HomeMy WebLinkAbout8.3 East Dublin Studies (� 00-so
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: April 24, 1989
SUBJECT: East Dublin Studies:
First Amendment to the Agreement between the
City and Wallace Roberts & Todd for Consultant
Services to complete additional work on the East
Dublin Studies.
- First Amendment to the Agreement between the
City and Alameda County for payment of a portion
of the cost to complete additional work on the
East Dublin Studies.
- First Amendment to the Agreement between the
City and Sponsoring Property Owners for payment
of a portion of the cost to complete additional
work on the East Dublin Studies.
REPORT PREPARED BY: Rod Barger, Senior Planner
EXHIBITS ATTACHED: Exhibit A: Draft Resolution approving the First
Amendment to Agreement for Consultant Services
between the City and ,,iRT.
Exhibit B: Draft Resolution approving the First
Amendment to the Agreement between the City and
Alameda County.
Exhibit C: Draft Resolution approving the First
Amendment to the Agreement between the City and
Sponsoring Property Owners.
Attachment 1: Draft First Amendment to the
Agreement for Consultant Services for
preparation of the East Dublin CPA Study,
Specific Plan Study and EIR.
Attachment 2: Draft First Amendment to
Agreement between the County of Alameda and the
City of Dublin for payment of a portion of the
costs of the East Dublin General Plan Amendment
Study, Specific Plan Study and EIR.
Attachment 3: Draft First Amendment to
Agreement between the City of Dublin and the
Sponsoring Property Owners for payment of a
portion of the costs of the East Dublin General
Plan Amendment Study, Specific Plan Study and
Environmental Impact Report.
Attachment 4: Summary of total General Plan
Amendment study costs to complete additional
geotechnical and biological work at $71,593.
Attachment 5: Suimnary of total General Plan
Amendment study costs to complete additional
geotechnical and biological work at $53,638.
..._ ,, ... . AttaCl'lilei,* v: TOL31 sponsoring property owner,
costs if sensitive species found.
i- Attachment 7: Total sponsoring property owner
cost if sensitive species not found.
RECOMMENDATION: � 1) Review agreements.
2) Adopt Resolution. approving First Amendment
to the Agreement between the City of -Dublin
and Wallace Roberts & Todd.
---------- ---- - ---------------------------------------------------------------
ITEM N0. Ips 3 COPIES TO: PA 87-031
3) Adopt Resolution approving First Amendment
to the Agreement between the City of Dublin
and Alameda County.
4) Adopt Resolution approving First Amendment
to the Agreement between the City of Dublin
and Sponsoring Property Owners.
5) Authorize the City Manager to sign the
agreements between:
a) the City and Wallace Roberts & Todd;
and
b) the City and Sponsoring Property
Owners;
all of which should occur after monies have
been received from sponsoring property
owners to pay for the additional geological
and biological work.
6) Authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to sign
the Agreement between the City and Alameda
County, after monies have been received from
sponsoring property owners to pay for the
additional geological and biological work.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT: See discussion below.
DESCRIPTION:
In the process of conducting tasks associated with the East Dublin
General Plan Amendment/Specific Plan Studies and EIR, it has been determined
(by Staff, Sponsoring Property Owners and the Consultant) that there is a need
to carry out additional work that was not included in the work program of the
original Agreement between the City and Wallace Roberts & Todd. This
additional work focuses on geologic and biologic aspects of the General Plan
study and EIR. Staff is asking the Council to provide the go ,:head to enter
into the appropriate agreement amendments necessary to carry out these
additional tasks .
Additional Geotechnical Work
The City' s General Plan calls for the avoidance of allowing development
on hillsides where slopes are predominateliy 30 percent or more, on lands
containing geologic hazards, and on lands containing significant ridgelines
and visually prominent slopes. Adherence to these policies could potentially
render a large portion of the General Plan Amendment study area non-
developable. Sponsoring property owners have indicated strong interest in
allowing consideration of more intensive development in the General Plan study
area (more intensive than current General Plan policies allow) . In order to
study the potential for more intensive development, additional geological work
must be carried out by the consultants.
Wallace Roberts & Todd would oversee the production of the additional
geotechnical work, using Harlin-Miller Tait as the geologist to perform
research and analysis. The tasks to be carried out as part of this work are
specifically outlined in Exhibit A-1 of Attachment 1 of this report. The cost
to complete this additional work is $24,440.00.
