HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 7.1 Attachments 3-7
..
"
CITY OF DUBliN SOUD WASTE FRANCHISING
Service
'l)"pe
Current
:\Iethod
Proposed Service
Ba~e Scrdce
Option A
Option B
Residential Refuse Manual Backyard Manual BackyaId Curbside Automated None
Collection
Residential Dean-up Four Annually Four Annually Three Annually Two Annually
Residential Recycling Curbside Recycling Current Materials Current Materials Current Materials
Collection .. Newspaper + +
.. Glass Mixed Paper HDPE
· Aluminum, Tin, Bi-metal (junk Mail, Magazines, 'Pl.astic Detergent
Containers Cardboard and Containers, Shampoo
· PET Plastic Conl:a.iners Phone Books) Boftles, etc.)
Residential Curbside None Option A or ""'eekly Collection Bi-WeeklyCollection .
Green Waste Collection lion B .
€
Commercial Refuse Regular Collection in Same None None
Collection Suitable Containers
Commercial Recycling None · Method Proposed by None None
Services Company
.. Implemented at
Ci sO tion
Debris Box Collection Regular Collection in Same None None
Suitable Containers.
Disposal No Long-Term Capacity Clpacily for the Te:rm. . None None
i
of the Agreement
EXHIBIT 3
,.
CITY OF DUBLIN
SOLID WASTE FRANCHISING'
t._~~~~..
.. _. . ~::;::;'..'..; .~;.. eO
IrOl)h.~
IhwOlUnwnc1ni ion
· Effective Date
April 1, 1996
· Base Agreement Term
Seven Years
· Term Extensions'
Three 12-Month Extensions at City's Option
· Franchise Scope
Exclusive
· Title to Solid Waste
Company, with City MaIntaining Flow Control
· Hepol'ting
· Monthly
· Quarterly
· Annually
· Fees
, 1) Franchise Fee (4.8% of Gross Revenues)
2) AD 939 Fee (Optional)
3) Administrative Fee (2% of Gross Revenues)
· Rate Adjustments
· Indexed Cost, Based on Company Proposal
· Rate Reviews for 3rd, 6th and 9th Year (if
'Extended)
· Profit
Operating Ratio Applied to Allowed Expel~8eB
· Balancing Account
None
'vi' . ., ";" i' ".::.,,~:(""';::: '. .. $$)$~~~ .... s..~A.. " $.--<<" . ;. .. ".' ... 'S:'
. .<.... .... ". "o$;~';\;;~
EXHIBIT 4
CITY OF DUBLIN
SOLID WASTE FRANCHISING
ii' .. . .Y. ..
Unh.'
Y(~m'
)l'j ~(~:d
YmU"
HM(~.H(~H h1A'
l\i,:t1mdohJg'~'
..__..._ w. _...__--..-l_...M........a&_.....
1 1996-1997
2 1997-1996
3 1998-1999
4 1999-2000
5 2000-2001
6 2000-2002
7 2000-2003
6 (OpUonnl) 2003-2004
9 (Optional) 2000-2005
10 (Optional) 2005-2006
fixed by ]1f(>p05ill
Fixed by PrQP08111
Detailed Rate RevIew
Indexed
Indexed
Detailed Rate RevIew
Indexed
Indexed
Detailed Rate RevIew
Indexed
''':'' : . ,~'{.. '... .~ Vi: .~ ........"^~.;~... -'N ... 'YO ..h'^~,,:x-;~..-..i( ~;.;,.;-".-..i..;=; :;..v.i;".;"",.i; "". ,....,. ......_ ._. ,.
EXHIBIT 5
~
CITY OF DUBLIN
SOLID WASTE FRANCHISING
....... ,", -. . :-."' ... .
,';Yo '.v' H;i'.'
" ":<<";
C01l1))()lwnt
]nd(~x
lh~suH
. Labor Costs
x
Consumer Price Index
= Forecasted Labor Costs
Vehicle Costs
x
Motor Ftte1 Index
= Forecasted Vehicle Costs
Other Costs
x
Producer Price Index
= Forecasted Labor Costs
Depredation
Actual Cost
:::
Annual Depreciation
..
-
.
7 Years
Profit
Fixed Operating Ratio
Allowed Profit
Pass..Through Expenses
None
=
Actual Cost
-.... .....
~'" -- .......
Projected Yearly Cost
. '...: ,"
~";l ';';"~
. ~l.lim!U.,\'K'il . ~
u.m
'.~"
... ", ':A...:::~~~:~t :v?u::":,;~",,,,:,,'''''''':':.. :~.:~...tt..:;
.EXCERPT CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
CONSULTANT SERVICES FOR SOLID WASTE COLLECTION,
LANDFILL & RECYCLING SERVICES (8l0-GO)
Assistant City Manager Rankin indicated in 1986, the City ot Dublin
assumed responsibility for solid waste disposal and collection services
from the Dublin San Ramon Services District. At that time, the city
entered into an agreement with Oakland Scavenger Company (recently
renamed Waste Management of Alameda County (WMAC). This agreement
created an exclusive franchise whereby the company was to collect,
remove and dispose of all solid w~ste accumulating in the city for a ten
year period which expires on April 1, 1996. The current agreement
provides for an extension of the agreement for an additional ten year
period, provided both parties agree to the extension.
The city also implemented curbside residential recycling and a multi-
family recycling program also provided by WMAC under separate agreements
which expire on March 31, 1996.
In 1989 the State Legislature imposed AB 939, the Integrated Waste
Management Act of 1989 which requires cities to develop programs which
will reduce the flow of waste to the landfill by 25% in 1995 and by 50%
in the year 2000.
There have been significant changes in the provision of solid waste
oservices within the past five years. It is hoped that a new agreement
will integrate all elements of solid waste collection and diversion
under a single contract. The City is also limited by the current
structure of its solid waste agreement in that the term of the agreement
does not provide a guaranteed disposal arrangement beyond 1996.
WMAC has expressed an interest in continuing to serve the residents and
businesses within the City of Dublin. The city has also received a
request from Browning Ferris Industries (BFI) , who is interested in
presenting a competitive bid for service. Given that WMAC and BFI are
the only landfill operators located in Alameda County, it is highly
likely that any proposals received will need to utilize one of these
landfill facilities.
In 1993 the annual cost was nearly $2 million. A typical agreement
covers seven to ten years so this would be potentially over a $15
million agreement over the life of the contract. There could be new
programs which would add to the cost.
There are two options available in considering the selection of the
provider of solid waste services~ The City may seek competitive
proposals or directly negotiate with a single firm. The approach
selected will affect the Scope of Consultant Services requested in the
draft Request for Qualification (RFQ).
The city will need Consultant Services whether the city seeks
competitiv;e proposals from multiple vendors, or negotiates with a single
provider. The Consultant would assist with solicitation and analysis of
competitive proposals.
I 0
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
Regular Meeting
CM - VOL 13 - 268
September 12, 1994
EXHIBIT 6
The current schedule would provide for the city to complete selection of
a service provider, as well as negotiation of a final agreement by
June 30, 1995. This schedule will allow the selected provider to have
adequate time to gear up for any capital purchases required and/or
development of public information campaigns necessary to implement any
new or expanded services.
staff's recommendation was that the City utilize a competitive Request
For Proposal process to seek providers for the service and that is the
manner in which the draft RFQ for Consultant has been structured. That
would assure the community that there is a competitive benchmark for the
services they are receiving, as well as responding to the interest the
city has receoived so far from more than one firm. Once the Consultant's
RFQ was circulated, staff would be bringing back to the Council a
recommendation on the Consultant, as well as an agreement.
Cm. Moffatt asked if there had been a comparison of the prices of others
with the City's current provider recently. As he remembered, the
present provider had the lowest price of all the Counties.
Mr. Rankin confirmed it was a lower rate, but what is in all the rates
has to be investigated.
Mr. Ambrose indicated that Waste Management provided services to other
communities at a higher rate. A lot depended on what goes into that
particular contract.
Cm. Howard asked for an explanation of what the $69,000 for consultant
services covered as she felt it was a lot of money.
Mr. Rankin explained this figure was an estimate based on some
preliminary discussions. The consultant would be working with Staff to
identify what should be in a minimum scope of worki For example, is the
city interested in looking at automated service or noti what type of
greenwaste programi and is the city happy with all the programs it has.
They would develop a Request For Proposal that would basically be a
document that the vendors could bid on by submitting how they intended
to do the program and what the costs with that type of program would be.
The Consultant would assist Staff in evaluating the proposals, which can
be quite complex. The Consultant would negotiate a final agreement for
service.
Mr. Ambrose indicated that during the annual rate setting process that
the city has with the current garbage provider, a consulting firm is
hired by the Joint Rate Refuse Review Committee, in which the City and a
number of other cities in Alameda County are a part of, to assist the
respective cities in evaluating the operations of the current Waste
Management provider to make certain costs that are being identified for
the operation of the service are appropriate as they relate to the
respective franchise agreements. It is not a simple issue. The
agreements must be structured in a way the citizens are protected wh~le
providing a fair agreement to the provider. It is very technical in
nature with a lot of legal issues in regard to collection costs and
landfill closure costs which/are reflected in cost of operations.
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
eM - VOL 13 - 269
Regular Meeting
September 12, 1994
Cm. Moffatt asked if the $69,000 for the Consultant, was a group rate or
the city's rate.
Mr. Rankin responded that it was a budget estimate for the City of
Dublin because the city of Dublin was currently the only City that has a
franchise expiring.
Cm. Burton asked if the Livermore contract runs out at the same time.
Mr. Rankin responded no, it was his understanding that in the last two
years, the City of Livermore had renegotiated an extension of seven
years with a three year option.
Mr. Ambrose indicated staff had talked with Livermore to see if they
would be interested in extending their contract to coincide with the
franchise agreement. There was no interest.
Cm. Burton asked if the bid would be separated, so that different
functions or programs could be selected from different people or would
it be all inclusive.
Mr. Rankin stated it was a possibility and was something staff would
want the benefit of experts in the field to advise the city on the
pluses and minuses of doing that. There are agencies that have gone
with different providers, but they have different problems in trying to
coordinate the service. For the consumer, there could be the confusion
of was today the greenwaste or was today garbage day. There is a lot of
technology happening now and whether some of that could be consolidated
into one truck down the street instead of three trucks are some of the
things staff needed to find out, as well as the cost for selecting one
method over another.
Cm. Burton indicated he had received a lot of public interest expressed
through telephone calls stating how satisfied they were with the present
garbage program. He felt we have all been well served.
Cm. Houston realized this was not a public hearing but perhaps there
were members of the audience who would like to speak to this issue.
Mayor Snyder agreed with Cm. Houston and realized all the Councilmembers
were probably deluged with phone calls over the weekend relative to this
item. He invited members of the audience to come forward to speak on
the issue requesting speakers to identify themselves for the record.
Gabe Mendoza, who has been a resident for 28 years in Dublin, asked the
Council to continue with the present service. He felt it has been good
service and it should be continued.
Cm. Burton wanted to make it clear that no decision would be made that
evening on the Request For Proposal, but the Council would approve
getting a Consultant to put the program together.
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
eM - VOL 13 - 270.
Regular Meeting
September 12, 1994
Bonnie Moss, Browning Ferris Industries Public Affairs Manager, urged
the Council to follow Staff recommendation. Browning Ferris Industries
is a world leader in the recycling and waste industry. They serve over
1,000 communities in North America and 3,000 worldwide. Locally in
Alameda County they operate the Vasco Road Landfill and most recently
having started September 1, they are the comprehensive collection
company for Fremont. She felt competition is good for the constituency
the Council represents. In the case of Fremont, they wanted to
originally extend their contract with their provider of 38 years, but
decided to release an RFP instead, go through the competitive process,
and in the end it was Browning Ferris Industries that was selected. In
the bid, BFI proposed a state of the art recycling truck. Also, BFI
produced a system that would recycle more for Fremont. They are
recycling over 150 tons more per day than they had done before under the
former system. The BFI proposal to Fremont was $3.5 million cheaper
than the next lowest bidder. Competition is good; it can increase the
quality of the proposal the City gets. It asks the people that want to
provide service to the City to roll up their sleeves, sharpen their
pencils, and in the end the City gets the better deal. They are hopeful
Council will follow Staff recommendation and engage in a competitive bid
process and know the process will require anyone who is interested to
really listen to the community and provide the service the community is
looking for. In Fremont the residents had been satisfied with their
former service provider, but after going through the process, people are
adjusting quite smoothly and consistently in a smooth transition which
has been implemented as of September 1.
