HomeMy WebLinkAbout4.07 John Woods Claim CITY OF DUBLIN
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: August 22, 1988
SUBJECT Denial of Claim Submitted on the Behalf of John Woods ,
et . al .
EXHIBITS ATTACHED Claim No . 0036DU received July 11 , 1988.
Excerpt from aerial topography map indicating City
limits .
RECOMMENDATION Deny claim and direct Staff to advise the claimant and
the City ' s Insurance Provider .
FINANCIAL STATEMENT: Claim alleges damages in excess of $10, 000 .
DESCRIPTION On July 11 , 1988, the City of Dublin received a claim
submitted on behalf of John Woods , Brenda Woods , Christopher Montano , and
Anthony Woods .
The claim alleges that the damages arose from an accident which occurred
where the Valley Christian Center private driveway intersects Dublin
Boulevard . Representatives of the adjusting firm hired by ABAG PLAN have
reviewed the claim and recommend that the City Council deny the claim. The
location of the alleged loss is not within the City limits. Therefore , the
City of Dublin would not have jurisdiction over the roadway in question.
Staff recommends that the City Council deny the claim and direct Staff to
notify the claimant and the City ' s Insurance provider .
COPIES TO :
ABAG PLAN Corporation
Black & Bland
.. - ..�x.:..<,_nn•�. r.,._....,.....5, .... ...... .,,:w.� ovntr,YCm4r.:<z,a,.aa2w b'.'f.} �-...,. s,�•a:.. s - . .. .., .,. ...,.,..
'Y .•Y:.
'^ RECEIVED . CLAIM RGAINSTTHE ,_-` • I
\ JUL. 111988
CITY OF DUBLIN •
cm, nc nURLIN - 00312-Du •
DATE RECEIVED CLAIM NUMBER
(Office Use Only) (Office Use Only)
Name of Claimant ••• c -••. ...• • ' ••s- ontano, Anthony
2525 Kelly Street Hayward Ca, Woods
� Address of Claimant y y
Telephone Number( ' ) -415 537-3787
Send Notices To: Law Offices of Sidney Sternick
7567 Amador Valley Blvd. Suite 106 Dublin, Ca. 94568 •
Date of Occurrence: May 17. 19AA Time of Occurrence: 1n•15__R.m. •
Place of Occurrence: (Provide detailed diagram describing the exact location,including •
physical landmarks or distinguishing land features,if appropriate) •
A blind intersection at the corners of Qublin Blvd. and Tip `Tlley '
chri Si i an ('enter Private nri veway
Circumstances of Occurrence: (if an accident,describe physical conditions
surrounding occurrence such'es weather,road,and traffic conditions,etc.)
' The weather and road conditions were clear and dry. The traffic was
light.
i
List names, addresses and phone numbers of any witnesses:
MicY,elle Momigne Hewitt 191 Mara Tana, San P men cA
• Linda Coleman 301E Leger Court Pleasanton Ca
Proulde a Description of Damage or to - • • •.- •.....•- • •- • .cle.
' owned by the Woods, and personal injuries to the family.
I
Name and Department of Inuolued City Employee (if any) :
Briefly euplain why you feel the City of Dublin is responsible:
The City of fl, hlin is recponaihle for the cortrell of tho intersection
including the control of traffic in that intersection.
Total Amount Claimed: (Note:Pursuant to State Law any claim for$10,000 or less must •
be specified as described In Government Code Section 910(f). If a dollar amount is not shown
indicate whether Jurisdiction over the claim would rest in municipal or superior court.)- '
Superior Court
Breakdown of Amount Claimed:(if applicable)
Dated; 7—s—SR Signed: • ' .� tc
Sidney Ste nick Attorney for the Woods
Note: A Claim relating to a cause of action for death or for Injury to person or to personal property
or growing of crops shall be presented not later than six(6)months after the cause of action. A claim
relating to any other cause of action shall be presented not later than one(1)year after the accrual of
the cause of action.(Government Code Section 911.2)If the date of occurrence was prior to January 1..
1988,different filing deadlines would apply.
