HomeMy WebLinkAbout6.2 HowardJohnsonCUP
r
CITY ,COUNCIL MEETING DATE: April 10, 1939
SUBJECT:
Continued Public Hearing - A~peal of PA 88-148
Howard Johnson's Conditional Use Permit,
Temporary Retail Sales and A~ctions within
existing conferencejbanquet rooms at 6680
Regional Street
REPORT PREPARED BY:
Associate Planner
EXHIBITS ATTACHED:
Exhibit A-I: Draft Resolution of Approval
upholding the Commission action approving the
Conditional Use Permit
Exhibit B-1: Site Plans (3)
Exhibit A-2: Draft Resolution modifying the
Planning Commission.action
Exhibit B-2: Site Plans (3)
Attachment 1: City Council Staff Report for the
March 27, 1989 meeting
Attachment 2: Appeal letter dated received
March 3, 1989
""","'A"",/!;?,,,,1 11:
~
1. Open Public Hearing and ~ear Staff
presentation.
2. Take Testimony from Applicant and the Public
3. Question Staff, Applicant and the Public
4, Close Public Hearing and Deliberate
5.. Adopt Resolution (Exhibit A-lor Exhibit
A-2) relating to PA 88-1.~8, or give Staff
and Applicant direction and continue the
matter
FINAi\1CIAL STATEHENT:
None
BACKGROUND:
During the meeting of March 27, 1989, the City Council heard Staff's
presentation and Applicant's comments on the Appeal of How-9.rd Johnson's
request for a Conditional Use Permit to allow temporary retail sales and
auctions within the existing hotel's conferencejbanquet rooms at 6680 Regional
Street. The Appellant, due to sudden unforseen circumstan:es, was unable to
attend the meeting and present comment. The Council conti":lued their
co~~irleration of the matter to its next meetip~.
Staff was directed to contact the cities of Livermor.a and Pleasanton and
report back as to what these communities require for this type of request.
Pleasanton's zoning regulations allow for temporary sales/auctions as an
accessory use within a hotel conference room if the hotel is in a retail
business zone and the use has a temporary business license.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ITEJo! NO.
6<>2
COPIES TO: Applicant
Owner
PA 88-148
-1-
>
(d
;"
(
Livermore's zoning requires the issuance of a Zoning Use Permit, even if
the site is zoned for the use. The Zoning Use Permit is i.sued administra-
tively by Staff. The Zoning Use Permit would require the property owner to be
co-applicant on the request and the City would be able to limit the duration
of the event (typically, no more than 10 days/events within a 6-month period).
In addition, the City has a business license program requiring the issuance of
a temporary business license.
Staff has also contacted the City of Walnut Creek, wnich requires the
issuance of a zoning administrator's permit, as well as a temporary business
license.
ANALYSIS:
The Appeal involves the temporary sales/auction activities only. The
City regulations (Section 8-60.60, 8-60.60.1 and 8-61) allow for consideration
of temporary uses in any district through a use permit process. The Hotel's
current use permit did not include this use, therefore, this activity needed
consideration through a separate permit request.
In October of 1988, the Staff learned of a planned tamporary sales
The operator,was contacted and subsequently applied and received
for a temporary. sales through an Administrative C.,nditional Use
event.
approval
Permit.
In subsequent discussions with the hotel operator, Staff learned that
the temporary sales and auctions had been a past practice ~ith the company and
one they wished to continue.
Staff informed ,the Applicant that to legally allow s~ch activities to
occur, an Administrative Conditional Use Permit or Conditional Use Permit
would be needed, depending on duration. Given that the Applicant felt they
would likely have several such activities throughout the y,aar, Staff indicated
a Conditional Use Permit could be applied for.
The City Attorney has reviewed the application and appeal and indicated
that should the Council feel the use appropriate, conditio'Ols could only be .
applied to the use itself, not the operators of the events. State law and
. permits pre-empts the local government from further regulating the actual
seller/auctioner (see March 27, 1989 Council Staff Report, Attachment 1).
Two draft resolutions are attached for Council consideration. Exhibit
A-I would uphold the Commission action, allowing the temporary sales/auction
uses. Exhibit A-2 would modify the Commission action not .approving the
temporary sales/auction activities, however still allowing the other
Commission approved uses to occur.
-2-
RESOLUTION NO.
- 89
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
---------------~-------~------------------------------------------------------
UPHOLDING THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S ACTION APPROVING PA 88-148 HOWARD JOHNSON'S
CONDITIONAL USE PER.~IT TO ADD A PROPOSED BARBER/BEAUTY S~)P (HAIR SALON), GIFT
SHOP, OFFICES, TEMPORARY RETAIL SALES AND AUCTION ACTI'iTITIES WITHIN THE
EXISTING HOTEL BUILDING AND A DANCE FLOOR WITHIN THE LORD DUBLIN
RESTAURANT/LOUNGE AREA.
lffiEREAS, Johnson Clark filed an application f.n a Conditional Use
Permit to establish a commercial recreational facility (daace floor) and to add
a proposed barberfbeauty shop (hair salon), gift shop, offices, temporary
retail sales and auction activities within the existing hotel building in an
existing restaurant at 6680 Regional Street; and
lffiEREAS, the City of Dublin Zoning Ordinance requires approval of
a Conditional Use Permit in the C-l District for the operation of a commercial
recreational facility (dance floor) and temporary sales; aad
lffiEREAS, the Planning Commission did hold a p'~blic hearing on said
application on February 21, 1989; and
lffiEREAS, proper notice of said public hearing was given in all
respects as required by law; and
WHEREAS, this application has been reviewed in accordance with the
prov~s~ons of the California Environmental Quality Act and has been found to be
categorically exempt; and
WHEREAS. the Staff Report was submitted recomnending consideration
of the Conditional Use Permit application appeal; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission did hear and consider all said
reports, recommendations and testimony herein above.setforth.
WHEREAS, on February 21, 1989 the Planning Comnission adopted
Resolution No. 89-005, approving PA 88-148 Conditional Use Permit for
additional hotel uses including temporary retail sales and auction activities
within the existing Howard Johnson1s hotel.
WHEREAS, the Commission action was appealed in regards to approval
of the temporary retail sales and auction activities withi-~ the
conferencefbanquet rooms of the hotel approved in PA 88.143, Conditional Use
Permit; and
~""':::r>:':AS. Froper notice of said F...!~]ic ~:'3rir:.6 '..:.:l~ b:......~n ....u a::
respects as ~t~~1red by law; and
fxb?'. ~,,',
-" ,....