Juan Padilla, a resident of Dublin for 7 years and an employee of Waste
Management, indicated he had attended the public hearing in Fremont
concerning the garbage service because the decision would affect him.
On written paper, it showed the service was $3.5 million less, but any
little adjustment to containers was nickeled and dimed and cost the
resident. Routes were suppose to be finished in eight hours, but guys
were still not finished with the routes up to 12 hours later. Some
people went from Waste Management to BFI thinking conditions would be
better only to find it was the worst mistake they ever made. Many of
Waste Management workers have 15 to 30 years of service with the company
and are residents of Dublin and are registered voters.
Tim Malone has lived in Dublin since 1991 and works for Waste
Management. He concurred what Juan said was true about the containers.
They are called pullman fees. When the gate has to be unlocked, there
is a charge. Commercial accounts are charged $5 to: pull the bin around.
He claimed when BFI took over Fremont, the rates were raised 41% to
residential. He was not sure what the rates to commercial were. He
worked today and got done at 4:45 p.m. and he saw garbage trucks coming
in the yard about 5:00 p.m. He stated that some of them keep their
garbage overnight in the trucks which is illegal because the dumps are
closed down at 6:00 p.m. He wouldn't believe what they say. If you are
happy with the service, stick with what you are happy with. Don't
adjust nothing. You might be sorry.
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
eM - VOL 13 - 271
Regular Meeting
September 12, 1994
Jose Vargas, a resident of Dublin, indicated he was happy with the
service and he felt it was good service and he wanted to stay with the
same company.
Dan Borges, General Manager of Livermore Dublin Disposal, indicated his
company has serviced the Dublin area for over 33 years. During that
time, they have provided excellent service to the customers. Dublin has
realized some of the lowest rates in Alameda County and other
surrounding communities. The city of Dublin had the foresight to be one
of the first cities in Alameda County to institute recycling services.
Livermore Dublin Disposal was proud to instigate these services
successfully. In the near future the City of Dublin will have to
implement other recycling programs to meet the goals of AB 939. LDD is
there ready to meet the challenges whether it be a greenwaste program,
commercial recycling program or any ,other program that is needed. LDD
has the experience and expertise to do this. Their track record is such
that any program that has been instituted by LDD has been successful
within the city. It has always been and will always be LDD's goal to be
a good corporate citizen. Some organizations LDD supports or are
involved in are the Chamber of Commerce having been a member for 25
years; Dublin Fine Arts Foundation helping in art projects to promote
recycling; the elementary schools of Dublin by providing lesson plans to
teach the children about recycling; supporting the FFA and 4H Programs,
as well as the Dublin Historical Society; they participate in the Dublin
st. Patrick's Day Parade with the entry of a recycling truck. Because
of the 33 years of service and involvement in the community, and the
continued low rates,LDD respectfully asked the city Council to direct
Staff to enter into negotiations with Livermore Dublin Disposal,
Division of Waste Management of Alameda County, to negotiate an
extension to their contract.
Cm. Burton asked what would be involved in the greenwaste program.
Different cities have different ways. Would LDD be proposing a way of
doing it or would the City make the specs?
Mr. Borges assumed the Staff and consultant would come up with some
specs. LDD presently collects greenwaste in the City of Livermore in a
program that started in July to 16,000+ customers and have not had a
problem. The material has been very clean due to their public education
to the customers and has been very successful. Already 500 tons of
greenwaste was moved out of the city of Livermore.
Cm. Burton asked what was being done to the greenwaste.
Mr. Borges responded at the present time, it is being treated and things
are being done with it. It is being composted, mulched, and some things'
are going to direct land application to augment agricultural lands.
Cm. Houston asked Mr. Borges to describe how the City has been looking
at LDD's books all along the way to examine their expenses and profit
margin.
Mr. Borges responded the Joint Refuse Rate Review Committee takes the
books of Waste Management of' Alameda County and hires an outside
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
eM - VOL 13 - 272
Regular Meeting
September 12, 1994
consultant and they go totally through the books and determine if the
costs are justified and at that point the company is allowed a
reasonable rate of return.
Mr. Ambrose indicated that procedure was on the basic garbage service
only. Recycling programs are not covered through that process.
Cm. Houston stated part of the reason the city has such great rates as
we do now is because the basic service is overseen to some degree.
Mayor snyder indicated that the option remains with the local political
entity to do what they want to do. All the consultant does is glean out
the information and allow the Council to deal with the information.
Mr. Rankin explained that each city had a person attend the JRRRC
meetings, but the JRRRCwas in a strange transition primarily because of
changes in membership. Votes are based on population. The Tri-cities
have now broken off, and Livermore is no longer a participant. The city
of Oakland from a technical standpoint can pretty much make many of the
decisions because of the weighted population. The other thing that has
occurred with sessions just starting is the Company has indicated the
rate of return that has been granted was not equitable and they are
pursuing the matter with their own team of consultants, which is
different from what has been seen in the past. They have accountants,
as well as consultants, to present their case. This year the JRRRC has
hired Deloitee Touche. The City of Dublin had been in a surplus
position, but the numbers have not been determined to find out where
they are this year. The Company has not dealt with the big issue of
closure/post-closure costs at the Altamont Landfill which run into
million of dollars and how those costs will be paid. The JRRRC is
trying to obtain the answers so the representatives can return to their
cities with the answers.
Mr. Borges indicated LDD has always operated efficiently to keep the
rates low in Dublin such as by changing to a two man crew.
Cm. Burton asked if the $70,000 consultant fee would be necessary if we
negotiate an extension of the LDD contract.
Mr. Borges responded that LDD could corne up with the programs and give
the city a proposal for them, but the need for a consultant is a
question that should be directed to Staff. Most cities hire consultants
to ensure that the city is getting the best for itsomoney.
Mr. Rankin indicated there are different directions that the final
negotiations may eventually take. For example, when the City went
through the process with the cable television franchise, when the
franchise was eventually granted, one of the elements of the final
agreement was that there would be some form of reimbursement for the
costs incurred in negotiating that franchise agreement. What that does
is make sure everyone who has an interest will work as efficiently as
possible to get it done. There are still a lot of details that need to
be worked out and which can't be done until Staff knows the direction
. I
Counc~l wants to take.
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
eM - VOL 13 - 273
Regular Meeting
Seotember 17.. ,QQA
Sean O'Brien, a resident of Dublin, stated he concurred with all who
said they were pleased with Waste Management Service. It is nice to
hear that Waste Management will modify its service to meet the city's
needs.
Mayor Snyder indicated this was not a public hearing, but it is
appropriate for the Council to make some determinations. He asked for a
clarification. It seemed there were two options; one is initially to
select a consultant that could be used regardless of what the Council
decided and a determination of RFP for provider could be done subsequent
to this evening.
Mr. Rankin stated Staff needed directions to be able to let the
consultant know what it is the city wants them to do.
Cm. Houston indicated he was very happy with the present service as a
councilman and as a homeowner. He hears people rave about the quarterly
pick-ups and what they are allowed to pick-up. Other cities may have
problems with "nickel and diming" the residents, but in Dublin anything
you put out, they will pick up with smiles on their faces. He would
like to see the City start negotiations with Livermore Dublin Disposal
and if an agreement cannot be reached, then the City would go to the
competitive bid process. Since the City has the absolute lowest rates
and great service, LDD is entitled to the first shot.
Mayor Snyder asked what Cm. Houston would anticipate a threshold would
be when the Council would make that determination as far as Staff
recommendation or negotiations.
Cm. Houston responded Staff would have to come back to the Council if
there was an impasse in negotiations.
Mayor Snyder felt there had to be a threshold where the decision has to
be made when negotiations were going nowhere.
Cm. Houston responded he would rely on the City Manager to make the
recommendation. He would really like the City to be able to work out a
situation, but if it cannot be done, then Council would have to go to
competitive bid.
Mr. Rankin felt placing a vendor in the situation where they know there
is a potential in the future that they may be forced into a competitive
bid situation, may mean you will never see the bott9m line before you
tell them the City is going out for competitive bids.
Mr. Ambrose indicated it did not place the vendor in a fair position
because if the Council left that option open, it is not fair to allow
their competition to look at what their proposal is.
Mr. Rankin explained that the cost alternative may not be the only basis
that the Council decides to award a contract on. There may be other
criteria.
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
eM - VOL 13 - 274
Regular Meeting
September 12, 1994
Cm. Burton agreed the Council would not be locked into just costs on the
bid process.
Cm. Houston said the Council would want to look at the whole package
which would consist of service as well as price. He felt LDD was
entitled to the first shot. If it did not work out, then the council
could go to the alternative. But he would like to start negotiations
with LDD because they have done a good job and a good price for the city
and he felt it would continue that way.
Cm. Burton agreed in principal that everyone seemed to be happy with the
service, but ohe still felt the Council had a responsibility to find out
because there are other factors to be cranked into the agreement as far
as additional services. He would like to see it broken down as to the
different programs. He had confidence that LDD would give the city its
best shot, but he did feel that as a matter of public principle and
pOlicy, the Council should go ahead and have a bid process after the
consultant is selected.
Cm. Houston stated that earlier in the year, there was a recommendation
for Request For Proposal for the Building Inspection Department. At the
time, the majority of the Council felt that the quality of work was such
that there would not be a bid process. So it is not unheard of not to
go forward with the Request For Proposal. Again, he felt LDD was
entitled to the first shot whether they get it down the road or not
because they have been doing a great job at a great price.
Cm. Burton felt there was not much time for a lot of maneuvering under
the timeframe that an agreement needed to beodecided by June 1995.
Cm. Moffatt wanted to see the Waste Management be extended until April
1, 1996. He concurred with Cm. Houston if the thing isn't broken, why
fix it.
Cm. Howard agreed that the community has gotten very good service and
very good prices. She would prefer to see LDD have first shot.
Cm. Burton asked what the timeframe would be. People should understand
that Waste Management has the contract until April 1, 1996.
Mayor Snyder responded that Staff recommended that an agreement be in
place by June 30, 1995.
em. Houston felt it was in the interest of LDD and the City to negotiate
and get something done in a timely manner.
On motion by Cm Houston, seconded by em Howard, and by unanimous vote,
the Council directed Staff to hire the consultant to whatever degree is
appropriate in order to initiate negotiations with our current vendor.
* * * *
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
eM - VOL 13 - 275
Regular Meeting
september 12, 1994
.. .:. '~, .'. r', II .;. h r:I ,) '.. .:' (:eo p~" 0F(JSlJrR.r.VE Y r) P,RE'P1\RED (, BY f.J ('(.If.' r) (.I (t (1 (I (. I,' '.' ~~
(}
n
o
n
{}
{I
n
n
n
n
!J
{}
H
n
{I
II
'.;
BFI WASTE SYSTEMS
Dear IJubLill Garbage RateJlayel~
',:
This past month the Dublin City Council voted unanimously
to hire a consultant to negotiate an extension of the city's garbage
collection contract with Livermore / Dublin Disposal Service, a
subsidiary of Waste Management Corporation. This new contract
is likely to significantly increase garbage collection rates for
Dublin residents.
"
q
I
Il
:\
:\
o
n
n
Unfortunately, as the enclosed September 19th editorial fron1
The Tri- Valley Herald describes, if this decision ren1ains intact there
will be no opportunity for public input or for con~peting garbage
collection cmnpanies to make proposals.
