HomeMy WebLinkAbout11-20-2007 Adopted CC Min
Mmudes 011' the Cnty CouHllcnll
011' tll1e Cnty 011' Dubllm
REGULAR MEE'fiNG -November 20. 2007
ClLOSED SESSKON
Ro II call
Present
Absent
CouncIlmembers HIldenbrand, Oravetz, SbrantI and Mayor Lockhart
CouncIlmember Scholz arrIved at 6 45 P m
The CIty CouncIl convened m closed seSSIOn at 6 30 pm, regardmg
I CONFERENCE WITH LEGAL COUNSEL -ANTICIPATED LITIGATION
(Government Code sectIOn 54956 9, SubdivIsIOn c)
InitiatIOn of litigatIOn (two potential cases)
<>
The CIty CouncIl reconvened m open seSSIOn at 7 00 P m for a regular meetmg of the
DublIn CIty CouncIl on Tuesday, November 20, 2007, In the CouncIl Chambers of the
DublIn CIVIC Center
<>
ROlLlL CAlLlL
PRESENT Councdmembers HIldenbrand, Oravetz, Sbrantl and Scholz, and Mayor
Lockhart
ABSENT None
<>
PlLJEJIJlGE OF AJLlLJEGlIANCJE
The pledge of allegIance to the flag was reCIted by the CounCIl, Staff and those present
DllffilLKN CiTY COlUNCilL MiNllJ'fES
VOlLUME 26
REGllJJLAR MJEE'fiNG
November 20, 2007
lP AGE <S72
REPOR'f ON CJLOSED SESSliON AC'fliON
Mayor Lockhart advIsed that no reportable actIOn was taken
<:> --
ORAIL COMMlUNJ[CA 'fKONS
Punlbllnc CommeIl1lts
7 02 P m 3 1
No comments were made by any member of the publIc at thIS tIme
-~<>
CONSEN'f CAILlENIDAR
7 03 P m Items 4 1 through 4 9
Mayor Lockhart requested Item 4 8 be removed from the Consent Calendar
On motIOn of Cm Oravetz, seconded by Vm HIldenbrand and by unanImous vote, the
CouncIl removed Item 48 and took the followmg actIOns
Mmutes (4 1) - None
ReceIved report (42 100-80), FIscal Year 2007-2008 Goals & ObJectives Status and CIP
Schedule
DUBlLlIN CR'fY COllJNClilL MJ[NllJ'fJES
VOLlUME 26
REG lUILAR MIKE 1LlING
November 20,2007
1? AGE 4173
Adopted (43 610-20)
ORJIJlliNANCE NO 23-07
REPEAlLliNG ClHIAlP'fERS 5 m~ "lF1IRlE CODE," ANJ!Jl7 32, "BUliILDliNG CODE,"
ADDiNG ClHIAP'fERS 5 08, "lFliRE CODE," ANID 7 32, "BUliILDiNG CODE," AND
AMENIDliNG ClHIAP'fERS 7 28, "BUlilLDING REGllJJLA'fliON
ADMiNliS'fRA'fliON," 7 36, "EILEC'fRliCAlL CODE," 7 <SO, "PILlUMBiNG CODE,"
ANID 7 <S<S, "MEClHIANliCAIL CODE," OF 'flHIJE DUBILiN MlUNliCliP AJL CODE liN
ORJIJlER 'fO ADOP'f BY REFERENCE ANID AMENIDPROVliSliONS OF 'flHIE 2007
EDli'fliON OF 'flHIE CAJLliFORNliA BUlilLDliNG S'f ANIDARIDS CODE, 'fli'flLE 2<S,
CAlLliFORNliA CODE OF REGULA'fIONS
RESOlLU'fliON NO 203 - 07
AMENIDiNG RESOlLU'fliON #<S9-06 AS li'f PER'f AiNS 'f0 BUlilLDliNG PERMli'f
V AlLUA'fiONS USED 'fO CAlLCllJJLA'fE BilllLDliNG PERMli'f FEES
Adopted (4 4 600-30)
RESOLU'fliON NO 20<S - 07
APPROVliNG AGREEMEN'f Wli'flHI ASSOCliA 'fED RliGlHI'f OlF WAY SERVliCES,
liNC , lFOR CONSUL 'fiNG SERVliCES FOR 'flHIE EX'fENSliON OlF
SAiN'f lP A 'fRliClK WAY
Accepted (45 600-35) Improvements under Contract No 07-11, CIVIC Center Roof
RepaIr, and authonze final payment to the contractor, less retentIOn m 35 days Ifno
subcontractor or supplIer claims are receIved
Accepted (4 6 600-35) Improvements under Contract No 07-08A, San Ramon Road,
Concrete Soundwall Sealmg (CIP No 94601), and authonze the release of retentIOn after
35 days If there are no subcontractor claIms
DllffilLliN Cli'fY COlUNCKL MliNllJ'fES
VOlLlUME 26
REGULAR MEE'fiNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE <S7<S
Adopted (4 7 350-20)
RESOILU'flION NO 205 - 07
AU'flHIORJIZlING S'fAFF 'I 0 PROCURE JIJllIGI'fAlL COlPlIlERS FROM SJH[AMROClK
OFFiCE SOlLlU1flIONS JPlURSUAN'f TO 'fJH[E lUS COMMUNi'fiES PllJRClHIASKNG
AGREEMJEN'f
Removed (48 410-30/600-40)
Mayor Lockhart removed Item 4 8 to request a prOVISlOn be added to the Agreement to
prohIbIt addItzonal extenslOns WIthout CIty CouncIl reVIew of the SIte Development
