The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutItem 6.4 Garbage Rate ExemptCITY OF DIIBLIN AGENDA STATEMENT CITY COIINCIL MEETING DATE: Auqust 24, 1992 SIIBJECT: Appeals of Determination on Applications for Ex emption from Mandatory Garbaqe Service (P repared by: Bo Barker, Manaqement Assistant) E%HIBITS ATTACHED: 1. Status Report on Mandatory Garbage 2. Administrative Procedures for Exemption from Mandatory Garbaqe Service 3. Public Hearing #1 7081 Alleqheny Drive A) Letter of Appeal B) Application for Exemption C) Property Inspection Form 4. Public Hearinq #2 7529 Rilrush Avenue A) Letter of Appeal H) Application for Exemption C) Property Inspection Form 5. Public Hearinq #3 7832 Gardella Drive A) Letter of Appeal B) Application for Exemption C) Property Inspection Form Dj Clarification of issues in the Letter of Appeal 6. Public Hearinq #4 11657 Solana Drive A) Letter of Appeal B) Application for Exemption C) Property Inspection Form D) Statement from the applicant 7. Public Hearinq #5 8656 Beverly Drive A) Letter of Appeal B) Application gor Exemption C) Property Inspection ~'orm 8. Resolution Approvinq Exemption 9. Resolution Denyinq Exemption RECOMMENDATIONa '~',~ ~~.~~`j° ~ ,~~~' io Receive Staff report ~ 2 o Open a public hearinqs 3. Hear Testimony from applicants and pul~lic 4. Close Public Hearings 5, Deliberate and adopt a~esolution approving or denyinq the exemption for each appeal considered. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: If the appeals are not qranted, the residents will be reguired to subscribe to a minimum level of ~ervice, the current ~ate is $6.65 per month. DESCRIPTION: In January, 1992 the City Council passed ~he Mandatory Garbage Service Ordinance, No. 2-92. The Mandatory Garbage Service p~ogram began March 16, 1992 for all residents in Dublino At the same time as the City Council approved ~he Mandatory Garbage Service Ordinance, a newr class of service was initiatedo The new class of se~vice provides for a 20 gallon container, curbside recycling and the four special Saturday pick-ups for $6.65 per month. This low monthly rate is the minimum level of service and assures that the costs of the recycling program and Saturday pick-ups are spread among the entire rate base. All residences were required to subscribe to at least this level of service unless they qualified for an exemption. Exhibit 1 identifies the current status of the Mandatory Garbage Programe In accordance with Ordinance 2-92, the law provides for an exemption and an appeal process (Exhibit 2)a According to Section 5.32.111 of the Dublin Municipal Code, an exemption is allowed when solid waste is not produced, accumulated in, upon, or from such propertye To be exempted grom garbaqe service, the resident completes an "Application for Exemption" and submits it to the City Manager's Office. An on-site inspection of the property is conducted to verify the information received on the application for exemption. The City Manager then makes a determination to approve or deny the application for exemption. If an applicant is denied, an applicant may ------------------------------------- COPIES TOe Dan Borgeso ~ ,~~sa Exemption Ap ica~ ITEA2 NO a ~, FILE a g 1 d ~ o appeal to the City Council. The individual filing the appeal must submit, in writing, the reasons why the application for exemption should not be denied. If an exemption is granted, the term of said exemption will need to be determined. The exemption can be revoked if the factual basis for granting the exemption changes. The determination of the City Council is considered final. The following individuals have applied for an exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. The applications and subsequent inspections indicate that they produce Solid Waste on the property and therefore, according to Section 5.32.080 of the Solid Waste Management Ordinance, the residents mus~ have the collector remove generated waste. Attached for the City Councilos review are five appeals. The public hearings begin with Exhibit #3 and end with Exhibit #7. The applicants' letters of appeal, their applications for exemption and property inspection forms are presented in whole accordinq to their particular public hearing number. The applicants were notified of this public hearing by a certified letter. Staff is presenting all five appeals on one report as not to duplicate information. It is recommended that the City Council open and close a public hearing for each applicant and make their determination before moving on to the next applicant. PIIBLIC HEARINGS Publi~ ~earinq ~1 Sergio Hernandez 7081 Allegheny Drive Basis of Exemption: The applicant states his waste is taken to work or to a relative°s house in Hayward, The resident also has access to a utility trailer for the removal of bulky yard debras. Staff Review of Exemption Request: The applicant submitted an applica~ion for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. An on-site inspection of the property was conducted. The inspection noted that solid waste is produced on the propertye Basis ~or Staff Denial: The inspection of the property revealed solid waste is produced on the property. According to Ordinance 2-92, Section 5.32s080, all solid waste produced on the property shall be removed by the collector at the minimum level o~ service, Action Required: Close the Public Hearing and adopt a resolution approving or denying the applicants request for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. Ptabli~ ~earing #2 Nessim Benhamou 7529 Kilrush Avenue Basis of Exemption: The applicant indicates that he hauls the waste to the Pleasanton Transfer Station himself. The resident also redeems ,. recyclable material at the Pleasanton Buy Back Center. Trash is disposed of twice each month and the resident indicates he does not typically accumulate more ~han one trash can per week. Staff Review of Exemption Request: The applicant submitted a application for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. An on-site inspection of the property was conducted. The inspection noted ~hat solid waste is produced on the property. Basis for Staff Denial: The inspection of the property revealed solid waste is produced on the property. According to Ordinance 2-92, 5ection 5.32.080, all solid waste