Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 8.3 - 1525 Updated Master Fee Schedule for Parks and C Page 1 of 3 STAFF REPORT CITY COUNCIL DATE: July 18, 2017 TO: Honorable Mayor and City Councilmembers FROM: Christopher L. Foss, City Manager SUBJECT: Amendments to the Master Fee Schedule for Parks and Community Services and Discussion on Non-Profit Rates Prepared by: Andrew Freeman Jr., Business Services Manager EXECUTIVE SUMMARY: The City Council will consider amending the Master Fee Schedule to include fees for Parks and Community Services that were deferred at the June 20, 2017 City Council Meeting. The City Council will also discuss future rate setting for non -profit use of facilities. STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Adopt the Resolution Amending the Fiscal Year 2017-18 Master Fee Schedule; and provide direction on non-profit facility rental rates. FINANCIAL IMPACT: In Fiscal Year 2017-18 Parks and Community Services is budgeted to generate $4.9 million in revenues and incur $11.1 million in expenses, resulting in a $6.2 million subsidy from the General Fund. Fee adjustments included in this amen dment to the Master Fee Schedule are reflected and included in the FY 2017 -2018 budget. DESCRIPTION: At the June 20, 2017 meeting, the City Council adopted an update to the citywide Master Fee Schedule. The Parks and Community Services fees that were included in the update were deferred so that a broader policy discussion could be held regarding the setting of non-profit facility rental rates. Staff had proposed to set the non-profit facility use rate at the same rate paid by residents. Background The Parks and Community Services Department (PCS) offers a multitude of services including field and facility space for rental use (e.g., community rooms, picnic areas and tennis courts); programs and activities related to aquatics, sports, youth and senior programs; and special events such as St. Patrick’s Day Festival and Splatter to support quality of life for the Dublin community. PCS programs and services are primarily Page 2 of 3 supported by the General Fund; rental and registration fees help to offset Ge neral Fund support for these programs and services. Annually, Staff undertakes a review of the expenditures and revenues of various Department programs to assess if fee adjustments are necessary. Based on these financial findings and survey of local markets, fees are adjusted within cost or market ranges. The City Council established a user fee cost recovery policy, Resolution No. 160-12, that specifies annual adjustments to fees for services provided by the City (Attachment 1). Additionally, City Council granted, through Resolution 111-16 adopted June 21, 2016, the Parks and Community Services Pricing Policy (Attachment 2) which allows the PCS Director to modify fees for existing programs at or below 20 percent and then document such modifications in the Master Fee Schedule updates conducted each year. In addition, the City Council authorized the PCS Director to establish rates during the Fiscal Year for new programs and document such additions as part of the annual Master Fee Schedule process. Notable Updates to PCS Fees The updates to the PCS Master Fee Schedule include fee adjustments for programs within the Director’s 20 percent range, along with an adjustment to after school program fees to fully recover direct costs and a portion of administrative costs. Demand for after school programs continues to be steady to support participation and additional cost recovery. The City’s after school program has exceeded 1,000 registrations over the past two Fiscal Years. The proposed change to the aft erschool full session fee for residents is an increase of $153 from the prior year (from $510 to $663). This rate remains below the fee charged by after school provider EDCC. The City’s proposed fee for residents is $2.83 per hour ($663 registration cost/13 weeks/18 hours per week), while EDCC cost for care is $5.27 per hour ($485 per month/4 weeks/23 hours per week). Other fee adjustments remain within the surrounding area market average and assist in closing the gap between expenditures and revenues in General Fund allocation for PCS programs and services. Discussion on Non-Profit Facility Use Rates Staff requested deferment of fees at the June 20 meeting so that the City Council could provide direction to Staff on the non-profit facility rental rates. At the June 19, 2017, Parks and Community Services Commission meeting, Staff presented the fee adjustments and noted the proposed increases to non-profit facility use rates. The Commission expressed concerns regarding the proposed facility renta l fees for non- profits and stated that they understand the need to increase fees and not operate at a loss; however, it is important to also recognize the