':f~ ~At>!_.""" ""a,.", __ <."",,* ~....,....... ~ ~ -",...x ~l,..,= ~ ""l:".=i=->>' ==
1 i\, l~ ffi ;:... 'j;:} I
t ~.J ii) \
I ,) tL \1.
\ L____,,__"__"_,u--,-,~~~'''' ----+-j
-_._-~_.~,=
'-,0
-...,,--------
--
<~
" ..,::
'-'>0...
..~.."~
.'-~>i
..>!
. .{
; .J~
,,~
....9
.~ .
.::: ;1
;
.~ :-=-....:.';.':-:":::-.:::-=:..._-~:;,":":'"".::~::-.':'::".::-'"":l;:-...~.:==-=.:.==--_""Z.:~_~"':~~-:cr~:.:'~~^';~~=,-::-.::x::.:=..';::::,==.::::-=:::"'-::;;::;"'-::::'":.:::.':::::.:.:~::::::-::;::::;.:::..-=.":'::':..~'=-..-:::-z:.,.'::;,'~':::.,:,,:,:::':,.~~-:,'-:-::--=,,:,,,:-..'':.~.'.,::...:.::::...::.--: :.:.-::;:;.::::':'.:.:..::..::.:::::....,-:::::::;-.:::::::~::::::::;:.::-.:::.~...:..'; ''': .':.~:-.. "-"::-,~" "~:'::+ t-..
.1
\ ~r-.,
ii};
!iW
uE
~) i
~ ~~I
~ d} I
to 1\, ~ I'
~ ~~ ~ t:
c:J q: l~;
'~l": ..
:: ~!;~ ;
;:) ~ ,"1 ~
:~ ~, ~ i
.J. \
~) ~
'D ":~ JI~
"j.: ?
} $
'<~ "-~JI
i3ou- 1~ ~
;; . "11
~ G ~ If
,- ~ ~ ~
V) W I'. 4 .
\.0 -J ~i :t ~ t'
~w 'ilth!
>~ ~,~~"'~~
-:;--;: ~ j ~ :~ . Ill!,
':::;'w 'I ~ ~ :. I '1
IL ~rrl ;: I P
O' ~ .:; I;,'
-...-.-- .~ ~ .'
-.~,,;J ~ '--
~IH .
:iffR I;
..r U~t:;' 1
i . 'I.' ~ ~l. y.1
f H!F ~I ::)
r Ha;;:z! .%
t L!~~ ~J
~ ~ ~ ..!;
,~ ~:,{' ~ :
:~; -:t--r.'
i! ;i'(l ,; I
,: .~'.j ,:
i!
p ;' ~ il
'1\ :. It
;; .
\l/$,
/r :
~ ~
I d
l!
i II ~I
~ ~~ ~~
(J} II "
z 1\ ;:
<( H ..
0:: :; ,
~ II ~~f
......... ,! ,'~f
L~ ; i ilL - -- '" -' ,,~c-.,Oc,.-,,''',,:'' ,",,-C,".," c. :-,:'u '.: .- .,:': '"." ,,".7'-0''::,0'': C.:',: '"':'C,.,,~' ...::.,
~ 'ro~' < ~w~ 1~t:_~_;tn~,~:I:'.!..~ .::.~~ ~~ :~ .Rr.\~.~~\-.-~~~~~)..~.~ ~~-'.~,'-":.' .....-.- .~ ."- - -." _.~-~ "--......-!~: ":- -. ". --~- -~;
-' '-'-' ::'- + .- . .::.., -. '..:: '" -.::. ;:. ~:. ~:. ::::.; .. ..~:: ",~,~,-::" ~::.: -:. ':-. ':'. ....
i- ~---l 1:>1" ~
~Q \ ;g~
....lZ ~6 ~l . '1' ~~
o...W aQ ~l ./
~~ ~6 ~l" JL "
.......0 ...--.::J ~
6~ 6~ ~
,.~
, !
..'.-':'T
" ::
.'~
~
'.'
.~
'- -. - '" ---......."
!
~
.'
(
J
"
'I
,i
:\
~i
"
~~
~
,(
:!
I!
~
.~
1\
~
:}
..;-....'1
" .:
:~]
: ..~':,
i ;
....~F
:~0
"
:1
"
~
~
~
~
I'
L\{l
:<
0'
U)
0,
Z'
....::~:~....:- ~-
...~.... .::.:-:~:...-...~ .. '. '" -
" - '::._~ >~"'::-:."'. .:::::.:::': -~.
2J\J(!(j (3)
'. .
H. "_"'_
.. - '- 'w_.
---'" --. .. ..t~_ Y;.' ~.,~ L f .....!