,. '
A.I
WHEREAS, the City Council held a public hearing on the Appeal on
March 27, 1989, and continued consideration of the matter to the April 10, 1989
meeting; and
WHEREAS, the City Council heard and considered all reports,
recommendations and testimony hereinabove set forth.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE Dublin City Council does
hereby find:
A. The use as proposed is required by the public need in that the
use provides a recreational facility (danca floor) contributing
to the diversity of recreational facilities available within
the City and will provide needed supplemental services for the
hotel and will fu11fill a demand for temporary retail sales/
auction space.
B. The uses will be properly related to other land uses, and
transportation and service facilities in t~e vicinity, as the
use is located in a hotel complex in downt,wn Dublin near a
major arterial street, the proposed peak hour uses of the dance
floor can be anticipated to be during late evening hours (9:00
p.m. to 1:00 a.m.) rather than at normal p,aak business hours,
and therefore will not conflict with existing commercial retail
and restaurant uses on site and in the surrounding area. The
gift shop, hair salon, offices activities ~ill serve as
supplemental suport services for the hotel patrons. Tempora~1
retail sales will be limited within the conferencejbanquet room
areas and not impact on-sice or ofr-site uses.
C. The uses will not materially adversely affect the health or
safety of persons residing or working in t~e vicinity, or be
materially detrimental to the public welfare or injurious to
property or improvements in the neighborho"d, as all applicable
regulations will be met.
D. The uses will not be contrary to the specific intent clauses or
performance standards established for the District in which it
is located, as the proposed uses will be c.,mpatib1e with the
adjoining uses.
E. The approval of the Conditional Use Permit will be consistent
with the Dublin General Plan and Dow~town Specific Plan.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT THE City Council d"es hereby
conditionally approve PA 88-148 Howard Johson's Conditional Use Permit for a
commercial recreation facility (dance floor) and to add a oeautyfbarber shop
(hair salon), gift shop, office, temporary retail sales and auction activities
within the existing building subject to the fol1o~ing conditions:
-2-
1. The dance floor area shall be restricted to th,a area as generally
shown on the floor plan submitted with the application dated
received on December 16, 1989 by the Dublin Planning Department
(Exhibit B).
2. The permit shall be valid for a period of one (1) year (March 4,
1990). The approval period for the Conditional Use Permit may be
extended two additional years (Applicant must submit a written
request for the extension prior to the expiration date of the
Conditional Use Permit) by the Planning Direct.,r upon the
Director's determination that the Conditions of Aproval remain
adequate to assure that the stated Findings will continue to be
met.
3. No loudspeakers or amplified music shall be permitted outside the
enclosed building. All activities associated ~ith the proposed
uses shall be conducted entirely within the su,ject building.
4. All activities shall be controlled so as not t., create a nuisance
to the surrounding businesses.
5. The Applicant shall comply with all applicable Dougherty Regional
Fire Authority requirements.
6. The Applicant shall obtain a valid Dance Permit from the Dublin
Police Department and shall submit to the Planning Department
documentation that said permit has been obtain~d.
7. The Applicant shall submit to the Planning Dep,artment documentation
that a Alcoholic Beverage License has been obt,ained from the State
of California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control.
8. The Applicant shall comply with all applicable Police Department
requirements including. but not limited to, th~ following:
Revised per A.
Police Dept
Review and
Approval
At all times there is dancing occurring, there will be at
least one (1) security officer on duty to check I.D.'s and
provide facility security (The number of security guards may
be increaesd by the Police Department, if necessary).
B.
All bouncers, doormen and security guard" while on duty,
will wear identifiable clothing displayi'Olg their names.
c.
Applicant recognizes his/her responsibility to comply with
Alcohol Beverage Control regulations, spacifically, that
intoxicated persons shall not be served alcoholic beverages,
D.
During all business hours the establishm,ant is open to the
public, all permits and licenses shall ba posted and
available for viewing by the Dublin Poli,:e Department.
-3-
E. All live entertainment or other amplified sound must not be
audible outside the structure of the establishment.
F. The parking lot of the premises shall be equipped with
lighting of sufficient power to illuminate and make easily
discernible the appearance and conduct of all persons on or
about the parking lot.
G. Exterior lighting shall be of a design a~d placement so as
not to cause glare onto adjacent properties.
H. The petitioner(s) shall be responsible f.n maintaining free
of litter the area adjacent to the premises over which he has
control.
I. There shall be no pool tables or coin-op,arated games
maintained upon the premises at any time.
9. Any modifications to exterior lighting shall b~ subject to review
and approval of the Planning Department and Police Department.
10. All uses shall be as listed, and occur, only within the rooms
indicated on the Site Plan and Floor Plan, rec~ived by the Dublin
Planning Department on December 16, 1988 (Exhi~it B).
11. Each individual temporary sales activities shall obtain a temporary
state sellers permit or resale license. (Auctions shall obtain and
submit a copy of the State Auctioneers Permit). This license/
permit shall specifically state the activity, merchandise to be
sold, and the Dublin location. A copy of this permit/license
shall be submitted to the Dublin Planning Department a minimum of
four calendar days prior to the event being held.
12. Each sales/auction event shall not exceed ten (lO) consecutive
days. A minimum of thirty (30) days shall lapse between events for
the same user.
13. No exterior permanent signs (other than allowa~le window signs)
shall be installed for the additional uses, sh,wn on Exhibit B.
14. Office use shall be limited to that which is primarily oriented
toward servicing the hotel patrons (i.e. travel agent, real estate
office). Any other related office use shall b,a submitted to the
Planning Director for review and approval.
15. Nothing in this permit supersedes any terms or conditions of
previous Conditional Use Permit, Site Developm3nt Review, Variance
applications on this site.
-4-
16. This permit shall be revocable for cause in accordance with Section
8-90.7 of the Dublin Zoning Ordinance. Noncom~liance of any
provisions of the above Conditions shall be ca~se for the
initiation of hearings before the Planning Comnission to determine
whether cause is present to revoke this permit.
17. If the Applicant and Police Department cannot agree to the final
wording of Condition #8A, the condition shall be brought back to
the Commission for further review.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 10th day of April, 1989.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Mayor
ATTEST:
City Clerk
-5-
:";;'~~~'~~~.;'.6.';.'('1I'~:;;;' . -
'@l; :';,:,;'.' ..:.:.:....o!ho\~M ...,' ...;y~.I.i.. "'\~/l~
~_.3' '. u..'l't.b ',. _-..:-.;r" __ 'N', , '. . ti" ~~o.i......,~-' .......