When a claim Is required to be presented not later than six(6)months after the accrual of the cause of
action,Is not presented within such time:a written application may be made to the City Council for
leave to present such claim. The application shall be presented within a reasonable time not to exceed
one(1)year after the accrual of the cause of action and shall state the reason for the delay In
presenting the claim. The proposed claim shall be attached to the application.
.
.5) r) .• % ' ' -‘1"(..:41:1.;.i !ra.' V.•••PI/ '..n.i.';:".' ) '' i i 4:-.;i:•i i(,/.4•;,f ,•,
I ; • ' ,'. ;. ::.":4!:::::.!,:fil.,,,,.. , 4.4:igligt,:i ..., 4,...44,,N,.4k,Aln,..\**...,..01%,,,..,.0jf.;45 §litti/144'..?•;:-.01!,1 Lk. II
,r, IC .• Ali lilt/.
I . .4 x i'? s' ',Ar:, ' ?.,..:,_1:_n'-_'-.:=,,;-;:,.t. * •;:frel-`--4,/.,-.-•"6"',03-1", . ,,Z#,te,x 4 ri :f i`,/,:;! !'M.. 1 44'1 Iriif44:'
%frun' -721144-.0Z.:147,,, ):4://: ffitii;:ft.ii s !.tv' *• ",.; f . /-4548.,4 .. i,
i /
14-.'„.. -i --..: '.."--: .2:,;:u.:4--w.i..1,11......, ' "..i,- .-)i!;;;;,:,::ii. .,47'-:„ 1;.4'',..:14":1,.-
10 5,4:±3,•$.7-...---3-- , r, '._,..,."51: 1,1‘'.,456,,,rer',,,Ii;e”:2;..i.ii,e.:T.„....::::....z,,col ,.; ,;4$ qtcli,...,•-,, ,:i 0, /xiff,il."4,:•„...s.i.:
[
... ...) i If ././.. • „;,;.,....„
i - I), L ,. ..,.r,•,- -ii .I-1;44.1.. -- „,••,: . 461._:p tl.. ...-.1. ,,,---., '
Ale g ''''t.s." 0. "tv.,..".7 'f -r'''' If T 14-.- V■6'41740 i-ll s i-' rop,a''' . .,.-.J.Vy/ ,A Y. _YkAiii,,'4.,:,.
F - i , .. 4 "..' r,r"*If ''.. ;'•1 *I'lr,ii. [:1'""41 kiA,e,*... ./: VC':`.3It'. -7:,.,t r,4f.t...eelt■-"..... J /,r,r ivy,-. ..-....7, -,..,.
.L '-8•41' Il/f. 1 •J-..:. '4;4`VA.S -':'`t: '14"'- 4*•" 1t0i.*:;,-i't-!`:` ',4.1: •%1_44-;:44.1.1V,_.):5-r...20,(/ 1/,..ffr.,e.-4.,,,,--c I ii....
kl
f,'•i f -!1/ il Z:,,ze 44, ,% •11C,4/ - i '-..-,... AklYd.k.'N''t'cA ,-1',....i it.". :X1'44; ": ,i,"/,4" 2 ' j- ''.'fIT -,!/?i2!
Zi 1 )/47'... .: ,./ Kir L..... . --' „,d .1„: .....,..,ittatf? ', ',...:.::-.:. -`..:?:: ';‘,V.-..1.v,V.I.,C:-..-..i...-"..z... - ,i`j- e,• ., - ,,,,,:!'4:,..,:4,-,:!,
i
1 ,4/. - • 4 Ykt. ‘ '4f4•''''" v '1174*41;351 '. \---;::!.1...;.:',71`: '-'.•-7-e--;'-ir.:."...•,-,....":70:0.,fr 1." Alt.' ''', fr' .I .e..15,L, '4.'..
