Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 8.4 Measure D Recycling Measure V �o CITY OF DUBLIN AGENDA STATEMENT CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: October 8, 1990 SUBJECT: Measure D: Alameda County Waste Reduction and Recycling Initiative do(Prepared by: Paul S. Rankin, Assistant City Manager) EXHIBITS ATTACHED: Exhibit A: Copy of Initiative Exhibit B: County Counsel's Analysis RECOMMENDATION: Consider whether City Council desires to take a position C/�%�`' FINANCIAL STATEMENT: If the initiative is approved by the voters and implemented, garbage rates will need to increase. The initiative levies a $6.00/ton fee, which would generate approximately $12 million countywide. DESCRIPTION: At the City Council meeting on September 24, 1990, Councilmember Snyder requested that the City Council consider this measure at their next meeting. Councilmember Snyder is the City's representative on the Alameda County Waste Management Authority. The following analysis outlines the primary provisions of the initiative. The initiative will appear on the November ballot as Alameda County Measure D. The specific sections of the initiative are noted in brackets. GOALS Measure D restates the requirements in State Law (AB 939) , which mandate cities to achieve a 25% reduction of waste disposed of at landfills by January 1 , 1995. AB 939 also requires a 50% reduction by January 1 , 2000 [64.040(A) (1 ) ] . In addition, Measure D Initiative requires the Recycling Board to establish by January 1 , 1999 a date by which the amount of solid waste landfilled is reduced by 75% [64.040(A) (2) ] . COMPOSITION OF RECYCLING BOARD The Recycling Board is appointed by the Board of Supervisors and consists of 11 members as follows [64. 130(D) ] : a. 5 members would be Waste Management Authority members. The Waste Management Authority Board is comprised of elected officials from its member agencies. Therefore, these members would be elected officials appointed by the Waste Management Authority. b. The following six appointments are to be made by the County Board of Supervisors and they must be residents of Alameda County. 1 . Representative of an organization engaged in operating recycling programs within the County 2. A source reduction specialist with substantial experience 3. A representative of the recyclable materials industry 4. A representative of the solid waste industry 5 . A representative of an environmental organization with a significant membership active in recycling issues 6. An environmental educator employed as such on a full-time basis The initiative allows the Board to operate as a subsidiary of the Waste Management Authority, provided the Authority concurs. Otherwise, the Board is to operate as a separate entity within the structure of County Government. The majority of the Board is comprised of appointees and not elected officials. As previously discussed, this Board will have discretionary control over millions of dollars generated from garbage rate payers in Alameda County. ---------------------------------------------------------------------- 4 COPIES T0: ITEM NO. ✓��� / � ''�/ The measure establishes a requirement that the Recycling Board shall meet at least once each month. There are also mandatory attendance requirements for the Board members. The Board will be authorized to receive compensation of $100 per meeting provided that the annual compensation does not exceed $3,000 per member. In addition, the Board is authorized to hire staff to carry out the provisions of the measure. PLAN DEVELOPMENT The initiative requires the development of a plan within one year of the effective date. [64.040(B) ] . The stated purpose of the plan is to establish recycling programs necessary to meet the goals discussed in the paragraph above. AUDIT OF PROGRAMS Section [64.040(C) ] of the initiative requires an audit to determine compliance with the Plan adopted pursuant to the initiative. Subsection 1 states that the audit would include an evaluation of recycling programs regardless of whether they were funded by Measure D. This requirement subjects programs to the review of the Recycling Board regardless of how they are funded. FUNDING Subsection [64.050] establishes a requirement to collect a $6.00 per ton fee on all refuse accepted at a landfill or incinerator within Alameda County. The initiative also establishes the manner in which the surcharge can be modified. Section [64. 050(E) ] allows for unexpended funds to be temporarily invested in accordance with accepted principles of financial management, in financial instruments that encourage, to the extent possible source reduction and recycling while discouraging non-sustainable uses of natural resources. Based on current estimates of waste disposal within Alameda County, it is anticipated that the surcharge would generate approximately $12, 000, 000. The investment criteria also differ from what is typically addressed with public monies. The California Government Code restricts the types of public agency investments. Usually safety and liquidity are the primary factors used to determine an appropriate investment. DISTRIBUTION OF FUNDS During the first 27 months, 80% of the funds are to be apportioned on a per capita basis to municipalities for the planning and implementation of Residential and/or Commercial Recycling funds. [64. 060(A) (1 ) ] Section [64.060(B) (1 ) ] reduces the amount of grant money apportioned to municipalities to 50% of the total funds beginning with the 28th month. The following chart and assumptions detail the estimated financial impact of the agency grant program to the City of Dublin. It should be noted that all calculations are estimates only and the projections were not adjusted for changes in future years. Assumptions: o 2 million tons garbage /year Countywide - subject to $6.00 fee o 1990 State Department of Finance Populations Alameda County 1 , 265,929 Dublin 25,825 (2% of County Total) o 23,850 tons of Garbage Produced in Dublin/year (Estimate based on Quarterly Survey 3/90) Annual Amt Distributed Annual Amt Generated to the City by Dublin Rate Payers Annualized $ first 27 months $192, 000/yr $143, 100 Annualized $ after 27 months $120, 000/yr $143, 100 Amts over a 10-year period $1 , 362, 000 $1 ,431 ,000 As shown above, the estimate projects that Dublin rate payers would pay more than is returned to the City during a 10 year period. Also, the formula provides for reduced funding after 27 months. Therefore, the cost of replacing the funding would need to be obtained from additional garbage rate increases. -2- During the first 27 months, 20% [64. 060(A) (2) ] or an estimated $2.4 million will be used for the following activities: a. Development of Source Reduction, Recycled Product Market Development, and Recycled Product Purchase Preference Programs. b. Expenses associated with the Recycling Board created by the measure and administrative costs. C. The preparation of the County Source Reduction and Recycling Element as required by AB 939. Beginning with the 28th month, 50% of the funds are to be disbursed on the programs noted below. The dollar values shown are for informational purposes based on the current disposal Countywide of approximately 2 million tons. (1 ) 10% ($1 .2 million) designated for a grant program for non-profit organizations engaged in maximizing recycling, composting, and reducing waste within the County. The measure designates the Recycling Board as eligible to receive these funds for conducting planning, research, and studies. [64.060(B) (2) ] (2) 10% ($1 .2 million) shall be applied to the Source Reduction Program. [64.060(B) (3) ] (3) 10% ($1 .2 million) shall be applied to the Recycled Product Market Development Program. [64.060(B) (4) ] (4) 5% ($600, 000) shall be applied to the Recycled Product Purchase Preference Program. [64.060(B) (5) ] (5) 15% ($1 .8 million) shall be disbursed on a discretionary basis by the Recycling Board to support activities described. A maximum of 3% of this category may be retained by the Board to cover the cost of administering the fund. [64.060(B) (6) ] The measure restricts contracts using Measure D funds to a five year period unless approved by the Recycling Board. [64.060(D) ] The Board could authorize a contract period of up to 10 years. The distribution amounts could be changed by a vote of the Recycling Board with a concurrence of the Board of Supervisors and a majority of the population. MUNICIPAL GARBAGE RATES [64. 