produced on the property shall be removed by the collector at the minimum level of service. Action Required: Close the Public Hearing and adopt a resolution approving or denying the applicants request for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. Public Hearing #3 Tayna Marie Clark 7832 Gardella Drive Applicants Request for Exemption: The applicant explains that a very small quantity of waste is produced on the property. The disposal of the waste is shared with a friend and the garbage is removed twice a weeko Staff Review of Exemption Request: The applicant submitted a application for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. An on-site inspection of the property was conducted. The inspection noted that, by the owner's admission, a small quantity of solid waste is produced. Staff has also evaluated several issues related to garbage service which are raised in Mrs. Clark's letter of appeal. The following information is intended to clarify information as to how the Mandatory Garbage Ordinance was developed. Consideration of Reduced Service Levels Prior to Im lementation of Mandatory Service * The City of Dublin did consider other service levels to address low-volume waste generators, with the introduction of a Super Recycler Service. The service is made available to all customers ~n order to avoid administrative costs of qualifying customers based upon income or age. Combetitive Selection of Garbage Service Provider * The current agreement for garbage collection and disposal was originally implemented in 1986. At that time ~he City requested proposals from several providers of these services. Only one responsible proposal was received from the parent company of Livermore Dublin Disposal. This agreement allows the Company to collect and dispose of all garbage. The initial term of the agreement has less than 4 years remaining. Public Testimonv on Adoption of the Mandatory Garbaae Ordinance * Prior to adopting the Mandatory Garbage Ordinance, special efforts were undertaken to obtain public inputo - A public hearing was conducted on January 13, 1992 and one member of the public addressed the City Council. - A special notice explaining the proposed ordinance and announcing a second Public Hearing was mailed to over 400 homes which did not subscribe to garbage service. - The press printed articles regarding the proposals - A second Public Hearing was conducted on January 27, 1992. Three members of the public including Ms. Tanya Clark and .. Mse Ella Clark provided public testimony on the ordinance. This info~mation should clarify the record related to these issues. Basis for Staff Denial: The inspection of the property revealed solid waste is produced on the propertye According to Ordinance 2-92, Section 5.32.080, all solid waste produced on the property shall be removed by the collector at the minimum level of serviceo Action Requireda Close the Public Hearing and adopt a resolut~on approving or denying the applicants request for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Servicee Public Hearing #4 Edward Bressinck 11657 Solana Drive Basis of Exemptione The applicant states that there is a very small quantity of waste which is taken to a friend's house in San Ramon. The applicant also uses a chipper to mulch yard debris. Staff Review of Exemption Request: The applicant submitted a application for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. An on-site inspection of the property was conducted. The inspection noted that solid waste is produced on the property. Basis for Staff Deniale The inspection of the property revealed solid waste is produced on the propertyo According to Ordinance 2-92, Sec~ion 5m32.080, all solid waste produced on the property shall be removed by the collector at the minimum level of service. Action Required: Close the Public Hearing and adopt a resolution approving or denying the applicants request for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. Publ~c Hearinq #5 Helen Fontaine 8656 Beverly Lane Basis of Exemptione The applicant indicates that all her solid waste is taken away by her daughter twice each week. The resident indicates that the amount of waste which is generated is too small to warrent regular serviceo Staff Review of Exemption Requeste The applicant submitted a application for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. An on-site inspection of the property was conducted. The inspection noted that solid waste is produced on the property. Basis for Staff Denial: The inspection of the property revealed solid waste is produced on the property. According to Ordinance 2-92, Section 5.32.080, all solid waste produced on the property shall be removed by the collector at the minimum level of service. Action Required: Close the Public Hearing and adopt a resolution approving or denying the applicants request for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Services Status Report Mandatory Garbage Service (Prepared August 19, 1992) Implementation The new law became effective February 28, 1992. At that time 308 residential accounts did not have regular garbage service. All units were contacted and advised of the need to establish minimum service by March 16, 1992 or request an exemption. Exemption Rec~uests A total of 37 exemption rec~uests were received. Property billing was suspended until the final outcome of the exemption process for these individuals. Exemptions Granted by Staff Pursuant to the Ordinance A total of 5 applications for exemptions were granted for vacant residential units. Exemptions Denied Bv Staff Pursuant to the Ordinance A total of 32 applications were denied given that they did not appear to meet the requirements of the ordinance. Ap~eals Received All applicants whose application for exemption was denied by Staff were advised of their opportunity to appeal to the City Council. They were advised the appeal must be, in writing and submitted within 20 days. A total of 5 applicants filed an appeal. Current Delinquencies ,. The Company has indicated that there are currently a total of 89 accounts which are delinquent. The Company is in the process of sending a final request for payment to the property owners. The notification also advises that unpaid amounts may become a lien on the property. ~~~~~~~ 1 CITY OF