Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 4.2 PG&E Claim CITY OF DUBLIN ( � o _( o AGENDA STATEMENT CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: July 22 , 19$5 SUBJECT Claim for Damages by Pacific Gas and Electric Company EXHIBITS ATTACHED Claim for Damages Submitted by Pacific Gas and Electric RECOMMENDATION Deny the claim and refer the matter to the Insurance carrier. FINANCIAL STATEMENT: Original claim submitted by Richard Leon Duncan, et al., was in excess of $7.6 million. DESCRIPTION On July 9, 1984, the City Council denied a claim for wrongful death submitted by Mr. Leon Duncan, et al . The claim has been forwarded to the insurance carrier, Continental Insurance Company. Mr . Brian J . Morris of the firm of Alton M. Chambliss is the attorney representing the City subject to the terms and provisions of the City' s insurance policy . Mr. Morris has filed a cross complaint in the matter which names among others Pacific Gas and Electric Company as a cross- , defendent . In essence this action will allow the courts to determine whether the cross-defendents are obligated to assume any fault or legal responsibility for any liabilities , damages , or judgements resulting from this claim. Pacific Gas and Electric has in turn filed a claim against the City of Dublin. Staff recommends that the City Council deny the claim and refer the matter to the City ' s Insurance carrier. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- COPIES TO : Ben Fernandez , Insurance Broker Br n Mo is La Offices of ITEM NO . pC� lton iamblis�s PG&E - c/o Mari C . Snyder CLAIM FOR DAMAGES TO: CITY OF DUBLIN FROM: PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY Claimant above named presents this claim to the City of Dublin pursuant to Government Code section 910 , et seq. (1) The name and address of the claimant is: Pacific Gas and Electric Company 77 Beale Street San Francisco, CA 94106 (2) The name and address to which claimant desires notice .of this claim to be sent is: MARI C. SNYDER Attorney at Law P.O. Box 7442 San Francisco, CA 94120 (3) The date, place and other circumstances of the occurrence or transaction which give rise to this claim are: As set forth in the attached cross-complaint and complaint which is attached as Exhibit A, and incorporated herein by reference. The attached cross-complaint was served on Pacific Gas and Electric Company on May 13 , 1985 . (4) A general description of the indebtedness , obligation, injury, damage or loss incurred so far as it may be known at- the time of this claim is: As set forth in Exhibit A, attached hereto. (5) The name or names of the public employee or employees causing the injury, damage or loss is not known to claimant at this time. (6) The amount claimed is as set forth in Exhibit A attached hereto. Dated: June 11 , 1985 . PAMELA C. CHRISTENSEN, Attorney for PACIFIC GAS AND ELECTRIC COMPANY 1 BRIAN J. MORRIS, ESQ. C►�J�C.r�,sr•il LAW OFFICES OF ALTON M. CHAMBLISS 2 100 Pine Street, Suite 950 San Francisco, California 94111 MAY ^3 1985 3 Telephone: (415) 576-8.280 4 Attorneys for Cross-Complainant, RENE C. DAVIDSON CITY OF DUBLIN BY: Pat Claf4 Deputy only Clerl� 5 6 7 8 SUPERIOR COURT OF CALIFORNIA - COUNTY OF ALAMEDA I 9 RICHARD LEON DUNCAN, et al. , 10 NO. H-101850-1 rn ; Plaintiffs, a 11 CROSS-COMPLAINT FOR APPORTION- W d V. KENT OF FAULT, CONTRIBUTION, o m 12 _ INDEMNIFICATION, AND DECLARATORY a m ADAM GREGORY MARE, et al. , RELIEF 13 U � U n Nn Defendants. U 14 / O a E� 0 15 CITY OF DUBLIN, a Municipal Corporation, 16 Cross-Complainant, 17 V. 18 `- COUNTY OF ALAMEDA, PACIFIC GAS AND . 