070] In order to be eligible to receive these monies, the City must adjust local garbage rates to provide full reimbursement to the local refuse hauler. The City can request the assistance of the Recycling Board to develop a product disposal fee in order to reduce the amount of the surcharge included in the garbage rate. The issue of a product disposal fee is a complex issue in which the State Integrated Waste Management Board is mandated to prepare a study concerning the state-wide consequences of such a fee. The concept involves a methodology for levying a separate fee on items which are not recyclable and are normally disposed of at a landfill. For example, a separate fee could be levied on disposable diapers. From a practical standpoint, it would appear extremely difficult to levy this type of fee on a local basis. In March of 1990 the local garbage company estimated that single family residential units generated 5, 400 tons of garbage per year. It is important to note that this is an estimate only generated from a quarterly survey. Assuming 4,935 residential accounts, the monthly cost to Dublin residents would be 55 cents per month. Adequate information is not available to identify the cost to commercial, industrial, and multifamily customers. The City currently imposes a $1 .25 per month charge for curbside recycling. SOURCE REDUCTION AND RECYCLING PROGRAMS Section [64. 080] discusses the content of the source reduction program and the following section discusses the Residential Recycling Program. Cities receiving money from the fund must provide a recycling program to each person who receives garbage service. The recycling service must be offered within 2 years of the initiation of the Recycling Fund. Within the current Dublin City limits, the provision of a recycling program to each single family residence receiving garbage service is convenient. However, in the event that less developed areas are annexed, this requirement may result in increased costs. For example, in areas which are currently rural, the cost of having a weekly collection may be extremely unproductive. -3- Typically, a curbside program is operated most efficiently in urban areas with a significant number of single family homes. It may be most efficient to provide the curbside service only after there is sufficient development to support the program. Measure D would not allow this type of phasing. Section [64. 1001 discusses the requirements for the Commercial Recycling Program. Similar to the residential program, the initiation must begin within two years of the initiation of the recycling fund. Any city receiving funds must have a commercial recycling program available to every business, government, and public or private institution to which garbage collection is offered. PROHIBITION OF INCINERATION [64. 1401 Measure D would prohibit the operation of an incinerator within Alameda County. In addition, the measure would prohibit the acceptance of incinerator ash at any landfill, regardless of the location of the incinerator which produced them. CONFLICTS AND DUPLICATION AB 939 became effective January 1, 1990 . This State Law substantially revised the process for Waste Management Planning statewide. In several areas Measure D would either duplicate or conflict with the current State Law. Also, agencies have been working for several months to implement the requirements of State Law. o Amount of Solid Waste Diversion State Law requires cities in 10 years to divert 50% of the waste typically placed in a .: landfill. The methods of reaching this goal include recycling, composting, and source reduction. Measure D exceeds the State requirement by requiring the Recycling Board to establish a date for 75% diversion of waste from the landfill. The Board is to establish the date by January 1 , 1999. o Preparation of a Recycling Plan Under current law (AB 939) , each City is required to prepare a Source Reduction and Recycling Element. In addition, the county is required to develop a Countywide Element. The City of Dublin as a member of the Alameda County Waste Management Authority (Authority) as been working on a joint project to select a consultant team to assist with this project. The cost associated with the development of a baseline plan is being paid for by the Authority through tipping fees already imposed. It is currently projected that the Authority will make a selection in October. In accordance with State Law, the City is to have the plan submitted by July 1, 1991. The law requires a comprehensive plan which addresses the following components: (a) Waste Characterization (f) Education and Public Information (b) Source Reduction (g) Funding (c) Recycling (h) Special waste (d) Composting (i) Household Hazardous Waste (e) Solid waste facility capacity Given the requirements in AB 939 to prepare this information, the development of a separate County Plan pursuant to the initiative appears to be a duplication. Also, the planning process is well underway in order to address the stated submittal date of July 1 , 1991 . o Distribution of Funds to Prepare County Source Reduction and Recycling Element (SRRE) Alameda County through the Waste Management Authority has been working to develop SRRE as required by AB 939. The Authority has implemented a tipping fee increase to pay for the cost of this work. In addition to the County plan, the Authority project will provide baseline information for the City planning requirements. The Authority has worked with the member agencies to develop a Request for Proposal and it is anticipated that the Consultant will be selected by the end of October. o Identification of Measure D Recycling Board as the AB 939 Task Force Section[64.130(B) 1 suggests that the Recycling Board serve as the Task Force required by AB 939. The Board of Supervisors is required to seek -4- the consent of a majority of the cities containing a majority of the population, regarding the designation as the AB 939 Task Force. The Waste Management Authority has already appointed an AB 939 Task Force. The group has already been conducting meetings pursuant to its charge in AB 939. If a new Task Force is appointed sometime after the November election, it will disrupt the planning process. AB 939 already has very tight timeframes for completing specific requirements. Additional delays would not be in the interest of timely completion of the AB 939 planning process. o Prohibition of Incineration This provision is more restrictive than what is allowed by AB 939. The State Law allows agencies to use the transformation process (i.e. , incinerator) to meet up to 10 percent of the required 50 percent reduction by the year 2000. There are other regulatory requirements within State Law regarding the use of incinerators. Overall, AB 939 involves a complex process to address solid waste management. The State recently released revised regulations for implementing the Act. The addition of an additional County process will further complicate waste management issues. It also appears appropriate to consider whether the provisions in State Law already address the primary intent of the initiative. COUNTY COUNSEL REVIEW The County Counsel is required to prepare an impartial analysis of measures which appear on the ballot. This document is included in the Voter Pamphlet and Sample ballot. A copy is attached as Exhibit (B) . The final paragraph of the County Counsel's analysis identifies potential conflicts with existing law. One potential conflict is with the imposition of a surcharge which may violate provisions of AB 939 . State Law requires that fees imposed be based on the types or amount of waste and the actual program cost. The County Counsel has also noted that the measure appears to apply some provisions to cities regardless of their participation in the County funding program. Those areas which are beyond the requirements in State Law may violate the State Constitution relating to the powers of municipalities. CONCLUSION The City Attorney has recommended that if the City Council wishes to take a position, that they should do so by minute action. Staff recommends that the City Council consider the measure. -5- THE ALAMEDA COUNTY WASTE REDUCTION. AND RECYCLING " INITIATIVE CHARTER AMENDMENT : ( Final Text : November 13, 1989) SECTION 64 : WASTE REDUCTION AND RECYCLING SUBSECTION 64 . 010 : NAME This Section of the Alameda County Charter shall be known and may be cited as the Alameda County Waste Reduction and Recycling Act of 1990 (hereinafter the "Act" ) . SUBSECTION 64 . 020 : PURPOSE The purpose of this Act is to: A. Provide for an Alameda County Source Reduction and Recycling Plan (hereinafter the "Recycling Plan") in conformance with new state law requiring all California cities and counties to plan, fund and implement a comprehensive source reduction and recycling program (Paragraph 64 . 040(B) ) ; B . Meet , by January 1 , 1995 , the state-mandated goal of reducing by at Least twenty- five percent the refuse landfilled in Alameda County, then meet by January 1 , 2000, the further state-mandated goal of fifty percent , and set longer- term goals starting at seventy-five percent (Paragraph 64 . 040(A) ) ; C. Ensure that the Recycling Plan provides for at least the following essential elements : 1 . An Alameda County-wide Source Reduction . Program (Subsection 64 .080) to minimize the generation of refuse; 2. Residential Recycling Programs (Subsection 64.090 ) to provide each Alameda County residence with curbside pick-up of recyclable materials; 3 . Commercial Recycling Programs (Subsection 64 . 100) to reduce the refuse disposal costs of businesses and government agencies; 4 . An Alameda County-wide Recycled Product Market Development Program (Subsection 64 . 