. I .1 f 1 .'-: \'` ,17:M , ......__
.L1).01,i•r: " - 't \\\k\:?.\\acYr5:
t
_ _ „. - . ,k• iv. t i ,.--‘--,i:
;,,t
'-1-1,s1:'7 o'4. •-.4" ‘,•
it , ,7: •/,, 21;4 . fil NA , ,... ..;
4.0-,
. 1---4t-,
rn --i , ...-
‘A .74 ,„‘t%,1 V.4‘\r ?ei.
i ku ,,z,.,..,,,,, k! .. vi 1,-- i.„w N(r,....7 2;
. 2) 5 -... 0.C. e. •
\\\‘'N,_ 't, t\ $44 ‘;;,•-••-- ' . '-j:: - i 11 • ',1- .. ) ... . ;;;A• ,,
rig" '--,;titi,: i eV 11
i ; ..
..- k, ..!,7>.,44,.8b,,,t\t‘ N \A, 44 Vilro‘31,tiA V;11.-4 - • 0.' . q
i i -- „,..- i i .
4 1
.. -:ti16'44`:\ I\\,Itll' N$:;. \-1,-,:t:::::-:::.;-...;,...,-.; .... fez----.0 ,..„\--; -,--------22---z-_..., .:. .._-, .-----A,A\r\--,:
I 1,-coA ILA' , i lop ilito\i, t :--.=.-, „. -
\
”' -
Vf:*1164'' /1417/,/ ''cal- 17.......:--7-
1 reVutillr-L4.-4114.' ' 4't,k.3104, tok)......v..;:-.-A..■...."-; --.14. : ..,...- - .4.:Ii. ,x ,...7),..r:4
pi!, , ,•,,Y . ."\.,,_.. ./. • -
.1 10 s - .2.• ;. l' r -,,k0A4, p ,4,.. 1.------7.„ :""'''' '
-T-., -.. . zp- .".r; l /-------,-------,---:\.„I. •iiip...•
,l,,.,:s,itc -4., _ r • %. LI,' 0,14.1:44,4,. ..
‘\ '-':11,A .•*3 .- 1 1, '---e& ,':NI te-Wr:. .4 71.
'14...-,:•, 41.-- %••• `^i.:re.;
TAZ:14 .,t4's 1.,..;cl.".-,:...:<01.1:Afel■ .., .›..,c.-...; Wt.gt,\*....-.;
fkivap.'''' l4 -' '; ---1-,1--41.-- s.----#1.)
..... .,.....„ :: :,... JP..• •,;\\„..r.„ . 'I
:• ,,,
' ;' „, .. ..;(11T-i'ci41-1:4&*-,=t-o” .f..- .
k.. . ,.. --0•;:k 'ie,;,--'
• '"'‘ 6'0 Y .- '•
' " ,••11•{Vt,:•-_,. . , .1/4. ,'Pr - ;AI 14- -, -
Ilk l' k P-4 1 1 tl.."': ;:-.4 - ,--zas, :\„‘-,1. : ---.714-if-,-.-----.1-. -- ,-. .,,e
,, •
/ -`• • . -.' ,,......----• ,
4,11. ' •••1. '_• . ''"A"..1.14:-N '
' 'e 6,..ii.N.)1:-,4 q - 4 ------`------A-N,-71 .,..r,-; -,-A"--7tit'.' 1 jl, •:**, --'-1,.4'.2. .' ."- -. -'.-,-..,,,,of ..-
... -i, ....." r 1 k ../•■:.'-''-,,,I.,..+ 1 1:41klIC•liz-1... . ::,1; - ft••• 'N)$ i ' ,,jili ....$.T•..,..',- ;*• - - -4''-46 4 v.!'1
.1%i.•.kk.. .' :( Paert;:t14-:Vil rit-Tigi .. ,4,:-;.■ )I,Y./ •.;•-e4.- • -.:.--s_e- : . *, % 1...!,
/
. ...k .-
-:14 Ie'? , • , v2, '--, % VA -. at4>'•fn---''..1■Zi.... Pr* i. ". .1=•ttWl , il" • ''•-•-•- .-• s 7