DUBLIN ADMINI5TRATIVE PROCEDURES FOR EXEMPTION' FROM MANDATORY GARBAGE SERVICE Section 5.32.111 Dublin Municipal Code In accordance with the Dublin Municipal Code, the following administrative procedures are adopted by Resolution of the City Council. I. Exemption AppliCations Attached hereto as Exhibit A is an application form for exemption from mandatory garbage service. The form used for this purpose shall substantially represent the information shown in Exhibit A. The form includes questions which are necessary to determine whether solid waste is produced or accumulated in, upon, or from such property. These forms shall be made available by the City Manager's Staff to persons requesting an exemption. II. Reference Information (Exhibit B) The application form (Exhibit A) shall include reference information such as that shown in Exhibit B. The purpose of this information is to assist the applicant, without a need to refer to the entire Solid Waste Management Ordinance. III. Inspection Reauired In order to verify whether the applicant qualifies for an exemption, an inspection is required. The purpose of the inspection is to verify whether the address appears to meet the qualification that solid waste is not produced or accumulated in, upon, or from such property. The applicant shall be informed that an inspection will occur. The inspection shall be completed by City 5taff. IV. Inspector__Recommendation Based upon the inspection, a recommendation shall be made to the Director (City Manager/or his/her designee) by the Inspector regarding whether the address qualifies for an exemption. The Inspector shall also attach any relevant information supporting his/her recommendation. V. Director's Decision The Director (City Manager or his/her designee) shall make a decision based upon information in the application, the inspection report, and the criteria in the Municipal Code. Following a decision by the Director, the applicant shall be notified in writing with a Notice of Determination. Said notification shall include information on the applicant's right to appeal the decision. VI. Term of Exemption Director shall identify the term of the exemption granted. Applicant may be required to submit updated information upon expiration of the exemption or if the City becomes aware of a change in the conditions, which would no longer warrant an exemption. VII. Revocation By Director As stated in Section 5.32.111 Dublin Municipal Code, said exemption may be revoked by the Director, in the event that the factual basis .. for such exemption no longer exists. Said revocation shall also be subject to the'appeal process as described herein. VIII.Authorization to Appeal • In the event the applicant does not agree with the decision rendered by the Director, he/she may appeal the decision to the City Council in accordance with Section 1.04.050 of the Dublin Municipal Code. IX. Notice to Appellant The City Clerk shall notify the appellant in writing of the findings made by the City Council on the matter. Date Adopted: February 10, 1992 Resolution No. 15-92 ~H~~I~ ~ JUL 3 ~ ~ga2 `i'o city of' Dublin. ~~ C~ ~ ~/ ~ j~ /~U G ~`3 i99~ This letter is concernin~; the denial of my exemption - ~ITY cJ~ DUGLt~V for garba~~e service. I don`t understand why my application was denied. I clearly explained that my garbage is thrown away once a week, either in my utility trailer or at my jo~. I sincerely thin?~ that tire should not be force to take on yoizr service if we do not need it. ~~~~~~ ~ CZT7l OF DUBLIN APPLICATION FOA:::EXE[~TION FROM MANDATORY..GARBAGE SII2VTCE perty Address: C~~ e ° Dublin, CA 94568 e of Applicant: ~ '~~/ v~Z-- ~~~~~~/l-~~ licant's Address (If Different from Above): e of Property Owner (If Different from Applicant) ~ress : !' ~•' '~- C ~i'r L: L1 a ~ r _~ ',~ ~ . 1 ~ /.J ~ 'V ~ ~ ) ~. /'~ ~.... I 1 ~r ~\ ~+ n~'Z~ R~~ _a, ; Phone Number : J~~~ ~G <~~ -~-~ 1~ Phone Number: ERTIFICATION: (Al_l Applicants Please Read Carefully) am submitting this application to demonstrate that no solid waste is produced or :cumulated in, upon, or from the property identified above. I have had an opportunity to =view the applicable sections of this law on the reverse side of this form and I believe ~at this property can legally be exempted from regular garbage service. order to assist the City in processing my application, I certify that the following ~wers are true and correct: Is the house vacant? Yes ~No If yes, on what date did the hou e become vacant? If vacant, is there a scheduled date when you anticipate the house will be occupied. Yes No Date Is regular mail service provided to this address?~Yes No Is food prepared or eaten at this residence? ~Yes No If occupied, how many persons (including children) reside at this address? ,G- Do any pets (i.e. dog, etc) reside at this address Yes ~No If yes, list type How is garbage currently disposed of? j`~Y ~~~ ~ ~lr't- ~ 1 L'~ S/!L~ L~/1~ ~r n~ ~ U~`_~~'~ 1 r~ . .f~ l n 1~ Q4`~'-.c,1,1d. 1{e~5 o G v~rN ;s Zy~bl~'"~Lki. ~~~f' ~~i15Cfl~t'S -~C GC~lr2ili~ ~C:~~I;'~,~1y'r.~- }~i~'~' ~c'~i4'~~ ow~often? eT~~~ •k ~ ~L ~) p~l~s ~i~ r cvo~.K z c~-,~ DiS~a~~- r~lY t-, Ic ~~ ~~~ /~%zc.c ~~ u~~~ r~' ~ dcct. w~~y How is landscaping debris disposed of? ]= J-{RdL ~}- Uti~i~Y ~rrllc'1' ~/~-~ /7~Y ~D~lc~"~ l~c~~,~ ~'c~c~k:.5 /"-c~ ~ ~~r~'Y ~U.'c ( t~ TT L~~~ cFi2cr~ ~i71f~ ~~~~~~1~5 c>~' 2 ~.~'~IzL fr~How o~ten? ~. ~ ,~r ~. f,~ ~ . . ~~.. ~jc~rticu~c. 15 ~: P~- d4 c ~i Addit ional documentation/documents ~ /= ,~e ,~'i~"1 ~ /l'~~~/C~7 ) S Ib'~=~~e'~ , j- ~{~z~`~~ ~~«'~F'fS •~-~, ~ rr" ~ r' r~.-~ I D ~'r?Z~i r~j` ~jZ~ <~ ' .~ ~-111 i'~~c~S` 9/'1 ~1 ~1] - .L ~J~r° ~L~ /ta.VC; 1?~ i . ' ' ' lf~'~5c' G~ear1 6v ~ I fl~;~il~ ~~y s~%L''~~~~r f~c b t .~- /1 ~ ~ar~~t e%~'s l.~ ~~~ ~=~ ~~ ~. n~ ~ f It s~ ~ n-v~ > > _ _ - . . . . _ ~~'"b`~~ NOTE: YOU WTLL BE CONTACTED TO SCHEDULE A PROPERTY TNSPECTION: .}~~rc'~ Q~ PRIOR TO FINAL;ACTION ON YOUR AP PLICATION ~' ~~ ti ~ hereby certify unde rue ar~6 cor~'ect . ,/ ~ ~-~.~.,_ ~r`~~~ ~. )) penalty of perjury that the foregoing information is ~'p,;~ ~~~ u;~N l c.c ni~ icrnature ~o ~~~'pe~~~ ~~ , ~~ t~~~~~~~ ~ti ~~~z~ 3 _~ V~ Date ~ ~ ~ ~Jf - (OFFICE USE ONLY) Date Application Received Inspector• Reconxnendation Approve/Disapprove Final Action (Director): Approve/Disapprove By: Date of Inspection Initial Date: Date By: Applicant Notified: ' ~ ~ ( ~,t.