110) to create and strengthen stable markets for recycled materials; and 5 . A Recycled Product Purchase Preference Program (Subsection 64. 120) to further encourage recycled materials markets by maximizing the amount of recycled products purchased by County government agencies; D . Fund the Recycling Plan by instituting a six dollar per ton surcharge on materials disposed of in Alameda county landfills (Paragraph 64 .050(A) ) ; E . Create an Alameda County Source Reduction and Recycling Board (hereinafter the "Recycling Board") to coordinate the Recycling Plan (Subsection 64 . 130) ; F . Prohibit the incineration of refuse within Alameda County (Subsection 64 . 140) . SUBSECTION 64 . 030 : FINDINGS The people of Alameda County find and declare that : A. The increasing consumption of single-use and environmentally harmful products depletes natural resources, produces huge quantities of refuse - - most of which is disposed of in ways that damage the environment - - and, ultimately, will injure future generations; B . The use of terms such as "garbage" and "solid waste" result from - - and serve to reinforce - - wasteful attitudes; the materials referred to by these terms retain their value as natural resources, and should instead be described and treated as "discarded materials" to be recycled rather than incinerated or landfilled; C. At least ninety percent of the discarded materials generated within Alameda County are landfilled as are vast quantities of discarded materials from neighboring counties; existing landfill capacity in the Bay Area will be exhausted in less than twenty-five years, while new Landfills are increasingly difficult and expensive to site; landfill is neither a long-term, nor a sustainable, nor an environmentally safe option for disposal of discarded materials; D . Refuse incinerators are a poor alternative to source reduction and recycling; such incinerators damage the environment by wasting natural resources that could instead be recycled, by accelerating the release of greenhouse gasses - - which worsen global warming -- and by generating toxic substances; E . Each person discards materials and should therefore be involved in solving the problems caused by the disposal of such materials; this involvement must include changes in individual behavior resulting from each person' s awareness of her or his role in creating or finding solutions to environmental problems; only through such changes can sustainable consumption and disposal patterns be established and the biosphere restored; F. The County government shares a responsibility with Alameda County cities and sanitary districts to provide a comprehensive source reduction and recycling program which will foster these necessary changes in individual behavior as well as ensure that the goals set by state law are met; and 2 ` I G. The best available method for funding the Recycling Plan is a surcharge on materials disposed of at landfills . SUBSECTION 64 .040 : RECYCLING POLICY GOALS AND RECYCLING PLAN A. Recycling Policy Goals : 1 . Consistent with the California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1990 (hereinafter the "CIWMA" ) , it shall be County policy to reduce, recycle, and compost, by no later than January 1 , 1995 , at least twenty- five percent (25X) , and by no later than January 1 , 2000, at least fifty percent (50X) , by weight , of all discarded materials generated within Alameda County. 2 . The Recycling Board shall establish , not later than January 1 , 1999, a date to reduce, recycle, and compost at least seventy- five percent (75X) , by weight , of all discarded materials generated within Alameda County, and, as necessary to the establishment of sustainable discarded materials management practices , shall subsequently establish a date (or dates) to reduce, recycle and compost further quantities of discarded materials. B . The Recycling Board shall develop, within one ( 1 ) year of the effective date of this Act , a plan to establish the recycling programs necessary to meet the recycling policy goals set forth in Subparagraph 64 . 040(A) ( 1 ) (all citations contained in this Act are, unless otherwise noted, to this Act) , said plan to be known as the Alameda County Source Reduction and Recycling Plan (Recycling Plan.) . The Recycling Board subsequently shall amend the Recycling Plan as necessary to meet said recycling policy goals, and as necessary to meet the further recycling policy goats established by the Recycling Board pursuant to Subparagraph 64.040(A)(2) . The Recycling Plan shall incorporate all Alameda County recycling programs, whether funded by this Act or not . In developing and amending the Recycling Plan, the Recycling Board shall consult with the Alameda County Board of Supervisors (hereinafter the "Board of SUpervisors") , the Alameda County Waste Management Authority (hereinafter the "Authority" ) and Alameda County municipal governing bodies, and furthermore shall seek to maximize public input as to the contents of the Recycling Plan by holding public hearings 'and establishing public advisory committees. C. The Recycling Board shall contract, not more than four (4) years after the effective date of this Act, and then every five (5) years thereafter, for an audit to determine compliance with the Recycling Plan and the degree of progress toward the recycling policy goal then in effect . Said audits shall be conducted by an independent auditor (or auditors) with experience in source reduction and recycling . The reports of said audits shall be completed within one ( 1 ) year and issued to each municipality, the Board of Supervisors and the Authority. Said reports shall include at least the following: 1 . A narrative and analytical evaluation of all recycling programs 3 within Alameda County, whether funded through this Act or not, both Alameda Countywide and within each municipality; 2. A statistical measure of the progress toward the recycling policy goal then in effect; 3 . An evaluation of the Recycling Board' s activities, including, but not limited to, an accounting of the monies spent by the Recycling Board; and 4 . Recommendations to the Recycling Board, the Board of Supervisors , the Authority and the municipal governing bodies for the maintenance and expansion .of recycling programs , and any necessary resulting amendments to the Recycling Plan. SUBSECTION 64. 050 : RECYCLING FUND A. Commencing not later than three (3) months after the effective date of this Act , each landfill or incinerator in Alameda County shall collect a surcharge of six dollars (56.00) per ton on all refuse accepted for landfilling or incineration at said landfill or incinerator. All monies collected through said surcharge shall be paid by the operators of each landfill or incinerator into a fund, to be known as the Alameda County Recycling Fund (hereinafter the "Recycling Fund") , established for the purpose of receiving and disbursing monies pursuant to this Act . The Board of Supervisors shall ensure the collection of said surcharge, either by modifying the use permits of said landfills and incinerators or by any other necessary means . B . Should the collection of said surcharge be found to be in violation of an existing contract or agreement to import refuse generated outside of Alameda County for landfilling or incineration within Alameda County, the Board of Supervisors may vote to waive collection of said surcharge for the refuse described within said contract or agreement . However, any future contract or agreement for the importation of refuse for landfilling or incineration within Alameda County, executed or negotiated after the effective date of this Act , shall provide for the collection of said surcharge for the refuse described within said contract or agreement. C. Any necessary costs of collection of said surcharge incurred by Landfill or incinerator operators shall not be subtracted from said surcharge but , consistent with Subsection 64 .070, shall be passed through to refuse generators by means of the refuse collection rates set by each municipality. D . Said surcharge may be adjusted only as follows: 1 . The Board of Supervisors may place a ballot measure on the Alameda County ballot for an alternative or additional funding mechanism for the Recycling Fund. Said funding mechanism may Levy a surcharge or disposal fee on types of discarded materials. Said ballot measure may also include a provision to adjust said surcharge in direct correlation to the funding resultant from the 4 proposed surcharge or disposal fee. 2. The Authority may pay monies within its jurisdiction to the Recycling Fund with the intent of mitigating said surcharge. Should the Authority vote to do so, the Board of Supe-rvisors shall adjust said surcharge accordingly, provided that no such adjustment shall result in a net loss to the total receipts to the Recycling Fund within a given year. 3 . The Board of Supervisors may vote at any time to adjust said surcharge in direct accordance with changes in the Consumer Price Index. 