: t ''■,` -: ' --.. •••••......t' A:;s\e,4 ..kwe'...".1,. t. ,44 ,e,dirt, -i.„,..;:l' • ,...tis.i _ • . • . ••c;'Jr itt,;1
I ,,',-, A. ,,i .-4...",.t_Ali •y, '• ,.410saa.,., 1 1•) --, 1 - i-..; .:. . - , . - - - .o,
tA
1 ' ior. ai i v 1; :. ")' -. kt.. 'P4
, ;-4 ).. •r i.A.Ate,.. siir, 54....,_,riao; „ ,-‘,.-} 4 9 v/la,k4_„L.3.1, Ot,,*0.- 7-".j'.:=':- ."' ' '.1--;:,.4 ';q;,.4
.,, • '1:.0-1.'4111,:t.•7 rfr •. .. ,I.e.,17 ' ',1?V.4y. - r Oa' 4 „. ,,,,,i W.,.,r.:',-`..-....-•, : ' . 1,04,4:\ ..t. *
11$- . li . V` -*- 4:. • ' '1,c 6' '''''t'sW.-- • • ■:**3-2Z ' . '''', .S.-,,i ..' '::'.?;:"..'',.1:-1-4:-:'- . 'ii
.v.,!Fig fi(esia5A1.:„.1 , .f.". .„,.. .-,,,,,, --, . i 1 . . 4.1:,v . .. ....-?....-;.„,...1.i4.-••,.:,.s.-.., - ...- s\ -.-
It,- ' - ..,-1 -% • ' ' ,r,"---,.., 1.... Pmi.'--t. ' 7 1-''' -4. ''..-:4 :,-.1.,....,.. -.,;...-.4 • - •-.
it, if''°•=" ..,,ki.(LW': ep,i'jli‘ „ .',J.'...,47. i. ' . \ `
4 ■ ‘:.:44,,‘47..... ., . ,, • ,' '''7 A.g./ 4:0- *,t1;-,r1 '.V 2gra b' ‘....-■'•• ...t!'''..j.i...Vre'' .: . .: , .I "N
c-....„: ..._ ,,,,:„ • ..„,.„....--. • „„ ,,,,,,,,_,....:-?„ . ..._ ,lej .f...,...,..___:, .. ..:_,.,-,1.4,L,-..-: 0.,„a„op.,: :.:,,_ 4.,%•.:-.
..; ,•• 7 ..- itN-.'" 4- '•17,......-d-7 ..,"'....."----=-:\::. •-- '„.ca,-to... . a- ...i.';'.4r A tr. ,
,I 1.3 ,t ,,_ ,.-' ...,..,„ ,.--, .....,...... . . . ,/„.1.-ii ... .nt A - k zwr...-7-1 ‘• ".' 1.9.4•-?` . 4.sup'rekirlZ..:*; '
,...,
:
xl—,:: ,...A.-. ;'- .,...',C.`'''.i•-..,—.41 ' " :,,,A1 St ' I., t*il tif,44 44'4$',,-A--ku -•••
t
)
I. ' • ,,,,,,,4,4.,.. 1.4.....40.*.r,Z,„„i* .2"7:. 114Z•vss.,
W.. • *.ia$, ....„,..f- ...Ay ;.• r> ,_ ' -4-,-., 'N ry"" 13-%,,, ,-;•4 .• . p'\ t. . ,, 1:— -
,,.
,.. 1;';'. .4 -, er*•t- ' -
EPARED FOR GROUND CONTROL. BY
I 0 PR
i D
Z IT1 _.1
-I ii ■
7 5-; CITY OF SANTINA &
INC'
C3 THOMPSO_ N
0 71 DUBLIN 1
411!le'
N 0 0
.At 0 C
1 LEI
XI p
I .
= '..... '
)
.< Z
1040 Oak Grove Road. Concord, California 9
L DUBLIN CALIFORNIA
C
...))■i;,- — -
- .
. j. .. .. . --
,-, ' C 1..
--- --.—, : 7 .:--. 7.7.4.-3;I::::-4/-2”-:7:1,.. t..'-'•'-'' '
-7.1.■,",** 'ritt.-:',:•-:1-.A.4-:-:.7 7•''!""-■:". .16'..%::'7■1 . '.;„I • !,..i.... _ •I ...___:, ..• • • -
• . •1 • '
.•-•....• ...