19 ELECTRIC COMPANY, ADAM GREGORY HARE, EMILY JOAN DESCOVICH, ROES I through 20 XXX, inclusive, 21 Cross-Defendant's. 22 Cross-Complainant al].cyes: 23 1. The true names and capacities, whether individual, corporate, associate or 24 otherwise of cross-defendants ROL I through XXX, inclusive, and each of tl101i), are 25 unknown to cross-complainant, who therefore sues said cross-defendants, aild each 26 of them, by such fictitious names; cross-complainant is informed and believes EXHIBIT "A" 1 and thereon alleges that each of the cross-defendants, designated as ROE, is 2 responsible in some manner for the events and happenings referred to and proxi- 3 mately caused damages thereby to cross-complainant as herein alleged. Cross- ' 4 Complainant asks leave of the court to amend this Cross-Complaint when the true 5 names and capacities have been ascertained, ti insert the same, herein. 6 2. Cross-ComplainanL- is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, taint at 7 all times herein mentioned, cross-defendants, and each of them, were the agents, 8 employees and servants of the remaining cross-defendants, and were at all times 9 herein mentioned acting within the purpose and scope of such agency, employment or 10 contract. o ° 11 3. Cross-Complainant, City of Dublin, is a municipal corporation. �JI �- 0 0 12 4. At all times, herein mentioned, cross-defendants County of Alameda, first U w 13 ROE, second ROE, third ROE, and fourth ROE, maintained, owned, serviced, con- 13 installed, located, placed, and annexed to �i N N in �� � 14 trolled, leased, rented, operated, ns , , u a H $ 15 county street lighting service area certain street lights on what is now Down as N 16 Amarillo Drive in the City of Dublin, County of Alameda, State of California. 17 5. On or about August 17, 1982, the Board of Supervisors of the County of 18 Alameda annexed the City of Dublin to Alameda County Service Area SL-1970-1 for 19 provision of safety street lighting to the City of Dublin by said County Service 20 Area and, therefore, the County of Alameda continued to exercise ownership and 21 control. of the street lights referred to in plaintiffs' Complaint, which were 22 initially installed and placed by the County of Alameda prior to the incorporation 23 of the City of Dublin. 24 G. At all times, herein mentioned, cross-defendants Pacific Gas and Electric 25 Company (hereinafter, "PG&E") , fifth ROE, sixth ROE, seventh ROE and eighth ROE, 26 -2- 1 designed, owned, constructed, serviced, maintained, leased, placed, repLic-1, 2 located, and/or suppliod said street lights at the above location. 3 7. At all times, herein mentioned, cross-defendants Gregory Adaw IlilIL11 4 ROE, tenth ROE, eleventh ROE, and twelfth ROE, were the owners and operatoj:s of a 5 1968 Oldsmobile Cutl�iJJ auLowobile, Calilorllia License No. 1f�Jl'"102, operat:u:i a��kl controlled on Amarillo Drive in the City of Dublin, County of Alameda, SLZILe of. con 6 7 California, on or about January 31, 1983, at the time and place alleged in 8 plaintiffs' Complaint. ntior,ed, cress-defendants Emily Joan >aoscov:i.ull, 9 8. At all times, herein me 10 thirteenth ROE, fourteenth ROE, fifteenth ROE, and sixteenth ROE, were stmidinR o 11 next to a parked vehicle on Amarillo Drive, at the above-described location, with W c 0 12 the door of said vehicle open towards the travelled portion of said highway and Wit~ n lW ion and hazard to vehicles' on said highway alul as more i 13 thereby creating an obstruct a C In " "- 14 fully set forth below. W in 0 plaintiffs, Richard Leon Duncan, Mark $ 15 9. On or about September 10, 1984, p chael Paul Duncan, David Milton Duncan, and Bonnie Marie noncan, 16 Richard Duncan, Mi 17 filed a Complaint for wrongful death, for the death of Ilse Marie Duncan, which. 