Model Construction
_ The. City needs to ..ba able,,tq,cvai:,ate the e:c' ects of alterna-five plan's'
on the visual quality of hillsides. In order to assist in this endeavor, a
model of the stud;r area (showing contour and property lines as well as
existing roads) would be constructed by California Model Design at a cost of
$3,745.00.
Additional Biological Jo rk
In order to fully comply with all requirements of the California
Environmental Qualitv Act (as well as other applicable State and Federal
regulations) , the need has arisen to conduct additional biological work in the
General Plan Amendment study area. This additional biological work will focus
-2-
on conducting surveys for the San Joaquin Kit Fox and other sensitive plant
and animal species in order to verify their existence or non-existence in the
General Plan study area. If sensitive species do exist, appropriate
mitigation measures must be established to reduce the loss of these species.
Wallace Roberts & Todd would oversee the production of the additional
geotechnical work using BioSystem Inc. as the biologist to perform the
surveys , analysis, monitoring and mitigations. The tasks to be carried out as
a part of this work are specifically outlined in Exhibit A-1 of Attachment 1
of this report. The cost to complete this work is $43,405.00. In the event
the surveys find that the Kit Fox or other sensitive plant and animal species,
are not present, the cost for additional work will be $25,450.00 rather than
$43,405.00, since there would be no need to perform work outside of the
initial surveys.
The total cost of the additional work is as follows:
Geotechnical - $24,440
Model - 3,748
Biological - 43 ,405 -or- 25,450 (if no sensitive plant
and/or animal species are
found
Total $71,593 -or- $53,638
The Agreement Amendments
Three separate agreement amendments are attached for your review.
Please refer to Attachments 1, 2 and 3. Each of those agreements must be
entered into prior to having the consultants perform the additional
geotechnical, biological and model construction work. It is recommended that
the City Council review Attachments 1, 2 and 3 (the agreements) and adopt
Exhibits A, B and C, the resolutions approving the agreement amendments.
In addition, it is recommended that the City Council:
1) authorize the City Manager to sign the agreements between a) the City
and Wallace Roberts & Todd, and b) the City anr' sponsoring property owners;
and
2) authorize the Mayor and City Clerk to sign the agreement between the
City and Alameda County;
with the signings to occur after monies have been received from
sponsoring property owners to pay for the additional geotechnical and
biological work.
It should be noted that of the fourteen (14) different sponsoring
property owners, ten (10) have decided to fully participate in paying for the
entire cost of the additional work. Attachment 4 shows breakdown of those
costs at the $71,593 additional study cost level. 'Attachment 5 shows a
breakdown of those costs at the $53,638 additional study cost level.
Attachment 6 provides a breakdown of individual sponsoring property
owners total monetary participation in the costs of the entire GPA/SP study
and EIR, inclusive of the additional geotechnical and biological work, if
sensitive plant and animal species are found in the General Plan study area
(at the $71,593 cost level) . Attachment 7 provides a breakdown of individual
sponsoring property owners total monetary participation in the cost of the
entire CPA/SP study and EIR, inclusive of the additional geotechnical and
biological work, if sensitive plant and animal species are not found in the
General Plan study. area (at the $53 ,638 cost level) .
In Attachments 2 and 3, it should be noted that all monetary figures and
blank spaces marked with asterisk(s) represent new costs associated with the
amendments to the agreements. All monetary figures and blank spaces that are
not marked with asterisk(s) , represent original costs that will be taken from
the original agreement between the County and City, and the original
agreements between the City and sponsoring property owners.
-3-
RESOLUTION NO. - 89
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A RESOLUTION APPROVING FIRST AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT (EAST DUBLIN)
WHEREAS, the City Manager has presented an Agreement entitled "FIRST
AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT FOR CONSULTANT SERVICES FOR PREPARATION OF THE EAST
DUBLIN GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY AND ENVIRONMENTAL
IMPACT REPORT" ; and
WHEREAS, the City Council is familiar with the provisions of said
Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council does resolve as follows:
The City Council approves said Agreement and authorizes the City Manager
to execute said Agreement.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 24th day of April, 1989.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Mayor
ATTEST:
City Clerk
RESOLUTION NO. - 89
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A RESOLUTION APPROVING FIRST AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT (EAST DUBLIN)
WHEREAS, the City Manager has presented an Agreement entitled "FIRST
AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE COUNTY OF ALAMEDA AND THE CITY OF DUBLIN FOR
PAYMENT OF A PORTION OF THE COSTS OF THE EAST DUBLIN GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT
STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT" ; and
WHEREAS, the City Council is familiar with the provisions of said
Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council does resolve as follows:
The City Council approves said Agreement and authorizes the Mayor to
execute said Agreement.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 24th day of April, 1989.