'" 1_. " I ;>', I ,;. I "" :L ' --'" . ,'" ~".
.::\:..~ ,._._.~~...,:. "i' ..., i-._..~--......~I- ...~i....:I.~~o..t..i '~.I.....I.:~':I.. "'1 -...:I\~~...~' "j)==
.,'..\.1 ' . I"'!' I', !. !!!'." I ^ ,} ~ j.:. ~ : A" p. .:",' 1~ .
'. .~"" " .1. :-1~-; , ' .. 1--- : ,. "00':, ,....+-.: -'-1.~ '\ -~-'l 'I' I ~~;~".n'.., . ;;
J'>"" ._... ....,. ~.J_L-!..:...! . ,'" ::
v":,,C:H/ '~ ~'r ---J....-:-_._..-':.!::-.-, ..~~':.- " - --. I.._.-'~' 'f'
"',., ~r &4'._- .!AI' . . I I'" ' i ,1' '7JI ,..---,-:' .Jr.''''' . '?'" 1:
_'_.. . "'.' ,", I :...~.:: __ . L, J ." "1.r~"'1't""~~ iII:7 "',' .
..... 'J r -,--'1 .... - L.... ,;....., . ......,. " ", I
'r''-'' .....'.'< 'I 'f~'.!.~" ~II ~ : l>, ~ ~ ~,; 1: ;::; "U' . ..:.,. ',r: ''''J'
, '" .,~..~.' . ,~or ,,;l ...-., .' .
./..:-,~,t,.. ' 11 I, ~ ' ; ~.~.~ I . !; . r. ", [:1, I.. .';'1\\1," ..-; ,"
f....""....'..v .' f ' ' /J . ,-,I. '.'
_ " ';' ,~: ;. t : ........1, . ' " , .:>-,: '''''1.,-~. i: :,:
, r. _ ',~.{.J ,~,: ' I .. ,.;-::r. ...,""'~ <, ;' . ' . ,',. . - 00 ..
,. " ,~7,~:. - .: /\ r " ..... T - ...../N..->' ,,.'. ';/ " ,:"--,,, ......
. ., ..........~""', -1r' '7 ,...',....
-....,_,/_-..".. I';, ,/ I. : "" ,', y ,., -, - .~,__-:.-.ro'- --
1> ,,~,."" / 'I ,-~ ,..:i --... U", . . /' ...J " !', ',: '.~.
_ .--1: <""_~I ,,9ToH.-;i! /' ."...../.>'O".~-"~....."""'-......, .. \ ..,.'r: ..~~j ~-/~~/=.
, ....'.:c'~ >7''' . .'-. ,i,"., .; : : --"~ ; d'':'~ ,':c:=' , ,;..~ ,,. , " )
,,""_' : '<.',."" ~-' ~ .", ~. I ~,.' ---1'..'.. .,-'"..,.-, -:: ' '~'"
,(" j' t~- _.' '10 ,';: "TJ _'. ,'"'''-''''' Yo-.? _.::;;;. ". c_
,..~ _'''':~{Ij.~.,.,;~~;e;:~ '-". - .' . ~ ~~:::?"" ":,"-' ,.~.~~(;;;.~.~:=;
..___~.-.. ' ._., I
. ' ' ': 'Jr;:--.
. It.. . h,J: . . -:0'.
--. ,""" ; ;", ' .
I .------'- '
I .--.----.
i
,
I
.-
i
~-..--... J
l
,
i
, -'~
'I ,. '
.i....:-lI:-.-
'\'-- .. j.
, -
'J
I
':\
,\
H
.., \
n
\
\
,J
'-
"
. .. ~
:
,~ :
",:'
. :: ~ ..
"
~; ~ '
.~,
. i ~
.~:: \
: ~ i
~
:.,'
"'1'
,';
:;1
.'
1:j:
;iJ1
~~,~. 'L'. ~ -:'" :~. :"".:: ,'"
.. r \10.;.:-"; r:.. ...\.,;~
gI :", ~'N_~'"
", ~...I.; ,t"_..
':":. "':I:-t
\~.~ f:'l"". ,;.c."'-"
~.2-l-~L-~~ It..' r ~ ·
.. ~ it ~ _ os
(~~..t.:.J...::'s\
c:: ~(J~) r:::1j~
~,,:,;":&
::1
;"
\
I
I
~
'1
~
"
"
,
"
L .:-
.\ %
~~
!
i
i
\
I
U
L=,
I '-, , - --\
......-- .;--:.. .: .
-
-----
--~' ._---,'~:~~
: ' '
\
"
~;,
'/
/'
\
;-=
1
L
:!~'
,~,D' L~J.->'>GM
, 'f ,~C l'~:'
'. .~, . .fl J i
~'~ ,p. R!.~t.l ~\l51; I r \'
, ::-^" t:'~""';"'-'S \.. -'-.;.
~~ :' I
BA.-40.\JQ : ,t .- - -:
~ : ~\
~;zro r\1 t ..\ I' ~ ::':-:.:.:1
L.; :.-/.
.
~
<
----~
i
~
'--'-
!
~.f.:!,.Jze.:-
,
'---.--
~ -~;!~~;~ ~~~
!
.r
VA,lJeE H.cce-
(~I("tq )
_...~.
..
c
.,.--
\,~
J
,
\\
....
,,/
.....
--.;- ..~
---
. _u_.._. ..
~ .
"
,
c:.
\, ":',
" '
" ".
; ." : ~ -:- I :" .. r .. '(" 'C :
!.(!~~~I!t:1
?~~-i,:~~
.. m ;--
,
,
'.
,
llo,::-::
~'" l'A'O'O - ~~;~:, .,C
"\~}40'" ~~'---L:
'1 r --- ---.,.
... .~-"
~\r " a' ""^- -- -~~_:-;;--- '-- '
~. - ~ -,
..i->\Il rM. ~vtk ~AMWlS . -.-=:::::::::..:.
o.ffi US
. _ .L.. ,\ ~ ~ I ." 'Il\ ~)~{AC..nc':,: ftc'lnS '
4-t.M~()A~ ~ ~C; S t:tu-q't...cF ~"C'I'~'S . . ~
_ "nd" ,,,, r}1O\'\.. ~c..~\J\~!..C; t~\~\~~~,-~~\)Exhlhtt
~':-;..: ~--;:.. '--
. t.' -: -~~-~.;-
-_.., - ------- ...:.'
'.. .
- .
:~
"
.' ~ ....
, r
<<O~ .