18 occurred on April 16, 1988, arising out of an accident which occurred on Amarillo 19 Drive in the City of Dublin, County of Alameda, State of California, on 20 January 31, 1983. A copy of plaintiffs' Complaint and the claim attached, tllereLo, 21 is marked as Exhibit "A," and attached, hereto. Without admitting any of the 22 allegations contained, therein, said allegations are incorporated by reference ' S 23 though fully set forth, Herein, in full. 24 10. If cross-colgplaillant: is held liable to plaintiffs, herein, or to any other 25 party to this action, said liability is and will be the proximate result of the 26 llegligellce and/or fault Oil the part of the cross-defendants County of Alaujoda and 27 ROES I through IV, illclusive, and each of them, in t1le maintenance, -3- I ownership, annexation, installation, operation, lease, rental, service, cti:;L-ody, 2 control placement and/or location of the street lights which plaintiffs ;iliege 3 provided inadequate illumination on Amarillo Drive in the City of Dublin, County 4 of Alameda, State of cal.ifornia, at the t Zme and place of an accident illvc>:I.vill(J 5 plaintiffs' decedent, Ilse Marie Duncan, and as more fully described in plaid- 6 tiffs' Complaint. 7 11. If cross-complainant is hold liabje to plaintiffs, herein, said 1.iabiliLy 8 is and will be the proximate result of the negligence and/or fault of crop;>;- 9 adefendants PG&E and ROSS V through VIII, inclusive, and each of them, with respect 10 to the ownership, design, construction, maintenance, service, supply, placement, n - �t and/or location of the street lights which plaintiffs allege: Providec�.1 11 .reylace,�eu of Alaill d 12 inadequate illumination on Amarillo Drive in the City-of:Dublin, County w r plaintiffs' CuiuplainL State of C % alifornia, at the time and location referred to in p n 13 W V r a n 14 12. If cross-complainant is held liable to plaintiffs, herein, or to 011Y r v p LL � S � 15 other party to this action, then said liability will be the proximate result o V) 16 the negligence and carelessness of cross-defendants Adam Gregory Flare and IDOLS 17 IX through XII, inclusive, and each of them, in the operation, maintenance, 18 service, ownership, control, repair and/or entrustment of a 1968 Oldsmob.i.lu 19 Cutlass automobile, California License No. 1DJP202, which was operated on 20 Amarillo Drive in the city of Dublin, County of Alameda, State of Califor,i:i.a, at 21 the time of the accident iirvolving plaintiffs' decedent, Ilse Marie Duncan. 22 13. If cruss-cuml)l:iiliai1L is hold liable to plaintiffs, herein, or to any otliei- p y is and will be the proximate result of party to this action, then said liability 24 the negligence and/or faulL of cross-defendants Emily Joan Descovich and k0l.'s 25 XIII through XVI, inclusive, and each of them, while standing on Amarillo nrive, ' 26 next to a parked vehicle, with the door of said vehicle open towards the -4- , 1 travelled portion of the highway thereby, among other things, creating a hazard 2 and obstruction to vehicles on the roadway. 3 14. An actual justicible controversy-exists between cross-complainant and • 4 cross-defendants, and eacl, of them, in that cross-complainant contends thaL- cross- 5 defendants -are obligated to indemnify cross-complainant from that portion of 6 liability, damage or judgment in favor of plaintiffs, herein, which corresponds' 1 to the proportion of cross-defendants' fault or legal responsibility for said 8 liabilities, damages or judgments. 9 15. Cross-Defendants, and each of them, dispute and denies these allegations. 10 16. This cause of action is based on the California Supreme Court decisions r1n y 11 in Li V. Yellow Cab 13 Cal.3d 804 (1975) and American Motorcycle Association v. w W ' �! ! 