AYES :
NOES :
ABSENT:
Mayor
ATTEST:
City Clerk
'-B
-2-
RESOLUTION NO. - 89
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
A RESOLUTION APPROVING FIRST AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT (EAST DUBLIN)
WHEREAS, the City Manager has presented an Agreement entitled 'FIRST
AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF DUBLIN AND THE SPONSORING PROPERTY
OWNERS FOR PAYMENT OF A PORTION OF THE COSTS OF THE EAST DUBLIN GENERAL PLAN
AMENDMENT STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT" ; and
WHEREAS, the City Council is familiar with the provisions of said
Agreement.
NOW, THEREFORE, the City Council does resolve as follows:
The City Council approves said Agreement and authorizes the City Manager
to execute said Agreement.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 24th day of April, 1989.
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
Mayor
ATTEST:
City Clerk
BIT
e- C
-3-
FIRST AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT FOR CONSULTANT
SERVICES FOR PREPARATION OF THE EAST DUBLIN
GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY
AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT
WHEREAS, the CITY OF DUBLIN ("The City") and WALLACE ROBERTS
& TODD ("The Consultant") are parties to an agreement entitled
"AGREEMENT FOR CONSULTANT SERVICES FOR PREPARATION OF THE EAST
DUBLIN GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY AND
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT, dated August 5, 1988 (the
"AGREEMENT") ; and
WHEREAS, additional geotechnical and biological services are
necessary for completion of the work to be performed under the
AGREEMENT; and
WHEREAS, The City and The Consultant desire to amend the
AGREEMENT;
NOW, THEREFORE, The City and The Consultant agree to amend as
follows:
A. Exhibit "A" is amended by adding-thereto the work set
forth on Exhibit "A-1" attached hereto and incorporated herein, to
be included within the scope of work.
B. Paragraph III is amended by deleting the sum of $500, 240
and adding in its place the sum of $571, 833 or the sum, of $553 , 878
(if no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other sensitive species are
found to be present) .
I rfl:h 0.
Except as expressly set forth herein, the AGREEMENT shall
remain in full force and effect.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties hereto have caused this First
Amendment to the AGREEMENT to be executed the day and year first
written below.
THE CITY OF DUBLIN
(a Municipal corporation)
By:
Richard C. Ambrose, City Manager
Date:
WALLACE ROBERTS & TODD
By:
Title:
Date:
mnrw/1114/agree/3specpla.ehs
SCOPE OF WORK AND COSTS FOR
ADDITIONAL GEOTECHNICAL AND BIOLOGICAL WORK
A. Geotechnical Services by Harlan Miller Tait
Task 1. Review Project Status and Existing
Data and Conduct Site Reconnaissance $ 1,000.00
Task 2. Revise/Prepare Maps 3,500.00
Task 3. Prepare Geologic and Seismic Setting
Document/Prepare DevelopmentConsiderations
Document/Summary of Opportunities and Constraints ' 2-,500.00
Task 4. Develop and Evaluate Alternatives/
Review Grading Feasibility/Evaluate Alternatives 2,500.00
Task 5. Report Production 1,500.00
Task 6. Attend Property Owner/Public Meetings 1,500.00
Subcontract Management _ 1,632.00
Map Preparation, three maps 1,348.00
Incorporation of Findings into Task 9/EIR
Setting 414.00
Revision of Environmental Factor Maps 450.00
Refinement of Task 11, Development Sites 1,268.00
Addition of Hillside Design Concepts to Task 13 1,298.00
Application of Findings to Task 14 590.00
Consultation with HMT, City, regarding
Alteratives 984.00
Interpretation of Findings in Alternative/
Final Plans 1,864.00
Preparation of Design Guidelines for Grading,
Task 25 932.00
OAF ,A(�RE�.�'Y1L A1T
Illustration of Design Guidelines for Grading 1,040.00
Additional Map Photographic & Reproduction Costs 120.00
SUBTOTAL $24,440.00
A general categorization and mapping of all land in both the entire General
Plan Amendment and Specific Plan study areas is expected, identifying land
which falls into one of the following three categories:
1 - areas that are free of geologic conditions requiring engineering
repair measures and will be developable with no further geotchnical
investigation; -
2 - areas that are potentially developable with minimal engineering
repair but for which further geotechnical studies will be required
prior to final approval; and
3 - areas where slopes 'substantially exceed 30 percent and/or contain
landslides that would be uneconomic to repair.