~~~~-=--.1
>1, "/'" \1 t... ,-""': _:-=-- .
'" \ <r.k ,..__~
" _._-~:;-......_-~
" / ----
.... "-- -"'--
.... --.... - '- ~ ..-
o ....- -- ~ ::: - -/::-
'1/1 - :::: ::: ::: ::: _ '_ _ _
i --'~-==~--._.
-'_ _ /1
-rl-
>ITIiM3QIS (':1)
'-
.
,
I
\
00
E-;
z
~
00;>-
~~
-.:r;Z
j~
OE-;
~U
O~
~E-;
E-;~
,Q~
~~
- ... .. y-
e
E-;
~
o
!-l
W ~
Z ,Q
~ -II. ~
~UU
~ S
~ ~A
S-~
E-;
E-;
~
o
PZ
J' $-
:::.z ~....... - _...~ :-:
~--.. .,~~
\
a
~
.:::::::::
.......- - __} {J
o
~
,', v
"': -<t
..~' n
'::2 8>
,.., ,
"70
::(z
~,~.
;j
~
..,) .~
'-
::>j)
~ r.(
co:::;:
::d
~ll
;::
:4
':::1
.,;{
...J
I"":,
--'"
.......-..
(-::;
....../
1!d1i~I' """_.....,.
, 'M
~
...~~ i
;.....j'
.,
I
0~t
!
I
"
n~\
~~ '-..... .
1~ \ ,
.K~ 'J
;-1 . It..
~11':. \ ~~=l-J
~ '\ '\'.
.; '. \ "., I
13 t.:')..... .... ;
~y <o"i' )
~J.J II:":;---r?y-':'" /
1~ i ,...-. 7'
\x < .', !--....:...._1------/
~3 ;1 f--'
>M q ~
" \1'
~~ il <
~~ ,., lie,
"~ 1 I
It r!
:Hi~;~., it r
, ~l
~ -". I
3 "
~' "
rl
----:1 ~
;
"
:j
l
~
~
!
I~
g~" :.: :~:;, <~'.~~ '~:: ~ '
,/
.J
, ..
l
!
"
..'
':'~
i'
0:: I;
LLl . .
i- 11
Z',
<(1'-.... -
....l ;;
0... "
........1 ~
2S11
~ ~
.'
"
. -.. ''',
I
"
"
<=
.
o
I
N
,....
'.
.;-:z..~
:~~
'....."
..,'
):)
'.\ :T' -~"
.;J~
\~G\
.....-/
"~
.=::'"
'\
"
~'.
:.'~
'."-
:l.~..,'
-:.
liJ~ -~
~ , . -:"
. .. '~,.; ".
~ ~ ........
...; .:.~ I "::..
J /
. ~ '...-:'-:
~ -..." ~
__ ~ . ...... ~ -,"""r-
"'" .:::...0/.
-.. ......
" '
:;: 'i
,~
~ ;
'_.. .1
.' ..":' ~."'~":' ~ ~'.:;~ ....;..':7:._ V'.':. ':'1T':-::.'7"~.,~-~";'.:.-:--:-:... .:::-..:."Z"..:::::...."":;:."':;'::.:~":'.~~~-...<};;:::::=_":; ~,,:'::::-:!;'.":"::":.-;;" .~~~......._.':.;;:~+:.:..l:,.~~.:'7_""~":'::'::~-:.~-=~=-';.=-~.:.:-z::...~~..;.~tt.::::."..:;;-:-'-;-".~,~:::=':':l'Z::::-.....~:-:::.-::':"=-:-..::.::::=:=..~.:::::.~-:c::-:::..:~.";:.;:..'":;'":.~:;;-..~.:..-;:-...::.~-::=::;::"'...:::::;-:c~~""C~..==':~~~.::..-::;::::=::~':.=;...:::'_.:.~"7."'.."::.:,..:::-:::"::..'
;':...-:;i
"di
Q
~
iZ2
o
~ifJ.
O~
~Z
~J:;:;.1
J:;:;.1~
~J:;:;.1
~>
~O
O~
~~
ifJ.~
Zl-I
e~
rJj~
>~
E2~
o
I
::;:1
-~JJ
....J
':::':"_",
I.:{~
,,I '.t
:;~#
,"<....y
:f 1"
"'- .
..-..='
d :~
,.;~
.....-Cf,t
{~
~:t i~
~f
f~
~, S
.1 .[
i'.,,~,
'".<..jI
..1"'11
\~.....~,J
E-<
00
;..J
><
~
\0
o
J
CO
l"-!