RevIew and project Condltwns of Approval, CItzng prevzous extenswn and length of tIme
sznce the ongznal approval
Cm Sbrantl requested clarificatwn of the extent of the addltwnal reVIew and the current
status of the project He spoke on negotlatwns to get the current plan and stated he does
not want to retreat on any of the deSIgn standards
CIty Manager RIch Ambrose responded Alameda County General ServIces IS negotzatzng
WIth Judges on cost(s) to determme the feaslblllty of reducmg the SIze of the facIZzty
Mayor Lockhart spoke on Camp Parks' changes and zn support of gomg back to the SIte
ReVIew Process for a decIswn by the new CIty Counczl, Cltlng potentzal benefits to the
commumty
SupervIszng ArchItect Gerald Leaper, Alameda County, spoke m support of the current
plan and zn OpposItzon of gozng through another SIte Development ReVIew process and all
other reVIews orzgmally reqUlred for approval of the project
ASSIstant Planner JamIe Raja responded on the revzew process and stated that if the
project IS resubmItted, zt would go back to the Plannmg Commlsszon and then the CIty
Counczl
Cm Sbrantl encouraged construetwn to avozd addItIOnal revIew for conSIderatIOn of
addUlOnal extenszons
DlUBlLliN CiTY <COlUN<CILIL MINUTES
VOLlUMlE 26
JRJB:GmLAR MEE'1I'KN G
November 20, 2007
JP AGlE 4)75
On motIOn by Cm Oravetz, seconded by Cm Sbrantl, and by unammous vote, the CIty
CouncIl adopted
RESOLUTION NO 206 - 07
APPROVING A SECOND AMENDMENT TO THE CITY/COUNTY AGREEMENT
REGARDING THE ENFORCEMENT OF CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL FOR THE
EAST COUNTY HALL OF JUSTICE (ALAMEDA COUNTY COURTHOUSE)
PA 02-030
as amended, to mclude a prOVISIOn m the Agreement to prohIbIt addItIOnal extensIOns
wIthout CIty Counczl revIew of the SIte Development RevIew, should the County fazl to
commence constructIOn by the expIratIOn date of May 16, 2009
Approved (49300-40) the Warrant RegIster m the amount of$I,717,527,01
<>
WRli'f'fEN COMMUNliCA 'fliONS
COll"ll"eslPonndleIl1lce 11'rom ABAG regardlmf! Pnorntv Connsell"Vatnonn Areas
7 12 (5 1 930-30)
Parks and CommunIty ServIces DIrector DIane Lowart presented the Staff Report and
adVIsed that correspondence has been receIved from ABAG mformmg the CIty that an
area wIthm the CIty of Dublm has been nommated as a Pnonty ConservatIOn Area (PCA)
for the FOCUS RegIOnal Plannmg Program The nommatIOn was made by the East Bay
RegIOnal Park DIstnct for Its RegIOnal TraIls System Gaps proJect and mcludes traIl
connectIOns along the TassaJara Creek TraIl, the Alamo Canal Trail and the Calaveras
RIdge TraIl
Cm Sbranh requested mformatIOn on the process followmg the nommatIOn
Mayor Lockhart requested addItIOnal mformatIOn on the locatIOn of the traIls
DUBLiN Cli'fY COlUNCiL MJ[NllJ'fES
VOLlUME 26
REGllJJLAR MEE'fiNG
Novembell" 20, 2007
lP AGE <S76
f
Parks and CommunIty ServIces DIrector Lowart responded that all three of the trails are
IdentIfied as future traIlslbIkeways m the CIty'S BIkeways Master Plan and the TraIls Plan
mcluded m the Parks and RecreatIOn Master Plan She stated that once local JunsdIctIOns
and the ReVIew Team have provIded comments on the nommatIOns, that If the project IS
chosen, It wIll be submItted for fundmg
On motIon of Vm HIldenbrand, seconded by Cm Scholz, and by unanImous vote, the
CouncIl dIrected Staff to notify ABAG of the CIty'S support for the nommatIOn
<>
Dou211nertv lBInlllls Do!! Park Petdnonn
7 15 pm
52
(290-20)
Parks and CommunIty ServIces DIrector DIane Lowart presented the staff report and
adVIsed that on November 5, 2007, the CIty was presented WIth a petItIOn seekmg "safety