4 . Commencing January 1 , 1995 , and once every five years thereafter, the Board of Supervisors may vote, with the advice of the Authority and/or a double majority of the cities, to pass an ordinance adjusting said surcharge by up to twenty percent ( 20%) . Said ordinance ma-y take effect immediately, but shall be subject to approval or repeal by a vote of the people at the next regularly scheduled Alameda County election. 5 . The Board of Supervisors may vote, with the concurrence of a double majority of the cities, to adjust said surcharge, if either the federal government or the State of California institutes recycling programs that duplicate and fund the recycling programs established by this Act . E . The Recycling Board shall administer the Recycling Fund in accordance with the provisions of this Act . Recycling Fund monies that are not immediately expended may be temporarily invested, under the direction of the Recycling Board and in accordance with accepted principles of financial management , in financial instruments that encourage, to the extent possible, source reduction and recycling while discouraging non-sustainable uses of natural resources. Any interest or other income resulting from such investments shall accrue to the Recycling Fund. SUBSECTION 64 .060: SUPPORT FOR RECYCLING PROGRAMS A. During the first twenty-seven (27) months after the effective date of this Act , the Recycling Board shall support recycling programs and otherwise fulfill the provisions of this Act by disbursing monies from the Recycling Fund as follows: 1 . Eighty percent (80%) of the total shall be apportioned on a per capita basis to municipalities for the planning and implementation of Residential Recycling Programs and/or Commercial Recycling Programs , for new or expanded recycling programs, and for the preparation of the city source reduction and recycling elements, pursuant to the CIWMA. Funds so disbursed shall be used exclusively for supporting municipal recycling programs. 2. Twenty percent (20%) of the total shall be applied to the 5 following : a. The development and implementation of the Source Reduction Program, the, Recycled Product Market Development Program and the Recycled Product Purchase Preference Program; b. The Recycling Board' s expenses for the administration of this Act; and C . The preparation of the Alameda County source reduction and recycling element, pursuant to the CIWMA. B . Commencing twenty-eight (28) months after the effective date of this Act , the Recycling Board shall support recycling programs and otherwise fulfill the provisions of this Act by disbursing monies from the Recycling Fund as follows : 1 . Fifty percent (50X) shall be disbursed on a per capita basis to municipalities _f..or the continuation and expansion of municipal recycling programs . 2. Ten percent ( 10X) shall be applied to a grant program for non- profit organizations engaged in maximizing recycling, composting, and reducing waste within Alameda County. The Recycling Board shall be an organization eligible to receive funds under this Subparagraph, for the purposes of conducting planning, research , and studies directed at furthering the purposes of this Act . 3 . Ten percent ( 10X) shall be applied to the Source Reduction Program. 4 . Ten percent ( 10X) shall be applied to the Recycled Product Market Development Program. 5 . Five percent (5X) shall be applied to the Recycled Product Purchase Preference Program. 6. Fifteen percent ( 15X) shalt be disbursed on a discretionary basis by the Recycling Board to support any of the activities described within this Paragraph . A portion of said fifteen percent ( 15X) may be retained by the Recycling Board to cover the necessary costs of administering the Recycling Fund, provided, however, that said portion shall not exceed three percent (3X) of the total funds paid to the Recycling Fund in a given year. C. For the purpose of apportionment of funds under the provisions of this Subsection, and for the purpose of sound discarded materials management, the Recycling Board shall cause accurate, reliable, and up- to-date estimates to be maintained of the amounts and kinds of recycling and refuse generation occurring in each municipality. For the purpose of ensuring comparability of data, any composition study or waste characterization study performed with Recycling Fund monies shall comply with standards to be established by the Recycling Board. Said standards shall include, but shall not be limited to, both methodology and categories of discarded materials . In establishing 6 said standards, the Recycling Board should utilize the categories for discarded materials outlined in Paragraph 64 . 150(0) . D . Contracts using Recycling Fund monies shall be made for periods of not more than five (5 ) years , except that, upon a finding of the Recycling Board that a longer period is necessary in order to capitalize a specific project , the Recycling Board may vote to allow a particular contract to be made for a period of not more than ten ( 10) years . No contract using Recycling Fund monies shall provide for an option to renew or any similar provision that would result in the extension of a contract , on a less than fully competitive basis , for a cumulative period of more than five (5 ) years or, in the case of a contract which the Recycling Board has authorized to be made for a longer period for purposes of capitalization, more than ten ( 10) years. E . Nothing in this Act shall prevent any municipality, other jurisdiction, or other organization within Alameda County from raising or expending additional funds or taking other actions in support of recycling programs . F . Commencing January 1 , 1995 , the Recycling Board may vote, with the concurrence of the Board of Supervisors and a double majority of the cities , to adjust the distribution of funds under Paragraph 64 . 060(B ) in order to further progress toward the recycling policy goal then in effect . SUBSECTION 64 .070 : MUNICIPAL RATE STRUCTURES A. In order to be eligible to receive monies from the Recycling Fund, each municipality must , either by adjusting local refuse collection rates or by instituting a product disposal fee, provide for full reimbursement to its local refuse haulers) for the costs of the surcharge established by Paragraph 64 .050(A) . B . Upon request of a municipality, the Recycling Board shall cooperate with said municipality, the Alameda County Joint Refuse Rate Review Committee and the refuse haulers) serving said municipality to design an incremental refuse collection rate structure which will : 1 . Fully reimburse said haulers) for the increased costs resulting from the surcharge established by Paragraph 64 . 050(A) ; 2. Encourage source reduction and recycling among residents by charging successively higher amounts for each garbage can collected; and 3. Provide residents with the option to use smaller garbage cans at a decreased rate in order to reward source reduction and recycling. C. Upon request of a municipality, the Recycling Board shall cooperate with said municipality, the Alameda County Joint Refuse Rate Review Committee, and the refuse haulers) serving said municipality to design a product disposal fee, to be levied on purchases of products , 7 with emphasis on those products that either are non- recyclable or are environmentally harmful , which will : 1 . Allow said municipality to fully reimburse, in lieu of or in addition to an increase in refuse collection rates , said haulers) for the increased costs resulting from the surcharge established by Paragraph 64.050(A); 2. Encourage source reduction among residents; and 3. Discourage the purchase of environmentally harmful products . SUBSECTION 64 . 080: SOURCE REDUCTION PROGRAM The Recycling Board shall disburse monies allocated in Subparagraphs 64 . 060(A) (2 ) and 64 .060(B) (3) , on a discretionary basis, for the development of an Alameda Countywide Source Reduction Program. Funded components of the Source Reduction Program shall include, but shall not be Limited to, the following : A. A county waste minimization program with a goat of reducing the weight of County purchases , and with a specific goal of reducing the weight of County purchases of paper products by ten percent ( 10X) by January 1 , 1995 , and by fifteen percent ( 15X) by January 1 , 2000 . Said program shall emphasize the conservation of paper products by means of a comprehensive employee education program. The Recycling Board may establish further goals for reduction in County purchases . B . An annual non-monetary award program for businesses which demonstrate a significant reduction in the use of packaging materials or the use of materials in manufacturing processes, or waste reduction through the durability and/or recyctability of their products . C. An industry and/or university program to research and develop source reduction opportunities and incentives. D. An intensive public education campaign to promote alternative individual consumer habits and in-house source reduction programs for businesses and institutions. E . Disposal cost reduction studies and waste audit services to demonstrate to businesses and institutions the efficacy of recycling programs. SUBSECTION 64 .090: RESIDENTIAL RECYCLING PROGRAMS Within two (2) years of the initiation of the Recycling Fund, each municipality receiving monies from the Recycling Fund shall provide a Residential Recycling Program to every resident to whom refuse collection service is offered on a regular schedule which is as frequent as said refuse collection. , However, it shall not be mandatory to provide said program to residents more than once a week. 8 SUBSECTION 64 . 