I
l.()
w
-.:1
25
lIJ
'7
,-;iF
-----
~7 Z
i-- -="'-=-.::.~=-_._._._._,_.:... -i...,,~
:;::
~
~
o
Cl
~
~
o
o
....l
W
a::
E-;
Z;
~
~
~
~
S \
\,
8 '),..1_ /<.,Jb
~ '-~~ '1_-=" .____
H. .~_..._~ }--------------
6 \\ '\ /'-~..
O \\ \
\\ ..
~ \\ \
~ \\:.
~ .. ~
q
"
'\
~\
:,
: t(
jL.~-\l.
~-. ..,\
,.. \1
\ ~
\:
d
'1
,.
i ~
ii
!( :
.:~
""';.."___!W___~
1 ~. ~
t;' .
.'
"
:;
;;
(IJ
~
Z
~
C
'Z:
:::>
o
0::
<:>
0::
w
a
z
::>
l-
I
o
::l
o
0::
..:(
>-..-....
.........e:.
zr::
~
~r~
/".......~'-\.
/'~ ~ e
/. /''''\ ~ '.:-......'-
.' / ~ ~~
\'5{J ,,' /~~y\ ~ ?~'<
~.......,. ',// // ~ ~ >~~
. /,., ./ y "<-7./ . ~ ~l ~) 1
,/ /. /X/' /' ):):.:::/',/ I
~ /'\ 0 / ,/
"'2(/~- . /;:!/ "'.'/, , ~ ~':/,
\\;{I:)/p/ //~~/
'\ .( 1;~ /., ./
If}jf / /
. \ ~/ / .'
/
/"'<
W
.........
\
"
....!...
~l
I
!
I
;~I
~~
.:.::\
5\
'c.l
! 1
':;1
:~;!
'1
I''''~~'\;~
"""R.;,
'I
'0
I
b
l'<')
o
1-
Cl
'9 W
! '-"
o ::>
;1; 8
,1:;
.,. :',:
".....~.~ .-....
~ ft
;g
!~
" .....
!~ :cn
:: ......
:,'~. ,'l<
:~
...
V
~
....
~
~
'.. ;.i"?:'l3SV .3
,~.'*
, \
\ "
:=~
''\.,
~J
'..j
,. ....
c)
f \.:.
'-2 ,':) ()
~.~~
'_.I'':'''': '"-
~~
:lJ
~
!3
i
, -.....
I \:,.l
IV
,I
'''----'';;::
.~~~
.-""'"
\\. ~'//
" /'"
\.....__//
~.;,nlLn
:)1--;80d
.'
'/:)\(1
~~O
.()
;; ).....
.< 6
-r
. '-
.;; ....'(
':..00
,
_/
'!
:(~~
_~tt..,
.1)-.Ot
,".-Q
J ,~
/'.
, ;
~_.,..._----------_... -.-1".-..-........-..--.-'....- .+-.. .-r~--l--j-_._-;...._._""
f i I I. . "'. "'~..-
" //
!l
i
nil
, " ij
,~""-
H
-'~~
i
i
,-I
..----__.........1--..--;)....
,,-
,.'>"=~
.:.~~.y
C;-
.<:-
'......
......,,:;~
.\ \\
!\ li
"',,:,$Y
'"
....
"
!
,
i
;....
'.
" ~..
"
,-
. ,}I.,f)
:1-
',l({,)
I'l~
, "
,/(
.K")
i~J.{)
nlVi
!4
.l: .~
.~ :...~
'::J t~
):1 "S
~ !l,:';(
)'\ }.:1 ~.l
',~ CC. ,,(
;:.:: 1:.) ;.,";
() .-. LtJ
(.) ..:; r;.}
,-., 'l, (Ii
~1.>J l'cl
Of".
~ ~t.y
ftl 23.
;;;:;~.z
~J"wO
~mQ'
lJi ".....
o ():.-:::.
D... t~- ...../
,(
.,,,,.,,,,,Jl
d
,~
-,'
'J.
::r
[,J
CJ
Vi
, ,
"
'.
:1
H ~
!l i
It I
it 1
,
;~
,~
1
Ii
t
~\
ia
:~
\1
~tl
--', jy
\\:::! ;
',.J l~
: :'~.n
,:;..~o
~
~li!~
...--..
w
......
.: .j,
.... J
,-;/
I
!
,
ii
':
'.
,
.'
I:
'{
!l
I'
l n
~ ...,,:,'. \. "'... '-':. "~.j ~
= ...... ~., .\.....'.. ,l:
8 ~:;-~'.~~<:. .',: '.~'.'>1 \
~ R . , ' , ."