and Improvement reVISIOns" to the Dougherty HIlls Dog Park She stated Staff has
prepared an analysIs of each requested reVISIOn for conSIderatIOn by the CIty CouncIl, as
follows, and dIsplayed a Power Pomt of the Artwork and potentIal locatIOn If the deCISIOn
IS made to move the art
o Artwork currently mSIde the Dog Park
o AgIlIty Items currently InSIde the Dog Park
o LIghtmg - currently noneXIstent
o Parkmg - congested "boxed m" vehIcles
Parks and Commumty ServIces DIrector Lowart spoke on Staff s mtent to close the Park
for mamtenance from January through March 2008 and clarIfied the CIty CouncIl wIll be
prOVIded WIth a report at a future meetmg related to draInage and turf condItions at the
Dog Park as they are not a part of the petItIOn She requested CouncIl dIrectIOn regardmg
the relocatIOn of the artwork (at the CIty'S expense at an estimated $13,870), statmg the
artIst had been contacted and was m agreement She spoke on the agIlIty course fixtures
and concluded her presentatIOn WIth Staff recommendatIOns to approve the request for
modIficatIons to the parkmg lot m order to ease parkmg congestIOn, but not InstallatIOn of
lIghts due to the prOXImIty of the Dog Park to adJacent housmg
DllffilLKN cliTY COUNC1IJL MliNllJ'fES
VOLlUMJE 26
REGllJJLAR MEE'fliNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE <S77
~ Of !Jli/f>'
~~~
111~1~~\~
19~~1J2
,~,
QU'fOv.,~~
Vm HIldenbrand asked If thought had been gIven to dIfferent types of surface, other than
turf, due to the number of dogs usmg the Park and assocIated mamtenance costs
Parks and CommunIty ServIces DIrector DIane Lowart responded that optIOns wIll be
brought back to CouncIl for consIderation at a future meetmg
CIty Manager RIchard Ambrose asked If CouncIl would be mterested m Staffbnngmg
back other optIOns that does not mvolve turV
Vm HIldenbrand stated she lIkes the turf at the Dog Park but It has created overuse, as It
IS the only one m the area wIth grass, an optIOn other than turf may be a way of adJustmg
use of the Park, cItmg the Park was not mtended to be a regIOnal park
Mayor Lockhart stated opposItion to reseedmg twIce a year and suggested changmg the
surface If necessary
Cm Scholz requested mformatIOn on mamtenance fundmg, on the type of preparatIOn and
research done for development of the Dog Park, and on the safety of the art work She
also spoke on a reSIdent's suggestIOn to use ~ of the Park at a time
Parks and CommunIty ServIces DIrector Lowart responded that Staff researched Dog
Parks throughout the Bay Area, mcludmg SIte VISItS, and Staffs mItIal recommendatIOn
was grass for the small dog park and bark for the large dog park, however, CommunIty
mput supported turf, WIth the knowledge that closmg the Park each year for mamtenance
would be reqUIred She stated fundmg was from the General Fund The next report to
CouncIl wIll mclude Improvement costs for CouncIl conSIderatIOn, and that the Art Work
was not antiCIpated to be a problem at the time the Park was approved
CIty Manager RIchard Ambrose clanfied that Park mamtenance IS budgeted on an annual
baSIS, but that the regIOnal use of the Dog Park was not antiCIpated
Vm HIldenbrand asked If there IS a way to mOnItor the Park to aVOId overuse
Parks and CommunIty ServIces DIrector Lowart responded that an occupancy SIgn could
be posted but enforcement would be dIfficult, as Staff to mOnItor the Park would be
prohIbItive
DllffilLliN Cli'fY COlUNCliIL MiNUTES
VOILUME 26
REGUlLAR MEE'fiNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE <S7B
Vm HIldenbrand spoke on the regIOnal use that prevents Dubhn resIdents from usmg the