~.~C~ "~<~ ~ . City of I ~lin <<{ , Address Garbage Exemption Evaluation ~ Cj -' ~~ (To Be Completed By City Staff Upon Inspection) Date of Inspection 1. Is the Property Vacant? If yes, describe all methods used to determine (i.e. conversation, physical inspections, real estate signs, etc..) /UO 2. Describe general appearance of landscaping. Front Yard 1~~~ /L~ ~ ~~'~ - Rear Yard N l~.~~~ 3. Describe location where garbage is kept: I.ocation: ~~~~ ~ ~~/'N~ - J~/~~ ~~~~ Quan[ity: Type of Containers, if any: ~ 3 Z 7~-L ~ Any detectable odors from waste: N D 4. Is solid waste produced or accumulated in, on, upon, or from the property? yes ~ no ^ 5. Who gave permission to enter the premises? (circle one) Owner or Tenant fJ ~'~"~~ ~~ ~ ~ Z ~ ~ ~ L 6 Who provided the information? (circle on~Owner or Te ~ a. How much garbage is generated? b. How much is disposed of? ~~ ~~ c. How much is recycled? ~'° d. Describe recycling methods: ~-?~ /C ~ ~ ..,d Je~ ~t-~t7 t~e a~ ~_ ~r Z-~-- ?b ~.~? ~-~ ~e'JZ S = g g ~ TC~ ~~.~1~. S ~~t.~~c /t~'~ •~ u-'`n(:. /'~.~%'; ty d. Where is the arba e tal:en. e. How is the garbage vansported? ~~( I~~C~ ~- ~~'2 f. How many times a week is the garbage tal:en? ~1)r. l~?~~~ '~Lt~ ~~~~'f ~ Commcnts: '~ . f ~ ,.,~r3~ ~ ! ~'~~ Inspeded by: ~ T~., i"`' ~ 1 l~ame of Occupant Property Owner if Different I. ,(name) do hereby give this representative of the City of Dublin permission to en~cr ihis property on this day, , 1992. Signature July 17, 1992 City of Dublin City Manager P.O. Box 2340 Dublin, CA 94568 Dear Mr. City Manager, ~~~ ~~T I am writing to you regarding the denial my wife and I received regarding Exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service. I have several concerns I would like to express to you and would like to make you aware of these prior to the City Council meeting I will attend. We terminated garbage service in 1982 for various reasons. First, the garbage collectors repeatedly left trash, including broken bottles, strewn about after their so-called collecting. We were forced to clean up after these men, including sweeping the street, after each of their visits so that our yard would be clean and safe. I found their poor service to be irritating and phoned several times to relay my feelings to the company. I was not listened to by them as was evident by each successive collection. Secondly, the trash handlers threw my trash can around, breaking and ruining more than just one. Again phoning the garbage collecting company to relay my dissatisfaction. My can was not put back in a responsible way so that on windy days can could be found at the end of the street in someone else's yard. On regular weather collecting days cans were left in the way of neighbors on the sidewalk out for a stroll or trying to pull into driveways. This was a nuisance and very poor service. As is the case with anyone that provides very poor service, I gave them more than a fair opportunity to change their behavior. Since they didn't I"fired" them. In our household we have two semi-retired adults. Our children are grown and out of the house and we now travel as often as possible. We do not generate large amounts of trash any longer. We have one garbage can in our rear yard that is well secured and never reaches more than halfway filled. When we need to dispose of our garbage, I take it to the dump in Pleasanton. We seperate out recyclables, glass, cans, and newspapers and turn these in for refunds. I have my last collection receipt I will ~rovide for your information. Our ho~ne is not and never will be any type of health hazard with ga~bage piling up. At any time of the day or night an inspector is welcome to our home to view for themself what I,L d.- ~/ (n, rC l f " '~ am telling you. In the event that I am forced to pay for mandatory garbage service, I will pay but I will not allow this company to collect my trash and will continue to take it to the dump in Pleasanton. I look forward to meeting you and the City Council regarding my home. I am proud of this city and understand that you are trying to keep it clean and safe. I want you to know that I desire the same things and am doing my part to `keep it safe and clean, but I also have principals regarding service I expect and receive. Please respect my descision as I respect yours. - Sincerely, ~ ~L~M^- ~ ~ Nessim "Max" Benhamou ~ 7529 Kilrush Avenue ~ Dublin, CA 94568 ( 51 0 ) 828-71 76 , Property Address: ~~~ t ~"!lLR,C/S'y f7 (~ Dublin, CA 94568 Name of Applicant: ~~~/~M .IVN{~/~QLLa Applicant's Address (If Different from Above): Name of Property Owner (If Different from Applicant) ~,/ . . ~ - n~ FEB 1. ~3 1992 r.~ •r n^ ni }.^~-,~,N. ~i u . -. . • ~ Phone Number : ~~ ~ '' ~~ ~ ~ Address: _. Phone Number: CERTIFICATION: (Al1 Applicants Please Read Carefully) I am submitting this application to demonstrate that no solid waste is produced or accumulated in, upon, or from the property identified above. I have had an opportunity to review the applicable sections of this law on the reverse side of this form and I believe that this property can legally be exempted from regular garbage service. In order to assist the City in processing my application, I certify that the following answers are true and correct: 1. Is the house vacant? Yes ~No If yes, on what date did the house become vacant? 2. If vacant, is there a scheduled date when you anticipate the house will be occupied. Yes No Date 3. Is regular mail service provided to this address?~Yes ` No 4. Is food prepared or eaten at this residence? ~Yes No 5. If occupied, how many persons (including children) reside at this address?~__ 6. Do any pets (i.e. dog, etc) reside at this address Yes ~No If yes, list type 7. 8. 9. How is garbage currently disposed of?~AR (-~A (r' E I~ TAi4~EN I N (R~ ~{~'/~' How is landscaping debris disposed of?~SRMC !~'1~l~NEfZ ~S FQ~. M~ ~~4kE3A6E - I / ~"'Y -~o T- E.l~ _-~~u µ? ~Q-L~k~ ~ c~ l.~ = -~ Additional documentation/documents .~ ~'~._.~i_~~(~R,O ~..-l ~ 1~ F~11~~2 E]`I/gT C~~1 T~/~d~c,l~' ~ l~~ Mv~vcy To t~qy FoK ~i~ Grp~,O~~~ f~~Ib ~Ecc~vE' J'1oNEy" Fo~ ?''`/~'~'~r.y~ _, _ . ,. . NOTE YOU:W:ZLL BE CONTACTED TO:SCHEDULE;A PROPERTY INSPECTION: ; ; PRIOR:TO FINAL,.ACT:ION.ON YOUR APPLICATION ~~S ~ ~~t= NC~ 2`fEM S I hereby certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing information is true and correct. 