[..-- 1
~. ." \
i
I '
i !
,-'--'-'-'
'..
.._'~ .
,,"
..".~\
'. (.:!.~
~ 1
'.. ..I
. ."' .".".. '!.
. ...1 .
L-..... . .--
UNrl 't-. . .'
'.
'j
I
--~
, .
:
. '
. . o....--._~.-. .-
.' '..
.Qt:! \.. E:._
."i'
i
\
I
\
I
:"j
I
i
.,. . i
- -- --- ~r'-l~-' -.\-
. j , .. 'II
LJ~~il A ~ .L--'-,,:~ '1~ ,~\\
i '
I'
.' -'.1
~ .
10:;-'
..'
n
u
i
,
. .-,
I ""Irj..
V /_
. .
.:~
~~ '.
l;~C ."
\t~ \
~.. ,::" t"'l ,'" I
; -/;"
.' ;
..
I "
.
"
I
~ ".
,
i
,
,
, .
, : . i "
\. '
. ~. I
___ ._,...J
--T ',1
'j
\
i
\
I
i
I
I
,
I
: \.
:- .D1';ii
- --_.- ~
fl~ ~.
n
.-l..-_J li. ,-::.',:
. . \'- I
._~~ .',.-
!~ L i U ': ",- ~:
;::; ~.::;; '. I ',' ~,'
\ II <). ' ::::
-e ""1 ,,::::::' ;
-6f'\ ~!
",I";
ti
. t\ ili
I!O:l:'::'
-. p"
. ("..,. ;"'\ .
._ .u-<.
~
. e'
'\0.0 c.
~
.- -
~T ~
\' .\
----
~ r'oo.
f:-G
\DId
0'2 .. ~.
N.:I
\' .,
t:i:
3'
. . ~ \
V"::' C'~' .'
.:" ~ :
':~ :\
0lfi
T\\ r;
. '
I
I
.~
t-1
&
Q.
:>\-
~
('\
i
I
I
I
. -r--
i I
I
i It,
! l'
I \
1/\-
, I
;
~ .
, .
~ i
I ~
1-'
! '
)
;
! ~ .
_.~-j--
~ .
. ,
,
~~
; :'T
j'"'
('
-I
-\
~~~t
~':::;.
.'~' .
....
,-
." '.
?/KJ(j;!!f.~r.rf1.f?
~r4:'U~~~~
~~(.:f.l;j;!!i!
",-~P1/1,'''''''''/1
p;; 'l/fl(.~~....7<<,
r:.-t;/; ':I,.~/{" ,.~
"/."!;i':;.~ :
~.r: i".'1-" .~
1.?~~;:'(i~~
;;..1..,.",.,., '
f:;';::-;$' ~
7"', ';'1'",., .
.~,..,.J-'.."......H".., '"
.,".'~,,.U;
:{/\':'~' '. :::
>
'iI"
',. .
I'.,
I~
t'~ .
">( ..
. ~ ::'~"'. . '.. .
l.~ ',-:" '
i'~. ..." 'fi?j1
iN.. '-' ~.
I-\~~-~\ ...
!....\~.
;:-- ---, ~. :
'\ r.
'I~' .:
[I, ~.
"
~
., .....
.:' r-
{, . iI,',
,-~ >@
\ " . ,,,
..,"V) <. .&.:.,..
.'
-"
.' .
'.
'.
ItA
..),~
~:-.~
.~ .,-
~
~ .', :"~:'
;'-0, . . ... ..< ~'::
'-" '. ". ~, '.
" . .,'1\' .~;,.
- : '''K~~
..,. \to ~. ,;
..~.';.:O~' . ::.:.
.ti
, ~.'. .
.
::,,(\
\J
gi
~~
~
. ~ .
.~
~
~\
I
,
~ '
..d'!' 0 J'
\ ::o!::;"l
\'
"
:::
.'...Q
'. \
;.: '"
?:::., ..-
,:. .
':~
, .
.:......-,_.
'~b-,l~~
E:~,c.~l~~~P-
\
I
a:-L'
\ "-
, \
"I, \ \
" -\ \
- IJ
',. '1.
'j-
;:. ,
:.~~
!.~ '
" . .. ~-
\=..: ..'
.,.
.,.1....11
,-~
\
,
Df.~, 16 19S~
NI'OtIN l'lA:-::-:\:((:
RESOLUTION NO.
- 89
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
-.-------------------------------------------------------------.-----------.--
MODIFYING THE PLANNING COMMISSION'S ACTION APPROVING PA 88-148 HOWARD JOHNSON'S
CONDITIONAL USE PERliIT TO ADD A PROPOSED BARBER/BEAUTY SHOP (HAIR SALON), CIFT
SHOP, OFFICES, TEMPORARY RETAIL SALES AND AUCTION ACTIVITIES WITHIN THE
EXISTING HOTEL BUILDING AND A DANCE FLOOR WITHIN T3E LORD DUBLIN
RESTAURANT/LOUNGE AREA.
WHEREAS, Johnson Clark filed an application for a Conditional Use
Permit to establish a commercial recreational facility (dance floor) and to add
a proposed barberjbeauty shop (hair salon), gift shop, offices, temporary
retail sales and auction activities within the existing hotel building in an
existing restaurant at 6680 Regional Street; and
WHEREAS, the City of Dublin Zoning Ordinance requires approval of
a Conditional Use Permit in the C-l District for the operation of a commercial
recreational facility (dance floor) and temporary sales; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission did hold a p'~blic hearing on sai.d
application on February 2l, 1989; and
WHEREAS, proper notice of said public hearing was given in all
respects as required by law; and
WHEREAS, this application has been reviewed in accordance with the
prov1s1ons of the California Environmental Quality Act and has been found to be
categorically exempt; and
WHEREAS. the Staff Report was submitted recomnending consideration
of the Conditional Use Permit application appeal; and
WHEREAS, the Planning Commission did hear and consider all said
reports, recommendations and testimony herein above setforch.
WHEREAS, on February 21, 1989 the Planning Comnission adopted
Resolution No. 89-005, approving PA 88-148 Conditional Use Permit for
additional hotel uses including temporary retail sales and auction activities
within the existing Howard Johnson's hotel.
WHEREAS, the Commission action was appealed in regards to approval
of the temporary retail sales and auction activities within the
conferencejbanquet rooms of the hotel approved in PA 88-143, Conditional Use
Permit; and
WHEREAS, proper notice of said publiL: hearing 'Jlas giVP.-D tp a-tJ
respects as required by law; and
-1-
ExJiit A.2..