Park
Cm Sbrantl spoke m support of lookmg at all optIOns of surfacmg and requested
mformatIOn on the agIlIty course and requested modIficatIOns
Mayor Lockhart asked If the agIlIty features are necessary and suggested lImItmg the cost
to $250 00 If replaced
Vm HIldenbrand asked If there were age reqUIrements for chIldren to be m the Dog Park
Parks and Commumty ServIces DIrector responded on the features and use of the agIlIty
course and on sIgnage relatmg to chIldren m the Park
Mayor Lockhart suggested makIng the sIgnage bIgger prohIbItmg chIldren under 5 from
bemg m the Park and statmg chIldren under the age of 12 must be accompamed by an
adult
Cm Oravetz commented on the cost of movmg the Art Work and suggested reducmg the
cost by only relocatmg the ArtWork m the large Dog Park, as that seems to be the
problem He asked how many actual cases of dogs gettmg hurt have been reported to the
CIty
MIke Hathaway, reSIdent adJacent to the Dog Park area, spoke m support of green turf and
m oppOSItIon to lIghts, cItmg Impact on surroundmg homes, and on regIOnal use of the
Park He stated perhaps parkmg meters could be used to lImIt time WIth addItIOnal fees
for non-Dubhn users
OZZIe Dashevsky, DublIn reSIdent, presented a power pOInt and spoke on agIhty
eqUIpment, parkmg congestIOn, and hghtmg He spoke m support of the Park and
recommended mstallatIOn of enough lIghtmg for safety, not stadIUm lIghtmg
John Sherwm, reSIdent adJacent to the Dog Park area, spoke m oppOSItIon to lIghtmg,
recommended CouncIlmembers VISIt the park to observe nOIse, cItmg the neIghborhood
dIsturbance He requested the Park be relocated or a Dog Park be developed m another
area
DllffiLlIN Cli'fY COlUNCliL MliNllJ'fES
VOILlUME 26
REGUILAR MEE'fiNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE <S79
Rich Sotelo, spoke m support of the Dog Park and requested the desIgn be reconfigured
for entrance of the dogs He suggested pamtmg the curb red to prevent parkmg and traffic
congestion
Estella & Emmanuel Lopez stated theIr dog was mJured on the Art Work at the Dog Park,
submItted the dog's medIcal hIstOry, and requested the Art Work be removed
Irene Alstrum spoke m support of the turf, suggested momtonng or controllIng entry mto
the park, cIted prevIOus use of a Dog Park m another area reqUIred an annual fee and proof
of vaccmatIOn She spoke on the mIsuse and overuse of the Park
Robert Hawkms stated he does not lIve m Dublm but uses the park at least once a day
because of the grass and the desIgn of the Park He spoke m OppOSItIOn to use of the
crawl tunnel by chIldren, cItmg CIty lIabIlIty
Ron Boggs stated he apprecIates the Park, lIkes the turf, and spoke m OppOSItIOn to lIghts
CouncIlmembers dIscussed the CIty of Dublm commItment to art m the Parks, potential
area to relocate the large Dog Park Art Work, parkmg Issues and parkmg lot congestIOn,
feaSIbIlIty of membershIp to use the Park, agIlIty features, regIOnal use and overuse of the
Park, costs assocIated wIth mamtenance, use of the Park and agIlIty features by chIldren,
commItment that the Park would be an amemty for the neIghborhood reSIdents, not an
mtrusIOn, feaSIbIlIty ofusmg a faCIlIty attendant at busy times, and OppOSItIOn to lIghtmg
On motIOn of Mayor Lockhart, seconded by em SbrantI, and by unanImous vote, the
CouncIl dIrected Staff as follows
o Remove ngId poles
o No lIghtmg
o Postmg better, larger sIgnage regardmg rules for chIldren
o Pamt curb red
o PolIce Department to enforce legal parkmg
o Relocate Art Work m the large Dog Park to Area 4 - parkmg lot adJacent to the
entry
DllffiLITN Cli'fY COUNCliL MJ[NllJ'fES