2,~ ~~r- /.2 plicant Signature Date (OFFICE USE ONLY) Date Application Received ~ 13 ~~ Date of Inspection By: Inspector Recam~endation Approve/Disapprove Initial Final Action (Director): Approve/Disapprove 8y: Date Date: Applicant Notified: ~ .....-.,-. , ~`~~2t.~S ~ City of L__~lin (~~~' ~ Address Garbage Exemption Evaluation ~~ 7' 9 Z (To Be Completed By City Staff Upon Inspection) Date of Inspection 1. Is the Property Vacant? If yes, describe all methods used to de[ermine (i.e. conversation, physical ~E~~~V~ inspections, rea~ ~~e signs, etc..) r~nY / 19~ IN 2. Describe general appearance of landscaping. Front Yard M!-~t ~ 1 ~f"l~L''~ Rear Yard ~ ~ 3. Describe location where garbage is kept: Location: l/U/~l7D~S ~ ~Z.~-~~4~.5 - Quanaty: ~ ~~ /N ~~~2.. `tJf'~R.O Type of Containers, if any: ~~~~ ~k- S/J~s77~- 1?~CsS Any detectable odors from waste: /V `~ 4. Is solid waste produced or accumulated in, on, upon, or from the property? yes ~, no ^ 5. Who gave permission to enter the premises? (circle one) Owner or Tenant 6 Who provided the information? (circle one) wner Tenant a. How much garbage is generated? b. How much is disposed of? c. How much is recycled? ~~ /o d. Describe recycling methods: Tit'1C~S ~'~ 'R~ j l~ ~n~'~ 1~+" IC .~~~ ~~~~ d. Where is the garbage taken? v~u5~l-~ ~~~TL caii., ~. e. How is the garbage transported? ~fCK-~~ TZG~ l~ , f. How many times a week is the garbage taken? 2 T~ l°`~ '~t7Z_. ~Lt t'~ i 1~'~ Comments: Inspected by: ~. ~~~'~~} ,DOUfc~J~'ri~ Name of Occupant Praperty Owner if Different I, ,(name) do hereby give this repres ~tive of the City of Dublin permission to enter this property on this day, S - ,~-~ , 1992. Signature ~ ,~ ~'~ ^.~ ~ ' ^~ . ~ , ~. _.. ~: ~<ECEIV~~ AUG ,3 19~2 ~ITY n~ DUQ~IN 7832 Gardel.la Drive Dublin, California 9l1568-1810 510-828-2338 August 1, 1992 City Clerk's Office 100 Civic Center Plaza P.o. Box 2340 Dublin, CA 9~+568 To irno~, It I•iay Concern: This letter is to be considered as an ap~eal to the denial of my Request for Ex_emption from NSandatory Garba~e Service. The action taken (denial of application) should not be approved because: I am complyin~ taith the City of Dublin r4andatory Garbage Service for all intents and ptirposes; I have provided for my own mandatory ~arba~e service on a ttaice weekly piclc-up basis; tiThich is actually a better provision than _T would receive from Livermore/Dublin Disposal. The City of Dublin apparently si~ned a contract r~ith L9.vermore Dublin Disposal (which, being oi~ned by ~~laste Mana~ement Inc., is a monopoly) without even investigating any alternatives sueh as open bidding, reduced rates for seniors and/or lota-income households, bi-monthly sevice, etc. Going F~ith a monopoly without open biddin~ is the same thin~ as sayi.n~ rrAluts" to our Free Enterprise System which I have always been under the impression is the very backbone of our country. Could I be mistaken about this all these years? Or is there some favortism (kickbacks or politics, maybe) bein~ sho~an for iahatever reason that only the City Council is aware of? The residents of Dtiblit~ did not ~et a chance to vote on this selection and even durin~ the so-called "publie hearing" on this raatter, [~~l~en alternatives ~•rere brou~ht up and aslced about by concerned citizens, the.y ~aere told they could not speak, the issue was cl.osed. That's ~overn- ment by democracy? I think not. P4ore 1il;e a minor dictatorship. Even the rec~uirement that no solid waste be produced on the property for ~ranting an exemption is ambiguous, because it is ~ impossible for even unoccupied (by hur~ans) property to not produce some solid w.aste such as in the forui of 4reeds, stray animals, etc. Therefore, I believe that the action taken by the City t~Iana~er's Office should not be approved and my application for exenption should not be denied! ~ (.i° /~GL~-e. (~~~~i2Z~ ~ Tany Marie Clark ~~~ ~~~ ~ ~, CITY OF DUBLIPI APPLxCATION:F'OR EXEMPTIDN FROM MANDATORY GARBAGE SERVICE Property Address: 7832 Gdrdella Drive Dublin, CA 94568 Name of Applicant: Tanya ~1ari e C1 ark Applicant's Address {If Different from Above): 1 FC~ 2 ~ 1992 r`.jTY r,,~ ~~.~~~._4~~ Phone Number: ~10_82g-2~38 Name of Property Owner (If Different from Applicant) Address: Phone Number: CERTIFICATION: (All Applicants Please Read Carefully) I am submitting this application to demonstrate that no solid waste is produced or accumulated in, upon, or from the property identified above. I have had an opportunity to review the applicable sections of this law on the reverse side of this form and I believe that this property can legally be exempted from regular garbage service. In order to assist the City in processing my application, I certify that the following answers are true and correct: 1. Is the house vacant? Yes ~_No If yes, on what date did the house become vacant? 2. :[f vacant, is there a scheduled date when you anticipate the house will be occupied. Yes No Date 3. Is regular mail service provided to this address?_~_Yes No 4. • Is food prepared or eaten at this residence? X Yes No 5. If occupied, how many persons (including children) reside at this address? 2 6. Do any pets (i.e. dog, etc) reside at this address X Yes No If yes, list type 1 toy poodle, 1 Cdt 7. How is garbage currently clisposed of? A CO~lbindti0n of garbac~e disnosal, recvclinq, and sharing a friend's 20 ~allon container on a weekly basis. 8, How is landscaping debris disposed of? Friend'S COmpoSt nile 9. Additional documentation/documents I estimatP th~t it wniilri t~„~_fl^0~'t f9~lr (a~,-- to six (6) weeks to fill one 20 ctallon container wit'h diS~~S~hIP_trath - _ . . . ___ _ NOTE: YOU WTLL BE CONTACTED TO SCHEDULE A PROPERTY INSPECTION `` ;; PRIOR TO::;FINAL ACTION:ON YOUR APPLICATTON I hereby certify under penalty of perjury that the foregoing information is true and correct. ~, ! ,~ , ~.-. J ~ ~~ ~~ 1~~~~"~/,~~~t~ C/CC%'2 %~'.