0 0 12 Superior Court 20 Ca1.3d 578 (1978) . w o _ ,. U oln 13 WHEREFORE, cross-complainant prays as follows: N '-" W 14 A. In the event that plaintiffs recover judgments against cross-comPlzlinant oar H $ � 15 for a judgment declaring that cross-complainant is entitled to a determination of a 16 the degree of fault, negligence, or responsibility attributed to each defendant, . 17 and for judgment allocating the percentage to be assessed against each defendant 18 and cross-defendant. 19 B. For judgment declaring that portion of costs, expenses and attorney's fees 20 to which cross-complainant is entitled fro►u cross-defendants, and each of them. 21 C. For such other and further relief as may be met and proper in the premises. 22 DATLD Ma _l., 1'�ti LAW O' ' CES OF ALTON LCIAM�ILISS 23 _2a By 1�"� B an J. Morr 25 A torneys fo oss-Complainant, CITY OF DUBLI 26 -5- I kIARTIN W. flrl5I.37.TAj ESQ- _. DAVID Y. ;VnNI;, l:�7. ;,._ l 2 13AS14Z'i A U D N. 172`,3 3 Ilaywn':d Air PlAz4r £ulta -1 110 � ' 7. � 2:C93 HZN00rian 13.)wevar%3 114Ywird. CA 9 t:i•11 4 (413) 837-2131 '. . :..':'.'!, ;' 1:... 5 11ttorney3 for t'1<<Il�titfy 7 8 SUP1:ItI4n COUAT 0? CAL11-FORNIA, COUNTY OF ALAMED'► 9 RICHARD LEON DuNrAN, 10 IMARK RI(71•1.9.:.1i) DUVCAN1 !�1I�:11AJiG [CAUL DUNCANI pAVID NMILTOIN DUN AN- C1 anct 11 I30"I'1It: MA 31F. D1114rAM? too COMPLAINT FOP. `V 11ONr7UL 13 -vs- DRATH 14 p7;11! IRF.GORY HARE, CrrV` OF 15 OUBLIN, and DOES I through : XX? lncluaivy, 10 Aaf�ndanta. / . 17 t8 CnNIFS NOW plAintiffs and 41114$6 as f"DRO N 10 F11= CAUSZ OP A=ON 20 1. 'i'h: trvc nnmas and/or capacltlsa, whothcr Individual, cor poratc, 21 as3ociato or otllor-NI of defcn�lants sued herein as DOES I through XXX a'c un.ciotivn 22 to plairltlr.ra, who thercf..)re sua 3:)Id ecfandants by such 11,4t10143 naMcs. ?]rzlMIM :3 are 1:►formed tind and Upon such Information and tx1lef, pUoga•thot each of 2a the herein as a Dart Iz nRgliBently reupati3lble In a r-z munrrc:r 25 i for t'.lv cevant:► alvi hn"onivip bo.-oll ra+arred to, and no(li,7nntly aa1:304 11 11`7 and 26 I)ANik{•S •1- 0KNLYS AT LAW s)vonl Au 1`1414 J1 Ilffyfflrn 01J, $Vif1 100 .. .rl.Cahlurna 94341 EMI 151 6 "A" 111710111•JI)1 a I the dooth of (!0codert 1111u prnXlmate cnu:scd c'amfigen therehy to plalntlt": 2 allegdcl. Plnintlffs Prulr I:nvc to am and this complaint whan the true a",dlor 3 cnpltc:ltlr� of th}� d�)fanciuntu sea herein as'.DnLS I through `CX`C are jj.�r.cr:a(ned, 4 2. At hI1 tiliios herein mentlonod, each of the defondants tires the a;opt 6 of 011th of the rn:i11i1:11n% cierandnnta, (%j,d at all ttjnea acting tivithln V10 P"rPose t�f 6 auld c; ' ncy And/er amnloyrile"t, and.oath of the defendants has ratified and npprova,! 7 th m defendant:;. e pc 8 g. At the time of tl'9 Rvanta described herein, and prior thereto until 8 January 31, 1983, the decadent, ILS3 MARIA UUNCAN, was an adult person in good 10 mental and phy3icn1 Condition:. 11 4. Z•l;ot oil or about JunuHry 31, 1983, on A-marillo Drive, i� the City 12 of Dublin, Cotmty of Alumvda, datsndant ADAM GREQROY HARE, so c4rele.wly and 13 re li aptly entrusted, manaKed, controAod p*malntained,.operutod, sarviead, ant'. required R 3 - 14 leis 18:13 Oletj3•nab1la Cutl:tw, California ilcanjae number 1DJP 20« so as to laroxlmntc ly 15 c:lu:tc it to collide wit:: the dvcodaat, 1L3F 41AAlA DUNCAN. . 16 5. As a diroct and proximate result of the ne$ilae11t cortiduet of ttty 17 defendants, and each of them, the decadent, II.88 MARIA pUNCAN, sufferuri s4r outs 18 and dehllitTtting lnlurie:� in said accident arid, as an additional direct and Proximate a.� % 19 •, result nf the nogligjant conduct of the defendants, and each of them, the clacedent 20 died on Apr11 113, 1-184. 