We believe the public is best served in an open competitive
process. This allows the public to get the best service for the
best price.
In an open process the city could decide to select the lowest
bidder, the city could choose the company it believes is best, or it
could extend the existing contract with the present company.
We would like the opportunity to be able to explain to the
City Council and to Dublin ratepayers how BPI can serve your
needs.
~ ~
"
()
Il
!I
"
/.
H
(,
;,
':;'
n
,}
()
')
p
"
I ~
!j
{j
o
(}
I'
o
.,
.t~
n
.q
~ }
u
~ ~
'l
(j
')
.}
.,
n
Here's what we'd like you to do:
1. Send the white postcard to the City Council or call thenl
at 833-6605. Ask them to open the process to allow
conlpeting conlpanies the 'opportunity to Inake proposals.
2. Send the blue postcard back to us. We'd like to lmow how
you'd like your garbage service improved.
Thank you for your help. If you have any questions please
do not hesitate to let us lmow.
.;}
u
i}
..,
: I
{.\
()
"
.,
"
u
1}
~,
(}
I)
~ ;
~ }
!l
~:
J\
(~
o
",
"
'\
1.\
. , '. ':' .:. .., r) ,) f) (.I .;, ':. (1 r.' I) (1 (, f) (, (, r;1 (, .) (1 I) I) (I (I r:, (.1 (,1';1 0 ';1 I) (J (1 I) r;, I') (I f.' " r:! (! ,;, (I (, .;, f.t ,;> (J 1'.1
EXHIBIT 7
'"
'toJ 100% ICCYcl<,cJ "ape,
.'.""~72
L-~..._
{}
n
{}
u
()
:,
..
,~ ..
I.
'i
n
il
n
,..,
(}
J.~
{}
{:
~i
.r;,
,;
.q
o
~;
n
II
n
U
{}
"
{I
'i
n
{}
p
{}
(}
U
'I
{'
U
U
{}
{J
(~
n
{I
n
(1
n
~~
{}
o
u
(i
{}
U
{}
(I
n
u
u
{}
{}
{}
o
()
{}
n
n
I)
'.'
(I
I!
~:.;;L,,:: '-'::~::'.~:.~~.:~....:: ~='::::;~::'-:-;--~~_: - .,. - .. --...; .. -...; .~",. ~
i~.:.,.. .... .........,.:~ .. ....' ..:. .. ..: .:..~{:i.i
~~I'I!{~'~~; . .... ..~i,~111
-...' .~-:-.; Box 5013 ....
:
Fremont, CA 94537-5013 ..
o ,=cI.dp.p", ~
1. Regarding your current garbage service, do you feel it is
o Poor? 0 Adequate? 0 Good?
2. How important is bady.ud/sideyard pick-up? 0 Very important
o I want whatever is cheapest 0 No opinion
3. Do you recycle now? 0 Yes, regularly
a. Glass 0 Yes, regularly
b. Cans 0 Yes, regularly
c. Plastic 0 Yes, regularly
d. Newspapers 0 Yes, regularly
_ _. e. Cardboard! junk mail 0 Yes, regularly
f. Yard waste (grass clippings, leaves etc.) 0 Yes, regularly
4. If a container for yard waste was provided would you use it?
DYes oNo - .
5. In what ways could service be improved?
NAME
ADDRESS
PHONE (Day)
(Evening)
o I prefer curbside pick-up
o Sometimes
o Sometimes
o Sometimes
o Sometimes
o Sometimes
o Sometimes
o Sometimes
ONo
ONo
ONo
ONo
ONo
ONo
ONo
Please
Place
Stamp
Here
Dublin City Council
PO Box 2340
Dublin, CA 94568
o ,=cl.dp.p", ~
- - .
. - , ~
. . - - -
. ,-~.. ~ - .
."1",',: .-. . .-.~,. ..'~. .-:.. . ...::'" _ .P-:;'_ . . - . ~ .
I/We would like to see the City of Dublin
require an open competitive process for waste
disposal and recycling service.
NAME
ADDRESS
PHONE (Day)
(Evening)
0000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000
~ri-~alt~~)fmUn
MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 19, 1994 ~ PAGEA-14
CONGRESS shall rrwke no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the .free
exercise thereof; or abridging the.freedom of speech, or of the press, or the right of the people
peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Go'Vernmentfor a redress of grievances.
FIRST AMENDMENT TO TIlE CONSTITtrI10N OF THE UNITED STATES, RATIFIED DEC. 15, 1191
EDrroRIALs
Garbage contract
should go out to bid
THREE communities in the Tri-
Valley area incorporated during
the 1980s.
The motivation that drove citi-
zens to incorporate boiled down
to local control: local people making deci-
sions that affected local residents. Dublin,
Danville and San Ramon all incorporated
within a two-year period. A common thread
through each incorporation was to operate
cost-efficient govemmeIlt that focused on
services that citizens needed.
The city of Dublin has stayed the truest to
its original' mission. It remains the leader at
providing city services by contracting with
outside vendors.
That conunitment has served citizens very
well over the past 12 years.
We therefore found it curious, to say the
least, that the City Council passed up an op-
portunity to drive down costs for its citizens.
The city's 10-year garbage contract is up.
Its staff members recommended putting the
contract to bid. The city of San Ramon .
saved a pile of money for its residents when
it opened the garbage contract to a compet-
itive situation.
Dublin was in a similar position. Garbage
giants Waste Management h1c. and
Browning Ferris Industries both do business
in the county. Both aggressively have
bought independent garbage companies
over the past decade. Waste Management
purchased the independent that served
Dublin.
Surprisingly, the council bowed to the
lobbying effort by Waste Management and
decided to hire a consultant for $69,000 to
negotiate. a new contract with Waste Man-
agement.
It was a waste of money, although we can
imagine there will be no shortage of appli-
cants for the consultant'sjob.
A simple competitive bidding process
likely would have driven prices down and re-
sulted in better service for the community.
That's what San Ramon experienced.
We believe Dublin residents would have
been much better served if the city had re-
lied on private enterprise to bid for the right
to provide services.
We're confident that both the bid process
and the eventual contract could have been
structured tightly enough that residents
would have el\ioyed equal or better service
. for less money.
It would be prudent, particularly in this
election year, for the council to revisit this
issue.
If the city is going to grant a monopoly -
a practice other communities in other states
don't follow - then the monopoly company
must at least win a competitive bid process.
{) 100% recycled paper ~f1f!'"E
SUMMARY OF RESPONSES ADDRESSED TO
CITY COUNCIL
:SFI WASTE SYSTEMS SURVEY
PAGES 1-20 = 731 Responses
Supporting A Competitive Process
PAGES 21-22 = 28 Responses
Supporting Negotiating With Current Provider
EXHIBIT 8
This is the list of people who sent in cards saying "I/We would like to see the City of Dublin require an open
competitive process for waste disposal and recycling service, or who called leaving that message:
~
Abrew, Brenda
Ackley, Dennis
Aguilar, Laura
Ahance, John M.
Albin, Sherry & Greg
Albrecht, Mark
Alexander
Allen, Edward
Allen, Marilyn
Allen, Tom L.
AlIens
Amador, -Nick
Amato, Ralph
Amesur, Madhuben
Anaya, Rob .
Anderson, Craig & Patty
Anderson, Dennis R.
Anderson, Mark R.
Anderson, Paul
Anderson, Steven J.
Anderson, T.
Angerman, Ken
Anthony, Geoffrey
Aquino, Eugenia
Arace, Glenn & Melanie
Argo, Ann
Armandaric, Jose & T.
Asp, Bill & Lynn
Astilla, Dennis & Mrs.
Athey, Chuck & Kathi
Avanzino, Al
Ayraud, Rose
B. Bruns
Babbitt, Sue & Don
I-d
~
o
trJ
>-'
Address
7644 Arbor Creek Cir
7873 Cranford Lane
7725 Hillrose Dr
11491 Silvergate Dr
7602 Coral Way
7526 Calle Verde Rd.
8363 Rhoda Ave.
7989 Iglesia Dr. '
8727 Edenberry Place
7250 Tina Place
8372 Davona Dr.
7476 Brookdale Ct.
6713 Poplar Way
11478 Winding Trail PI
11688 Silvergate Dr.
6933 Prince Drive
11611 Castilian Ct.
11412 Rothschild Place
7635 San Sabana Rd.
11445 Marwick Dr.
7388 lone Ct.
7621 Tuscany Dr
7271 Burton St.
6905 Penn Dr.
7710 Frederiksen Lane
8498 Longford Way
7509 Brighton Dr.
6576 Amador Valley Blvd
7356 Quartz Circle
7777 Castilian Rd
11928 Rhoda Ct.
11842 W. Vomac Rd.
6827 Penn Drive
11626 Regio Ct.
Phoneff:
828-6654
828-5198
460-2382
538-4813
829-5377
803-1231
551-7454
828-5552
829-0731
829-2688
829-2268
481-6440
828-2997
732-1233
803-0840
828-4815
828-2928
828-4118
829-2346
828-5831
227-0133
829-1001
803-1761
833-8508
829-3711
829-5684
833-8427
846-6052
829-4287
Additional Comments
~.~~:.- .
A consultant is not needed
A consultant is not necessary and is
ridiculously expensive to choose garbage
service for Dublin
Back, Ken
Baker
Ballard
Ballard, R. D.
Bandisi, John & Nell
Banich, Bob
Banister, Jeff & Sue
Bar, J.
Barbee, Joel
Bareiss, H.
Bareiss, H.
Barnes, Wayne R.
Baucom, Janet
Beattie, Quin
Becker, Florence
Becker, Jon
Behm, Harley & Betsy
Bell, Dan
Bell, Tom
Benafield
Bendezy, Silvia
Bennett, Joan
Bergbower, R.
Berman, Marshall & J.
Bernard, Russ
Bernstein, George
Bias, P. O.
Bielke, M. L.
Bielski, Art
Bird, Kirstin
Blaedel, L. L.
Bodie, Pete
Boggs, Denise
Borgeson, Glen & Denise
Boricchio, Jim & Shar
Bosque
Botton, Don
Branagan, L. A.
Branch, C. A.
Branch, Beverly
I-t1
>
o
trJ
N
7824 Firebrand Dr.
11454 RollinghilLs Dr
8710 Galindo Ct.
6760 Maple Drive
8801 Davona Dr.
7752 Shady Creek Rd.
11476 Wildcat Ct.
7564 Burnham Way
11595 Betlen Dr
7444 Limerick Ave.
7366 Tone Ct.
6549-A Cotton Wood Cir
7265 Prince Dr
7036 York Drive
7904 Shady Creek Road
11477 Silvergate Dr.
7681 Donohue Drive
7680 Kilrush Ave.
6680 Maple Drive
8682 Shamrock Place
6897 Amador Valley Blvd
7724 Crossridge Rd.
7335 Emerald Ave.
8546 Zandol Ct.
7945 Crossridge Rd.
7442 Oxvord Circle
7516 Burnham Way
6813 Amador Valley
8031 B South Lake Dr.
7335 Hansen Dr.
11293 Rolling Hills Dr.
8795 Davona Dr
11383 Dillon Way
11732 Corto Ct.
7941 Bristol Rd
11636 Circle Way
8736 Atlgust Ct.
7986 Elgin Lane
7848 Gateway
829-9682
829-0507
828-5911
828-4046
828-8047
828-9494
357-4610
829-0122
828-7628
828-0231
829-2492
828-9026
828-5031
833-0683
842-5857
828-0863
829-6045
592-8337
573-0773
829-6480
829-1994
551-8297
828-3064
828-3675
829-5852
829-8483
828-9427
829-2178
But only if the increase would surpass the.
annual inflation rate.
-.....~......_"
Any major contract should be bid!
We don't need to pay a consultant to do a
job ~ are elected to do!
please get bids for garbage.
What's going on?