~ Fahriiay^~L~$, lqQ2 - Applican Signature Date (OFFICE USE ONLY) Date Application Received Date of I~spection Inspector Recommendation Approve/Disapprove Initial Final Action (Director): Approve/Disapprove By: Date: • Date By: Applicant Notified: . ,.. „-, r. ~ --~, ,~ ~l~. ~~~Gc:2~~ .,• . City of L _ulin ~,~ ~, ... .., Address ~ Garbage Exemption Evaluation -5 ~ Z-~ z- (To Be Completed By City Staff Upon Inspection) Date of Inspection 1. Is the Property Vacant? If yes, describe all methods used to determine (i.e. conversation, physical inspections, real estate signs, etc..) ~V ~ , ~ O~ ~I;Yl. i~~'" i_7:i1,,y~~.../ry ;''~j' (.,~~,+r ~° ; /~ ~~ ~'t,.'. .:'i;- q~ s,~ ~ Sf~..~.--. , ~''; ~ , _ ;,a..; o i ,,,,; ,,,: ~,~ ;~ 2. Describe general appearance of landscaping. FrontYard j'/~~7ti~r~"7s ~~Y,~ Rear Yard /~~I ~~~'J ~~'? ~ 1.~ ~:2? . 3. Describe location where garbage is kept: L.ocation: S/~I cc (~% ~~~'0~~+;~ Quanaty:~~ . ~ ~ ~-~:~r r ~fFti C /1 eJ Type of Containers, if any: 5~L G~/lv~~ %~ ~-- % ~J l~i i r f~~t ~~ Any detectable odors from waste: ~• ' 4. Is solid waste produced or accumulated in, on, upon, or from the property? yes~ no ^ 5. Who gave permission to enter the premises? (circle or~rr wner o Tenant ~~'~~it~,~.~~ ~-( ~? t L 6 Who provided the information? (circle one Owner Ten n~ /~ ~n~Z~ ,._ ~~ ~r~,~,L- j-r ~._ % ~ a. How much garbage is generated? ~~~I''U~ S~i.l. ~is.tr.t~~J i b. How much is disposed of? ~ CS)''- I~I - c. How much is recycled? V]O (:~ - d. Describe recycling methods: i~~< <.,~.p-~Jr~t t(~-t ~~~~ ~ c'AaJ ~ 1 y~ E~:• ~'~ 1'~'C~ r ~CC~')!'~ri^ y~+,'1_; /~> . d. Where is the garbage taken? e. How is the garbage transported? ~~-~~/~ ~~'~}~r~ l~ f. How many times a week is the garbage taken? ~~-~ c-~~ /Y- ~~ T';~. Commcnts: ~'1.~'~r7/ S /LCO~~ /S ~~i~ ~Q Dc-~=5 .~ic~1 ~~'t;'-C~ ~i't/1! ~.~, rl~.. '~ ~'~ ~~M~ ~~'¢"~~ /'~~- r?.v~,~ ~ f~~.~. in~~7 LU~~Ii: l,V S':'G'c'' < /~~i~'~~ ~~ „ C.~..•/Z-y'Z '~ ~vuiZ 1 !rl~v(y~"i2.. ,(~uri;.cLL Lf'f=r) Inspected by: ~1 ~ ~:~~''~/~u~!2!~~~~ _ Name of Occupant Proper[y Owner if Different I, to enter this property on this day, ,(name) do hereby give this representative of the City of Dublin permission I 1992. Signature July 23, 1992 OFFICE OF THE CITY CLERK 100 Civic Center Plaza P.O. Box 2340 Dublin, CA 94568 Dear Manager: R;~c~~~Ep ~u~ 2 ~ a9sz `~'T Y ~r ~~1~L~N Reference your form letter dated 14 July 92 in which my request for exemption from the mandatory garbage collection law is denied. I hereby appeal the decision for reasons as follows: l. I do not want or need sucti service. I take care of this myself in a legal, timely and sanitary mannE:r. 2. My home is in a trust and is not usually occupied. Maintenance of home and yard is accomplished at least bi-weekly by myself or associates. Any waste is removed and is not allowed to accumulate. 3. The action proposed by the city of Dublin is in violation of MY CIVZL RIGHTS. Since I am responsible for the pay- ment of my debts, I should be the only one to make such obligations. I will. make myself availabl=e to attend a hearing of the appeal at anytime except from 28 Jul}~ 92 to 3 Au~ 92 as I caill be out of town. YOU ARE HEREBY OFFICI~LL1 NOTIFIED OF THE FOLLOWIr:G: 1. No one is auttiorized to make a cor.tract far services for my property except myself. 2. I will not pay for any garbage collection serviczs unless ordered by me. . 3. Legal action will be taken against any person or persons who attempt to record a lien on m}~ property for tne pur- poses of coll.ecting a garbage collection service fee. 4. Livermore/Dublin Disposal and Waste Manager~ent Company is notified not to provide garbage collection servi.ce until I order it. Edward F. Bressinck 11657 Solana Drive Dublin, CA 94568 (510)828-9374 ~~~ IBIT Co .-~ - ' Property Address: fl E~~l "7 ~c~.'l-f~r~ ~J,~.=~..~; Dublin, CA 94568 Name of Applicant: Ct C-U ~ ! _ ~ ~ ~j l/.,~',~`f'~~r~ ~,.,~- . Applicant's Address (If Different from Above): Name of Property Owner (If Different from Applicant) Address: 'r'(~' .l ~i j~~c. ~ '' '' ;,, Phone Number: ~~~~ ;~~5~ ~ crr- ~'2~ 13 J% Phone Number: CERTIFICATION: (Al1 Applicants Please Read Carefully) I am submitting this application to demonstrate that no solid waste is produced or accumulated in, upon, or from the property identified above. I have had an opportunity to review the applicable sections of this law on the reverse side of this form and I believe that this property can legally be exempted from regular garbage service. In order to assist the City in processing my application, I certify that the following answers are true and correct: 1. Is the house vacant? Yes ~o If yes, on what date did the house become vacant? 2. If vacant, is there a scheduled date when you anticipate the house will be occupied. Yes No Date ~ 3. Is regular mail service provided to this address? // Yes No 4. Is food prepared or eaten at this residence? Yes ~No 5. If occupied, how many persons (including children) reside at th is address?_,~ 6. Do any pets (i.e. dog, etc) reside at this address Yes !/No If yes, list type 7. How is garbage currently disposed of? `~-~~~, ~~ j~ ~~~~ ~~ .~~, ~ , ~ • '` , ~ ~ ~`{'~ (~.~ ~ Gl-~~~ ~,-~ ~, G vf.~ How of ten? , 8. How is landscaping debris disposed of? ~~,ti ~~_„Q~,.~J ,~ ~ tC.- J - c -- ~= r ' ~ ~ ` 1 , ~ ~ How ~ of ten' i ~~%~,.,~~ ~ ~`Y 9. Add itional documentation/documents . ~- 9„ ~A t , . --, NOTE: YOU:;WTLL BE CONTACTED TO SCHEDULE:A:PROPERTY.INSPECTION: _ _ _ ;:: `.. PRIOR ;TO FINAL .-ACTION ON YOUR APPT;ICATION ' _~~~~~q~ ~ ~ , ,~ ~~~~~ MAR 1,3 1992~ ~ , _ _ .._____ _._ _ MlTY :C~;~• ~~Jn~.IN _ _ _ ~Q ~~~ '`r~-~. c~, _ _ ^ _ ~.~Q-e~ ~~ ~ ~ - ~ ~ C ~~~~'. ' _ /Y~La~ ~ -C (~ " _ ~~~ _ ~/ .~- ~ I ~b ~ ~ ~i-~I.~-4.~ /~~ / _ Q'---o ----~4~'~~(~G-c-v--v -. ---_. ___ ___ _ .. _ ~ _ _ ~ ~ . _ . _. ~~ _ ^ ~-y~'c--~r' ~ ~~ . . ... ~ ~ ;:~~. ~,~~ _ Q~ ..~.~.- ~ . ~ . . . _~ _ ~, ~: _. d __ ~ . _ ~~ _ _ ~`~`-~- ~ _ . , ~ `~ ~~ _ ~ ~~~ . . r ~ ~~~-a-- . ~ ~ ~ ~~~ ~~ ~~$~ r~~ r ` O rr ~~L.~ J !'G'~ I ~^~'~s'~1%~ ~i$' ." ~ ~ ~ ~~- %l ~ ~ ~~'~--~-e-~-~~ ~ - .~,----- o~~~--~--~-.'~--,_._~ e~----_ ' -, •- ----~- ~~'~ . o~. ~c~~ ~,r-- .--~~,-~-~ '--~~e -~'-~~=-a--~ 2~ .- U ~ . ~~ _ ~'~ ~ ~ ~~e r / C~ 2~ ~ , ~ ~ ~~-- - ~'v~- , ~ ~ ~~.--~ .~-z- `'~~ c~ ~~. ~-,. ~ . cQ ~~~ c,~ ~ Q'~ ~ ~ ,~'1-l1"-~-- r ,aSLc` c ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~~L..1~(.~~ - f ~ ~ G~ . .-~_~~ ~~ ~~-~ ~~ .~- : :~ _~ , . ;~_ . .-~.__. ~~ ~-- z~. ~'iv~-- ~ _ _. ._ ~ ~ . .~ - -~-- r ,~ J ~ A ,~r A 1~~; `y.~- Y d ~ i { i' ~, GtJ..v c~ ~-n.e~- ~~"'1 ~ a~-, ~_~-~-- ~' ro~ ~-~' ~ .