Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout7.1 SB343 Summerhill Homes GP 5-21-13 SB 343 Senate Bill 343 mandates supplemental materials that have been received by the City Clerk's office that relate to an agenda item after the agenda packets have been distributed to the City Council be available to the public. The attached documents were received in the City Clerk's office after distribution of the May 21 , 2013 City Council meeting agenda packet. Item 7.1 Caroline Soto From: Christopher Liao • Sent: Monday, May 20, 2013 11:13 PM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic "bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise, the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping &dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages" within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Christopher Liao 1 Caroline Soto From: Joanne Wong - - Sent: Monday, May 20, 2013 11:11 PM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic"bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping&dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages" within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Joanne Wong 1 Caroline Soto From: rugved vaidya Sent Monday, May 20, 2013 9:38 PM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise • Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved,this land use conversion will be a classic"bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise, the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years.Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping&dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages"within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students. As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. • Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, rugved vaidya 1 Caroline Soto From: charles tovstein Sent: Monday, May 20, 2013 5:40 AM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned thatit is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic"bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise, the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse,the loss of a shopping &dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages" within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, charles tovstein 1 Caroline Soto From: Susan Miller < _ Sent: Sunday, May 19, 2013 2:12 PM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic"bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping& dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages" within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students. As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Susan Miller • 1 • Caroline Soto From: Timo Ripatti < Sent: Thursday, May 16, 2013 6:16 PM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic "bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise, the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping&dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages"within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Timo Ripatti 1 Caroline Soto From: maged armanuse <. Sent Thursday, May 16, 2013 10:53 AM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic"bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise, the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping &dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages"within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded. The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students. As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, maged armanuse 1 Caroline Soto From: Sanjay Asrani Sent: Thursday, May 16, 2013 7:57 AM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved,this land use conversion will be a classic"bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping&dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages" within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students. As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining,the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Sanjay Asrani 1 Caroline Soto From: David Campomanes Sent: Wednesday, May 15, 2013 7:56 PM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic "bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping& dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages"within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to _a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, David Campomanes 1 Caroline Soto From: Salil Peshave <! Sent Wednesday, May 15, 2013 1:18 PM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic "bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the ' DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse,the loss of a shopping &dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages" within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. • East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Sall! Peshave i • Caroline Soto From: Shuvojit Chowdhury _ Sent: Wednesday, May 15, 2013 10:01 AM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade,and l am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic "bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping&dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages"within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Shuvojit Chowdhury • 1 Caroline Soto From: Joel Grave Sent: Wednesday, May 15, 2013 9:51 AM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. I am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic"bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse,the loss of a shopping&dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages"within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded. The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated • by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students.As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. • Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos.Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? • Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Joel Graves 1 Caroline Soto From: Nathan Hale Sent: Wednesday, May 15, 2013 8:25 AM To: citymgrwebsite; arounddublin @gmail.com Subject: Keep the Dublin Ranch Villages Promise Dear City Councilmember: I do not support any more conversion of commercial projects to residential projects, including the ones proposed by land owners such as John DiManto of San Jose Construction Company and Jim Tong of Charter Properties, in Dublin. am disappointed that Dublin City Hall has opened the door to build more condos at the Promenade, and I am gravely concerned that it is about to do the same thing at the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza. If approved, this land use conversion will be a classic "bait and switch" scheme made possible by Dublin City Hall. For ten years, new East Dublin residents in the tens of thousands have been told that the Promenade would be an upscale shopping destination to rival San Jose's Santana Row. The retail on the DiManto parcel between Dublin Ranch Villages and the Waterford Plaza was supposed to be part of that grand plan. Now that everyone has already bought or rented homes in and around Dublin Ranch Villages based on that promise,the City of Dublin is trying to shoehorn more condos into an area already saturated with high-density housing. The prospect of more high-density condos instead of the upscale shopping center promised to residents could not have come at a worse time. Property values have cratered over the past few years. Scrapping the Promenade and the DiManto commercial project in favor of additional high-density condos beyond the 1,400 units already built as part of the Dublin Ranch Villages will further reduce the value of my home. Even worse, the loss of a shopping &dining district within easy walking distance of thousands of residents will seriously degrade the quality of life that all of us were seeking when we purchased in the Dublin Ranch Villages. It also completely contradicts Dublin's vision of creating "mixed-use walkable villages" within the city and instead condemns Dublin Ranch Villages to be just another high- density residential neighborhood almost entirely dependent on cars, and yet with seriously insufficient parking for those cars. East Dublin schools are already overcrowded.The Dublin Unified School District will likely use the impact fees generated by the new homes to pay off funds borrowed to build Kolb Elementary School instead of creating additional long-term capacity for new students. As a result, students in the already oversubscribed schools in East Dublin could be diverted to a school in West Dublin. Residents living in the Villas and Cottages at Dublin Ranch Villages are so desperate for parking that they have been parking on the dirt patch KB Home wants to rezone for more condos. Will there be enough parking once more residents move into the new KB Home condos? Dublin is a wonderful city to live in, and I trust that you will do what is right for the community. Please maintain a long- term vision for Dublin instead of falling prey to short-sighted planning based on temporary economic conditions. Please vote against the request by Summerhill Homes and John DiManto to initiate a General Plan and Eastern Dublin Specific Plan Amendment Study that no one in the community supports. I urge you to stop Summerhill Homes, KB Home, and Charter Properties from ruining the full glory of the Dublin Ranch Villages that has been promised for a decade. Sincerely, Nathan Hale 1 From Steve Pietsch Sent: Tuesday, May 21, 2013 4:01 PM To: citymgrwebsite Subject: Summerhill Homes request for rezoning study We have recently learned of the proposal to rezone land owned by Dublin Land Company and Summerhill Homes, which is on the agenda for tonight's City Council meeting. While we are unable to attend this evening, we do want to register our disagreement with the changes proposed. We recently moved into our new home in the Sorrento Community at Dublin Ranch, adjacent to the parcels in question. We were attracted by the development plan that called for mixed use residential and commercial, especially neighborhood commercial. Like many of our neighborhoods, we strongly support the vision of a mixed use walkable community here on the east side of Dublin. We are desperately short of small and large shops, restaurants, gas stations, and other amenities and services. With the projects already under construction here, the population in this area is going to continue to boom. We strongly urge the city of Dublin and our elected officials to hold to the original vision for mixed use development, and lower densities to reduce congestion. Dublin will be better off in the long run if this is an attractive, walkable, livable community where people want to live and invest. This is certainly why we chose to move here. Best regards, Steve & Liz Pietsch 1