B. Biological Services by Biosystems Analysis Inc.
Task 1.1. Surveys for Sensitive Plant Species $ 4,400.00
Task 2.1. Kit Fox Surveys 13,879.00
Task 3.1. Other Sensitive Species Surveys 5,125.00
Tasks 1.2. , 2.2. , 3.2. Biological Assessments 8,069.00*
Tasks 1.3. , 2.3. Consultation 6,086.00*
Subcontract Management 1,632.00
Map Revision/Preparation, two data maps 900.00*
Coordination with Regulatory Agencies 1,024.00*
Incorportation of Findings-with Task 9/EIR Setting 414.00
Revision of Environmental Factor Map (See
under Geotechnical Studies, above)
Refinement of Task 11, Site Recommendations 616.00°
Consultation with BSAI/Preparation of
Mitigation Measures, Task 14/EIR 1,180.00*
-2-
Additional Photographic/Reproduction Cost 80.00*
SUBTOTAL $43,405.00
*The seven tasks with asterisks will be performed only if kit fox,
sensitive plants or other sensitive species are determined to be
present in the General Plan study area.
C. Study Model by California Model and Design
Model at 1" = 400' with 25" contour intervals
showing property lines and existing roads $ 1,950.00
Model Construction Subcontract Management 350.00
Additional Visual Impact Assessment
(Alternative Plans) 1,448.00
SUBTOTAL $ 3,748.00
TOTAL ADDITIONAL COSTS $71,593.00**
**Total will be $53,638 if seven tasks identified by single
asterisks under paragraph B are not performed.
-3-
FIRST AMENDMENT -TO AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE
COUNTY OF ALAMEDA AND THE CITY OF DUBLIN FOR PAYMENT
OF A PORTION OF THE COSTS OF THE EAST DUBLIN
GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY
AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT
WHEREAS, the County of Alameda and the City of Dublin are
parties to an agreement entitled "AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE COUNTY OF
ALAMEDA AND THE CITY, OF DUBLIN FOR PAYMENT OF A PORTION OF THE COSTS
OF THE EAST DUBLIN GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY
AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT" , :which agreement is dated July 12 ,
1988 (the "AGREEMENT") ; and
WHEREAS, additional professional services are required for the
purposes of preparing the General Plan Amendment Study and
Environmental Impact Report ("EIR") ; and
WHEREAS, the total cost of such additional services is
$71, 593 . 00 or $53 , 638, if no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other
sensitive species are found to be present; and
WHEREAS, because this Amendment relates only to costs for the
General Plan Amendment and EIR, the agreement of all Sponsoring
Property Owners is not required to the amendments set forth herein;
and
WHEREAS, the County and City hereby agree to amend the
AGREEMENT as follows:
UT
A. Section 2 is amended by deleting Section 2 and adding a
new Section 2 , to read as follows:
2 . County Payment to City. The County will pay the
City the following amounts as its proportional
share of the cost of preparing the General Plan
Amendment, the Specific Plan, the Environmental
Impact Report and related documents as more
fully described above:
General Plan (County property only) $32 , 483. 00
Additional General Plan (geotechnical
and biological) 17 411 nn *
Specific Plan (County property only) 67 ,796. 00
Additional Specific Plan Costs
(the County's proportional
share of the costs ascribed
to the parcels owned by
non-participating property owners) 12 , 520. 00
Total $130,210.00 **
B. Section 3 is amended by deleting Section 3 and adding new
Section 3 , to read as follows:
3 . Method of Payment. The County agrees to pay The
City a total sum not to exceed $130,210.***. The
County further agrees to pay The City monthly based
on an itemized monthly statement and reflecting the
County' s proportional share of the costs billed for
work completed by the Consultant.
*If no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other sensitive species are
found to be present, the total "Additional General Plan" cost will
be $ 13 , 044 . 00
**Total will be $ 1?5, 843 , 00 , if no sensitive plants, kit foxes or
other sensitive species are found to be present.
***Or $_125,843.00 , if no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other
sensitive species are found to be present.
Except as expressly amended, the AGREEMENT dated July 12 ,
1988 remains in full force and effect.