~-~_ r/y~°~G ~ ~ h ~1, ~~~~ r~'-~-~----- ~-~'-° ~~'y`~" ' G~~'~J ^ ~ -~~'~ ~~~ ~-- ~° ~ ~ _ _ __ ~~~~-~--~ r ~ . ( .~ ~ ~ _ r _ .. - . ~ ~ -~~p ~~~-~ _ ~' - ~.~ r~ cc~,. ~~---c~~ ~ ^ -• -'~_ .. .. - -' . . . . ~ ..-.. ~I. '" - ------ - ^~--,. , ~~ -~ ~~~ ~z~. ;_ ~ ~~ ~--~~~~ ~ ; ' ~ ~ r . - ~ /1 f~y~ a~ ~j Q ) l~~_c~ v ~ ~ ~ r~ - _... _ _ ~. G~"~~t ~~~- . ~- ~ - ~~.~ ~-~~~ ,- . !~ ~ a- ~~"~~ -~-~ ~ ~~ ~ ;Y r/ r ~~~ ~` - `~~~ ~ ~ ~-_ ~~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~~-- - ~ ~~~ _ ~"~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~- ~ .~~ ~ __ _. - ~`~ . . . ._._._ . _ ----- ___ ------ - -~- _ ~,__._._._.-.-- - " '~ . ~ '.. ~ ~ ~~~„~/,~- i)/; . City of Lablin I,~ ~ Address Garbage Exemption Evaluation - ~~. '~~ ~ (To Be Completed By City Staff Upon Inspection) Date of Inspection 1. Is the Proper[y Vacant? If yes, describe all methods used to determine (i.e. conversation, physical inspections, real estate signs, etc..) !V v 2. Describe general appearance of landscaping. Front Yard l~'I ~~i~ r~ ('`l~ - Rear Yard ~L1~,r~ 1~'1 N~~ 3. Describe location where garbage is kep[: , Location: .~~ ~r-;,.n>/' ~Cr~'- Quantity: I -S i r R-gt?( ~J-'`~:*•'(`` i°'"'s" ~ - Type of Containers, if any Any detectable odors from waste: / V a 4. Is solid waste produced or accumulated in, on, upon, or from the property? ~~ 5. Who gave permission to enter the premises? (circle o e~ Owner~or Tenant ~___- 6 Who provided the information? (circle one) Owner or Tenant yes~no ^ a. How much garbage is generated? ~~ n Y U~L~ b. How much is disposed of? (J~~.. %~--I ~- (~ c. How much is recycled? ~-~ ~'~~~~u•,!~ d. Describe recycling methods: ~~tT'KF"~ ~'~^-~ ~~ ~ ~-b--~-~- /~t~"r ~5 m'~S 5~~~ - d. Where is the garbage taken? I (~ ~ `~ '~~Y /~ Z ~° ~'' `, i i ~ - .s . ~1~~71.~ ~f ~°` e. How is the garbage iransported? I^/~'1C r t~ ~~'~ ~~'/~ f. How many times a week is the garbage tal:en? ~~ +r ~ l~y ~~~~ ~ Comments: f'~U~NF-"~. S'fYt'~':~ /~""~- c~t `l z-> j (~'ZC° ~~ :1r:;~; r'~ ~ il i~! ~;~ `~. -rr ~ ~~rt.~~h~ l~ ,~,~- ~~~~~~-V ~ ~ r ~r~;r ; ~;~ ~ - Inspected by: Name of Occupant Property Owner if Different ~ C~~'~~l ~ to enter this property on this day, - PU. i v ~~' ~.. l l ca r Vac.~ •'~<.~11 cs n 3~I1 ,(name) do hereby give this representative of the Ciry of Du~lin permission , 1992. Signature ~i _,_~~ .% ~~.G~r`-~~ . %' .0' i~ Gi ` `i ~'.. ;, ;,~ ~. ~„ ,~ t~i:~...~,~~~'~.r TO DUBLIN CITY 1~'IAYOR AND COUNCIL PJIEMBERS ;:'; j~' ~~` ~'''~ In regard to hearing about mandatory garbage collectio~•;•~~.r r,~- ~E ,w~ ~~~; in the case of Ed Bressinck. I wish to acquaint you with the information as follows; I fear that there;w~:ll';not ~~ time to state my case or that you will not listen to things you do no~ want to hear. I.'.spoke to as many as twenty five citizens about the the situatiori and they all agreed that for the City to make a contract for service with a private firm for a~.citizen when such service is not required or wanted is clearly a violation of a person°s civil rights. The proposed way of forcing payment for such service is abhorrent and authoritarian. Placing a lien on property and adding tJ~e fee to the taxes is something you might expect from a totalitarian regime . This may be a break because ~taxes _ are -:~~. .', ~: deductible. The argument that the ord~iance:~.s required because some people are disposing of their waste is invalid because there are '~~ laws in effect~against ~~zch practices. Your proposed act~.on punishes everyone and violates their rights because of a few who may well be transients,tourists or homeless people. Hardly anyone in town knows that they cannbt~.canceL~their garbage service even if they want to. The attitude of the people at the disposal service is t~hat they have the pQwer of City Hall to whip citizens into being hostage clients. If this situation gets publicity (which I will try to get) There will be many furious p aople in town. In my case it will be costing me money for which I wil~ receive no'benefit because I will have nothing to collect... It is suggested that the ordinance be rescinded or revised. Requiring persons who do not subscribe to~waste collection service to explain what t~iey do with their waste would be, in my view, no~.objectionable. It is thought that the welfare of the citizens should be considered above all whr~n you have to listen to the clamoring of the special interest groups who want to me~ke a profit. Additional developments shoukl not be considered while we ha~re a severe water shortage and traffic:problems. Sincerely ~~ , ~ ° . f~'~~% ~~'/. --~~ ~~/~'Y~=~7 ':/~-/ ,y ~Edward F. Bressinck D~Z~i~~ins~ a~~~~~ive Tel 828 937~ ~ ~~- , a-~-,-~u-.~r-- n c~~ ~ v t D~ c, I`/ '~- Ul y~~- ~G ~~ . ,~ ~ ~ ~1 U L 2 21992 . ~; N C~- ~.~ 6 g" ~ ~ CITY OF DUBLIN / /1 !~ ~ y~'J~~'L(./~~ I`n J ~ __ ~~~_ n ~ vv __`' ~ v~ / - / _ ~~,-' ~ / ,~~~ ~ 3 ~ 3 ~- _. ,.. v~-~o~-~~ ~ / ~-~ oP ~,,- . ~ i~~~~'% 4 ~.,,~ `~ ~ ~ ~~ ~ ~.~~ ' ~~ . ~ ,~ . ~ ~' ~ ~ ~ ~~ . . ~ ~ Q-i ~ ~ . e L ~~~L:1:/~ V' `", , '~~ ~i ~ OC~ r ~;~~„`'`ti( ~ ~' ' ~- ~~ ;~ , -r , g3J9. -~~- ~ ~ r . ~~~ ~~ , ~~-`- ,~-~-- . ~ - ~-- ` .~-~~ ~~`-~ ~-- _ ~ ` ~. CITY OF DUBLIN ' APPLICATION FOR EXEMPTION FROM MANDATORY GARSAGE SERVICE ~ ~ Property Address: ,~[- ~ ~ .~.2•-~ZC; ~,y2_- Dublin, CA 94568 ~ Name of Applicant :~~~~~ ~ "~, t~ r/~-; ~~~ c~ Applicant's Address (If Different from Above): ~ =~: _ P,~,~~ ~~ ~ s?~'t'~ ~~''~ , ~~ ,~~2 r-•T ~-,~~,~~r Phone Number : ,~,~ ,~~ ~,f .'~ ~' Name of Property Owner {If Different from Applicant) f~, ~1';'~`;~.= Address : `r T_ j ~ b'~ C' F~~ JR ~ Phone Number :_ CERTIFICATION: (All Applicants Please Read CarefuJ.ly) I am submitting this application to demonstrate that no solid waste is produced or accumulated in, upon, or from the property identified above. I have had an opportunity to review the applicable sections of this law on the reverse side of this form and I believe that this property can legally be exempted from regular garbage service. In order to assist the City in processing my application, I certify that the following answers are true and correct: 1. Is the house vacant? Yes ~_No If yes, on what date did the house become vacant? 2. If vacant, is there a scheduled date when you anticipate the house will be occupied. Yes No Date 3. Is regular mail service provided to this address?