Brandes & Trumbo
Brassea, Rob & Rose
Breilh, Mary
Brewer, Rick & Joan
Brezicki
Briest, Don & Nancy
Brightman, Ray
Brown, Don
Brownell, W. H.
Bryant, Mike
Buffleben, George
Burby, Allan
Burd, Cindy
Burden, Ray & Martha
Burdoin, John F.
Burnham, Bill
Burton, Louann
Byrd, Francis H.
Byrne, Jim
Bywater, Bernice
Calder
Caldwell, Bob & Mrs.
Cambra, Ruth
Cameron & Jackie Raether
Cancel, Hilton
Candland, Larry
Cappa, Loretta
Carbone, David F.
Cardella, Laurie
Carrillo, Robert & V.
Carter, Jay
Casselman, Thomas N.
Castelluccio, Phil & C
Castillo, Dan & V.
Castle, M.
Cathy
~ Cauble, L.
o
!:%1
W
7968 Crossridge Rd
22625 Circle Way
7733 Woodren Ct.
8236 Mulberry Place
8233 Elgin Lane
7503 Rolling Hills Cir
7799 Crossridge Rd.
7323 Limerick Ct.
7838 Alto Way
8327 Ferncliff ct.
22625 Manzanita Lane
8649 Briarwood Lane
7797 Woodren Ct.
7332 Glenoaks Way
6533 King Way
8423 Locust Place
8320 Vomac Rd.
22896 Vomac Road
6589 Ebensburg Lane
7706 Firebrand Dr.
7292 Bedford Way
7634 Turquoise St.
22622 Juarez Ct.
6603 Ebensburg Lane
7008 Tory Ct.
8364 Cavalier Lane
22672 Harlan Rd.
7270 Price Drive
7520 Silvertree Lane
22034 Rolling Hills Dr
8289 Elgin Lane
22426 Winding Trail Ln
8456 Wicklow Lane
8358 Mulberry Place
8632 Fenwick Way
829-5547
829-8443
889-2520
552-3332
829-3257
828-7205
828-2597
829-8027
828-8202
833-0860
408-292-7253
828-5300
829-5206
828-6636
829-6726
828-2899
828-4276
803-0763
828-4475
828-5760
833-0236
829-5325
784-4235
803-9272
8;.!!~-0395\
204-2659
833-8552
902-3022
552-5825
828-4434
803-2347
829-4692
803-8946
828-2657
~Present co. does not take cardboard,
plastics such as soap containers, no yard
clippings. Services could be improved while
keeping cost down.
We need a change
The open bid process is one of the best ways
to get the most competitive price.
No competitive bidding and a $69,000
Consultant!! Doesn't sound prudent!!!
Cavaleiro, H.
Cejda, Doreen
Celada, Errol
Chandler, Bob & T.
Chang, Allen
Cherin, Kristine
Childers, Lloyd
Christensen, Martin
Cirincione, Peter J.
clancy, Diane
Clark, Bill & Diana
Clark, T & L
Clegg, Roger & Melissa
Clemenson, Mike
Coble, Anna
Cocilova, Bob & Helen
Cohen, Jeff & Jan
Cohn, Chris
Cole, Carollynne
Collier, William
Collins, Cliff & Mary
Collins, David
Collins, John & SS
Colon, Peter
Commer, Jay & Sonja
Conlogue, Robert
Constable, STeve
Cook, Dean
Cooney & Tanner
Cooper, Louise
Corden, M.
Cottrell III, Al
Couchman, George
Culwell, Mary A.
Crawford, Jerry & Mary
Creighton, John & M
Crislip, Dave
Crislip, willis
Cruz, April
I-d
~
t%j
~
6896 Brighton Dr.
7975 Oxbow Ct.
7016 Cedar Ct.
7748 Canterbury Lane
7415 Oxford Circle
7724 Canterbury Lane
7324 Hansen Dr.
8225 Rhoda Ave.
11449 Seine Ct.
7933 Iglesia Dr.
8532 Ardmore Pl
7255 Cronin Circle
8638 Beverly Lane
8798 Longford Way
6700 Dougherty Rd. #84
11713 Serra Court
7755 Squirrel Crk Cir
8142 Locust Place
8512 Beverly Lane
7648 Brighton Dr.
7453 Rolling Hills Cir
8240 Locust Pl
7264 Brighton
7532 Burnham Way
7702 Turquoise St.
7562 San Sabana Rd.
8266 Creekside Drive
7577 Landale Ave.
8799 Augusta Ct.
8432 Briarwood Lane
7448 Oxford Circle
8734 Shamrock Place
11908 W. Vomac Rd.
11555 Santo Ct.
11622 Estrella Ct
6947 Pine Ct.
6840 York Dr.
7880 Gate Way
829-4473
829-0857
828-4904
828-2875
829-0461
833-2777
829-4286
803-0295
829-6550
829-4338
828-3235
829-7362
828-3781
833-7271
244-6098
442-4423
803-9652
828-2878
483-7935
828-6924
829-5852
833-0965
828-5319
829-5233
551-7760
828-1481
551-8377
828-2849
803-9858
828-4455
833-8915
828-3871
828-3279
551-8209
833-0732
Spend $69,000 to hire a consultant is a big
waste!
We also need a comparison with services for
other communities
(Pager)
>. . ~
'." . .
Let's keep our City'S costs as low as
possible.
Curr, John & Mrs.
Dahlquist, Brenda
Dana, Lanny
Daniels
Danskin, Mrs. Elmo L.
Danskin, Rebecca
Davis, Bertina
Davis, Russell & Mrs.
Davison, William
Day, Ray & Michele
De Goey, Wayne
De Jong, Kathy
Decker, M. Christine
Dedon, Erica R.
Deka Cruz, Louis
Delgado, Lorena
DeLong, George
Dembrowicz, Kurt & M
Demmel, Harry
Denham, Gayle
Derksen, Karen
Detwiler, Ron & Pat
Dexter, Elain & Keri
DiCiano, Roseann
Dick, Kevin & Carla
Dickinson, E.
Dietrich, Lori C.
Digirolamo, David
Digirolamo, Debbie
Dimla, Debra Ann
Dinelli
Dix. L.
Dixon, Tom & Lorraine
Dodds, Doug & Linda
t-d
ll>
<<1
trl
lJ1
7909 Firebrand Dr.
6960 Cedar Lane
7354 Dover Lane'
8787 Brighton Ct.
8449 Longford Way
7716 Bonniewood Ct.
7425 Brighton Dr
6912 Cedar Lane
8622 Davona Dr.
11843 Newbridge Way
7438 Oxford Circle
8026 Crossridge Rd.
7075 Prince Dr
7579 Amarillo Rd
6520 Nottingham Pl
8411 Cavalier Lane
7633 Frederiksen Ln
8128 Mulberry Place
11674 Los Ranchitos Ct.
7542 Rolling Hills Circle
8181 Locust Place
6700 Birch Ct.
8685 Galindo Dr.
7500 Bonniewood Lane
8142 Peppertree rd
6638 Ebensburg Lane
8375 Ferncliff Ct.
6588 Ebensburg Ln.
6635 Maple Prive
7860 Firebrand Dr
6979 Portage Rd
11391 Cresta Lane
7598 Calle Verde Rd
11550 Soleado Ct.
829-5043
551-3307
829-5304
828-6042
829-4647
833-7642
828-4647
829-1239
551-7858
866-1~83
828-1631
828-9183
373-9398
828-9401
829-6712
828-4848
551-3332
861-6107
828-9712
551-7629
828-5263
829-6294
Repeal the $130.00 recycling fee!
Open competitive process - ABSOLUTELY!
$69,000 salary to contract negotiate is a
~! You could beautify the city with
that!
Use open bid process
If savings are passed along.
I think that the City should do something
about the water service. We're paying $60
(almost, $57) per bill for sewer and meter
maintenance!
Was not aware the service bidding was not
prevalent and a normal course of operation.
Why a consultant expense?
Donnell, Diane
Doolittle, Fred
Douglass, Robert
Doyle, Ron & Carole
Druschke, Barbara C.
Duda, Thomas R.
Duffey, Carlyne
Duner, Laura
Dutra, Jim & Carol
Dyer, William H.
Ebker, Cecile B.
English & Layman
Engstrom, Gail & John
Engstrom, Rich & Choral
Erickson, lleen
Ericson" Stephanie
Esposito, Rich
Eubanks, Gary
Evans, Don M.
Falke, Lana
Farr, Jim
Farrell, Dan
Fasulkey, Bob
Fent, Thomas P.
Feo, John
Ferguson, Rich & D.
Ferreira, Andrew P.
Ferrier, Paul
Ferris, Jean
Finan, John
Fiori, Christina
Fisher, Lisa M.
Fisher, M.
Floth, Edward
Fontes, Angela & Marc
Fontes, William J.
Ford, Janine A.
Ford, Tom
t-d
~
(j)
~
0\
7876 Cranford Ln
6840 lone Way
8396 Cavalier Lane
8121 via Zapata
8674 Beverly Lane
7359 Hansen Dr.
7390 Dover Lane
6990 Prince Drive
7903 Peppertree Rd
8662 Bloomington Ct.
7100 San Ramon Rd. #166
8742 Galindo Dr.
11931 W. Vomac Rd.
8481 Rhoda Ave., CR67
11472 winding Trail PI
8301 Mulberry Place
11743 Castle Ct.
7294 Dover Lane
7810 Tuscany Dr.
8462 Rhoda Ave.
7762 Crossridge Rd.
7012 Lancaster Rd.
7776 Topa~ Circle
8318 Cypress Ct.
11321 Marwick Drive
7718 Creekside Dr.
11628 Betlen Dr.
6789 Sapphire
7625 Bonniewood Lane
7317 Dover Lane
7508 Hillrose Dr
7544 Oxford Circle
8365 Creekside Dr.
7212 Quartz Circle
8702 Edenberry Place
6769 Hyde Ct.
8451 Beverly Lane
7262 Tina Place
829-0743
847-6867
828-5434
828-5163
833-9457
828-3154
833-8916
829-7632
828-1708
833-0198
847-7808
803-1145
828-8378
828-9575
829-6939
828-3640
803-8899
803-0568
828-4665
829-3140
803-9286
829-6299
551-7818
803-9936
551-3812
828-3113
828-6916
828-2356
803-1517
803-2918
833-8732
879-1824
829-9126
829-9646
No more funding for channel 30! PLEASE!
But included in consideration should be
review of fair employment practices, i.e.,
are benefits given, is pay competitive, etc.
Priority for unionized companies.
. ,.:
'.'
Forsberg, David & M
Foster, A.
Francis, Maril
Frank, J.
Franz, Rick & Heather
Freeman, Anita
Freeman, James
Freiling
Fronsdahl, Jim
Fung
Fung, Kenny
Gallagher, Helen
Garcia, Barbara
Garcia, Leonard
Garibaldi, A.
Garretson, Steve & Eve
Garrett, R.
Gartner, Debra S.
Gatzke, Kathi & Mark
Gaudiano
Gear, Elizabeth
Gehring, Kurt
Germeyer, Charles & C.
Gheorghita; Victor
Gibbons, J. C.
Giese, David C.
Gillengerten, J.
Gillespie, shirley
Glass, Tony
Goldstone, Rhonda
Gong, Dennis
Gonsalves, Jeffrey
Gordner, Randall
Gordon, F.
Gori, Linda
Green, Bob
Greene, Jacob & D.
Greenwood, J.