21 G. As it Fro:iirnzts result of the said negligence of the defandant', rind 22 each of tl:rm, the cfeced>ant, IL3r MARIA AUyt:A*i, sustulnod personal injuries, all 23 of 1•+hleh syld 1nJi:ris, c.:lust�d the dooadant And piaintSfta great msntNl uslri phyoic�i 2.1 pniti and suff:rin(t up 11") donider.11a depth vn April 13, IU4, 25 a 7. A* :c furthl)tr pr„xirnata eeauli n! the s31d naglSntat eono:jet c►f t::►' 26 l,�intlffa wero requirat! to amlc)y j?hyriailjn3 and cPfan�i:ant:;, )tnri Inc!: of t'�Nm, P ' ;Ia7.i-� 1 gA�1�4S —«- 1'Tt)ItVI'YS AT (.Aµ II+yMrJ Au 1`I114 WV) Ilropcnon UIaJ suet IM weij.C+M(vrnr.Ol)11 (11)1 11111J1 I survooiw to examinee Vent and care .tor the discsWent, U.sF %TARIA IMINCAN, an 2 1"id,lnour modivul anti 1rsQldantal exfmnz(:3 up until the doct�'.ant'3 duatl) all April IC 3 a 8. As a further proximato result of tha said nogll Oat cran,Juat 5 defandants, and cwh of them, the decedent II.►3 MARIA AUNCAN 1•:nv) prcwnta� 6 from 'uttonding to her usual oeeu.04tiOn up until her death on April 16, �W-1 7 9. As n further proximato result of the said negligent ean<!k)at 4i till 8 dvfandants, and $itch of them, the daeadent, IL53 HARM DUNCAN, dli�d on Apr! 9 161 1984, requiring plalntlffs to Incur funeral and burial oxponsaa for th•3 decedent 10 10. As s direct -and proximato result of the nogllgent conduct of the 11 derundatlt, and ottclt of them, plaintiffs have been deprived of the cohablts tlon, care 12 guicsnae, ydraiety, comtart, 60"Iass, protectlon and support of the doar..dent? IIZI, 13 MARIA DUNCAN. 14 WI11'.:i�P0:1;s, p141ntlt3's pray for Juc:,gmunt as Jtcrelnattar set trot; be o•n• 15 SECOND CAUSR OF ACTION 16 I1. FiAint3f4,3 incorporate by oatarcnoa A4 though tally sRt 'lorth hcreit� 17 at lon;�th all the sllvltationm contained In the first cause of cation, Pjmy;aphs. l 18 through 10. 1s ` 1M. PI3intiffs alinge that the City of Dahlia was and is a city duly 20 organized and e:tjstlnj under and pur ant to the 14wg of the state of California. 21 13. On June 27, 1?84, plaintiffs RICIIARD Lj!OLS DUNCAN, 50NNI 22 MARLS DUNCAN'? a snivor, through her Guardian ad Lltnm RICHARD LEON PUHCAN; 23 tAt:X Rli HAR1) 1)UNCAN; MICHAEL PAUL: DUNCAN] and DAVID <<IILTO`( 24 n�?1•'c;.�y, duty pt-wi-ontod a aLalm for the wrongful death of ILSE MARIA 1)L'XC'AAi 25 that is flip, brt*13 of tills complaint to the City of DUMn. J cc�,y r,1' th^t ciwi+n, :6 )5l'rA � Q.�MIF.1.5 [0KNBY3 Ar t.Aw .Itywo(d Air rim OV)Ilrry.ri.o Ulyd. $vd. 16Q WON.CNdurni.91711 " 1.171 117..!I J I �. ,; ;r.l� �a J�rlc�:ir � •1 J:�•1•c'�;r ianor�cntrL'. ir. tlii., ,' rr..pl�l:�'. 1 •ilat•1<nrJ l?';lilhlt �\", ( Itttt �. , ,� 2 �ni c.ai;" wilt; ;•.,j��o+::ci In It's vnto1rct! L•y t;t4 D,I:tlln City Council cn •7;,'.;i fJ, 10° 3 ll. At P-11 t1;:+uK har:ln r.:nlltionvd, tho vicinity in and nroun,l Arinrlllo 4 Drive was puh14O property within o3 juris�ilaUOn of the City of T;ublln. 5 I�� A; in.ntlanc•l, dr.lslt�Ja;lt City of 6 o er+it d� n1aintxined, congtruc.tacl, dozlor d, inapectcd and controlled Amrlrlllo Dr V, P Including but not 1lmlted to atrcat 113hting;. Plaintltiz ar3 informed and tl�•lll�vl�, :I+ui a upon ouch iztormation and 1xilof ausgs that the City Of publin did neglirpmtly and 9 raal(l#)ssly ow,11 Oporatu, inaintaitl, construct, doyt%n, insPact, and control valet Amarillo 10 T:rly©, inclur+ing but not llmlted: o strcnt 11gli%ing, which said nogliganae and detac.l•ia 11 oN.ncrr:+hlp, aparatio,�, aal%struutlon, maintanancal deviKn, inspuoticn and control cJJJ 12 dlraatly and flrnxl.�lstcly aallse the Injuries end clama9as to tha daa>3�ie��t and to 13 plaintltls ss hcroinaltsr aliRgoct. - 14 1G. �}• rca$an of t:1a naliliKatloe't At the r:cfvndllat as hcrvtofor� nllsq^ ., 15 laintiffs rava.