~_Yes No 4. Is food p~ep~red or eaten at this residence? ~_Yes No 5. If occupied, how many persons (including children) reside at this address? j 6. Do any pets (i.e. dog, etc) reside at this address Yes ^ No If yes, list type 7. How is arba e currentl dis osed of? '' ~ l ~ C' ~^~~,~ ~.C'~"~> .i~ ~ 9 9 Y P %~~ t ~~.L(.« l~T ~~'t c~ ~ c 1 ~ J xow often? J ~/ 1.~~_t~_!L• ~ 8. How is landscaping debris disposed of? ~j',~~~~;~,~,~ How often? 9. Additional documentation/documents _ _. . _ _._ _ . . _ _ ___ _ __ _. __..__..__ . ... _ __ ..... .._ ..... _ _ _ __ ___.. . .._ _.._ _ ..__._ _ _. .... ..... . .__ .......__ ____. __.. . _ _ _ _ _ ... ..... .... .__ .. _ __ . .... __ _.._ .. __ .._ __ _.. .. ... .... .... . .. _ . _ . . .. .. ..___ ._ __. __.. .. _.. .. __ _ .. . .. _ . _ _. _ _....._ __. . __ _. . __ _ _ _ . ._.. ..... . ..__ __. . . .. ._. ....__.... ... iNOTE. `YOU::WIT~L BE`:;:CONTACTED T0;`:SCHEDULE:_:A;:PROPERTY:TNS:PECTTON:...... _ _... _ _ . ,, . __ _ ' ` PRIOR;TO FINAL;ACTION ON;YOUR.APPLTCATION ' I hereby certify.under penalty of perjury that the foregoing information is true and correct. > ~_~~ _~~~~~1,_ _ _5 -~ ~: --y~- Applicant~Signature Date (OFFICE USE ONLY) Date Application Received Inspector Reconmendation Approve/Disapprove Final Action (Director): Approve/Disapprove By: Date of Inspection Initial Date By: Date: Applicant Notified: a: exmpappl , forms ( OVER ) ~~~ 1'~`~C~11~ ~.7' C..: City of L~lin '! ' Address Garbage Exemption Evaluation ~' ~~( Z- (To Be Completed By City Staff Upon Inspection) Date of Inspection 1. Is the Property Vacant? If yes, describe all methods used to determine (i.e. conversation, physical inspections, real estate signs, etc..) ~ ,(,c~ - p?~~J~..~ Y1.J~~ ft'rl ~ ~~c~ 1~_ 1~ot,.,S.~' ~ 2. Describe general appearance of landscaping. Front Yard J~~+ ~~~ ~~ ~"1~ Rear Y 3 Describe location where garbage is kep[: Location: ~~NC'z(~ 1 ~ ~Lc~C.I¢z~ Quantity: ~ ~-~'~~' Type of Containers, if any: ~~n ~(~'.~~." "' S~kC-~- s~2~~- Any detectable odors from waste: lv~ 4. Is solid waste produced or accumulated in, on, upon, or from the property? 5. Who gave permission to enter the premises? (circle one) Owner or Tenant yes ~ no ^ 6 Who provided the informadon? (circle on wner o Tenant a. How much garbage is generated? /~'7(r7" U?~'Lr~. _ b. How much is disposed of? ~'~-( ~ f'~ c. How much is recycled? ~~~~ d. Describe recycling methods: d. Where is the garbage taken? T~ ~-~'f'~~1 J ~"~~~ ~~~ e. How is the garbage transported? f. How many times a week is the garbage taken? 2~~ -~ V~C~t°1~~Y M ~Nr'v'c~M. Comments: C~C-_`~T ,~0~ ~~r=~ ~r17~C f~i~ ~T•~-,~f~`'f~ C!/~N~i'~L'~ " ~ ~~.SGkI- 1 !~ X11 C ~-ft"O '~ ~i"t';~ '~'~ ~: ~, C~~(t ~.~' c~C.,... ~:~."'6~.. J~.r.cF~'l~L'(!., F~/~ 12,~.^r..t~Uc.S Ci~~ ;~ :~ r~,.a•~~ ~/1.l~~ ~a- ~...r-~ (r- - ~ Inspected by: Name of Occupant Property Owner if Different I, to enter this property on this day, ,(name) do hereby give this representative of the Cily of Dublin perrnission 1992. Signature -SAMPLE APPROVAI,- RESOLIITION NO. - 92 A RESOLIITION OF THE CITY COIINCIL OF THE CITY OF DIIBLIN *************** GRANTING AN EREMPTION FROM MANDATORY GARBAGE SERVICE «address» ~iEREAS, the City Council of the City of Dublin adopted Ordinance 2-92, amending the Solid Waste Management Ordinance to provide for Mandatory Garbage collection and procedures for collection of delinquent garbage service bills; and ~iEREAB, the City Council also adopted Administrative Procedures for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service; and WHEREAS, a resident can initiate an exemption from garbage service by completing an application form and submitting it to the City Managers Office; WHEREAB, the City of Dublin Ordinance 2-92 identifies criteria for approval of exemptions; and WHEREAB, after an on-site inspection of the property the City Manager makes a determination to approve or deny the application for exemption; and ~PHEREAS, if the applicant is denied by the City Manager, the applicant can appeal the determination to the City Council; and AHEREAS, the City Council accepts testimony in a public hearing and makes findings on the appeal of the application for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service; and WHEREAB, the City Council conducted a public hearing on August 24, 1992 related to an appeal from a resident at «address» NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Dublin hereby approves the application for exemption from mandatory garbage service for a period of PASSED, APPROVED AAJD ADOPTED this 24th day of August, 1992. AYES: _ NOES: ABSENTs ABSTAIN: ATTEST: City Clerk Mayor ~~~~~~ ~ -SAMPLE DENIAL- RESOLIITION NO. - 92 A RESOLIITION OF THE CITY COUNCYL OF THE CITY OF DIIBLIN ***~*~*****~*~* GRANTING AN EXEMPTION FROM MANDATORY GARBAGE SERVICE «address» WHEREAS, the City Council of the City of Dublin adopted Ordinance 2-92, amending the Solid Waste Management Ordinance to provide for Mandatory Garbage collection and procedures for collection of delinquent garbage service bills; and WHEREAS, the City Council also adopted Administrative Procedures for exemption from Mandatory Garbage Service; and WHEREAB, a resident can initiate an exemption from garbage service by completing an application form and submitting it to the City Managers Office; WHEREAB, the City of Dublin Ordinance 2-92 identifies critexia for approval of exemptions; and WHEREAB, after an on-site inspection of the property the Ci~y Manager makes a determination to approve o~ deny the application for exemption; and WHEREAB, if the applicant is denied by the City Manager, the applicant can appeal the determination to the City Council; and WHEREAS, the City Council accepts testimony in a publgc hearing and makes findings on the appeal of the application for exemp~tion from Mandatory Garbage Service; and WHEREAS, the City Council conducted a public hearing on August 240 1992 related to an appeal from a resident at «add~ess» NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Dublin hereby denies the application for exemption from mandatory garbage service. The applicant shall initiate service within 15 days of this action. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 24th day of August, 1992. AYES: NOES: ABS EN~' : A~STAIN: Mayor ATTEST: Ci~y Clerk ~~~~~~ ~