Greer, Randy & Mary
'"d
g:;
t>:I
'--J
11893 West Vomac Road
7532 San Sabana .Rd.
7864 Bristol Rd.
7760 Gardella Dr.
7591 Landale Ave.
7474 Oxford Circle
7815 Diana Lane
11581 Rolling Hills Dr.
7408 Hansen Dr.
78043 Stagecoach Dr.
8483 Galindo Dr.
7633 Sharon Ct.
7015 Spencer Ct.
6650 Ebensburg Lane
11894 Flanagan Ct.
7359 Limerick Ct.
7697 Starward Dr.
8381 Creekside Dr.
8444 Rhoda Ave.
7313 Cronin Circle
6848 Eden St.
7769 Deervale Ct.
7314 Emerald Ave.
7060 Corinth Ct.
11420 Winding Trail
7814 Alto Way
8324 Countess St.
6551 Nottingham Place
8008 Agate Way
8405 Locust Place
7014 Wineberry Way
7638 Canterbury Ct.
6550 Nottingham PI
6875 Ione Way
7300 Sheffield Lane
8316 Creekside Dr
8382 Cypress Ct.
277-5375
828-1795
833-2724
829-9189
803-0613
829-9409
829-8388
408-742-0083
828-5165
829-7000
551-3148
828-6584
828-4129
272-7188
828-3571
828-2952
828-1692
275-2898
828-3903
829-5741
833-7632
828-1605
828-2118
829-5456
828-1079
833-8757
828-9616
829-1041
815-8363
803-9139
828-1380
828-2432
Why are we hiring a consultant at $69,000 to
negotiate a contract? Why not open bid?
Bid for competitive garbage rates
.~ . .
Why aren't we going out for bid? Since City
took over, has been put on his taxes and has
increased 16%.
Gregory, Terison
Griffin, Chris
Griffin, P. A.
Griffin, Tom & Carol
Grossman, william O.
Guiles, A.
Gullet, David
Gurney, James H.
Gustavson, Randy
Guthmiller, W. & Mrs.
Guttierrez, Johnny
Hackerott, Michael & D
Haight, M.
Haims, Dale & Laurie
Hair, Christy
Hale, D~rcy & Alan
Hall, James & Patricia
Hall, R. J.
Hans, Chalmer & Judy
Hansen, David & Mary
Harbster, Robert G.
Harris, Betty
Harris, Jim & Judy
Harrison, Mr & Mrs.
Harrison, Wm. L.
Hartman, Sue
Harvey, Leonard
Hatchie, Joe
Hatcox, W.
Hayden, Kenneth
Heady, R.
Healy, Elliott
Heartz, Linda
Heavey, Tom
Hellmann, Debbie
Helman, Ken C.
Hemenway, Michael & Jan
Henry, James & Peggy
Hernandez, Lynda
I-d
:t>
4.>
t>:l
ex>
7748 Woodren Ct.
8748 Augusta Ct.
11864 pollardstown Ct.
8066 Brittany Dr.
11612 Castilian Ct.
7000 Utica Ct.
7364 Limerick Ct.
11477 Winding Trail PI
7105 Prince Dr
7419 Oxford Circle
7533 Brighton Dr.
8671 Fenwick Way
11502 Silvergate Dr.
7311 Glenn Oaks Way
8103 Via Zapata
7599 Hillrose Dr.
8053 Jade Circle
11384 Marwick Drive
6933 Cedar Lane
6873 Darian Ct.
7899 Diana Lane
lone Way
11861 Bloomington Way
8091 Iglesia Drive
11518 Padre Way
7626 Arbor Creek Cir
6997 Cedar Lane
8036 Via Zapata
8638 Galindo Dr.
11565 Manzanita
11389 Rampart Dr.
11362 Betlen Dr.
6792 Onyx Place
7585 Amador Vly Blvd #14
7071 Allegheny Dr.
8521 Valencia St.
8324 Rhoda Ave.
8146 Holanda Lane
551-8784
833-0213
829-2009
803-1676
829-6448
828-3307
828-6743
829-8584
828-2801
829-2671
803-0285
833-8268
828-5056
828-2461
828-4601
828-0811
833-8730
829-8553
828-2341
828-5055
828-2733
438-4500
833-8214
828-2304
829-3:262
833-0562
828-1394
829-3636
803-0771
828-3068
829-8541
(Mr. Houston) What is your position on
this?
Get bids, but composting should be included
in service; also include plastic milk jugs
and light cardboard
Herrero, Carlos C.
Hill, Daniel C.
Hill, Shirley
Hillyer, Cameron & M.
Hindman, T
Hiner, Bernie & Harv
Hio, Robert B.
Hoenig, Mark
Hoffman, Robert
Hoifjeld, Annabel R.
7800 Woodren Ct.
7980 Via Zapata
6637 Ebensburg Lane
7456 Oxford Circle
7959 Bristol Road
7605 Millbrook Ave
8471 Briarwood Lane
7821 Oxbow Lane
8225 Vomac Rd.
11200 Rothschild Ct.
Holland
Hollis, Robert
Holloway, L. B.
Holmdahl, G. R.
Hoon, Daryl
Hooper, Tim
Hootman, Paul & Mary
11721 Betlen Drive
7718 Burnham Way
6930 Post Road
8524 Beverly Lane
6786 Pearl Pl
7166 Pike Court
8189 Tamarack Drive
Hopkins, Marilyn
7510 Calle Verde Rd.
Horn, Donna & Gerald
Horrillo, Lisa & Tom
7005 Amador vly Blvd
11302 Village View Ct.
Hourany, Larry
Hoxie, Mary
Hrasok, Ann
Hudak, Betty
Hunkler, M. E.
Hunter, Robert L.
Hutchinson
Hveem, Sonya
7724 Firebrand Dr.
6549 Ebensburg Ln
8748 Davona Dr.
6938 Mansfield Ave.
11586 Estrella Ct.
8316 Locust Place
11686 Regio Dr.
8256 Rhoda Avenue
'"d
~
(j)
t<J
\0
8928-4887
828-0275
828-5512
829-9005
803-1083
828-2868
828-3914
727-4553
828-2820
828-9302
828-0253
833-9488
803-5747
829-7321
828-2066
828-8434
833-2692
828-1024
829-3771
828-6813
829-5137
829-8134
Or keep what we have now.
. -
Add cardboard recycling
Why are we paying $69,000 to a negotiator?
Why weren't we consulted before council made
a decision to award contract to one company?
OPEN JOB TO BIDDERS! Why did citizens lose
the choice of using the city garbage
collection by having it added to property
tax bill??
Why not, guys?
We feel the recycling program is extremely
lacking. All other Bay Area communities
have extensive recycling of all plastic, all
paper.and all cardboard, not just profitable
items. We have selective recycling!
Not happy about $69M being spent for
consultant!
We would like the City of Dublin to consider
the opinions of its citizens. We make up
the "City of Dublin."
Hyde, Bill & Mary Jane
Hynd, W. R.
Ishikawa, David & P.
Jackson, Tina
Jakobowski, Jeff & Mija
James, Wendy & Jerry
Jemo, wendy
Jenezon, James
Jenkins, Jr., William
Jensen, . Bob
Jensen, Donald L.
Jensen, Donald L.
Jesse, Richard & Carol
Joffe, Greg & Josye
Johnoliln, NOel C.
Johnson
Johnson, John & M.
Johnson, Ken & Renate
Johnson, Linda
Johnson, Lori
Johnson, Ruth E.
Jones, R. D.
K. Fuschser
Kang, Won Shik
Kasdan, Gloria J.
Kearns, Jane & Max
Kekos, J. J.
Kelly, Sean
Kennedy, Bill
Kennedy, Russel & Mrs
Keys, Colonel & Mrs.
Khandar, Bhagwat
t-d
:>>
o
trl
I-'
o
7426 Mancini Ct.
7041 Newport Ct.
7684 Arbor Creek Circle
7016A Stagecoach Rd.
6887 lone Way
7283 Dover Lane
11561 Fenwick Ct.
7962 Tamarack Dr.
7965 Gunshot Ct.
7310 Hansen Dr.
11432 Rampart Dr.
11432 Rampart Dr.
11348 Bloomington Way
8325 Locust Place
8449 Wicklow Lane
11556 Estrella Ct.
7938 Agate Way
7469 Hansen Drive
7546 Rolling Hills Cir
6941 Brighton Dr.
11672 Manzanita Lane
8268 Cardiff Dr.
11472 Silvergate Dr.
11418 Winding Trail
8300 Rhoda Ave.
11495 Silvergate Dr.
8524 Zandol Ct.
8340 Locust Place No.
7175 Prince Dr
8131 Brittany Dr.
P. O. Box 69
828-0318
828-5880
829-6320
828-7473
551-3378
828-6082
803-5705
803-5705
829-5426
803.0531
828-5541
828-8948
828-3092
828~4991
551-3365
833-9664
828-2691
829-1845
833-0546
829-9671
829-6693
828-3083
828-2565
829-8637
828-9687
828-0831
828-3173
We were quite surprised to discover your
method of selection. Doesn't appear to be a
good use of tax monies. I'm still not happy
with the recyling method. It's very limited
- only the stuff the company can sell easily
- I could sell it!
& Stop billing via tax rolls! Bill customer
monthly or quarterly!
"
I'd like to have the option, which was once
available, of using a smaller 20 gallon can,
to get a lower rate as a senior citizen. I
rarely generate enough garbage to fill a 30+
gallon can.
We don't need more people on our payrolls
Kidman, Karl & Deb
Kihara, Jerry
7486 Brighton Ct.
8~26 Locust Place
King, Raymond
Kirbie, Hugh & S.
Kitterman, Joni
Klees, Brian
Klescewski, S.
Klimkosky, Mike
Klopfstein, Dan
Klug, Wayne
Koski
7146 Pitt Ct.
7766 Turquoise St.
7764 Tuscany Drive
7445 Oxford Circle
6843 Lancaster Rd.
7508 San Sabana Rd.
7825 Castilian Rd.
6555-A Cottonwood Cir
8067 Via Zapata
Koual, Andor A.
Kramer
Krekorian, Don
Kruse, Arthur
Kumar, Ruth
Kurtz, Donald P.
Lancaster, Walter D.
Landow, Carolyn
Lange, Richard
Larese, Ricci
Larsen, Dale
Lasalle, patricia
Latorres, Alberta
Lavagnino, Mario & M.
Leana, Jose
Leary, Pete & Mrs.
Lee, John
Lee, prescila
Libby, William E.
Lindahl, R.
Lingo, Bob
8635 Davona Dr.
726~ Tina Place
6842 Brighton Dr.
~~805 Shadow Drive
7639 Shady Creek Rd
23~ Market Pl. #~44
7004 Cedar Ct.
739~ Tamarack Dr.
7678 Coral Way
8245 Brittany Dr
8365 Lucania St.
753~ Rolling Hills Cir
7592 Kilrush Ave.
~~706 Murietta Ct.
~~736 Shadow Drive
7800 Firebrand Dr.
8269 Brittany Dr.
7737 Crossridge Rd.
8934 Marwick Ct.
774~ Callan St.
7765 Dublin Green
Lopez, Sal
Louis, Rod
Luce, Ramond & C.
I-d
>
o
M
~~723 Juarez Lane
764~ Canterbury Lane
8206 Creekside Dr.
.......
.......
829-390~
803-8864
828-6632
829-~753
828-0202
833-8832
833-6424
803-~058
833-~697
828-3749
55~-3337
829-0383
828-0796
828-4~58
224-3~24
829-0738
829-6549
828-6429
842-2~94
828-7~35
828-0239
829-3729
828-5953
824-2430
828-2087
This is an internal price control, without
this, people in positions of authority will
abuse it.
::->....-
Dublin needs yardwaste, plastic, cardboard
and junkmail pick up (recycling). $~25
annually in taxes should cover this!!!
,. "
.:,"-
'. .
Hasn't been happy with Waste Management;
they do not pick up items other communities
pick up. Ridiculous to pay $69,000 to
consultant; should go out for bid.
How can you justify NOT going out for BID??
Lund, Tamara
Lundberg, David
Luton, Alice
Luzar, Alison
MacDonald, B.
MacLean, Rory
Macy, Marsh & Debbie
Maidus
Maige, Jonathan & J
Malicoat, Kathie
Marengo, Josephine D.
Markey, John
Marrone, John
Martin, Evamarie K.
Martinez., Joe & Isabel
Martinez, Ralph D.
Mar~ini, Phyllis
Martucci, Frank
Masterpole, Viola B.