`•baen deprive J of the nnc as a direct a:l�J proxim+lta res:llt tharaAf, p 16 . society, comfort, prctca:ion, vorvica tract olipgoct of t:10 dac3dvlli, Iu�':: '�'•�?1:�. 17 laUNCAN, and havo thereby suit-ahl-ld loss. 18 IVH7 rl�n;:r, plQillt:ff:3 prsy iul#Mont as follohal 1. For l Und Incidental axpcnsas in a sum OccO;rang to 20 proof; 21 2. ,.,Or lcs:l of wakes tecording to prr-Ot; 22 3. I'or };c,irral drllarc;tas in n cum to be aacsctaineL;; a. ),or ccsu of suit heroln; 24 5. l a- I�uc11 othpc and further rallaf Its tha court may Ils:c3m J'. t xn�l 25 26 gcaPer. C:A;1.;7`: :111;u•:t ^;1, i.,,g:t ftAS113?TA & n,',?IIFLS �1.1•� !� AANIt;LS rVµNN.YS AT LAW sy.•fJ Au Yr•n •VI llc.yawn U1VJ. w i. 100 . . w. A5i«IG•fA, . uJ. C•Idore. 9011 • •... 1�1)► N+•JIJI .J� 1 ( MARTIN W. fil,"l�iZ'i'A, r`'��;• ' p.N'rI7 Y. ti157.TA 6: j1!1Nt;.1.5 2 g A• }ijywrrd Air 3 Z2r.y3 Itttl,ptri:.n T1��al1 v ,rd Elayward, CA ri.•l1 a (415) AGS-�l;il • 5 - Attorioy.t f'.'r 1'lt•it+tlti:t 6 7 8 r;,,.fitiphamli. covaT Of CkLII0AHI.k 0 (:CUNTY fey ALAMEDA 10 i?I^ti+1RD 1,L.014 pU:ICAN, MARIE RICHARD DUNCAN, MICHAEL 11 PAUL, I)UN;:AN, D.*%VILI MILTON nuNCArT, 8Q`JI't1:: ti'IARIV.. AuNCA.I, a 12 m1nor, through her C1uardiRn %d I,itsrn, 13 RIC..!!AjW LEON PUN0AN1 plaintitl�, MC'. 14 '. CLr1I:1 F Iti't".C:iCFL"I. 1N?ATIi V, (�"1ov�t~tr4cnt. w.�c?a F PIC) 15 ���• �r• n"r.L:N ttnd DOES 0"-Z .. 16 I TEN, lncitl:ivs, , t11.�ari�t 17 I ^Gfs:t:l:r•ts. i8 I19 I T0+ THE CITY OF lIUIIII,INt YOU A1tF HEREBY NOTIFIED that RIC►iARI� L. DL'NCAN, '.9;1R1� I'•• '2� �J'11:A`•J 1 DUrJCAY, '.1;C:Ij;1•.i. P. t�G!iCAt�, DAVID ,1. nUNC:AN, and BCNNIR M, L. DUNrAA, woa Z, d minvr, ti)r011►'tl her Gunrdlan :td Itotn, TUCIARD ..3 t;�p �11I�:Irl110 Ito�t�l, l�ttblln, Cali:ornin, claim damati^a from tho CITY OF DUDLIN in the r.mount, curll�tttttd H� of t,.10 date of prcaontaticn Of this 41a1m, ��a of 25 i7,tts ZG ,I,I. A a eAGE .i. Of `3 I j tWOl'S AI I.AW •1'• ,1,,.414 %rt Yln+• ,,11y.11411 alw EXHIarr "A" 1..N L'1111�rnH Ni11 • .•. 1.1)111l•1111 �� 1� �ur;,�rt c1+1 Pacyanal injuries and tilt, 011h3equent dcat:l n'! JCill':Aa, the 1vlf� oi' cicii+.rcpt 1110HARl) UU:NOW.".1 aitd tt.c nothm, ( f el:,irnn111: 3 MARK VJNCAN, rL T.)UN%'.ANr DAVID 1)UNCAN and lit)NNIT. 4 atutQinal on or nb°.at Ju.+uary 21, 1Sr3I, In the vicinity uz' Amarillo Its„�1, +:a►•th vI 5 Luna t'ourt, 1i:1:ier Vie iplla�vi�rc� ciccvl:lst;+;1r.•�y: - • Str,UC% end injured w1:11a r+nll:ing on Amuci!1� f i 7 DrIvor north of Lunn Court, a publla strcot in tha City of Di4WIn, wheilein sho.w'�) 8 struck and lr4urcd �Y A. motor vohialc. Glaln+ant svtteracl uecivus and c+.�Uilii.ztJ;:Y r. 8 injurlea In acid ac411ttrnt, un4 (11ed on April 1$, 1934, 1110 Situ wtroro (;lair,+ant was 10 i;,jl+CJ� ►v:as located bcst.�roan't�ro lighted po-eons of Amarillo Drive, City or Dublin- 'i'nc rlcTmo(s) ct tt+a 11 puhUc cmpl•�yto(s1 cui+toing olnlrnzsTt's ir.JurlaA fsr,►i 12 subg4quL;nt death undir t`+e dolcriwd eirvuvnstanc9l Ara not known to el.�tr.-Iccnt. 13 I wined by al:sirnKr�t aoneiat%l of aet►vr8 f:aeturin) Of both J'l►s ltljurl� suet . ,. 14 leas, s sevcre iractu:n Of the rl�ht Rrrn, numarau4 injuries to her upper• 10 an 15 H Icw•rvorN hrncl lrljlr:; cauSIr);; el.�lmarlt tM l colnn. .1:1 II ce.ru t )lyi,itift is �i b.,ici lrrjuclus, l diod on April l , I"B• - 17 n;1TOIu)t cLnfincd, as of tho dot: of presentation of _ Ns c;r11, is 18 computed as folloi,151 -10 Aamr►s;u3 is+curre; 20 lixpur+see for !,jejlic4l and liosilital taro $24 1112 6 `•2 21 f 193^ 13,583.00 I•v::� of l:ar:11��;;s ar 22 $1RSO.CO 23 of 24 Srt1�C,C�0,0�) Censr4 Dun;a,:a Total I)nrl+ng�5 laul:rr:d t.: I)9tP lG 11 4I A 4 l)ANIUL-S w�• eAU 1'I0IIhL'Y$AT LAW (1.1"41J 411 111416 11oY.1 1111P•11en UNJ. Xvi1. 