VOILlUME 26
REGUILAR MEE'fITNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE <SSO
Parks and CommunIty ServIces DIrector Lowart clanfied costs are aVaIlable III the current
mamtenance budget to do the mamtenance suggested m the Staff Report dunng the
closure penod, and dependmg on what optIOn CouncIl chooses to deal WIth the turf Issue,
there could be very sIgmficant costs to be consIdered as part of the budget
CIty Manager RIchard Ambrose clanfied the Park FaCIlIty OrdInance will be scheduled
for an upcommg CouncIl Meetmg and suggested mcorporatmg rules at that tIme He also
c1anfied that only the ngId poles WIll be removed from the agIlIty course
<>
PUBILliC lHIJEARKNGS
Punbllnc lHIearmg (COIl1ltllIl1llLlled!1from :B.Jl/06/(7)
Mntngated! Negahve DedaIr'atnoIl1l, West DUlllhUm BART Sjpecnfnc Pllann Amennd!mennt,
Stage 1 DeveHopmennt PHsnn Amenndmellllt Slllld! Stage 2 PllSIl1lBlled! Devellojpmennt Re710nne for
a 309-Unnnt Resnd!ennhall Communmw. lP'A 06-009 Wmd!stsr
8 20 P m
6 1 (400-20/410-55/450-30)
Mayor Lockhart opened the publIc hearmg
Semor Planner Enca Fraser presented the Staff Report and adVIsed that Wmdstar has
proposed a 309-umt reSIdential proJect located wIthm the West DublIn BART SpecIfic
Plan area and the development of the Site plays an mtegral part m finanCIng the
constructIOn of the West Dubhn BART TransIt StatIOn She presented an overvIew of
transIt onented developments and stated the ApplIcant has requested an amendment of the
Stage 1 Development Plan for the SIte to Increase the total number of permItted umts and
has proposed a Stage 1 Development Plan Amendment and Stage 2 Planned Development
Rezone to allow the constructIOn of the proposed reSIdential proJect The presentatIOn
concluded WIth a reVIew of parkmg standards, proposed parkmg UnIts, the feasIbIhty of
offenng a flex car on SIte, and the proposed heIght of the development
Cm Oravetz requested clanficatIOn of flex car use and aVaIlabIlIty
DOOLKN CITY COlUNCKL MlINllJTES
VOJLUME 26
REGULAR MJEE'f[NG
November 20,2007
PAGE ~81l
SenIor Planner Fraser responded a flex car IS a car that can be used by the resIdents when
transIt IS not a vIable option and CondItion of Approval 29 reqUlres the ApplIcant to look
mto the feaSIbIlIty ofhavmg a flex car on sIte
Cm SbrantI spoke on the proposed overall parkmg ratIo of 1 55 parkmg stalls per UnIt and
clarIfied that the CondItions of Approval recommended by the PlannIng CommIssIOn were
not bmdmg
Cm Scholz requested clarification of the parkmg ratIO, cItmg mcreased densIty, and
questIOned resIdents use of publIc transportatIOn
Mayor Lockhart clarified there are no establIshed parkmg ratIOS for tranSIt onented
development
SenIor Planner Fraser clanfied the parkmg ratIOS m the Code are based on suburban
development and the Code has not been changed to mclude parkmg ratios for tranSIt
onented development
Cheek Tang, MVE ArchItects, representmg the ApplIcant, mtroduced development staff
and clanfied the purpose of transIt onented development IS for resIdents who use mass
tranSIt He dIsplayed a power pomt of the proposed proJect, SIte, deSIgn m conjUnctIOn
WIth surroundmg busmesses, proposed publIc art feature, street and mterchange
Improvements, enforcement of parkmg, flex-car avaIlabIlIty, and clanfied that
profeSSIOnal property management WIll be on SIte 24 hours
Cm SbrantI asked If a SImIlar proJect IS planned m Pleasanton and would the same
parkmg ratIO be proposed He also requested clanficatIOn of the gated/ungated parkmg
areas
Mr Tang responded a proJect IS m the development process m Pleasanton WIth a proposed