The County of Alameda
(A political subdivision of the
State of California)
By
Chairman,
Board of Supervisors
Date
Attest:
By
William Mehrwein, Clerk
Board of Supervisors
Approved as to Form:
County Counsel
City of Dublin
(a Municipal corporation)
By
Mayor
Date
Attest:
City Clerk
Approved as to Form:
City Attorney
114\AGREE\1SPEDPLA.EHS
' FIRST AMENDMENT TO AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE
CITY OF DUBLIN AND THE SPONSORING PROPERTY OWNERS
FOR PAYMENT OF A PORTION OF THE COSTS OF THE
EAST DUBLIN GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY
SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY AND ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT
WHEREAS, ("the Property Owners") and
the City of Dublin ("The City") are parties to an agreement
entitled "AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE CITY OF DUBLIN AND THE SPONSORING
PROPERTY OWNERS FOR PAYMENT FOR A PORTION OF THE COSTS OF THE EAST
DUBLIN GENERAL PLAN AMENDMENT STUDY, SPECIFIC PLAN STUDY AND
ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT" (the "AGREEMENT") which agreement is
dated and
WHEREAS, additional professional services are required for
the purposes of preparing the General Plan Amendment Study and
Environmental Impact Report ("EIR") ; and
WHEREAS, the total costs of such additional services is
$71, 593 . 00 or $53 , 638, if no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other
sensitive species are -found to be present; and
WHEREAS, because this Amendment relates only to costs for the
General Plan Amendment and EIR, the agreement of all Sponsoring
Property Owners is not required to the amendments set forth
herein; and
WHEREAS, the Property Owners and The City hereby agree to
amend. the AGREEMENT as- follows• u..-w
A. Section 2 is amended by deleting Section 2 and adding
new Section 2 to read as follows:
2 . Payment To The City. The Property owner will pay The
City the following amounts as its proportional share of the cost
of preparing the General Plan Amendment, the Specific Plan, the
Environmental Impact Report and related documents as more fully
described above:
General Plan
(The Property Owner's property only $
Supplemental General Plan
(Geotechnical and biological) $
Additional General Plan Costs
(The Property Owner's proportional
share of the costs ascribed to the
parcels owned by non-participating
property owners) $
Specific Plan
(The Property Owner's
property only) $
Additional Specific Plan Costs
(The Property Owner's proportional
s.-,are of the--cos`s ascribed to
the parcels owned by non-
participating property owners) $
Total $
*If no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other sensitive species are
found to be present, the total "Supplemental General Plan" cost
will be $
T3'Total will be $ if no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other
sensitive species are found to be present.
B. Section 3 is amended by adding thereto the following
sentence:
The sum indicated in paragraph 2 as "Supplemental General
Plan" cost is Property Owner' s proportionate share of $71, 593 or
$53 , 633*** and shall be paid by the Property Owner to the City
within thirty (30) days of execution of this amendment. Except as
expressly amended, the AGREEMENT shall remain in full force and
effect.
THE PROPERTY OWNER THE CITY OF DUBLIN
(a Municipal corporation)
By: By:
Richard C. Ambrose,
Printed Name: City Manager
Date: Date:
***If no sensitive plants, kit foxes or other sensitive species
are found to be present, the total "Supple*zantal General Plan"
cost will be $ 53,638
SUMMARY OF TOTAL GPA COST TO COMPLETE
ADDITIONAL GEOTECHNICAL AND BIOLOGICAL WORK
AT $71,593
NON-SPONSORED TOTAL
SPONSOR SPONSOR COST SHARE COST ADDITIONAL COST
Alameda County $ 9,286 $ 8,125 = $ 17,411
Crosby/Bank of the West 1,804 1,580 = 3,384
Doolan East Assoc/D.Wilson 8,563 7,490 = 16,053
Doolan West Assoc. 2,993 2,619 = 5,612
Fallon Investors 1,503 1,310 = 2,813
Chang Su-O-Lin et al 8,956 7,837 = 16,793
Mission Peak Homes 657 578 = 1,235
Pappas 1,546 1,353 = 2,899
Redgwick Construction 1,554 1,360 = 2,914
TMI/Dublintown Ltd. 1,324 1,155 = 2,479
TOTAL $38,186 $33,407 = $ 71,593
There will not be any reimbursement of General Plan costs.
These costs are applicable if the biological surveys verify the existence of
the San Joaquin Kit Fox or any other sensitive plant or animal species.