WHEREAS, the City Council held a public hearing on the Appeal on
March 27, 1989, and continued consideration of the matter to the April 10, 1989
meeting; and
WHEREAS, the City Council heard and considered all reports,
recommendations and testimony hereinabove set forch.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE Dublin City Council does
hereby find:
A. The use as proposed is required by the public need in that the
use provides a recreational facility (danca floor) contributing
to the diversity of recreational facilities available within
the City and will provide needed supplemental services for the
hotel. However, a demand for temporary retail sales/auction
space does not exist as it can be fulfilled by existing
available retail space and businesses within the community.
B. The uses will be properly related to other land uses, and
transportation and service facilities in t~e vicinity, as the
use is located in a hotel complex in downtown Dublin near a
major arterial street, the proposed peak hour uses of the dance
floor can be anticipated to be during late evening hours (9:00
p,m. to 1:00 a.m.) rather than at normal p~ak business hours,
and therefore will not conflict with existing commercial retail
and restaurant uses on sice and in the surrounding area. The
gift shop, hair salon, offices activities ~ill serve as
supplemental suport services for the hotel patrons. Temporary
retail sales although proposed to be limit~d within the
conferencejbanquet room areas and will imp.9.ct on-site or off-
site uses and not be commensurate with hot-a! uses as these
activities would cater to the larger community and not be
oriented to hotel patrons.
C. The uses will not materially adversely aff~ct the health or
safety of persons residing or working in t:,e vicinity, or be
materially detrimental to the public welfare or injurious to
property or improvements in the neighborho"d, as all applicable
regulations will be met.
D. The uses will not be contrary to the specific intent clauses or
performance standards established for the District in which it
is located, as the proposed uses will be c"mpatible with the
adj oining uses.
E. The approval of the modified Conditional Use Permit will be
consistent with the Dublin General Plan and DOw'Tltown Specific
Plan.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED THAT THE City Council does hereby delete t~e
Commission approved temporary retail sales and auction activities within the
conference/banquet rooms and does hereby c0ncHti.:'!1ally appreve r_\ ~" :.'~e p.c~..;J.:::':'
-2-
Johnson's Conditional Use Permit for a commercial recreati"n facility (dance
floor) and to add a beautyfbarber shop (hair salon), gift shop and office,
within the existing building subject to the fol10~ing conditions:
1. The dance floor area shall be restricted to tha area as generally
shown on the floor plan submitted with the application dated
received on December 16, 1989 by the Dublin Planning Department
(Exhibit B-2).
2. The permit shall be valid for a period of one (1) year (March 4,
1990). The approval period for the Conditional Use Permit may be
extended t~o additional years (Applicant must submit a written
request for the extension prior to the expiration date of the
Conditional Use Permit) by the Planning Director upon the
Director's determination that the Conditions of Aproval remain
adequate to assure that the stated Findings will continue to be
met.
3. No loudspeakers or amplified music shall be permitted outside the
enclosed building. All activities associated ~ith the proposed
uses shall be conducted entirely within the su,ject building.
4. All activities shall be controlled so as not t" create a nuisance
to the surrounding businesses.
5. The Applicant shall comply with all applicable Dougherty Regional
Fire Authority requirements.
6. The Applicant shall obtain a valid Dance Permit from the Dublin
Police Department and shall submit to the Planning Department
documentation that said permit has been obtain~d.
7. The Applicant shall submit to the Planning Department documentation
that a Alcoholic Beverage License has been obtained from the State
of California Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control.
8. The Applicant shall comply with all applicable Police Department
requirements including, but not limited to, th~ following:
Revised per A.
Police Dept
Review and
Approval
At all times there is dancing occurring, there will be at
least one (1) security officer on duty t" check I. D. 's and
provide facility security (The number of security guards may
be increaesd by the Police Department, if necessary).
B.
All bouncers, doormen and security guards, while on duty,
will wear identifiable clothing displayi~g their names.
C.
Applicant recognizes hisjher responsibility to comply with
Alcohol Beverage Control regulations, spacifically, that
intoxicated persons shall not be served alcoholic beverages,
-3-
D. During all business hours the establishm,ant is open to the
public, all permits and licenses shall b,a posted and
available for viewing by the Dublin Poli,:e Department.
E. All live entertainment or other amplified sound must not be
audible outside the structure of the establishment.
F. The parking lot of the premises shall be equipped with
lighting of sufficient power to illuminate and make easily
discernible the appearance and conduct of all persons on or
about the parking lot.
G. Exterior lighting shall be of a design a~d placement so as
not to cause glare onto adjacent properties.
H, The petitioner(s) shall be responsible f,n maintaining free
of litter the area adjacent to the premises over which he has
control.
I. There shall be no pool tables or coin-op,arated games
maintained upon the premises at any time.
9. Any modifications to exterior lighting shall ba subj ect to revie'.;
and approval of the Planning Department and Police Department.
10. All uses shall be as listed, and occur, only within the rooms
indicated on the Site Plan and Floor Plan, rec,aived by the Dublin
Planning Department on December 16, 1988 as modified (Exhibit B-2).
11. No exterior permanent signs (other than allowaJle window signs)
shall be installed for the additional uses, shown on Exhibit B-2.
l2. Office use shall be limited to that which is primarily oriented
toward servicing the hotel patrons (i.e. travel agent, real estate
office). Any other related office use shall ba submitted to the
Planning Director for review and approval.
13. Nothing in this permit supersedes any terms or conditions of
previous Conditional Use Permit, Site Developrn.~nt Review, Variar.ce
applications on this site.
14. This permit shall be revocable for cause in ac:ordance with Section
8-90.7 of the Dublin Zoning Ordinance. Noncompliance of any
provisions of the above Conditions shall be ca'~se for the
initiation of hearings before the Planning Comnission to determine
whether cause is present to revoke this permit.
l5. If the Applicant and Police Department cannot agree to the final
wording of Condition ;;8A, the condition shall ',e brought back to
the Commission for further review.
-4-
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 10th day of April, 1989.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Mayor
ATTEST:
City Clerk
.5-
.L..../'7...."rlO "" ,:U''''~ , --:-'(,J.") . . .... ...-- 1'./' '''ttl]..~.. ,-- -'-"-' -.... ' I
~ _', ... . II. ~ . ... .,,, YJ" " (, 'J#<~ ' ,.