1011 /..n. L'. 1••wN N141 11111 1.!•!111 1 1 Fstlmllt�� + E'r1�pu�•t'sr'�► -��s�n;1PC.� __._ 2 Futw•� i..�r» :.� Uz ninp 3 O•chor I'rc�gn•_!(v•, F(�<:rlp; G�tllny;crl •. Amount tlltkr:, v11 a Nrvrpvotiv�:• Gen•a:al Liarul<uoa 2,0u0,ou��.nw 5 WWI 1'.�1111:,1to11 C•rosr,%•ctiv� l�wris•crt;l In Exaasq 61 $31400,00 l.l.u0 7 AU t1ot1�••►:� or othor coin,Tjwllcat�onv vilth rr,ard to this cl$.(1 I,itoulcl 1,,� 8 aaszt to thn rlatrn�r.l»t, at 7620 Amarillo Road, UuDUn, Galltcrzlla 8 4688, jal:tt t11sclr 8 Rttorrlayi, 8a�idxtx � C?anisb, Attornay� at i•���,'ZM093 Iie�pvrlan £oul.�•;�1•�, liuitu 10 ic30, l•;ay%varc;, CA J•t:i,ll. 11 1984 12 UASIS:TA 4f DANIEL! 13 by MAR71Y" 1i. BASIMA 14 15 16 17 18 ' .\ 19 20 21 • 22 23 .24 25 3 26 's' PAGE 3 11�I�.vC1'1; A I.Aw Ili •ruJ MI 1'I�i• :14+11 II •yalre p1J• ,.1�1 ar�•�tN � i PLAINT SUMMONS : - cizoss-coM (CITACION JUDICIAL) ro/1 cuuili•iii•c Un; CROSS- rmulu 0+N.4 a►u w r.. (11,,1, NOTICE TO/DEFENDANT: (Avisu -1 ,4013400) 0) 0)UNTY oF ALAMLOA, 11AC:I1•'IC: GAS AND LLI:C,vR1C.' COMPANY, ADAM t_;1tL(_;ORY HARE, L•'MI1,Y JOAN t)ESCOVICH, ROSS I through XXX, inclusive, YOU ARE K-11VU SUED RY~fAIf Fffx CROSS-COMPLAINANT, _ 0 Od, le ('Wif derll.lildalldu) c t'1•Y Ol' r)U13LIN, a Muliicipal CurNuratiun, do quo iv vntrvguvrr vsla You huvo 30 CALUNDA11 DAYS actor this sum- Qvilwes t'il.rtiun judic';.,; uiftvl ttio:ls is ourveJ on you :o NO U 'VQQwri;::n re- livnv un plazv do 30 DIAS CAIENDARIOS p,lnt p.st,1llar (In.) rtipuvi(a titrla is m,iquirl.l D)tIliu at tlllti CUtIfI. A lultur ur phunu call will nut prutuct you; your Urulvcctidn; iu reS ulti(al{vit'rilh,lallIn idtlirl.11tlit•1,t't,clllt' typuwfitturl ruspunsu must bu in propor IQUal p p (urnl it you want thu court to hour your CASU. culnplir Cull lai fvrmalidadvi logilvi .Iprupiadd ti; uslrcl 11 you tlu nut lilu yuur rusponsu Oil tintu, you may quivre quv la curie viCUCllt• iu ONU lulu tlw casu, and your waUus. nwnuy .tntJ pro- si uiltd no pre3wnla 1w rt•ipu{'ii,l .1 li"111)u, put'Ilt lnv�Irr party urt Uu tc+iwn without lurthur wum(ntJ troll) do aw prop��d sinla/iv adic un it pur'p ark,dc,l.l�t uriv thu court. Thuru aru uthur luUul rvqquiru+rluntS. You +Ilay fxiilcw u(rui rn%luliilui /rules. Nuc•dc• clot' ail{'c! tluit'r,, want w call an atturnuy riullt away. It you do not Alal.ir.1 un a!x)ffiadu iurntYli.11.Inlrnlr. 11 nu "1114" luww all attvnwy, you tnayy wall an atturllcy rulur- :Il)ug.lc/tt putvt/v Ilamar a tilt at•rviciu c/{, rt•li'rc•/1,i., tlt' fill survicu or a IuUul aid olficu (listud in 1110 phone lv/vfcSnicvl. a una ul'icina dv ayud,l Iv�tal (vr.l al clirz', luriu 1II� INM/111YU 1 t.,,.,/ IIw nanw fold addlusti ul tllu cuu(l it;: (0 lfullibw y dirt't•tit)ll th•l.+ curls•t's1 IJ-101850-1 :;UI'L.pioll COURT OF A1,AMEr)A COUNTY X4405 Amador Street U.tywctrd, CA 94544 cross-complainant's 'I'IIu rnunu, addruss, alld tuluphunu nunlbur of pWjQ69$b/uttornuy, or plaintill without an uttornuy, is: Ill 1111111111!'. 1.1 dili-4.4- 11 y el lullnera de l{104,1llu dW dbuhaldu deft dt'/ll.110,111w u tlt•/tlt'lll.11l{lill+({•{lllt• /lu rlt'llt'.Illtllj.l{l 1. t'>J 131C1AN J. MORRIS, lrSQ. 'Pole. No. (415) 576-02130 Lily: orr•IC:-IS OL' ALTON M. CIW413Liss 100 Pine Stroot, Suite 950 San VrallciS;Lx), Calil:urnia 94111 --_--... h'�� Clan Unrl:: MAY -3 1985 U-U: L LL D AVIUSOW Clark, by _____-._._.------ .___ ll t•,l,.,l 1�a•1,,.IriuJ _ .. -- - - NO WI: TO THI: pallSON 60VIZO; Yuu uro survutl I. (_� us un individual dulundant. V. �__•j ;It; lltu purson suud under the lit;tiliuus nunlu ul Isput;ilYJ: 3. un Uuhull of (spud/yl: Pacific Gas and Electric Company urldw: CCP 410.10 (culpuratiun) L CCP 4I1u.d0 11161m) CCP 410.20 (dulw101 oorpoluW111) Cta' •IIG./U I4t)IIt11VnlUU) CCP 410.40 (association or purtnorShip) CCP 416.90 (individual) other: —__.