SUMMARY OF TOTAL GPA COST TO COMPLETE
ADDITIONAL GEOTECHNICAL AND BIOLOGICAL WORK
AT $53,638
NON-SPONSORED TOTAL
SPONSOR SPONSOR COST SHARE COST ADDITIONAL COST
Alameda County $ 6,957 $ 6,087 = $ 13,044
Crosby/Bank of the West 1,352 1,184 = 2,536
Doolan East Assoc/D.Wilson 6,415 5,611 = 12,026
Doolan West Assoc. 2,242 1,962 = 4,204
Fallon Investors 1,126 981 = 2,107
Chang Su-O-Lin et al 6,710 5,872 = 12,582
Mission Peak Homes 493 433 = 926
Pappas 1,159 1,014 = 2,173
Redgwick Construction 1,164 1,018 = 2,182
TMI/Dublintown Ltd. 992 866 1,858
TOTAL $28,610 $25,028 = $ 53,638
There will not be any reimbursement of General Plan costs .
These costs are applicable if the biological surveys verify the non-existence
of the San Joaquin Kit Fox or any other sensitive plant or animal species.
_.. ' :.�-
I
TOTAL PROPERTY OWNER COSTS IF SENSITIVE SPECIES FOUND
i
Originals' New Addtn'l General"
General Plan-, Additional Plan Costs for Specific Plan" Additional*
(Property Owners General Geotechnical and (.Property Owners Specific
Property Only) Plan Costs Biological Work Property Owner) Costs TOTAL
Alameda County $32,483 $ -0- $'17,411 $67,796 $12,520 $130,210
Crosby/Bank of the West 6,309 5,639 3,384 -0- -0- 15,332
Doolan East Assoc./D.Wilson 29,942 26,704 16,053 -0- -0- 72,699
Doolan West Assoc. 10,465 9,336 5,612 -0- -0- 25,413
Fallon Investors 5,257 4,673 2,813 11,395 2,018 26, 156
Chang Su-O-Lin et al 31,344 27,946 16,793 65,397 12,073 153,553
Mission Peak Homes 2,311 2,064 1,235 4,823 890 11,323
Pappas 5,408 4,827 2,899 11,271 2,080 26,485
Redgwick Construction 5,433 4,848 2,914 11,345 2,096 26,636
TMI/Dublintowr Ltd. 4,631 4,118 2,479 9,646 1,780 22,654
Andersony,�- 1,677 1,489 -0- 3,474 642 7,282
Branaugh** 1,352 1,212 -0- 2,824 525 5,913
P. Lin lr* 10,390 9,274 -0- 21,691 4,008 45,363
Righetti*** 1,677 1,458 -0- 3,474 601 7, 210
'This column represents existing costs covered under previous agreements.
"This column represents additional costs to be covered under agreement amendment to pay for additional geotechnical and
biological_ work,
*"Represents sponsoring property owners that chose not to participate in the additional General Plan costs for the
additional geotechnical and biological.
t
?;vI
t a Ali ""T 1 7
jTT&Pi e d i9i V,@L.frIo U 9
r
' TOTAL PROPERTY OWNER COSTS IF SENSITIVE SPECIES NOT FOUND
Original* New Addtn'1 General**
General Plan", Additional Plan Costs for Specific Plan* Additional*
(Property Owners General Geotechnical and (Property Owners Specific
Property Only) Plan Costs Biological Work Property Owner) Costs TOTAL
Alameda County $32,483 $ -0- $13,044 $67,796 $12,520 $125,86'
Crosby/Bank of the West 6,309 5,639 2,536 -0- -0- 14,4
Doolan East Assoc./D.Wilson 29,942 26,704 12,026 -0- -0- 68,6-/ .
Doolan West Assoc. 10,465 9,336 4, 204 -0- -0- 24,005
Fallon Investors 5,257 4,673 2, 107 11,395 2,018 25,450
Chang Su-0-fin et al 31,344 27,946 12,582 65,397 12,073 149,342
Mission Peak Homes 2,311 2,064 926 4,823 890 11,014
Pappas 5,408 4,827 2, 173 11,271 2,080 25,759
Redgwick Construction 5,433 4,848 2, 182 11,345 2,096 25,904
TMI/Dublintown Ltd. 4,631 4, 118 1,858 9,646 1,780 22,033
Anderson**:; 1,677 1,489 -0- 3,474 642 7,282
Branaugh*** 1,352 1,212 -0- 2,824 525 5,913
P. Lin °^* 10,390 9,274 -0- 21,691 4,008 45,363
Righetti"* 1,677 1,458 -0- 3,474 601 7,210
*This column represents existing costs covered under previous agreements.
**This column represents additional costs to be covered under agreement amendment to pay for additional geotechnical an,
biological work.
*"Represents sponsoring property owners that chose not to participate in the additional General .Plan costs for the
additional geotechnical and biological.