..~. . "'~:,'I' I,':. -!hO\' t',.. ".~'.' ",V.;?J',;"~ (r= ~~'~fJ1"J',I>.I!"-""-""
rr-;. Y. ,. . . . d"_" , . .",' '(t I . ,It.~'
I,. ..'..,11. ...,p(..ZJ.... -.--' --,~ I ~-
;:1;'-'--~-~~" I . ;)', - \ ,J - ';,;1." .!.. fl'; ..~h"~ ~.I~'
t. :;:c:~"-: .~.~ ..... f" ....~ ...-...... -.. .,.____._....._,u-1...., , -.7.,.. ....,...---. -... ~.~.;~ ,~, J_
t~.I.1~'~.\ ." +~,!j. ,! ~~,. f..1 I.I,.\},I 'A! /0 /o)=.it.\ /0.1 ;'1'" j. :~:.;;J ~ "
~,:".,..J, J',- " -" _: -.. ';-.....-: ~-'. ....:..1."1"1 -h t ~..~ ~:. >
f: ~~ . 1. I' .~__." I t . ," :.- . t " .. }. '"
,., }l~ I ,,; J. t ....."'..... 't~ ~~ - ....-.- .. '~j
-" '... j --rt--. ---...- .....-., 17fI""-r:-::;-;-, "I' '/1:.. -'J '~!r ~ " ;}
~-vr;:",:.zI'/>. ~.. I :; '~.' :j t. 1 " :"'!';'J:"4~'~t' """-;"';"~' _,_,?j '1'
;.J1"'._.Jor tA,..~ 14 -: ~.;...:. __ _.:.-...I.... L...... j ~"-~~I ~".".., '. r:' ~ '
.......,_.. _ . '-r, ., '-j --"" tj ; ~ " 1,:- ":1,,,, ~.t..~t"" J.~n .'J,...., .. -1 .
..~;.:...., ,_,_-,,)' I .(rt.::.....' ~ i ~ '.,. ',. r;'. I 'I '..: ~!J. ',,:,,:),\1: ':-" !
f ':- t.lf.~ _ "( 11 . I ~l" - >"""...: ) 1 . ).; ~ -t": ,,'-- ~;;'1",-.~:., i: :J-
~. 'f"" ..",,'I' 'y"I.,,: 'c, f t ':
. c.. 'J... I ~' :~ ,.~,~ .~.;
- r." . ';'~'~I("'''~''' t.~ I., /. :-'t,o .1-' -'" " ____.r: . - ----"-r
: I ",' i~ l;~4.. '1 7t[ ; . "7., ''''I. ~.:-;. \~..... ~.4 ~.: :,~.
.. ~ ~. .:-~... _ ....r.. . oj' .. ~ '.K.' 1'/ --' 'f ; :)71(. ,.'. "'-. !."":,"^ '.-
:?1 . ;;.,:;;; / H <'" ::';I"'?-.;;~"':i"I"" /' ........; t.71'.,:::I.C.__Tp~~"':'rr:!'....' ... : .,;.~\ .:. f.:'" _ /r...
.. .._. .:.. ;'" ~ ..:....,._;~'.:.,/: ..:~__~--=f1~.,,1;~...::....:._.:'-=~.;.:..:.f.,!:T.ft': .,.;.,.-:.'....:.. ... =':~
/:,;...'...-7_if.t~.... "'.":"'- ~ ,,. a ~ I L" I ,.,'; . 'v,.,.C"-'"~.... . y;:;::;- ~'V ,.
:i;.;r:-;'(..... ./. ~7~;~:{;': '~'J '! ......,: r',:,~-).:- '.. ~:J~".? ~ . .-~- ..[~:;-;7;..:.'~
_. / ~;.J ~"""I . . ~ ..... .... ;......~:,;.~~
.... l;Ji' _1:'07 "'~""'<< ~ _ 1'.
_____,~~--.I-,(/ ~'--'-. ; . r..:' .: ':-il~'~ '.," '-("1<' :.-::;/;)
I ~ :'.' ~t. . \ ~ .. /"
~ ,~.~-..:-'_.- '.. .' .._--.~---. "
."
\
I
ICJl'"
I '
) !
L__~~. , I
l.._ -:_~ "\
\. .... . .
,.
:-..'-: i
,
! \
!
i
I
~
'I
'~'"
~
,
,
'\
'c,
:
,\
,i
,>
:i
!
i
i
;
1
"
!
,
i
,
l
i
I
I
i
!
J
.).
. :l....:' :...~ .".:-
:'..... ~.....::':... :...:..~,,'...
'~ru :..~......;...: .""\.)
:;\
.':;r_1.l \r:'''':.
;\l'::."i.
.':'l--=.~.l",:.""
:
"
,~
".
./
\
'h~
-;i.... I
~ ~ /.,~ j ,
r:l'f';::'
, I
, ,
l~-. ~l
i' -. ~
-t
, . '- i
,. I ~.-"
I r--.-....
.,
I
;
L.-
! .,. I ~ "':" I .. ~_.Y__~ It." J rI "
--~.:io:.S. (~;,.::.'..r;:r--:':'$~
c- '(e) ~~~~ -,-:';''':&
Il.
r I
,
~. !
I
\
I
\ I
U
r--
, \
1:'- . - :.
-:-..- .~ -- .. .
'-'-
!
.
.
.
<
:, _r::~~.-....;.. ..:;_...:
i -:~ :::;.~::....:.:-
~ }--
j
~
'"
"
.
..
J' .~-
, ::
..
! ~
,
!
;
I
I
t. ~_.f_;.!',J ~ ~_:
W,J.1CE Kco2..
C~I(,,:!:Ii)
-'- .~.
,
.,......---,
.L
,
~ -
,,-
\
\
J
,......-/
':--.
----
----.:
" ....
"
'-...
:; \. : .; -: I !II ; '! } <. r.
l.<!~-:~!l"'~:~
~~Z";,.~_:~~ ----~
,.... (;,;::'7, ~~ ,=-,;;;0:;;::',:\ . ~~
" ili' : ':
'ol.::-::
~...:-;:..: ":\. .. "-'
.t.' -: --~-.~~
--- '-
~ ;.
..
..
"
~..
..... ."
"
"
"
..
~ '~-~---!~.~~~.~ ..' . , : '
La v -- '~r- '.'
_~f'l \ ~ ,--.. "
r"'Y'1...... ----- -..-....
r --~'-__' .
", --~:.:-~
u.SLS ~ ~ fjfO ·
t\t~ f:,\\CP
~ ~~vtt ~~cn~
\\! i'Y"'l . " " ' ; ,.. .\ )
Ot\tCLS '
..\ ... ... ,-.., .tf M 0("' (0.,_ ck dU,I\ A.r\ + J
.'