100 : COMMERCIAL RECYCLING PROGRAMS Within two (2) years of the initiation of the Recycling Fund, each municipality receiving monies from the Recycling Fund shall make an adequate Commercial Recycling Program available to every business, government , and public or private institution to which refuse collection is offered, on a regular schedule. Municipalities may determine that a Recyclable Materials Recovery Program is an appropriate means of satisfying a part of this requirement . SUBSECTION 64 . 110: RECYCLED PRODUCT MARKET DEVELOPMENT PROGRAM The Recycling Board shall disburse monies allocated in Subparagraphs 64 .060(A) (2) and 64 . 060(8) (4) of this Act , on a discretionary basis , for a program to develop and expand markets for recycled products . Funded components of the Recycled Product Market Development Program shall include, but shall not be limited to, the following : A. A regional cooperative marketing strategy; B . Grants for demonstration projects targeted at new uses of recycled materials and new techniques for recycling materials; C. An Alameda County-wide information exchange which targets potential users and sources of recycled products; and D . Municipal programs to administer permit assistance to recycling industries . SUBSECTION 64 . 120: RECYCLED PRODUCT PURCHASE PREFERENCE PROGRAM A. The County shall purchase Recycled Products where they are comparable in function and equal in cost to products manufactured from virgin materials. B. The County shall apply, to the extent made possible by the availability of monies under Subparagraphs 64 . 060(A) (2) and 64 .060(8) (5 ) , a price preference of ten percent ( 10X) to its purchases of Recycled Products where said Recycled Products are comparable in function to products manufactured from virgin materials . 1 . Price preferences shall be applied to a full range of recycled product categories, including, but not limited to, recycled paper products, compost and co-compost products, recycled glass, recycled oil , and recycled solvents and paints . 2. The Recycling Board may establish a price preference which is greater than ten percent ( 10X) for certain recycled product categories , if it is demonstrated that the manufacturing costs for said recycled product categories are higher than the manufacturing costs for similar products produced with virgin materials such that a ten percent ( 10X) preference is 9 insufficient for said recycled products to be competitive. 3 . Commencing January 1 , 1995 , the Recycling Board may reduce the price preference for certain recycled product categories , if it is demonstrated that the manufacturing costs for said recycled product categories are competitive with the manufacturing costs for similar products produced with virgin materials, and that any such reduction will not result in a substantial decrease in the percentage of recycled products purchased in the category affected by the reduction. 4 . Any monies remaining after fulfilling the other requirements of this Paragraph in a given year shall be apportioned by the Recycling Board to municipalities which have established similar price preferences and recycled product specifications . C. Consistent with Paragraphs 64 . 120(A) and (B) , the County shall modify its purchasing forms and procedures to ensure that , beginning no later than one ( 1 ) year after the effective date of this Act , information as to the recycled content , including both postconsumer discards and secondary discards , of all supplies and materials purchased by the County is available and taken into account during the purchasing process. Said information shall also be obtained for the supplies and materials portions of all public works contract bids that are received by the County. D . Any County agency which has responsibility for drafting or reviewing specifications for procurement items shall be required to revise said specifications, within one ( 1 ) year of the effective date of this Act , to eliminate exclusions of recovered materials and requirements that said items be manufactured from virgin materials. E . To the extent that the practice of accepting bids for multiple products inhibits the purchase of recycled products, the County shall accept bids for individual products and/or bids for fewer products . F . The Recycling Board may establish standards for a recycled product category which exceed the levels of postconsumer and secondary discard content established by this Act, provided, however, that said standards will not result in a substantial decrease in the percentage of recycled products purchased in said category. G. Notwithstanding any other provision of this Charter, this Subsection shall apply to the supplies and materials portions of all public works contracts made by the County. The County may set minimum amounts of recycled products, both by quantity and by category, to be utilized in the execution of said contracts; and shall contract separately for the supplies and materials portions of said contracts where such separate contracting would result in more complete compliance with this Act while not significantly increasing the cost of a given contract , except as allowed by Paragraph 64. 120(8 ) . H . It shall a County policy goal to purchase recycled paper products such that , by January 1 , 1995, at least fifty percent (50X) of the total dollar amount of paper products purchased or procured by the County 10 shall be purchased or procured as recycled paper products . Not later than January 1 , 1999, the Recycling Board shall recommend to the Board of Supervisors further policy goals for County purchases of all types of recycled products . SUBSECTION 64 . 130: RECYCLING BOARD A. The Board of Supervisors and the Authority shall appoint an eleven ( 11 ) member board, to be known as the Alameda County Source Reduction and Recycling Board (Recycling Board) , to administer this Act as well as to carry out any other tasks consistent with the purposes of this Act that may subsequently be given to the Recycling Board by the voters or the Board of Supervisors. B . To avoid unnecessary administrative duplication, the Board of Supervisors shall seek the consent of a double majority of the cities for the Recycling Board to serve as the local task force mandated by California Public Resources Code Section 40950 (as enacted by the CIWMA) . A failure to obtain such consent shall not be construed to inhibit the establishment of the Recycling Board. In the event that the Recycling Board is not named as said local task force, the Recycling Board shall review any recommendations of a local task force regarding source reduction and recycling. C . To further avoid unnecessary administrative duplication, the Authority may, within ninety (90) days of the effective date of this Act , accept the Recycling Board as a subsidiary body of the Authority. Should the Authority not so accept the Recycling Board, or if the Authority at any time ceases to exist , the Recycling Board shall be established as a separate entity within the structure of County government . However, notwithstanding an initial failure by the Authority to so accept the Recycling Board, the Board of Supervisors may at any time, upon request of the Authority, make the Recycling Board a subsidiary body of the Authority. D . Members of the Recycling Board shall be appointed in accordance with the following : 1 . The Authority may appoint five (5) of its members to sit on the Recycling Board. Should any or all of said five (5 ) Recycling Board members not be appointed by the Authority within four (4) months of the effective date of this Act, the Board of Supervisors shall cooperate with a double majority of the cities to appoint said member or members, except that a member appointed under such circumstances need not be a member of the Authority, but must be a member of the governing body of a municipality. 2 . The Board of Supervisors shall appoint six (6) Alameda County residents to the Recycling Board as follows: a. A representative of an organization engaged primarily in operating recycling programs within Alameda County; b. A source reduction specialist with substantial experience as 11 such; C . A representative of the recyclable materials processing industry; d. A representative of the solid waste industry; e . A representative of an environmental organization with a significant membership active in recycling issues within Alameda County; and f . An environmental educator employed as such on a full - time basis . 3 . The membership of the Recycling Board shall reflect expertise in the field of source reduction and recycling . 