~',,' -. "'. .'..... I!
r.....1 ~ '\. '. \. ~, '" I
~ if " " . ,':,
;>- f'~'>'~""" .:'~;
~ 11.,_ , '.. . ".
.~ I t<>::ti!
k "',,...... ,.'<:
I - -=r" _'::""'::'-'__,.;.,.J~
I y -........,.~. .......~. ,~ti
I ~ ;:
I ;\
"':I.~u
,
i
\'!
i~~ I
( ~
!
!
l
I
I
~'-'-....:-r~--.--._~=t
l I
I I
i ~"\\
' ~
. 1 .' I
. ! u:;
1 . :
t
1
,
:.....__. .~- .,.___.._.__....;J._
~ l'
).-. I
6 I
h?
(;)
I
I
I.
~,
r-
1"'Jl>'J:S&~~~-;,'v;\ -
~q((:tl.
:~;)01~
'..
"s
.......
w"7'x.'....",.$.1"'~"'~~
.\
(.;)
l
j!
,I
,
,,'
qJ(q~ <'.
~ 7J[,,,, "i}-
ce"" ~~"-l.(('7'>-
,:( , <!J.:z.r~
0.. < __
~ Tr.....
Nt <..(, <1..f:( .
-=-90Z. {(':.:,,, ,~j')......
~, .\., . <'..(v
p-:! s:: F' ".
.:;: l1J :'5
~~:)
,_ ,:r; ()
::!::wcc
_-' a:: -=
'..l..lOU
"
,.
"
"
ii
.'
"
il
,:
it I
. ~ j,.,
H
.H i
,", " ...... H )
l " ..... .... "..'n ~
~.:...:: :'.' ~ ..>:~'11 r"--
,',. ' . ". ~ .'., II '
l< >'" ;:~.:.~r:",\...
r:. '-1 \:
. ','
"
'J.t
()
Vl
o
o
<>
:\~\.\\
(, ::'\
..\ .
/, ':"
\,\ .\
\Z-:.\
"
"
\\ - ,\
.: .. ~\
. "
'.\'"\~\
',\ \;,
,\ ,~..
\' \\
';. \\
", '.
"
" \"
... \.
\\ \'.
.\ ..\
\~ ,'.
,\ \\
" '
'0
!
" .
\\ 'I.'
~ "
"
\ "
\\ \'
\', \
\ ...
C
'"\',1
.1
,"
'.:-> t\J
'- ::.>
'~~
:"-) (")
','
~ :~
~: [;.~
..'~ l',r:
".!
. [/;
t..)"'()
.....:---
:-l~~
2
r,...":.:,..~~';+.....:...:'.....~.. ~ ~.:z.'I..!'.~...-::..~..::::;.':~~!~":.::-:::...::~.:-:;:."::-....._:~...:....::i~:~.':.;.........-:-..":..:-: :_-.~...::. .:;'" ..,,~ ':'~-' '-.-:~
hi
,..,\
"
.,
,
,')
i
l
",)..\
'1'
Ii
.~'>\
;;:
(5
\~: It
".
,)
(( 1
\,\
(~
I
"'!
------
!\ :::,
.. ~ ::
~~.
~-""''''''''''
I
.;-t
....'":
.....,.....
"
'T..../
, )
',1
rr' '\
!
I
~
'1
~
:~ ~~:
E-;
t:t::
o
-
~
~
, ~
~ ~
\~
~
~
.'-
,,> ,....
,~
l ...~
,
~. .::5
'- ",
, ~
"
. H!
J "
.,..... ,'.:..-;
,\.(..,J,H,,,.'.. .'.\...... ......,..'.''>;..If.:.~:.-\J.:. ......:~,.':'.":'::.'';':;'(~~;.~.~J~~~ I. . -..a,\'?r:.~'.:J.;.'~...:~-2-:'.,f~('.~\,......r.'.1"'.n:...~;"':)....;:c;:..\'.... ''''''''j'~'' .' '.."" ..~.~r..
1 (~ I :"
J./ .. ~
'i" ".."
..,..... ,~,',""''''. " ....,. ,\.. "-.'\:,~ ...1V, ~ .
:t.'\!}l ....:IHd( \,1 t I
: "! . qt)')(,
.: \:.:'I~ir':~.'i<X) (;'~Mi{~ { '/",(J .~,1]1i\J
)~,i I
\ "" I / \ t l\- \
.~; '\:\~i' '\' ,
.1
i';
"\,I': ~'\~}i
->-..
""
..'t
."
,.
~.~,:;1 i~~
......:.;. 7~2
:j~l
.2 :: -:;:]
,
.J
..,
/
;?~
"
,(
'\
.\
'I ~'j
d ;?~
~i .