1 3 parkIng ratIO He clanfied the reSIdent parkmg IS m a gated area and the guest parkIng
IS ungated
DllffilLKN cli'fY COlUNCliL MliNllJ'fES
VOILUME 26
REGULAR MEE'fiNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE ~82
CouncIlmembers and the Mayor dIscussed varIOUS Issues related to the proJect, mcludmg
bIkeway, development of a plaza area, and support for a restaurant wIthm the hotel
DavId Bewley, spoke on concerns related to tranSIt onented development, mcludmg
oppOSItIon to proposed parkmg ratIOs and mtersectIOn level of servIce and spoke m
support of bIkeways
Mayor Lockhart closed the publIc heanng
Mayor Lockhart spoke m support of the project and transIt onented development,
mcludIng dIfferent parkmg ratIOs, m support of St Patnck Way Improvement, cIted the
opportumty to lIve and walk to many busmesses m the area, and encouraged the
development of bIkeways
Cm Oravetz concurred wIth Mayor Lockhart's comments, cItmg tranSIt onented
development as an amemty for the CIty of DublIn and spoke m support of mcludmg a
restaurant
Vm HIldenbrand spoke m support of tranSIt onented development and expressed
concerns wIth the proposed 1 55 parkmg ratIO, speCIfically guest parkmg and BART
patrons usmg the ungated guest parkIng spaces
Cm SbrantI expressed concerns wIth the proposed 1 55 parkmg ratIO, BART patrons
usmg parkmg spaces desIgnated for resIdents, lack of guest parkmg, accumulatIve Impact
relatmg to parkmg and traffic He spoke m support of a flex car on SIte
CIty Manager RIchard Ambrose stated the bUlldout for downtown has been analyzed and
necessary Improvements to mItigate the traffic have been IdentIfied He also spoke on the
adoptIOn of the traffic fee to Improve downtown streets
Enc Heffuer, ApplIcant, spoke m support of the proJect deSIgn and on the goal of parkmg
spaces utilIzed by the resIdents and theIr guests, statmg rents WIll be tIed to the number of
vehIcles a resIdent has and that a profeSSIOnal property management wIll be avaIlable 24-7
to enforce rules on the property
CouncIlmembers and the Mayor dIscussed Issues relatmg to parkIng enforcement
DllffiLlIN Cli'fY COlUNclilL MlINIU'fES
VOLlUME 26
REGUlLAR MEE'fliNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE <SS3
Cm SbrantI spoke m support of CondItions of Approval, to mclude rents tied to the
number of vehICles a resIdent has, BART parkmg, and avaIlabIlIty of a flex car IS not
optIonal
On motIon ofCm Oravetz, seconded by Cm Scholz, and by a maJonty vote, wIth
Vm HIldenbrand and Cm SbrantI votmg no, the CouncIl adopted
RESOLU'fliON NO 207-07
AIDOlP'fliNG A Mli'fliGA 'fED N]EGA 'fliVJE ANID A Mli'fliGA 'fliON MONlI'fOmNG
ANJ!Jl RElPOR'fliNG lPROGRAM FOR 'flHIE WliNIDS'fAR lPROJnEC'f PA 06-009
RESOILU'fliON NO 208-07
AlPlPlROVliNG AMENIDMEN'fS 'fO 'flHIE WES'f DllffiLKN BAR'f SlPECliFliC lPlLAN
FOR 'flHIE WliNIDS'f AR lPROJnEC'f lP A 06-009
and waived readmg and mtroduced an Ordmance approvmg a PD Planned Development
Rezomng to Amend the Adopted Stage 1 Development Plan and Adopt a Stage 2
Development Plan for the Wmdstar ProJect (APN 941-1500-046-01), PA 06-009
<>
lUNFliNlISlHIED BUSiNESS
So11'tw~lIre System Assessmennt Report ~mdl Autllnornzatnonn to Cnrcullate a Request 11'011"
lPlI"olPosall (RlFlP) 11'011" lProculI"emeIl1lt 011' Accounntml! &. Bunlldlml! Permnt Systems
9 54 P m 7 1 (350-20/600-30)
AdmmIstratIve ServIces DIrector Paul Rankm presented the Staff Report and adVIsed that
an Assessment Report evaluatmg current Accountmg PermIt Systems concludes that the
CIty should proceed wIth a procurement process by releasmg a Request for Proposals