4 . No for-profit corporation, including its divisions , affiliates , parents and subsidiaries , wholly or partially owned, may have more than one ( 1 ) employee or representative on the Recycling Board at any one ( 1 ) time. 5 . All members of the Recycling Board shall be appointed within four (4 ) months of the effective date of this Act . Members of the Recycling Board shall serve a term of two (2) years , and may be reappointed for one ( 1 ) successive term, except that , for the purpose of ensuring continuity in the administration of this Act, the initial terms of two (2) of the members appointed by the Authority and three (3) of the members appointed by the Board of Supervisors shall be one ( 1 ) year. Should a Recycling Board member appointed by the Authority cease to be a member of the Authority, or if a Recycling Board member who is a member of the governing body of a municipality should cease to be a member of said governing body, or if a Recycling Board member ceases to be a resident of Alameda County, her or his seat on the Recycling Board shall be immediately deemed to be vacant . b. Should a Recycling Board member for any reason vacate her or his seat , the governing body (or bodies) that appointed said member shall appoint a new member within two (2) months of the date the . seat is vacated, except that if the appointing body is the Authority and the Authority has either ceased to exist or has failed to appoint a new member within said two (2) month period, the Board of Supervisors shall cooperate with a double majority of the cities to make the appointment. All such appointments to the Recycling Board shall otherwise be made in compliance with the requirements that applied to the original appointments . 7. In the event of temporary incapacity or other inability to attend Recycling Board meetings, a Recycling Board member may request that the governing body (or bodies) that appointed said member appoint an interim Recycling Board member to serve, for a period of no more than three (3) months, in the place of said member. E . The Recycling Board shall schedule and conduct regular meetings at 12 least once each calendar month, and shall schedule special meetings and committee meetings as necessary to the business of the Recycling Board. Regular meetings shall be scheduled with at least one ( 1 ) month advance notice to the public . Special meetings and committee meetings shall be scheduled with at least one ( 1 ) week advance notice to the public. F . Recycling Board members shall attend at least three fourths (3/4 ) of the regular meetings within a given calendar year . At such time as a member has been absent from more than one fourth ( 1/4 ) of the regular meetings in a calendar year, or from two (2) consecutive such meetings, her or his seat on the Recycling Board shall be considered vacant . G . Consistent with the principle of maximizing public participation in all Recycling Board activities, the Recycling Board may establish advisory committees and shall provide for full participation of the public in the functions of such bodies . H . The Recycling Board shall hold its meetings , hearings , public hearings , and other proceedings in such places and at such times as are likely to maximize access to said proceedings by as broad a range of Alameda County residents as is reasonably possible. To this end, the Recycling Board shall hold at least one ( 1 ) regularly scheduled evening meeting per year in each supervisorial district in a location accessible by public transit and shall ensure full access to all Recycling Board meetings by the physically disabled. I . All hearings , meetings , proceedings or other discussions of the Recycling Board, or of any committee or other subsidiary body of the Recycling Board, shall be open to the public, as shall the minutes, records of proceedings or documents received or discussed by the Recycling Board or its subsidiary bodies . Access to meetings or documents of the Recycling Board may be restricted only in circumstances authorized by those provisions of the Ralph M. Brown Act (California Government Code Sections 54950 et seq. ) , or of the California Public Records Act (California Government Code Sections 6250 et seq. ) , or of any successor legislation to either said act , relating to actual or imminent litigation or to evaluation of an employee of the Recycling Board. No such restriction shall be lawful unless it is first justified in the relevant written notice of meeting by specific identification of the actual or anticipated litigant or by specific identification of the position of the Recycling Board employee to be evaluated. All Recycling Board documents shall be made available for copying by members of the public for the direct cost of the copies only, not to exceed a limit of ten ( 10) cents per page. Said limit may be adjusted by the Recycling Board in direct proportion to the Consumer Price Index. J . The Recycling Board shall formulate rules for its own procedures and other rules as necessary to facilitate the implementation of the provisions of this Act . K. Each Recycling Board member shall have one ( 1 ) vote. A quorum for decisions of the Recycling Board shall be a majority of its members, 13 except that a smaller number may vote to adjourn meetings . L . The members of the Recycling Board shall elect from their number a chair to be the presiding officer of said Recycling Board. The term of office of said chair shall be no more than one ( 1 ) year and shall expire at the end of the calendar year in which the chair sits . H. Each Recycling Board member shall receive compensation not to exceed three thousand dollars ($3, 000 . 00) for one ( 1 ) calendar year , not to exceed one hundred dollars ($100. 00) for each regular meeting of the full Recycling Board, or each special meeting or committee meeting of at least two (2) hours duration, which said member has attended. N . The Recycling Board shall hire such staff as are required to implement the provisions of this Act . Staff salaries and benefits shall be paid out of the monies allocated for the administration of this Act , pursuant to Subparagraphs 64.060(8) (2) and 64 . 060(C) (6) . 0. The Recycling Board may apply for , receive and expend supplementary funding grants from private and public sources . P . Conflicts of Interest : 1 . No Recycling Board member shall participate in any Recycling Board action or attempt to influence any decision or recommendation by any employee of or consultant to the Recycling Board which involves herself or himself , or which involves any entity with which the member is connected as a director, officer, elected official , consultant , or full - time or part- time employee, or in which the member has a direct personal financial interest within the meaning of California Government Code Section 87100, or any successor statute thereto. 2. No Recycling Board member shall participate in any proceeding before any agency of either the County or a municipality as a consultant or in any other capacity on behalf of any solid waste handler, recycling organization, or other person or organization which actively participates in matters before the Recycling Board. Nothing in this Subsection shall be construed to prohibit a representative from a municipality from fully participating in the deliberations of her or his own governing board. 3 . For a period of one ( 1 ) year after leaving her or his seat on the Recycling Board, a former Recycling Board member shall not act as an agent or attorney for, or otherwise represent ,. any other person before the Recycling Board by making any formal or informal appearance or by making any oral or written communication to the Recycling Board. 0 . Ex Parte Communications:' 1 . No Recycling Board member, or person who serves as a consultant or in any other capacity on behalf of a solid waste handler, recycling organization, or other public or private entity which actively participates in matters before the Recycling Board, or 14 other person who intends to influence the decision of a Recycling Board member on a matter before the Recycling Board, excepting a staff member of the Recycling Board acting in her or his official capacity, shall conduct an ex parte communication unless the following steps are taken: a . The Recycling Board member shall notify the person who engaged in the ex parte communication that a full disclosure of said communication must be entered in the Recycling Board' s record; and b. Either the Recycling Board member or the person who engaged in said communication shall , prior to the next regularly scheduled meeting of the Recycling Board, submit a full written disclosure of said communication which shall be entered in the Recycling Board' s official record. 2 . For the purposes of this Paragraph , "ex parte communication" shall mean any oral or written communication concerning matters , other than purely procedural issues , under the jurisdiction of the Recycling Board which are subject to a vote of the Recycling Board, but shall not mean any such communication performed before the Recycling Board, or any subsidiary body thereto. R . Violations of Paragraphs 64 . 