,
r
~
11'0:
. 't'"
~
l
~
~
i
11
H .
~ ~Ji
tl
~
~.
~
1
~
: ..tt~?
\.:.i::4A
,
.-
"\
I
;r
1
1
,1
1
't (V
I
;
I
.i
~
<1
1
'i
'j
:f-
u
~
"
~
'j
:1
"
:1
'\ ~,
'j , '
{
I
J
t
H
:l
~
~
fl
~:.
t:.~.
f'"
~
~l
~
.,
R
rr
n
"
~
ij
R.
"
~
~ tf;t
~
~
~
Q
~
ft
~
~.-
~
~
11
~
1,
:\
~
r,
i;,~
~
~
~
Ii
P,
ft
l~
:t
~t
~-
t!
*
"
(.\
"
~
Ii
~
;'\
~.
!<
R
{t
"
...
(~
!i
~
<!
'.
....~'h
.~y
:~....~~~
,'/':\'X"JS
,c~.
,~'C<<.#"
e..
. .
':.\., .
:>
i.
EXHIBIT 0
to the SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
CITY OF DUBLIN
PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT
100 Civic Plaza
Dublin, California 94568
(925) 833.6630
PERMIT NO.
ENCROACHMENTPERNUT
PERMIT TO DO WORK IN ACCORDANCE WITH CITY OF DUBLIN MUNICIPAL CODE CHAPTER 7.04
AND ANY SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS SHOWN OR LISTED HEREIN.
Telephone
Bond: Suret $
Cash:
Address:
e:
ApplicantlPermittee:
Name:
Total Fees:
Total Paid:
Recei t No.
PLEASE READ THIS PERMIT CAREFULLY. KEEP IT AT THE WORK SITE. TO ARRANGE FOR
INSPECTION, PHONE 833-6630 AT LEAST 48 HOURS BEFORE YOU START WORK.
JOB LOCATION:
(...40 l
t::>vB-1- i......J ~ l-iZ:\J~
DESCRIPTION OF WORK: (Attach 2 copies of plans. Attach additional pages if needed.)
I~~-r..c;;:t--J CF A Pt-..:yz.:T~~ c:>F \--JA-r~ ~G-~F~ ~iG..E:-s:....
A'l-J~ E;'l-J"::::"L-C;;:>c;;,..u~ it-J ~,-l c::- VZ-\<......HT t.?F w.~ ""'~ ~~"'-' -::::r-!
A-r-r..~H~ pt~. '::::"1""", 'TO' F\....~ i~~~-rl.:::>t-J,
Length of Excavation tJh4... I.f. Width o...J /.e..... I.f. Depth ;.J JI'\ ft.
U. S. A. IDENTIFICATION NUMBER (if applicable)
t....J /A. '~lUI-1t:r or ~-~f-'h I i'S..S".~,
ATTENTION IS DIRECTED TO THE GENERAL PROVISIONS PRINTED ON THE REVERSE SIDE OF THIS
PERMIT AND TO THE FOLLOWING SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS:
1. Permittee shall provide and keep current a certificate of Public Liability and Workers Compensation Insurance
which names the City of Dublin and its employees and agents as additional inSureds.
2. Worksites left in an unsafe condition will be secured by the City Maintenance Department and the cost charged to
the permittee.
,) Pl;;::e.t-", ~!3,.t::. ...,.""n....~ f"b\e- jo..Ji.......,eT.,...-t-'i--'~ [4'4 '\ '-(~s...
Prooecutlon of Work: All work authorized by the permit shall be perf'ormed In a worlananllke, diligent, and expeditious manner, and must be eomplete to the satlsfaetton of
the City Engineer.
L1ablUty and Damages: The permittee shall be responsible for all liability Imposed by law for personal Injury or property damage which may arise out of the work
permitted and done by permittee under this permit, or. which may arise out of failure on the part of the permittee to perf'orm his obligations under said permit In respect to
maintenance and encroachment. The Ittee shall protect and Indemnify the City of Dublin , Its officers and employees, and save them harmless in every way from all
ns or property that may arise out of or.be occasioned In any Wlly because of his operations as provided in this pennit.
City Engineer
By:
Date ofIssue:
Inspection Record (Note date, type of inspection, and comments.)
Com letion Date:
Ins ector:
CITY OF DUBLIN GENERAL PROVISIONS
1. The permittee shall begin work as authorized under this permit within 90 days from the start of issuance, unless a different date
is stated in the permit. If the work is not begun within 90 days of the time stated in the permit, the permit shall become void.