Mateus, M.
Matheny, Mike & Erin
Matson, George
Matzat, STeven E.
Maurer, Mike
Maxfield, Melene
May, J. W.
May, Shirley A.
McBride, Jim & Sandy
McCarn, W, L & C
McCarron, Patricia
McCullough, Kevin
McDougall, Derek
McGovern, Joe
McKenna, Don
McMichael, Pat
McMillan, Bill & Val
McNew, Joan
McWhirter, Beth
McWhorter, Jim
Meadows, Wayne
'"d
:>>-
Cj)
tz:l
......
N
8466 Longford Way
8340 Creekside Dr.
7575 Hillrose Drive
7316 Bedford Way
8794 Wicklow Lane
8341 Creekside Dr.
7568 Silvertree Lane
7488 Bedford Ct.
8103 Holand Ct.
7314 Amanda St.
8176 Via Zapata
11742 Murietta Ct.
7964 Fall Creek Rd #201
8366 Vomac Rd
11730 Murietta Ct.
8709 Deervale Rd.
7810 St. Raymond Ct
7300 lone Ct.
11490 Silvergate Dr.
8206E North Lake Dr
7649 Kilrush Ave.
7148 Amador Valley Blvd
11884 W. Vomac Rd.
7581 Oxbow Lane
7528 Hillrose Dr.
7791 Alto Way
7548 Ashford Way
11668 Padre Way
8169 Via Zapata
11812 Southwick Ct.
11933 Rhoda Ct.
7668 Topaz Circle
7798 Turquoise St.
11721 Shadow Dr.
7541 San Sabana Rd.
6981 Amador Valley
11799 Bloomington Way
11502 Soleado Ct.
828-0730
828-5901
803-2932
829-0941
803-1902.
803-1457
829-3587
828-0621
829-0138
842 - 0771
829-5499
803-9591
829-3177
828-1803
828-7083
829-3977
833-6084
828-0534
828-7965
275-2995
803-9817
829-5716
828-2252
829-4512
803-8123
829-0650
829-2987
829-6915
829-0943
833-0687
829-0119
829-4149
975-0828
833-1661
828-5799
Urges Council to have competitive bids
~. :;.
I'd like to know why we aren't competitive
bidding. Competition reduces expense!
Get the charges off the property tax bill,
tool We need more recycling services.
Although current service is excellent
Medley, Doyle E.
Mellb, Teresa
Mellor, George H.
Meltzer, Mr & Mrs.
Menezes, Kimd de
Meyer, Pat
Mezz, D.
Miller, JOhn A.
Minniear, STeve
Mitchell, Dave
Mitchell, John
Moeller, Todd & Julie
Mohring, Michel
Mole, Gary E.
Monohan, M.
Montal vo.' Mark
Montano, A & C
Montemayor, Tony & Kath
Montoya, T. Mack
Morales, Al & Pat
Morissette, Diane
Morshead, S~anley D.
Moser, Al
Mosley, James C.
Motsenbocker
Mowrer, Sheridan
Mu~lins, J.P. & Mrs.
Murray, Sheryle
Myers, Jordan
Myers, Marie
Nagazima, Bernard
Nagle, F. & Mrs.
Naples, David
Naruo, Gerald
Neal, Emmett
Nelson's
Nelson, virginia L.
Newbeein, Jan & Ed
Newman, Mel & Mary
"tl
::>
o
trJ
I-'
W
6914 Post Road
7630 Arbor Creek Circle
7607 Carlow Way'
7482 Oxford Circle
7518 Calle Verde
7645 Hansen Dr.
7439 Limerick Ave.
8207 Aldea St.
11709 Shadow Dr
11821 Dunstown Ct.
6851 Langmuir Lane
7589 Kilrush Ave.
6655 Ebensburg Lane
7779 Cardigan St.
8460 Galindo Dr.
6502-C Cottonwood Cir
7670 Bonniewood Lane
7014 Locust Ct.
7124-C Cross creek Cir
8774 August Court
6867 Brighton Dr.
7986 Shannon Ct.
7530 Kilrush Ave.
7712 Canterbury Lane
7766 Alto Way
7584 Sutton Lane
8150 Cardiff Dr
7611 Quail Crk
6626 Pioneer Lane
7850 Bristol Rd.
7048 Lancaster Rd.
11702 Padre Way
7317 Quartz Cir.
11420 Cresta Lane
8705 Edenberry Place
7457 Brighton Dr
8628 Beverly Lane
7515 Bonniewood Lane
828-2824
829-6441
829-8687
828-8206
829-2512
833-8662
833-8545
829-2818
829-2124
833-9451
833-1730
829-8079
828-8282
675-5512
828-5369
829-4874
828-7609
803-0671
828-7981
803-5940
828-1295
803-9853
828-8106
829-3685
828-7466
828-5139
803-9283
828-2517
828-4968
833-0866
829-0913
828-5603
988-0700
829-4422
However, BFI may not be the answer.
. .
How does NOT bidding the service help Dublin
residents?
We believe our city should require open
competition for our garbage service also.
Thanks. God bless you all.
Newport, John
Nicolini, D.
Nida, Collette
Niegsch, Frank J.
Nourain, Farah
Nygard, Robert
O'Harra, Mark & Barb
O'Sullivan, Thomas
Odom, Marilyn
Oehrle, Gary
Oida, Joanne
Olgilvie, J. & Mrs.
Oliver, Kathy
Olsen, Jim & Renee
Orman, Rodney
Ortega, . Herman
Osada, Edwin
Osborne, Bud
Oswill, Ken
Oto, Ronald & Sally.
Pacheco, Michael
Packer, Matt
Pallotti, Mary
Palmer, Rick & Susan
Pankovich, W & Mrs.
Papineau, Nancy
Park Ave. Limousine
Parker, W. W.
Parrillo, D.
Pascoe, Joyce
Passmore, Tracey & Dan
Patrick, Richard
Patson, Marjorie
Patterson, Robert
Paul, Grace & Angela
Paulson, Daryl & Jen
Pavao, Adelaide
l-d
~
o
trl
......
.p..
8501 Davona Drive
8831 Marwick Ct.
8650 Beverly Lane
6880 Lancaster Road
7521 Oxford Cir
6941 Penn Drive
7667 Gardella Dr.
11669 Solana Dr
8346 Ferncliff Ct.
11331 Champagne Place
7979 Countess Ct.
8249 Rhoda Ave.
7755 Shady Creek Rd.
11721 Casa Linda Ct.
7880 Firebrand Dr.
11320 Betlen Dr.
7710 Squirrel Creek
6604 Conestoga Lane
7645 Arbor Creek Cir
11612 Alegre Dr
8577 Bandon Dr
7452 Limerick Ave.
7900 Crossridge Rd.
7849 Barn Hollow Ct.
6680 Spruce Lane
7238 Tamarack Dr.
6525 Sierra Lane
11829 Norfolk Place
8400 Rhoda Ave.
6580 Conestoga Lane
8276 Wexford Ct.
7258 Newcastle Lane
11707 Juarez Lane
11522 Rolling Hills Dr
7266 Quartz Circle
6985 Ann Arbor Way
8202 Holanda Lane
828-2569
829-8191
803-8710
828-9197
829-3055
828-5089
833-9794
828-3821
833-0475
803-1299
828-2939
828-1330
833-9260
803-8825
829-4640
829-9285
828-6560
667-3938
551-8710
828-5134
828-1701
829-4964
828-2033
828-4327
828-6992
833-0828
847-4334
829-4977
833-0686
833-8826
828-3458
829-1897
828-4962
829-5945
828-1193
I would only like to say, where do the
people who run this country think the money
is supposed to keep coming from? People's
wages have been cut, yet you think we can
keep paying for higher services.
Thanks to BFI for bringing this to our
attention
Include yard waste recycling
Payton, Greer L.
Pearson, John & Flo
Pecorraro, John
Pejman, Kamran
Pentecost, Kathy
Perrin, Bob
Perry, Barbara
Perry, Mr & Mrs
Peters, Dwight D.
Petersen, M.
Pfitzer, A.
Piek.
Pierce, Tim
Pimperl, Danny
pistochini, Peter & Mrs.
Pochmara, Ray
Poulson, Ed
Pray, Ruth
priestegard, Peter
Prieto, John
Pulliam, Jim
Quijano, Evelyn
Rady, George
Raica, Peter A.
Rascano
Ratto, Bernard
Redick, Merritt D.
Redic, Thomas Jr.
Reed & Ornelas
Reis, Louis
Resident
Resident
Resident
Reuter, David & Pat
Reynolds, Myrle J.
Ribeira
'"d
:>
c;J
t:t1
~
V1
7705 Creekside Dr.
7060 Elba Way
7823 Cross ridge "Rd
8018 Creekside Dr.
6981 Darian Ct.
8657 Fenwick Way
7173 Kingston Place
8232 Wexford Ct.
7648 Arbor Creek Cir
8816 Bandon Dr.
11865 Dublin Green Dr
11940 Rhoda Ct.
6767 Tory Way
6985 Spencer Ct.
11695 Harlon Rd.
7485 Limerick Ave.
P. O. Box 2392
11693 Regio Dr.
11575 Estrella Ct.
7364 Tamarack Dr.
7681 Kilrush Ave.
7794 Barn Hollow G.
7609 Frederiksen Ct.
11578 Rolling Hills Dr
7054 Ann Arbor
11439 Rampart Drive
11768 Solana Dr
7227 Elba Ct.
11439 Marwick Dr.
7565 Sunwood Dr.
Unknown
Unknown
Unknown
7329 Starward Dr.
7907 Shannon Ave.
11671 Betlen Dr.
828-6339
828-4272
829-6889
957-3288
803-0575
828-7849
551-8742
829-5625
833-8338
829-2307
803-9515
828-6389
803-0809
829-7912
828-0700
828-0360
828-8641
828-9711
803-8490
828-4703
828-7872
829-2254
829-7398
828-3856
829-3280
828-2273
829-4019
828-3251
828-5988
. '.
. .
.. ,.. ~
Also would like to go to dumps without
paying twice as much as surrounding cities.
Cost of garbage service is way too high.
Let's look at the cost vs. services offered
to the community. BFI provides a good
service in Fremont. Let's compare with an
open mind.
Suggestion - why not have curbside recycling
every two weeks? Looking at neighbors -
Ribitz, Mr & Mrs Ken 6763 sapphire St: . 833-7640
Richardson, Larry 7749 Ironwood Dr. 829-1437
Rimshaw, Ed 7611 Hillrose Dr 828-2938
Rinshaw, KM& TA 6890 Brighton Dr. 828-2157
Rivas, Edward & Joanne 7640 Cardigan St.
Rivera, Jose 11889 Dublin Green Dr 828-6255
Roberts, Brian & Nancy 7048 Elba Way 833-0486
Robinson, David 8579 Beverly Lane 803-1106
Robinson, Don 11688 Amarillo Ct. 828-4420
Rose, R. 7147 Hansen Dr. 828-8588
Ross, Eliot 7005 Corinth Ct. 829-5148
Rossington, R. H. 7649 Catalon Ct.
Roth, Alfred R. 8696 Valencia St. 828-5486
Rubert, Alvin & C. 7863 Landale Ave. 828-2101
Rubianes, Jennifer 7704 Chantilly Dr. 828-1987
Rubino, Sylvia 8317 Lucania St. 829-6295
Rubrecht, Barbara 7928 Vomac Rd.
Rusconi, John & Debbie 8164 Via Zapata 803-1158
Russell, Dan
Russell, Robert & Jo
Russo, R.
Russo, Tony & Mrs.
Saenz, Y.
Salazar, G. E.
Samaro, Louis & Therese
Samples, Robin
Santos, Robert
Saunders, Charles
Schem, Mrs. F.
Scheppler, Robert L.
Schneider, Rita & Walt
Schuitemaker, A.