130(P) or (Q) shall be punishable as a misdemeanor. S. Upon request of any person or on her or his own initiative, the Alameda County District Attorney may file a complaint in Alameda County Superior Court alleging that a Recycling Board member has knowingly violated Paragraphs 64 . 130(P) or (Q) , including the facts upon which said allegation is based, and asking that said Recycling Board member be removed from office. If , after trial , the court finds that the Recycling Board member has knowingly violated either of said Paragraphs, it shall enter a judgement removing said member from office. T . All documents issued by or in the name of the Recycling Board shall be printed double-sided on recycled paper with the highest postconsumer content available. SUBSECTION 64 . 140: PROHIBITION OF INCINERATION It shall be unlawful to operate any incinerator within Alameda County. Furthermore, it shall be unlawful to landfill within Alameda County the ash or residue from any incinerator, regardless of the location of said incinerator. SUBSECTION 64 . 150: DEFINITIONS The following words and phrases used in this Act shall have, for the purposes of interpreting and applying this Act , the following meanings : 15 A. "Act" shall mean this Section, Section 64 of the Alameda County Charter as enacted by the Alameda County waste Reduction and Recycling Act of 1990. B . "Alameda County" shall mean the geographic entity, including both the incorporated and unincorporated areas . C . "Authority" shall mean the Alameda County Waste Management Authority. D . "Board of Supervisors" shall mean the Alameda County Board of Supervisors . E . "Buy-Back Program" shall mean a program to purchase recyclable supplies , materials or goods from the public. F . "Charter" shall mean the Alameda County Charter as amended by this Act . G . "CIWMA" shall mean the California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989, presently codified as California Public Resources Code Sections 40000 et seq. H . "Commercial Recycling Program" shall mean a program to collect , purchase, receive, process, and/or market discarded materials generated by businesses or institutions, public or private, for the purpose of recycling said discarded materials; and shall include a Recycling Education Program to encourage the participation of said businesses or institutions. I . "Compostable materials" shall mean nontoxic materials collected for composting, including, but not limited to, plant debris, putrescibles, wood and soils . J . "Composting" means the controlled biological decomposition of organic materials that are separated from the discarded materials stream. K. "Composting Program" shall mean a program to collect , purchase, receive, process, and/or market compostable materials, or co-compost said compostable materials with manures, dairy discards, or fish processing discards, with the aim of producing a nontoxic finished product usable as a compost , soil amendment, landfill cover, or potting soil . L . "Construction and Demolition Debris Recycling Program" shall mean a program to collect , purchase, receive, process, and/or market discarded materials generated in the construction and/or demolition of improvements to real property. M . "Consumer Price Index" shall mean the index for the San Francisco Bay Area issued by the United States Department of Labor. N . "County" shall mean the government of Alameda County, including any department , board, commission, agency or duly authorized official thereof . 16 0. "Discarded materials , " "discarded materials supply" and "discards" shall mean materials that a person, business, industry, or institution has delivered to a disposal facility, or has set in or next to a receptacle that is regularly emptied for disposal , or has abandoned in a public place, but shall not be construed to mean materials that must be handled as hazardous or infectious waste; and shall be composed of the following categories : 1 . "Chemicals , " including , but not limited to, recyclable and/or reusable solvents , paints, motor oil , and lubricants; 2 . "Crushables , " including , but not limited to, rock, ceramics, concrete, and nonreusable brick; 3 . "Glass, " including , but not limited to, glass containers and window glass; 4 . "Manures , " including, but not limited to, sewage sludge that has been dewatered, treated or chemically fixed, and livestock and horse manure; S . "Metals , " both ferrous and nonferrous , including cans, parts from abandoned vehicles , plumbing, fences , metal doors and screens , and any other discarded metal objects; 6. "Paper , " including, but not limited to, newsprint , ledger paper, computer paper, corrugated cardboard and mixed paper; 7. "Plant debris, " including, but not limited to, leaves , cuttings, and trimmings from trees, shrubs and grass; B. "Plastics , " including, but not limited to, beverage containers , plastic packaging , tires, and plastic cases of consumer goods such as telephones or electronic equipment; 9. "Putrescibles, " including, but not limited to, garbage, offal , and animal , fruit and vegetable debris; 10. "Reusable goods, " including intact or repairable home or industrial appliances, household goods, and clothing; intact materials in demolition debris, such as lumber or bricks; building materials such as doors , windows, cabinets, and sinks; business supplies and equipment; lighting fixtures; and any other item that can be repaired or used again as is; 11 . "Soils, " including, but not limited to, excavation soils from barren or developed land, and excess soils from yards; 12 . "Textiles, " including, but not limited to, nonreusable clothing, upholstery and pieces of fabric; and 13 . "Wood, " including, but not limited to, nonreusable lumber and pallets. P. "Disposal facility" shall mean a facility to receive, purchase, 17 process, incinerate and/or landfill discarded materials . 0. "Double majority of the. cities" shall mean a majority of the cities representing a majority of the population in the incorporated areas of Alameda County. R . "Drop-Off Program" shalt mean a program to accept the donation of recyclable materials at a fixed site for the purpose of recycling said materials . S. "Hazardous waste" shall mean any material defined as hazardous waste by California Health and Safety Code Section 25117, or by any successor statute thereto, but notwithstanding said section or successor statute shall include ash and/or residue from an incinerator . T . " Incinerator" shall mean a facility that burns , as a means of disposal and/or energy production, refuse, refuse-derived fuel , any material recovered from a mixed supply of discarded materials , any type of plastic, and/or any type of hazardous waste, but shall not mean a facility dedicated to burning infectious waste or potentially infectious waste. U. " Infectious waste" shall mean any material defined as infectious waste by California Health and Safety Code Section 25117. 5 , or by any successor statute thereto. V. "Landfill " shall mean a facility that buries discards as a means of disposal . W. "Municipal recycling programs" shall mean recycling programs within a municipality, or recycling programs administered as a joint effort between municipalities . X . "Municipality" shalt mean a city or sanitary district located in Alameda County. T . "Postconsumer discards" shalt mean finished materials which would have been disposed of as discarded materials, having completed their life cycle as consumer items, and does not include manufacturing discards . Z. "Recyclable Material Recovery Program" shall mean a program to receive,. separate, and process mixed discarded materials for the purpose of removing materials which will later be used in the fabrication or manufacture of recycled products . AA. "Recycle" or "recycling" shall mean a process by which any good, material , supply or other object , which otherwise would be wasted, is recycled, reused, salvaged, or.. otherwise retrieved, collected, processed and/or marketed for return to use by society, either in its original form or in a new form; but shall not mean, with the exception of compost used for landfill cover, a program for landfilting or incinerating . Be . "Recycled product" shall mean a product, good, material , or supply, no 18 less than fifty percent (50X) of the total weight of which consists of secondary and postconsumer discards with not less than ten percent ( 10X) of its total weight consisting of postconsumer discards; or any product , good, material or supply which has been diverted from the supply of discarded materials by refurbishing and marketing said product , good, material or supply without substantial change to its original form. CC. "Recycled Product Market Development Program" shall mean a program to create or improve markets for recycled products , including, but not Limited to, one that facilitates the exchange of information between potential sources and users of recycled products; supports the development of techniques , systems, and practices of incorporating recycled materials into finished products; encourages enterprises that