The permit shall be valid for a term of one year from the date of issuance, or as otherwise stated on the permit unless
discontinued by the use or removal of the encroachment for which the permit was issued. (City of Dublin Municipal Code
Chapter 7.04)
2. This permit is issued only for that portion of work in the City of Dublin right-of-way.
3. The permittee shall notifY Underground Service Alert (U.S.A.) at 800/227-2600 prior to excavation. All underground
contractors must have U.S.A. inquiry identification number.
4. Permittee is hereby cautioned that unless otherwise noted herein, traffic signal detector loops, wiring, etc., and irrigation
facilities shall not be disturbed. Request marking from City of Dublin Public Works Department at 833-6630.
5. All excavations shall conform to the requirements of the State of California Division of Industrial Safety.
6. Permittee shall furnish all safeguards for pedestrians and post warning signs in advance of work area for vehicular traffic and
shall clear the roadway of any obstructions or debris at the end of each work day. All safety devices shall conform to the latest
edition of the State of California "Manual of Warning Signs, Lights, and Devices for Use in Performance of Work Upon
Highway. "
7. No public road under the jurisdiction of the City of Dublin shall be closed to travel by the general public without special
permission of the City Engineer in writing. No lane closures will be allowed between 6:00 a.m. and 9:00 a.m. or between 3:30
p.m. and 6:30 p.m. At other times, at least one lane of traffic shall be kept open to the general public.
8. The pavement shall be sawed 6" outside the edges of the trench excavation in order to leave a smooth contour of the pavement
surface. Cutting with air tools or other devices leaving jagged edges shall not be pennitted.
9. No more than 300 linear feet of continuous excavation shall be opened at one time.
A. Excavate only that length of trench which can be backfilled the same day.
B. Except for bedding or shading requirements by utilities, Class IT Aggregate Base is the only acceptable backfill
material.
11.
Backfill shall be placed in accordance with the current "State of California Department of Transportation Standard
~pecification." 1lw s= :(~QR Qf 1A:::, iw:1J.es ~f tile UeRcll. bll':kti~thm the paved areas shall be
mchelJ AC. flU inehes .^..B. 8ft iRsR@s .^.JI.R. ;...Jc;Jf ~V..~ .?
Metal plates of sufficient thickness for legal load traffic or temporary paving 1-112" mimmum thickness shall be placed at the
end of each work day. Sidewalk construction areas shall be left in a safe condition.
Material excavated from within the City road right-of-way under this pennit shall be removed from within the right-of-way and
disposed of in a legal manner.
The right-of-way shall be left clean and orderly to the satisfaction of the City Engineer or his representative. The pennittee
shall give particular attention to maintaining the project in a dust-free condition while performing the various items of work
and during non-working periods, including weekends.
All work shall be done in accordance with the provisions of the Clean Water Act, which protects the storm drain system. No
dirt, rock, debris, concrete, or other materials or fluids will be allowed to enter the storm drain system during the course of
work on this permit.
Final asphalt concrete surfacing shall be placed within 5 days of completion of each 300 lineal feet of excavation. If the edges
of the trench have ravelled prior to fmal surfacing, the edges shall be resawn.
Line-and grade shall be left to the satisfaction of the City Engineer. All work shall conform to the current "State of California
Department of Transportation Standard Specifications" and City requirements, and the City Inspector shall be notified at 833-
6630 24 hours prior to pouring concrete.
10.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
A. Line and grade shall conform to grade of existing curb.
B. Line and grade shall conform to adjacent sidewalk.
C. Line and grade shall conform to plans prepared by B\,,-F G:\->~"'iI~~~S attached hereto and made a
part hereof.
D. No concrete shall be poured until forms have been inspected and approved.
E. Where concrete is to be removed, the edges are to be sawn at the nearest joint or score mark.
17. Where concrete is poured in a planter strip, score lines, construction joints, expansion joints, shall be continued across entire
sidewalk area. Where curb, gutter, and sidewalk are poured monolithically, the "back edge" of the curb shall be scored.
18. The permittee will notifY the proper utilities or persons that the location of an existing utility pole, fire hydrant, tree, or other
encroachment at the site or within the traveled way is such that relocation is necessary for proper execution of the work and/or
safety of the general public. Said relocation shall be made at no expense to the City of Dublin. In the event such encroachment
is not removed, the permittee will be pennitted to construct a blockout with dowelled bars in a location and in a manner
satisfactory to the inspector. Upon completion of relocation of such encroachment, permittee shall complete construction of
curb, gutter, and/or sidewalk within 30 days. .
19. No culverts or storm drains are to be cut or disturbed. Direction of flow and capacity of existing surface water drainage
facilities shall not be materially changed.