from vendors He stated the purchasmg code allows thIS procurement method for
DllffiILKN CliTY cOlUNCliIL MliNllJ'fES
VOILlUME 26
REGllJJLAR MJEE'fKNG
November 20, 2007
lP AGE <SS<S
technIcal purchases, when authonzed by the CIty CouncIl The presentatIOn mcluded the
estimated cost and concluded wIth a response to Mayor Lockhart's questIOn on mterfacmg
systems
On motion of Cm Scholz, seconded by Vm HIldenbrand, and by unammous vote, the
CIty CouncIl adopted
RESOILU'fliON NO 209-07
AU'flHIOmZliNG AN EXCEP'fliON 'fO 'flHIE COMPE'fli'fNJE BIDDliNG
REQUlIRlEMEN'fS FOR 'flHIE SELEC'fliON OF ACCOlUN'fKNG ANIDPERMlI'f
SYS'fEM SOlF'fW ARE ANJ!Jl AU'flHIOmZliNG 'flHIE REILEASE OlF A REQUJES'f
lFOR PROPOSAIL
<>
NJEW BUSKNESS
Poet ILaureate &, ILocalllHInstornann
10 00 p m
8 1 (910-75)
Hentage and Cultural Arts SupervIsor John Hartnett presented the Staff Report outlImng
two new volunteer posItions for the CIty, a Poet Laureate and Local HIstonan, and asked
the CIty CouncIl to authonze the recruItment and selectIOn process He stated the
proposed Poet Laureate wIll serve as a publIc advocate for the apprecIatIOn and
advancement of the lIterary arts for the CIty of Dublm and the proposed CIty HIstonan
WIll aSSIst researchers, students, lIbrarIans, members of the publIc, the press and dIrect
them to resources for hIstoncal mformatIOn The presentatIOn concluded WIth a
recommended selectIOn process
Cm Oravetz spoke on the reqUIred qualIficatIOns
Mayor Lockhart spoke m OppOSItIOn to the qualIficatIOn for the pOSItion of CIty HIstonan
to possess the abIlIty to prOVIde first-rate customer servIce, cItmg It sounds more lIke a
Staff person than a volunteer, and recommended alternate language
DllffiLlIN Cli'fY COUNCliL MJ[NllJ1I'ES
VOLlUME 26
REGllJJLAR MEE'fKNG
November 20, 2007
PAGE <S35
Hentage and Cultural Arts SupervIsor Hartnett responded that qualIficatIOn could be
omItted
CouncIlmembers and Mayor Lockhart dIscussed the two posItIOns and the proposed
length of appomtment wIth opportumty to be reappomted
On motion of Cm Scholz, seconded by Cm SbrantI, and by unammous vote, the CIty
CouncIl approved the Poet Laureate and Local HIstonan posItions for two year
appomtments wIth optIOn for reappomtment, and authonzed Staff to advertIse the
pOSItIOns
<>
O'fHER BUSKNESS BrIef INFORMATION ONLY reports from Councd and/or Staff, mcludmg
Committee Reports and Reports by Councd related to meetmgs attended at City expense (AD 1234)
10 10 P m
CIty Manager RIchard Ambrose asked If CouncIlmembers want one or two meetmgs m
the month of January CouncIl consensus to meet once m January, the thIrd Tuesday of
the month
CouncIlmembers reported on attendmg the Mayor's Conference
Cm SbrantI announced the Alumm Dublm HIgh School Soccer Game
Vm HIldenbrand requested amendment of CouncIl rules and procedures to mclude a
prOVISIOn based on state law to prohIbIt polItical actiVIty dunng CouncIl meetmgs, at CIty
events, or when carrymg out elected duties CouncIl consensus to lIst on a future agenda
Mayor Lockhart thanked Hentage and Cultural Center for Mayor's Conference and read a
letter of thanks from PrmcIpal, Poway HIgh School to FIre ChIef, Alameda County, for
theIr support dunng the Southern CalIfornIa fires
DOOJLliN Cli'fY COlUNCliL MJ[NllJ'fES
VOLlUME 26
REGllJJLAR MEE'fKNG
NovembeJr 20, 2007
PAGE <SS6
AID>J01UR.NMJEN'f
There bemg no further busmess to come before the CouncIl, the meetmg was adJourned at
10 25 p m III memory of our fallen troops
Mmutes prepared by Intenm CIty Clerk Carolyn Parkmson
ATTEST c&:L~~~
~
DUBLKN Cll1I'Y COlUNclIJL MliNU'fJES
VOLUME 26
RlEGUJLAR MJEETlIN G
November 20, 2007
PAGE 487