use recycled materials in place of non- recycled materials; and/or assists in the establishment of cooperative arrangements or organizations for marketing or purchasing recycled products . DD . "Recycling Board" shalt mean the Alameda County Source Reduction and Recycling Board established pursuant to this Act . EE . "Recycling Education Program" shall mean a program to promote participation in recycling programs and/or disseminate information about the benefits of recycling; and encouraging sound consumption and disposal practices by using language and concepts consistent with achieving a sustainable environment . FF . "Recycling Fund" shall mean the Alameda County Recycling Fund established pursuant to this Act . GG. "Recycling Plan" shall mean the Alameda County Recycling Plan established pursuant to this Act . HH . "Recycling programs" shalt mean Buy-Back Programs , Commercial Recycling Programs, Composting Programs, Construction and Demolition Debris Recycling Programs , Drop-Off Programs, Recyclable Material Recovery Programs, Recycled Product Market Development Programs , Recycled Product Purchase Preference Programs, Recycling Education Programs , Residential Recycling Programs, Salvage Programs, Source Reduction Programs, and/or research and planning to implement any of said programs . ll . "Refuse" shall mean mixed discarded materials that are disposed of by landfilling or incineration, including, but not limited to, discarded materials that have been contaminated and thus rendered non- recyclable during the disposal process, either by being mixed during compaction or by any other process, and discarded products of a manufacturing process which combines natural resources in a manner which renders said resources unrecoverable. JJ . "Residential Recycling Program" shall mean a program to collect at Least three (3) different kinds of materials, from at least two ( 2) different categories of discarded materials, by means of one ( 1 ) or more containers , separate from conventional garbage containers, where said recyclable materials are placed by residents at the curb or an 19 equivalent location; and shall include a Recycling Education Program to encourage the participation of residents . KK. "Salvage Program" shall mean a program to collect , purchase, receive, process and/or market any fabricated good, material , and/or supply for reuse. L.L . "Secondary discards" shall mean finished products , or fragments of finished products , of a manufacturing process which has converted a resource into a commodity of real economic value, and includes postconsumer discards; but shall not include excess virgin resources of said manufacturing process, such as fibrous wood discards generated during the manufacturing process , including fibers recovered from waste water , trimmings of paper machine rolls (mill broke) , wood slabs , chips, sawdust , or other wood residue. MM . "Source Reduction Program" shall mean a program that results in a net reduction in the generation of discarded materials , including , but not Limited to, a program to reduce the use of non- recyclable materials and hazardous waste; replace disposable materials and products with reusable materials and products; reduce packaging; reduce the amount of plant debris generated; reduce the amount of household hazardous waste generated; establish refuse collection rate structures with incentives to reduce the amount of refuse that generators produce; increase the efficiency of the use of paper, cardboard, glass, metal , plastic, and other materials in the manufacturing process; and/or maintain public education programs to accomplish any of these ends; but shall not be construed to include any steps taken after the material is discarded. NN . "waste" shall mean discarded materials that have been rendered valueless by being incinerated, 'buried, contaminated, or otherwise destroyed; or the act of incinerating, burying, contaminating, or otherwise destroying the value of discarded materials . SUBSECTION 64. 160: EFFECTIVE DATE Unless otherwise specified in this Act , the provisions of this Act shall take effect on the date it is accepted for filing by the California Secretary of State. SUBSECTION 64 . 170: EFFECT ON OTHER COUNTY LAWS No provision of this Act shall be construed to bar the enforcement of any existing County ordinances or regulations where the subject matter of said ordinances or regulations is wholly or partly the same as that of this Act , or to bar the enactment of any future such County ordinances and regulations . All County ordinances or regulations involving the subject matter of this Act shall be construed to further the purposes of this Act . SUBSECTION 64 . 180 : STATUS OF EXISTING CHARTER PROVISIONS 20 Any provision of the Alameda County Charter in effect prior to the effective date of this Act which conflicts in any way with any provision of this Act is hereby declared to be amended by implication. No such existing provision of said charter shall be construed to affect the application of any provision of this Act in a manner inconsistent with the purposes of this Act . SUBSECTION 64 . 190: SEVERABILITY If any subsection, paragraph , subparagraph , sentence, clause, or word of this Act is held unconstitutional or otherwise invalid, either on its face or as applied, the invalidity of said part or application thereof shall not affect the validity of the other parts of this Act , or the applications thereof ; and to that end the parts and applications of this Act shall be deemed severable. It is hereby declared, notwithstanding any finding that a part or application of this Act is unconstitutional or otherwise invalid, that each of the parts of this Act would have been enacted separately. 21 ! COUNTY COUNSEL'S ANALYSIS OF MEASL._ D ' Measure D, if approved by a majority of the voters, will amend the Alameda County Charter to provide a Source Reduction and Recycling Plan, which is intended to conform to the California Integrated Waste Management Act. This already existing state Act requires all California cities and counties to plan, fund, and implement a source reduction and recycling program. Measure D includes programs to: (1) encourage reduction of landfill refuse through public education campaigns, (2) change consumer habits and promote conservation of paper products, (3) provide residential and commercial -` recycling programs, and (4) encourage recycled materials markets. The measure prohibits all incineration of refuse within Alameda County. The measure institutes a $6 per ton surcharge on refuse disposed of in landfills. Under this measure, the Board of Supervisors is required to ensure the collection of this surcharge, which will be passed on to residents and businesses. The fees so -collected will be paid to a Recycling Fund estab- lished pursuant to this measure. Eighty percent of the Fund monies are to be apportioned on a per capita basis to municipalities for the planning and implementation of residential and/or commercial recycling programs. The remaining funds are for the development and implementation of a source reduction program and for administration expenses of the measure's provisions which, after a start-up period of 28 months, are not to exceed 370 of total funds. Administration of this measure is by an eleven-member Recycling Board, to be appointed by the Board of Supervisors and the County's Waste Management Authority, for a term of two years. Compensation of each Recycling Board member may not exceed $3,000 annually. The Recycling Board will be a subsidiary of the Waste Management Authority, or, if not so accepted by the Authority, will be established as a separate entity within the County government. The effect of the measure on existing law is uncertain; if. there are legal challenges, the courts may prevent portions of the measure from taking effect on the grounds that some of its provisions appear to conflict with the California Integrated Waste Management Act or impinge on the powers of cities. For example, the $6 per ton surcharge may violate the provisions of the Act, which require that fees imposed be based upon the types or amount of waste and the actual costs of. implementing waste management plans. The measure permits cities to avoid the obligation to establish residential and commercial recycling programs by choosing not to seek recycling funds. By including cities within its definition of "Alameda County," the measure's countywide restrictions and regulations, including its ban on incinerators, ra � the $G p e er ton surcharge, skid she required /5% reuuctlua in refuse at cne source, appear to affect even those cities which choose not to seek recycling board funds. This apparent attempt to regulate activities within cities in ways not required by the Act appears to violate provisions of the California Constitution relating to the powers of municipalities. KELVIN H. BOOTY, JR. COUNTY COUNSEL The above statement is an impartial analysis of Measure D. If you desire a copy of the measure, please call the Elections Official's office at 272-6973 and a copy will be mailed to you at no cost to you.