20. Access to public and private properties adjacent to the public road in which work is authorized shall not be denied by reason of
such work. Special measures shall be taken to insure passage for emergency vehicles over and at the site of work at all times.
21. In thG C:,Clat that auy rut"", m.pHhc:meftt of tile road right ef'!;ay Rll':essitat.." th.. ....In-;:atiga 9[111(;. wU...IUlldllU<;l.d. fM ',vhieh.-th,i.s
FnnH;" ;"'31",1, th'i" PemHttll@ sball wleElat@ ri:1lHl@ at h1~ ~ole expetl:tl6.
22. Priority shan be given to operations performed under contract let by the City of Dublin for certain work at this location.
Coordination shall be effected through said Contractor and the Project Representative for the City.
23. Any existing facilities damaged or removed in the course of the work shall be replaced in kind or better, including ground and
pavement surface, signs, striping, markers, curb, gutter, survey monuments, trees, and other vegetation, etc., to the satisfaction
of the owner of said facility.
24. The ea3h bondplaec:d rOl this '..ode win be held fer six (6) ffl6ftths after the flll8l ffispectien.; OOWEWef;-~vent...tI1e
pmMttl@ QQeli ~t @i.vethoCitythen9tice r@qmreQ ~ P-aFa~aph 3 ~@ and the, vlefk i~. . ~HnspeGtien-,
the oaBfl. 5elll! 'MIl 5e Rela fer 9fle year after tile final lBSfl8GtUlIl. ........c;:>'f fL--q......I~~ .~
PERMITTEE SHALL NOTIFY CITY INSPECTOR AT 833..(j630 WITHIN 3 DAYS AFTER WORK IS COMPLETED.
FAILURE TO COMPLY WlTII THESE PROVISIONS WILL RESULT IN THE CITY'S TAKING
WHAlEVER NffiASURES ARE NECESSARY TO CONFORM TO SAID PROVISIONS
AND BILLING THE PERMIITEE FOR ALL EXPENSES INCURRED.
-v- ?-
I/'/'
..\-,::>,r /'
~(... /"/)
I //
,//' -
y,/ -
'v ,/
/1 /,/
~~
': \
'? 1\
:/'"
i z-m-
AY TAPER
~e::>-JT ~ ~N<.'>)(I~)
~........r t:.L.."~ .
i
"D8- 2" +701
36.00' RT '
T
I ,
I-
I
"dT - .. +21.
4.00 RT
BEGIN, END
CAL T.Rf ANS
(ltYP A1-2
I
rt I 197,.
16+90 'MATCH LINE
SEe SHEET OF
>-
t-
~~ ~ ~""-O)('''''''~IE:.)
~N 11:..L.~ .
i
~
>'
z-m -
AY TAPER
"D8-2" + 70t
36.00' RT I
1-
"dT - " +21.
4.00 RT
BEGIN, END
CAL lRANS
(~Pf Aj-2
f'-- 197, .
16+90 'MATCH LINE
SEE SHEET OF
>-
f-
.........
EXHIBIT E
to the SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT
DAVID W. SKINNER, ESQ., SBN: 146285
CLAUDIA J. GORHAM, SBN: 142344
2 MEYERS, NAVE, RIBACK, SILVER & WILSON
3 555 12TH Street, Suite 1500
Oakland, CA 94607
4 Telephone: (510) 808.2000
Facsimile: (510) 444.1108
5
6 Attorneys for Plaintiff
CITY OF DUBLIN
7
8
IN THE SUPERIOR COURT OF THE STATE OF CALIFORNIA
IN AND FOR THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA
9
10
18
) CASE NO: VG05222845
)
) JUDGMENT IN CONDEMNATION
)
)
) APN: 941-0205-010-03
)
ANGELO GASPARE, Trustee of the "A & ) Complaint filed: July 15, 2005
o Gaspare Trust" Dated February 10, ) Trial Date: Not yet assigned
1993; UNION OIL COMPANY OF )
CALIFORNIA, a corporation; )
CONOCOPHILLlPS COMPANY, a )
Delaware corporation, Successor by )
Merger to Tosco Corporation, A Nevada )
corporation; KAYO OIL COMPANY, a )
Delaware corporation; S.S. KRESGE )
COMPANY, a Michigan corporation; )
JAMES E. LANGE; DUBLIN )
BOULEVARD INVESTORS; JOHN E. )
MADDEN and VIRGINA J. MADDEN; )
MICHAEL R. HILDE and BARBARA A. )
HILDE; LAWRENCE J. PLlSSKIN and )
SUSAN J. PLlSSKIN; PFEIFFER ) .