Schuler, Paul
Schultz, Ron & Susan
Schunk, Janet
Schwartz, Susanne
Schweser, Tom
Scott, D.
Sehrgosha, Mazy
>d
g:;
trl
.....
0\
8333 Lucania St.
11625 Ladera Ct.
8240 Vomac
11741 Regio Dr.
7617 Canterbury Lane
8560 Rhoda Place
7734 Squirrel Crk Cir
7472 Oxford Circle
7932 Countess Ct.
11906 Dublin Green Dr
7965 Iglesia Dr.
8109 Via Zapata
11689 Amarillo Ct.
7937 Hansen Dr.
7595 Carlow Way
7078 Lancaster Ct.
7325-D Park Wood Circle
7374 Cronin Circle
11576 Manzanita Lane
8518 Zandol Ct.
11825 Norfolk Place
828-4627
828-5878
551-8072
829-8725
828-9441
828-6693
828-4355
829-0822
829-9698
551-7416
803-0206
828-3349
803-8154
829-7517
they don't have enough to put out every week
- save money.
Also provide for green recycling SOON
If it's cheaper!
It's my money!! We MUST open bid!!
We need to be able to recycle all plastics &
cardboards, too!
::'
Seilhymer, Judith
Shaddy, Jeff
Shanks, Donald R.
Sharp
Shepherd
Shetterly, Grover & Mrs
Sickel, Jim & Ann
Sidbury & Blackburn
Sieber & Perez
Sieler, vic & Jan
silva, Art
Silva, Marilyn
Silva, Olivia
Simmons, David
Simonds, James C.
Simone, .A.
Simone, J.
Simonson, Roy & Mrs
Simpson, C.
Singh, Hargobind
Sizer, E. R.
Skipper, A. J.
Slesnick, Donna K.
Slofkosky, Rich & C.
Smaus, Greg & Sue
Smith, Cheryl
Smith, Greg & Marley
Smith, Martin
Smith, Robert J.
Smith, Willie
Smyth, Steven L.
I-d
~
t>:I
.......
'-J
8351 Cavalier Lane
7992 Agate Way
7681 Ashford Way
11700 Regio Drive
7701 Bonniewood Ct.
7654 Cardigan St.
11452 Rothschild PI
11690 Padre Way
8359 Mulberry Place
8491 Wicklow Lane
828-2979
829-0403
828-3331
829-5891
829-7302
833-9412
828-1894
803-1911
7638 Coral Way
7782 Castilian Rd.
7511 Hillrose Dr.
6536 Maple Drive
7793 Peppertree Rd
8663 Fenwick Way
6964 York Dr
7588 Silvertree Lane
8374 Cypress Ct.
8680 Fenwick Way
7841 Canterbury Lane
6544 Conestoga Lane
7527 Sutton Lane
7466 Oxford Circle
7557 Hillrose Dr.
11492 Bloomington Way
8500 Beverly Lane
11624 Luna Ct
11494 Wildcat Ct.
6745 Hyde Ct.
(415) 973-2469
828-5547
828-5926
829-8367
829-1161
828-3166
833-1610
828-9047
803-0173
829-4597
842-4841
820-0971
803-1890
829-0499
828-7345
829-1350
828-2371
829-9655
828-7946
~;~.
Basically, competition will encourage better
service and will discourage the toierance of
collectors retaliating when complaints are
made. The decision made by the city of
Dublin which forces me to pay the present
provider (sometimes) of service with no
regard as to the quality of service,
handling of complaints, etc. If I were
allowed to choose I would already have
chosen to take my business elsewhere, to
someone who would be more responsive to the
needs and to the resolution of problems.
Soares, John & Nancy
Soares, Manuela
Soliman, Sam
Soliven-Pitman
Songey, Art
Soong, Gwen
Soshe, Chuck & Danielle
Souza, James & Marge
Spayde, Ralph L.
Speed, Hedy & Russel
Spooner, Joie
springer, Carl D.
Stanton, Mark
Staub, Mae & Ed
Stegeman, Richard
Stein, Russ
Stewart, Jim
Stone, Minnie L.
Straus, Cathy
Streepa, G. J.
Stretton, Paul & Mrs
Strong, Ron & Rebecca
Sulikowski, W. Z.& Mrs
Sullivan, Tim
Swanson, Jel
Sweetser, M.
Swiers, Gretchen
Swokla, R.
T & T Solar Service
Taegen, Skeet
Taketa, Gary T. & D.
Tan, Renee
Tatman, Paul E.
Taylor, David
Taylor, Heidi
l-d
>
<:;")
t:rJ
......
00
7846 Crossridge Rd.
11422 Bloomington Way
8684 Waterford Ct.
11803 Castle Court
11726 Bloomington Way
7075 Corinth Ct.
11511 Silvergate Drive
7504 Honey Ct
7330 Hansen Dr.
11754 Castle Ct.
8525 Bandon Dr.
6522 Amador Valley Blvd
8597 Wicklow Lane
7451 Hansen Dr
11848 W. Vomac Rd.
7593 Frederiksen Ct
7502-Calle Verde Rd.
6648 Maple Drive'
7826 Alto Way
Po Box 2395
7697 Shady Creek Dr
7543 Bonniewood Lane
7004 Wineberry Way
6881 Doreen Ct.
7957 Peppertree Rd
11688 Ladera Dr
6910 Pine Court
6700 Goodfellow Rd. #27
8452 Deervale Rd
11637 Luna Ct.
6602 Pioneer Lane
11402 Rolling Hills Dr
7657 Sunwood Dr.
7750 Tuscany Dr
7193 Elk Ct.
828-9127
828-4882
828-9340
829-8956
829-9369
829-0326
828-0203
828-6610
829-4425
463-0611
829-1013
829-2998
833-7618
829-1743
828-3716
828-5041
823-9797
833-8989
828-2677
829-1894
833-9257
828-6745
828-5892
833-9793
828-0105
842-1866
828-4976
895-0500
828-1862
_..~-
Spending money to hire a consultant to
negotiate a contract that could be obtained
at no cost through a competitive bid is
ridiculous. Why, if you decided not to bid
the contract, can't the current employees
i.e., City Manager, Asst, etc., negotiate?
.. ,. "
I like our garbage service, but I like
Castro Valley's recycling service.
Please help improve disposal and recycling
service. Very poor as it now is!!
Taylor, James & Evelyn
Taylor, Jean
Taylor, Steve & Ann
TeStruth, Craig & Mrs.
Thomas, Charles D.
Thompson, Carles & D.
Thompson, L. Scott
Ting, Richard
11447 Winding Trail Ln
11565 Estrella Ct.
11508 Padre Way'
6768 Pearl Place
8553 Longford Way
7476 Limerick Ave.
7754 Starward Dr
7696 Arbor Creek Cir
Tinkler, Dorothea
Tirnetta, Albert
Toda, J.
Todd, C.
Tolar, John
Tomasetti, Richard
Tomerlin, E. E.
8019 Bristol Rd
7545 Brighton Drive
6713 Elm Ct.
7319 parkwood Apts #F
8219 Mulberry Pl
7551 Sutton Lane
6828 Eden St.
Torres, Ken
Torrez, Elias
Tripi, Vincent & Mary
Trujillo, Lisa
Uchytil, John
Uriyu, Steve
Valvo, Leonard
Vance, Carolyn
VanDorn, Steve
vanier, Devanie
Vann, Valerie
Viera, Michele
Vigil, Ester
8701 Davona Dr.
8095 Aldea St.
6946 Amador Valley Blvd.
7427 Mancini Ct.
6944 Tyne Ct.
7986 Castilian Rd
8364 Creekside Drive
8145 Via Zapata
8018 Iglesia Dr.
7942 Fall Creek Rd #107
11447 Rampart Dr.
7031 Utica Court
8125 Tamarack
Vinci, Oronzo
Vitello, Lnda M.
Vrba, Diana
Wadman, J. Thomas
Wai, Allen
Walch, Tom
Walters, Dan & Denise
Ward, Caroline
Wargin, Joyce
Wasak, Eugene
Wasserman, Paul
'"d
g:;
tTJ
11543 Circe Way
11~14 W. Vomac Rd
8115 Brittany Dr.
8250 Rhoda Ave.
8398 Mulberry Place
7359 Emerald Ave
8851 Longford Way
8395 Cypress Ct.
6747 Tory Way
80~0 Iglesia Drive
7480 Brighton Pl.
.......
\.0
415-396-5696
828-1744
828-2034
829-3065
828-6640
803-0298
829-4064
828-9310
828-7495
828-1161
828-2017
551-7791
828-3245
828-1816
828-5484
551-7890
833-8053
828-2563
828-0718
551-8474
829-8477
828-4893
828-1726
803-2996
833-0489
828-1985
569-2949
829-5441
828-4226
829-1617
829-5656
727-4228
Only if competitor offers equal or better
service
~.~....~."
Also need to recycle milk cartons and bleach
jugs - olease aoen issue
-.
.., . - - '.~ ....
Please get bids so residents can have better
service at a cheaper price
Webb, Richard
Weeks, Brent & Jennie
Weisberger, Mr & Mrs.
Weiss, Gerald & Mrs.
Whitaker
Whi te, Nancy
Wilberg, Gary & Mrs.
Wilcox, Susan
Wilkins, Harry
William E. Spruit
williams, Don & Ruby
Williams, Hans
Williams, James
Wilson & Lewis
Wilson, Martha
Winter, Sue
Wixson, Nina
Wolf, Carolyn C.
Wong, Eric
Wong, Terry
Wood, G. R.
Woods, Harrell E.
Woods, Michael W.
Woodward, Diane & A.
Wright
Wright, Joan
wyosnick, Nancy
Young
Young, Charles & Mrs.
Zaharan, Janet
Zajac, Joe & Elizabeth
Zarodney, S & V
zeigler, A. J.
Zekman, Maureen
Zika, George A.
Zoller, M~rk
Zollicoffer, Mrs. L.
Zqpler, E.
Zweigel, Linda
t-d
~
<:;")
trl
N
o
7343 Glenoaks Way
7018 Mulberry Ct.
7348 Sheffield ~t.
11158 Brittany Lane
7890 Bristol
11623 Castilian Ct.
7313 Castle Dr.'
11774 Castle Ct.
11565 Soleado Ct.
11624 Ladera Ct.
7128 Hansen Dr.
11729 Silvergate Drive
7871 Crossridge Rd.
11619 Silvergate Dr.
Silvergate Drive
8450 Beverly Lane
7403 Cronin Circle
7919 Peppertree Rd.
67933 Amador Valley Blvd
7714 Chantilly Dr.
8091 Jade Circle
7970 Vomac Rd
7949 Shannon Ct.
11438 Rolling Hills Dr
6729 Birch Ct.
7512 Oxford Circle
11773 Bloomington Way
7420 Tamarack Dr.
6906 Cedar Lane
8307 Davona Dr.
11521 Marwick Drive
6943 Darian Court
8338 Vomac Rd
7072 Lancaster Road
8046 Peppertree Rd.
11754 Murietta Ct.
8428 Galindo Drive
6525 Ebensburg Lane
11937 West Vomac Rd
828-6353
828-0678
828-0308
235-2362
829-1676
829-6023
833-8720
829-7700
828-8779
828-2362
828-2267
828-3286
828-1211
828-1604
828-4943
828-1670
494-4456
833-7603
828-0758
828-7022
803-1343
828-4863
828-3373
829-4122
828-1127
829-4731
803-9549
828-6284
828-8582
829-7930
828-4350
803-8818
828-2968
828-4383
. .
Should be a competitive bid
Okay, except our present service is very
good.
. ... ~:.. .
Copy Pleasanton's garbage service - it's a
good one.
Can the City of Dublin do anything to
control the cost of water? We pay more than
any other area!
CALLS AND CARDS AGAINST GOING OUT FOR BID
Allender, Jody
Barbas, Jose
11336 Bloomington
8687 Royston Ct.
828-3387
829-2640
Beilke, Selma 8456 Beverly Lane
Bonasch 11453 Rampart Drive 828-0737
Bush, N. 11927 W. Vomac Rd.