.....
~vhihft
~ ... 7___
.ti
" t\ ii;
llo::t.'~
p':
r-,-:j"
.. ")..-.u-<.
-~. tl ': :;
- e ';
..- 0 .
. _~=--l--. ~--=-
. .v~~i
. I I
!.
I
I
I
.-. .
. l'
..... i
.1' .
. ,'r .
L__oo_ . .--
. ,
!
,
: .
. . i -,
\. .
___._J
'.
:i
',.
I
I
uNit ./-,
-~-----"~
' '
" :
.. f.-
.l1S::!\1 2._
--T - :1
-j
I \
.. I
\ \
-lFY -- -~\~: : ;
. '. : . 'I l \.
. 'j' r."'- '" \' - "i"l"\~I,
~ ,_-----:~:.J 1-:-- .~!I' :.. - --_.~
\ .
. . 0..-- ~.- -.-' .--
I
.,-\ -
I
.
, ,
. ,
.;
10;7'
. tJt~\1 A
_ - -', i
~ .
n
-11
w.
- \
. ,
\
,
I
. .-,
I ".j.,
V /-
j. .
-I' --- i
'- ~- \
.,-
I i
i:
I.
I '
~
. ~l;:;'.
. ;
'.
D '; <;'
'L"I'
- \ ,: : ',,~,
\157. :i tJJ1, '0:r~:
r> ../ \' D ; i ~
_ \).::: '. 1 \'" ~
I" ,,<::- --..' : :::::
of} :1\ "\ --- ;
- .... '" ... \
.. r: ", (;'0. .
hr.:::. \
' . ;
....~. .....
\ "i . .
-,\06- ::c;
.- ,
~T -!i
\' '\
~ -.
\''\
8ri\
I DC>-
\).
.":i\-
.3
('\
r-r-; ~
V_. I
,..:' : I
, : ~ I
~:
E'
'v..::-;\:'~' ..\'
~-: j ~ ~
~:\ i
~ ;:;. ili\ .
rJ ii'\ Ii
n.: . 1
j
I
I
I
--' -..---
\
k.
.'
. I
1 \'
I i
1/\
, ,
l
t ;
. I
1 ~
I -I
l '
'7
.-!--
I
I .
I
, .
.~
,.
/~
"
-I
-\
;,...;r",l.o,=-1. '.I.'::~~;,"'''",-'r:''''''';~';''-~ "'-'1.' ..."
:t.,.~""'- _11I'iiJ.,~."....._..'';''';'.U.'.,.,-.-~'''JI'",,:,,",,'''-'.=.-- ,.. l' . . .' .
..,'..,..,;..,~_..-:..;....., ":." ;.~>:/._~;J.:;~lXt-;;:;;~~;.:I~:r;.:;:~::;vt2~::~::~ "",:~, :.:,.,,, ';
.:' .' '._. ".,?::,::J.... "'.'i.';;';I,.~.-;'I,.i/."':I";i",,,,"..1'~, ,...; .:'; ',' ," .-..
,<'. ~':._:.,:J'''1 ".' .:':'z":':.:':~'; ~:-~";" .;;,::.~.:,:_~:~';<,..~.",~~:\' . -!~.."
/1 ",,'i""." .v"..I"""~'I"'I'" ~'''''' .... II"" ..f" -<fD -' ..~
." ........J:..J..,",..!::f4J! 1:IIolT >M;<l.Z{'("::"~.i'i!p:Jfit'fr.IJ::.:Jr ~ ;""""t1.: l~"'i:-"" -'/'f.1,;"I: ""';..,.: '
.' ",r''l3!,'~'~':1'''' 1".;;:..''{,...... ,_",g., , };;~'{,r,..:~.,;;r~'l~ ',\'''.-''-' ,; ""- .!.:.~<,:r:.: ",,'r:. ,/2'/"'-'.:
::;, r";Y/7.q~~f.B';~ ~/;-1,~t.'J.;(~.!;'I,.~ z ,. '~wPLJ..{:~1.j,~ft3'i'.'1'2';-t"'1 ~ r~/'.r;",/.,..~.~...Z' .f. /..
Lir'i.l_:,;~~~;; itijl~,,~f~ ~ '.,',,~_.'.,.,';"':,'r";~:'...','..'.,..'.,;,-. "~""":'~""" ,;...,~.',':,'- .~~,~..:,.:~-:~..',~,,:.< ,.:,.;";,~:,:~,:":,:,;."'~_:...'.:",,,,l.,,.;.',.:,..,:..:,:;;'.~,..~','
."".." , 1. I" .~...' ,. ~.~~71,'.,' " :.r.".,.~..~.:.;.,.,:1,':' ...,'~..',:.~.W\~. '~.....~.::::.,:"~~.~:,.,,.;,::~.;,:,.,::.~,',~....','.~.'.'...' '
",..,.;.;.';;:,t . .~~.',:/~..:,f~.':,~.,:::~!:.:,(.;;:.:.:",'.~.1.,:'.r',~,:::':~,'.~,:::,.~:fk_~'. ::-t:.!f.". . 0 ?d .~~" ,,":i.:I~' "~'I '! I ~ . .. -
.;.:.~_,':",':",:,",~,':.~'.._' ,:. :" ,;;.a ~... . :J I"~'.
~:;J"; '" ~;.?~A(~.'fU.:
,...~. .... "..-....'. " ,.,.. -.\"
-:.: ;.,'~.. >",~:::~;,:',;,:::~:2L :-.:~~...--
<::.;:.;. .':':}r:- :'~/ ~'.:.': ::-.~.
.,'. ':' i;.. II : .:.;. ;:. ":;' ~ .
'~.': .-
''j. \ .
. .~tjr/ ,i,~!.r-
.' .
.....
:"'.
Q\
\,
. '.
I
;F,
;.~
.!.~.
t~
t~.>- @
r\.~::J-'~\
I".r~
;~ --, ~
'\
~~~"
j;
" .
t""
'.:
~~ .
.'
= r~
\ .
:-~
-@
'.
&.
'.
i.:.:
'"
.J~
B ..~
~ .
~
~ :_~.
'0' '~
:tft ' . lit .. ~ ':
. ". '( .
.:: c.;:,~
I; ~..'
~.~:O~ .
..
-
~
"
~t
~a
~
~
\J
; .
~
~
~~ .
..d'LO ,r
I
\'
~
-'
\
I
(\lr
, I I
\ ~ I I
~V \ I
!
;.