RANCH INVESTORS, INC., a California )
corporation; AHMAD All NIAKAN dba A )
& H BP PETROLEUM SERVICES; and )
Does 1 - 25, inclusive; )
)
)
)
CITY OF DUBLIN, a municipal
corporation,
11
12
13
Plaintiff,
14
vs.
15
16
17
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
Defendants.
28
Judgment in Condemnation
In the above-entitled cause, plaintiff CITY OF DUBLIN (UCity") and defendants
2 ANGELO GASPARE, Trustee of the "A& 0 Gaspare Trust" dated February 10, 1993
3 ("GASPARE"), KAYO OIL COMPANY, a Delaware corporation and CONOCOPHILLlPS
4 COMPANY, a Delaware corporation, Successor by Merger to Tosco Corporation, a .
5 Nevada corporation, ("CONOCO") having stipulated that judgment be entered as follows:
6 IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that upon payment of just
7 compensation to defendant ANGELO GASPARE in the amount of $106,219.00, and
8 $49,958.00 to defendants CONOCOPHILLlPS and KAYO OIL COMPANY, the property
9 described in the complaint shall be condemned for the public use of plaintiff.
10 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the payment of just
11 compensation as set forth above shall constitute full payment for the property so taken,
12 and for all claims of compensation, including but not limited to, compensation for land,
13 interest, attorneys' fees and costs or damages of every kind and nature suffered by
defendants and each of them by reason of the taking of the property or by reason of any
14
action or inaction whatsoever on the part of the City or its agents in relation to the property.
15
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that, defendants Union
Oil Company of California, James E. Lange, Dublin Boulevard Investors, John E. Madden,
17
Virginia J. Madden, Michael R. Hilde, Barbara A. Hilde, Lawrence J. Plisskin, Susan J.
Plisskin, Ahmad Ali Niakan dba A&H BP Petroleum Services, having filed disclaimers
herein, judgment is granted as to these disclaiming defendants, and that such defendants
claim no interest in the property being acquired herein and are not entitled to any
compensation under this Judgment.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that, defendant Pfeiffer
23
Ranch Investor, Inc., a default having been entered as to it, judgment is granted as to this
24
defaulting defendant, and that such defendant claims no interest in the property being
25
acquired herein and is not entitled to any compensation under this Judgment.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that in accordance with
27 the parties' Settlement Agreement and this Judgment in Condemnation, the State
28
16
18
19
20
21
22
26
Judgment in Condemnation
Treasurer is hereby ordered to cause warrants to be drawn on the Condemnation Deposits
2 Fund in the sums and to the payees as follows:
3 Angelo Gaspare $106,219.00
4 and mailed to the attention of his counsel, Mr. Tom Nagel, at Erickson, Beasley, Hewitt &
5 Wilson, LLP, 483 Ninth Street, Suite 200, Oakland, California, 94607 and
6 Kayo Oil Company $24,218.00
7 and mailed to the attention of its counsel, Dawn Ceizler, Glynn & Finley, LLP, One Walnut
8 Creek Center, 100 Pringle Avenue, Suite 500, Walnut Creek, CA 94596, for disbursement
9 to the payees.
10 IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that pursuant to the
11 provisions of section 5081 of the Revenue and Tax Code and section 1268.410 et seq. of
12 the Code of Civil Procedure, any current or delinquent real property taxes, penalties or
13 assessments that are a lien against the property actually taken in fee shall be prorated,
14 apportioned, deducted and paid to the Tax Collector of Alameda County as of September
15, 2005, the effective date of possession as set forth in the Order of Prejudgment
15
Possession entered on July 21, 2005.
16
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that any taxes, penalties
or assessments of Sacramento County or any other taxing agency accruing on the
18
property actually taken in fee after the September 15, 2005 effective date of the Order for
Immediate Possession are hereby canceled, and the plaintiff shall take free and clear of
any lien or encumbrances therefor on said parcel.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the use for which
said real property is sought to be condemned, to wit, the construction of the City's Capital
23
Improvement Program (CIP _ Project NO. 96852, Dougherty Road Improvements-
24
Houston Place to 1-580, with Scarlett Court Access to Dublin Boulevard Limited to Right
25
Turn Out only and Right Turn from Dublin Boulevard to Scarlett Court Eliminated, is and
26 I / I
27 / / /
17
19
20
21
22
28
Judgment in Condemnation
2
was a public use, and the taking in condemnation by plaintiff of said property is and was
2 necessary for said public use.
3
4 Dated:
JUDGE OF THE SUPERIOR COURT
5
6
7
8
9
10
114-4006/855907 _i.DOC
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
Judgment in Condemnation
3