__.___......._... 4. by purSU11411 dulivury 01) /ddlul: ............ I'om,AJuuwJ W now M (Sou ruvuf*u for WOW u1 Survicul JUJII',ul cuull a V){:ultlu„u.l SUMMONS CO,4)1.:U UUYIV1Iu,IIIVv. IWWYI� I. {UU41 PROOF OF SERVICE — SUMMONS l�, jparate proof of sarvlve for 000h person ud1 1. 1 sorvud•tho - I : amonded complaint a, Hsummons --) complaint [l amondod summons Other (specify): completed and blank Case Questionnaires Lx on dulundunt (na/nu): Q by serving ED defendant other (name and tlt/e or rolatlonship to person served): d. by dulivury E�D ut Ilulllu at llusinuss (1) dutu: 12) time: - (3) address: a by Inuilinu (1) data: (2) place: 2. Murmur ul survicu (chuck prupur buA): u. Pursunul survicu. BY pursunully dulivurinp copies. (CCP x10.10) U. Substituted service on corporation, unincurporatod assoclation (including partnership), or public ul,tity. Uy lu;,vir,�. Burinpp usual office hours, copies in the office of the person served with the person who apparontly w;ls in ch;lrt)o and tl,urualtur muillnpp Iby liras class mail,postage propaid)copies to tho parson survud:It thu placu wlwi thu uulnu:• wutu lull. ICCI' 415.201u)1 C. �__� t;ubatit%nud vorvieu Q$1 'lot persell, minor, uunsurvutuv, or candWutu. lay IuavinU cupws at thu lum I nui Iwus�r. usual plucu ul ubodo, or usual place of buslnoss of thu erson served In the prosuncu of a cunlNutunt n,umuu( ul thu housurwld or a person apparently in charge of the office or place of businoss, at least 1S yuars of atlu, Who w;l:; inlurmud of thu uunural nuturu of the papers, and thurcuftor muslin (l. (irst•clasll Inclil, t�uetatlu hruhal�l) �:ul�iuu it tl►u Ilursun survud ut thu plucu whuru!hu co sus wuro lull. ICCP x10 Of )) (Attach supararu d004it ln,)n or allillavir starinu acts ruiiud ur1 w us106/Islr rousunablo dlllgunov In !list artvnrptinv p0/renal survi0u.1 d U Mail and ich r moiling Mail ii euou r i I��JOf the form d ackowlod 9ont and a return nvulop pusi dUu urvvdoput,awith two cuNos vvnp/vvd rkrowvdyrrurrt of rvc0ipr.1 uddrussud to 1110 sundur. (CCP 410.30) (A4avlr. I� u LID Curtlrind a roturn roeei Iltl copios to the person sorvod�CCP 416.40)0 �ttavh s/gnvd rvtum rvice.�i or vrhur uvidunuu ruqul fl of aoruol de/ivory to d o person served.) 1. 1= Othur lspucify cudu sucriun): ,I U udditiullul pogo Is :lttuchud. 3. 1'llu Notice to tho Porson Served" (on the summons) was completed as follows (CCP 412.30, 416.10, and 474): a. P 6v an individual defendant. b. us thu pursun suud undur thu lictitiuus nuluc ul ("pacify): all WIWI of is ucifyl: CCP 416.60 (minor) other: under: CCP 410.10 (corporation) CCP 416.70 lconsvrvatoo) _ CCP 410.20 (dufunct corporation) CCP 4115.40 (ussociut)un or partnurship)- CCP 410.90 (individual) by pursunul dulivury un (14110): 4. At tl,u film of survicu I was at luust 113 yours of age and not a party to this action. G. Full for survicu: $ U. Poison survirlu: a. Q California sl,urill, marsllul, or cunatablu f N county address stration andnumber I,d, it ;Ipplicaulu, b. Rugistorud California procuss sorvur V. E11 oyou or indupundunt cuntractur of a rugisturud (�:llllulllla pl'ucuut; *ulvul. i d. L_ Nut a mUit;turud Culilulllia lllucu,s sulvur. u, U Exun,pt Iron, ruuistrution undur taus. & Prof. Cudo 223GO(b)• (For Calllorrrlu slroriff, marshal, or oonsta IG usu on )ly I duclaru undur pul,ulty ul purjury undur tl,u lows of thu State 1 oortlf that the foregoing is true and corrocl. of California that tho foruuoing is true and corruct. Y 6 g Oulu: Uutu: - rsrvN.liuiur ilU11uI1J1 Illuv.JwwNy 1, IU04I