Cabral 7404 Rolling Hills Cir
Cardinal Construction Union City
Caulkins, Alice A.
6956 Lancaster Rd.
828-1459
Conklin, Michael
11432 Winding Trail Lane
Cushman, F.
11474 Betlen Dr.
833-1984
Fraser, John H.
Hanzel, J.
7709 Bonniewood Ct.
88605 Longford Wy
829-0846
Hirano, H.
7555 Amarillo Road
t-d
o
N
I-'
Keep the garbage service the way it is!
Do not put it for open competition. BFI is
no good. Promise a lot but don't live up to
it - talk to Fremont residents. (Enclosed
two letters to the editor from Fremont
residents complaining about BFI)
Never!!! Our current service is excellent
and rates are okay.
Please leave well enough alone. Garbage
service is fine.
Present service is less expensive and less
hassle than in San Ramon
Very satisfied with Waste Management.
Please don't change.
BFI is the worst company they have ever
dealt with - they screw up every single job
order placed. They use a lot of dumpsters
in their business, very unhappy with BFI
service.
-!.". '.,
'.. " '.
.', ." '.
We are very satisfied with the service we
have now.
I trust in my City Council's efforts to keep
cost down and provide excellent garbage
service.
This solicitation is being provided by BFI.
I'm much happier with current service than I
was with the prior BFI service I had!
Current service is excellent. Please
continue!
Why? It's okay as it is.
I would hate to see Dublin get a bum
treatment with rates going sky high with BFI
just like Fremont has
I want good service at a reasonable cost.
How you get this is up to the City Manager.
Cost is NOT the primary criteria. Good
service includes provisions for reduction of
waste to landfills - recycling pickup, yard
waste pickup, responsive to dumpsters, etc.
Hoyan, Jane
8455 Beverly Lane
Hughes, John F.
6600 Maple Dr
Jones, Steve
'7762 Tamarack
Lavagning, Mario
11680 Manzanita Lane
Padilla, Mecia
7985 Via Zapata
Pedersen, Linda
Resident
Pecota, Debbie
Resident
Resident
11302 Rolling Hills Dr
Unknown
Unknown, Dublin
Resident
Unknown, Dublin
Resident
Unknown
Sanders
Ybarrolaza, Phil & Al
7251 Amanda St.
'"d
:;t>
o
trJ
tv
tv
Ziebarth, Gary
8393 Rhoda Ave
828-0842
828-3514
833-8433
829-2532
551-0495
828-2987
828-1603
829-5252
What basis do we have to judge if BFI can
provide good service. Ways to improve
service - extra bag or can on occasion at no
extra cost; provision to order small
dumpster (about 2 cubic yards); hauling of
old appliances, beds, etc., with phone call.
.I like our service - Dublin-Livermore just
like it is - NO CHANGES!
Why? We now have superior, deluxe, backyard
service at a very fair price. Curbside
service would make oUr city look like mess.
Leave well enough alone. NO NO NO NO.
I DO NOT WANT BFI IN DUBLIN. KEEP
LIVERMORE/DUBLIN DISPOSAL.
Only if we have the same or better
conditions like having cleanup 4 times a
year. A lower bid should also be tied to
lower garbage rates.
I do not want any change - keep BFI out -
they provide terrible service in Fremont
Thinks we have great garbage service. Men
always friendly & wave, doesn't want us to
change service
Please don't change garbage service!
STAY WITH THE ~ COMPANY
Works for Waste Management, happy with
service now.
Works for Waste Management, happy with
service now.
Does not want to pay $69,000 for consultant.
Satisfied with how we have it now; likes
mandatory garbage for everyone; doesn't want
rates to go up.
Does not want Council to go out for garbage
bid - been here since 1965 & rates are just
fine. Doesn't feel it would be a fair shake
to go out to bid.
Keep the waste disposal and recycling
service that we presently enjoy. We DO NOT
want curbside service.
. .
"
Stick with Livermore/Dublin Disposal, and in
addition, recycle #2 plastics, misc. paper
and cardboard.
~~Waste
Iii.o~
/ _cv.t'i
" /
JI 11.1~, /1/
C {; UJ .~~(.
necyclmJ paper *
BROWNING-FERRIS INDUSTRIES
Alameda County District
January 9, 1995
:~5.~':" r-:.i v' 1: 0
Mr. Paul Rankin
Assistant City Manager
City of Dublin.
P.O. Box 2340
Dublin, CA 94568
JAN 9 .. 1995
CITY Or- DUOLlN
Dear Paul:
Thank you for YO~II' interest in Browning-Ferris Industries as you consider releasing a competitive
Request For Proposals to provide comprehensive n.:cycling .md wa~tc services in the Cily of Dublin.
BFI is very eager 10 pHrticipate in such a process and equally motivated to become your future service
provider when your current contract with Waste Management expires in 1996.
As you know, we n.:ccnlly comlucted a community survey mllong Dublin residenls to learn more about
their unique needs and wanls regarding Dublin recycling and waste services. Our survey was
conducted through direct mail, reaching approximately 8.000 households during the months of
November and December, 1994. The BFI mailer contained an informationallctter. a copy of a Tri-
Valley Herald editorial supporling an open competitive RFP process. and two postcards through which
residents could provide feedback--one to the City expressing opinions on whether or not the City
should release a competitive RFP; ,l11d Hnother to BFI expressing opinions about current recycling and
waste services, and how those services can be improved.
In my conversation with you the other day J was pleased to learn of the overwhelming support among
Dublin residents which you have recorded so far--724 to 24--in favor ofreleasing a competitive RFP
to interested proposers who wish to servc your community's future recycling and waste needs. We
were equally impressed with feedback to BFI. As of January 3, 1995, a whoppinl! 1.157 residents-
nearlv 140Ic,--had returned response cards to our offices! That's a phenomenal response rate given
that 1-2% is more commonly expected and 5% is considered outstanding. Our major findings include:
97% of the respondents want the City to agree to an open competitive process where
various waste companies compete to provide Dublin's future recycling and waste services,
Although residents periodically recycle, most would recycle more if it were more convenient.
65% don't recycle cardboard or junk mail in any way.
66'% don't recycle yard waste in any way.
78% say they would use a yard wm;te container if one was provided.
In uny event. 28% want more recycling services.
.
Many residents are conccrned about cost. 39% want whatever service is cheapest.
.
Residents prefer curbside to backyardlsideyard service by a slight margin.
26% prefer curbside service. '
19% prefer backyardlsideynrd service.
11 % had no opinion.
.
.
Over 40% state that current service is just adequate or below.
42600 BOYCE ROAD (945~8) · P.O. BOX 5013 . FREMONT, CALIFORNIA 94537-5013 . (51E EXHIBIT 9
~e
.
Recycled paper <I
Mr. Paul Rankin / City of Dublin
January 9, 1995
Page 2
Beyond these survey results, it may also interest you and the City Council to know that nearby
communities arc discovering significant benefits in releasing competitive RFP's for recycling and
waste services. The enclosed article highlighting the City of Newark's experience is one such
example. The City of Fremont, another nearby example, saved its community approximately $3.5
million by going with a competitive process.
As you know, with an open competitive process, the City will have options. You could decide to
select the lowest bidder, you could choose the company you believe is best, or you could extend the
existing contract with your current service provider. We hope you consider the overwhelming
feedback ti'om your community when making this important decision.
Thank you for keeping BFI informed on the status of your process. We look forward to attending
your January 23rd City Council Meeting to participate in further discussions on this important issue.
Meanwhile, if I can be of any additional service please don't hesitate to contact me at (510) 657-1350,
extension 3005.
Happy New Year!
cc: Dublin City Council
enelosure
'~e
.
:Garbage,
rec::ycling
rate~ may
go down
By Chris O'Connell
STAFF WRITER
NEWAJaK - Residents and busi-
nesses wEU likely see lower garbage
and recyc ling bills when a new col-
lection seLVice begins in April, city
officials al'illounced Friday.
: Rates should fall by about 4 per-
cent if the city stays with Waste
Management of Alameda County as
its trash .and recycling contractor,
city officiaLls said.
. For the majority of households)
which use one 32-gallon trash con-
tainer along with recycling binS, a 4
percent ,drop would lower the
monthly ;::harge by 49 cents, to
$11.77 from $12.26. The new rates
would app ear on bills in April.
. . The cit.:y is in the final phase of a
competitiv'e process designed to se-
lect a tras:h and recycling collector
for the neJa seven to 10 years. New-
ark's curmnt agreement with Waste
Manageml5!nt expires March 31.
.: . City ofIicials will ask the City
. Council on Thursday to choose
Waste Mmlagement again as the
contractor and authorize city staff
to negotiate a new agreement witlt
the company.
. . Details yet to be resolved include
whether the new service will be
mandatory for residents. and
whether l'ecyclables will be picked
up weekly. or every two weeks. Man-
datory coJllection and biweekly recy-
cling wouLld mean more savings,
according to city officials, who said
they will ask the council to conduct
a special public meeting to go over
such issue:s. .
:..; ~The .mcellhOOd 'o! lower~'rates'
comes as.;8. pl~t.sUrprise,'esP~
.'€ialJy.~el1 p~<:~(~tial!Y"~~~=i
. pected'.:to\go}.JlP".sai(t~~"'H~~'r
assistant;:;:city.,,~er JiS:The;}bJgf
. factor was unprecedented' compe~~;
'lion, Hu~~o said: Waste Manage-.
ment was one of three companies to
submit a proposal to Newark out.
lining services and likely rates.
The Argus
January 7, 1995
'For de!lMes, Waste Manage-
ment, fonnerly Oakland Scavenger,
e.qjoyed long-term garbage con-'
tracts with Fremont, Newark, Union
City and other Alameda County
cities.
. The oth,er companies vying for
Newark's contract were the Green
Team of S:an Jose and Browning-.
Ferris IndUlstries of California. BFI'
is a re1ativ.e, newcomer to the area
. thatrecentlly landed Frelnont's gar-
,. bage:axid rE~cling conJ;Tact~ . .'
: ''Tlllu, nlore'than'likely, 'woke up
a' lot ,.of, people "at "Waste. Manage-
"rhent," Hue,zo said.J;'
,: The <company's. proposal to
Newark"wa'S:the;;Ieam,;,~expensive of.
the three .~q:mpe1itors, and partly ,at- ..
.. 1ributablet;.o:,~'the aggressiveness of . .
BFI," Huezo said.' '<!
In its piroposal, Waste Manage-
ment offered to handle the city's
trash and recycling for about
$4.4 milliOHl a year. The company
currently cblarges the city $4.59 mil-
lion.
.,' BFI offel~ed a price of $4.61 mil-
~on, while 'the Green Team offered
- .
Ple;ase see Garbage..A-17
Garbage: Lower bills expected' .~:;
Continued from A-1
$4.63 million.
Waste Management, which oper-
ates in Newark through its subsid-
iary, East Bay Disposal Co.,. . was
able to lower the price from its ..
existing level chiefly because the'
city is willing to switch from back-..
yard to curbside service, said Dan
Borges, division president and gen-
eral manager of East Bay Disposal.
The change means the company
can start using trucks with aut0-
mated arms that will pick up and
empty the garbage containers,
Borges said. That, in turn, means
the company can staff its trucks
with one worker instead of the. cur-
rent two, he said.
There will, however, be no n~t'
loss of jobs for company employees
in Newark, Borges said. "
"Some of them will be doing'~
different job, but there won't be anY'
less jobs available to them," he said.:'
~; (l
Contingent upon the council'~j
. approval and an agreement on ~;
final contract, the new garbage and
recycling service will start April 1. A.
new feature will be a separate con-
tainer, ~bly 64 or 96 gallons, for,
yard c1ip~ings.
The continued emphasis on recY':
cling is a result of a 1989 state law.
that requires cities to cut their gar..'
bage production in half by the year
2000.;\ .