, .
i;. . .l
'. .,r
.'. ,
{O,-
!. -- '-
~~' =!,
'J' ~
. ~ I
~::
,\:J
~
; ~.b.r I~S
J3.g~.:t\y.~P.
DE.C 1 6 i~SS
7;:
j:;
'I :::: ..
l..;~
~:~
.\
.-'<-
PUSl\N rL:\:\:-:\:\c.
i-
---_.~ .
,:;..---
/
SUBJECT:
REPORT PREPARED BY:
EXHIBITS ATTACHED:
RECOHl1ENDATION:
FINA.\1CIAL STATE-!EST:
DESCRIPTION:
l\ack~rO\.::-<i :
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: Harch 27, 1989
Public Hearing - Appeal of PA 88-148 Howard
Johnson's Conditional Use Permit, Tecpora~J
Retail Sales and Auctions within existing
conference/banquet rooms at 6680 Regional Street
Laura Hoffmeister, ~~sociate Planne~
Exhibit A-I: Draft Resolution of Approval
upholding the Coocission action approving the
Conditional Use Pe~t
Exhibit B-1: Site Plans (3)
E~~ibit A-i: Drafc Resolution modifying the
Planning Commission action
Exhibit B-2: Site Plans (3)
Attachment 1: Appeal letter dated received
March 3, 1989
Attachment 2: Pla~~ing Commission Resolution
No. 89-005, Conditior.al Use Percit a??=oval
Attachment 3: Pla~ing Commission Minutes for
the February 21, 1989 meeting
Attachment 4: P1a~,ing Commission Staff Repor:
~:"' ,h, "0='''' n. "89 ..,,,.,
2.
3.
4.
5.
Open Public Heari~g and hear Staff
presentation.
Take Testi~ony froQ Applicant and the Public
Question Staff, A?plicant and the Public
Close Public Hearing and Deliberate
Adopt Resolution (Exhibit A-lor Exhibit
A-2) relating to PA 88-l~8, or give Staff
and Applicant ci~action and continue the
matter
None
In December 1988, the Applicant made a Conditional Use Per.nit application to
consider additional uses at the hotel which were not included in previous
conditional use permits (barber/beauty shop (hair salon) gift shop, offices, a
dance floor in Lord Dublin Restaurant Lounge] a~d to allow for temporary
retail sales and auctions to occur 'Within the conferencejb3nquet rooms.
----~---------------------------------_._-------------------------------------
ITEH 1\0. 6..., 6
f"nrIES TO:
Applicant/
O\.!ncr /
rA SS-l4S V
Attaciment --L
~~!i_
,
:\
j
"
.i
i
!
i
, I
i
I
!
:..~8tl14:.r?':::,t~"AJ"~ "'-~~~-'::~':.:;;r."'I;';N",_~~;.:.;-;'I.;':'-'lj:.;--""?'.{;.I.'I:'/J,;'t,:,;.. -"'.:.":':"::'~; ,U.!..t~....;4"""~-' ,.., ~,....~....--- "
On February 21, 1988, the Planning Commission considered snd spproved the
C~nditiona1 Use Permit with conditions (see Attachment 2 and 3).
On March 3, 1989, the Commission action was appealed by Councilmember, Peter
Snyder. The appeal was in regards to only the Commission action which allowed
the establishment of temporary retail sales and auctions within the
conferencejbanquet rooms of Howard Johnson's hotel.
Analysis:
The Zoning Ordinance allows consideration of temporarj retail sales by a
Conditional Use Permit.
The Planning Commission expressed concerns as to how temporary retail
sales/auctions could be regulated/monitored. Conditions included and
recommended by Staff and adopted by the Commission would require that these
activities could only occur in conferencefbanquet rooms, and prior to each
occurrence applicable State licenses/permits (auctioneers permits, State
resalers license, etc.) would need to be submitted to the City to ensure the
event would be a retail sale or auction and that the proper sales tax would be
collected.
Given the concern stated in the appeal of the Comcission action approving the
temporary sales/auction, Staff has contac~ed the City Attorney to determine i:
other conditions could be required for these activities.
According to the City Attorney, the temporary use of retail sales/auction
activities is a discretionary consideration throu~~ the Conditional Use Permit
process. Each site and proposal is reviewed on its own merits to determine i:
the required Conditional Use Permit findings can be made in support of the
request. ;The Council would need to determine if the findings could be made to
support the request or not. Should the Council determine that the uses are 1)
not required by public need; 2) not properly related to other land uses in the
vicinity; 3) and not appropriate or compatible use for this site, the Council
could disapprove or the retail sales/auction.
Should the Council determine that the findings can be made to support the
request, conditions could be applied to minimize potential impacts. However,
the conditions could only apply to the use event, not to any individual
conducting the event as State law controls the lice~ing/permitting of the
individual.
The City Council could consider conditions that would regulate the type of
goods to be sold or auctioned, the hours of the event and frequency of the
event. Should the Council feel additional conditions are appropriate, the
Council should include them and codify the title in the Draft Resolution of
Approval Exhibit A-I accordingly, then adopt the codified resolution.
Attached for Cou~cil consideration are two draf~ resolutions. Exhibit A-I
would uphold the Comcission action approving the te~porary sales/auction uses.
Exhibit A-2 would modify the Co~nission action not approving the temporary
sales/auction activities, however, still allowing dancing and the other
Commission approved uses to occur.
, i
pees)
C?( 5)
UI~
':jile,
,"
...
March 3, 1989
Laurence L. Tong
Planning Directo~
City of Dublin Pla:u,ing Depa~t=ent
6500 Dublin Boule7a~d, Suite D
Dublin, CA 94568
J.
".i
,\
'I
i
i
i
I
'.i
RE: PA '88-148 Eo~a~d Johnson
R~t~i1 Sales/Conditional Use Parmit
Dear Mr.~ Tong:
I am appealing t:-.=I ,':Jove refa~a:".~=c. p:-arming ~~,?::cG.::io~ in re[a:'~s to
tha R~t~il Sales/Auction sectio~ of t~at a??l:cz~:=~.
"
dIY, /
J7~-J;~p:-rv-
Peter Snycer
Councilce:ober
PS:ga
..
'.
:
!
, ,I
i
i
;
,
I
,
.\~E~E\Y.ED
!i1:V, 0;: '1969
DUBUN FL~'lN\NG
"-. -"..)._.'","
.... ----~.;..-
. ~ .:..
..:;.l
. ~ ~
'"
AttachllEnt ~
~_._----,-----'-'---."'"
. . .' .