benefit the non-profit organizations provide to the community. The Commission did not express any concerns with the other proposed fee amendments. Currently, non-profit rates for facility use are extremely low and subsidized by the City, which is estimated at $100,000 annually based on the resident rate paid in Fiscal Year 2015-16. For example, the rate at the Civic Center for use of the Regional Meeting Room is free during the day and $68 per hour if used for fundraising purposes. Use of the Shannon Center Ambrose Hall is free during the day, is $85 per hour in the evening for meetings and $188 per hour when used for fundraising. A resident renting those Page 3 of 3 same facilities would pay $90 per hour and $250 per hour, respectively regardless of time of day. With the start of the City’s update to the User Fee Study by MGT Consulting, Staff believes that deferring any decision on rates for non-profit facility use would be appropriate until additional market information can be obtained. This study will also allow Staff to not only consider amendments to non-profit facility rental rates, but changes to facility rental rates overall. Staff is not recommending specific changes to facility rental rates and policy with this report, but is seeking policy guidance on the setting of the non-profit rates. Specifically, Staff wants direction on the following options: 1) Keep the non-profit rates consistent with the current practice. This will likely result in a greater subsidy over the long term. 2) Adjust the rates to a certain percent of the resident rate. This will result in a partial cost recovery for facility use by these groups. 3) Set the non-profit rates at the same rate as the resident rate. This will result in a greater cost recovery. The work with MGT is expected to be completed in December 2017. As a result of the work currently in-progress by MGT, Staff recommends the fees for facility rental use remain unchanged at this time. Moving forward Staff will continue its work with MGT to refine pricing for facility rental use and apply City Council direction on evaluating non -profit facility rental rates. With City Council approval of this direction, Staff will present these finding to the Parks and Community Services Commission for review in early 2018, and then present the report to City Council for approval. NOTICING REQUIREMENTS/PUBLIC OUTREACH: None. ATTACHMENTS: 1. Resolution 160-12 - User Fee Cost Recovery Policy 2. Parks and Community Services Pricing Policy 3. Resolution Amending Fiscal Year 2017-18 Master Fee Schedule 4. Exhibit A to the Resolution - Fiscal Year 2017-18 Parks and Community Services Amendments to the Master Fee Schedule RESOLUTION NO. 160 - 12 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN ESTABLISHING A USER FEE COST RECOVERY POLICY WHEREAS, on June 7, 2011, the City Council authorized the City Manager to execute an agreement with Capital Accounting Partners to conduct a User Fee Study and a Cost Allocation Plan; and WHEREAS, the purpose of the User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Plan was to determine the full cost of providing fee-related services, including City-wide indirect costs; and WHEREAS, the User Fee Study and Cost Allocation Plan were prepared and submitted to the City Manager by Capital Accounting Partners in June 2012; and WHEREAS, the City Council wishes to establish a general policy for establishment of general fees and recovery of related costs; and WHEREAS, the City Council desires to have within its policy procedures for the regular updating of general fees and charges. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Dublin does hereby adopt the User Fee Cost Recovery Policy attached hereto as Exhibit A. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 4th day of September 2012, by the following vote: AYES: Councilmembers Biddle, Hart, Hildenbrand, Swalwell, and Mayor Sbranti NOES: None ABSENT: None ABSTAIN: None Mayor ATTEST: a/i/OZIGCLC City Clerk Reso No. 160-12,Adopted 9-4-12, Item 7.1 Page 1 of 1 City of Dublin User Fee Cost Recovery Policy Resolution—Exhibit A) Measuring the cost of government services is useful for a variety of purposes, including setting user fees and performance measurement/benchmarking. Ongoing Review It is planned that a comprehensive user fee study should be conducted at least every five years to assure that user fees reflect the City's underlying costs. The last such study was completed in fiscal year 2011-12. Annual Increase User fees established as part of a Master Fee Schedule will be increased each July 1 to keep pace with increases in the City's costs. In years between comprehensive user fee studies, the increase should be calculated based on changes in the preceding December Consumer Price Index (Bureau of Labor Statistics, San Francisco-Oakland Urban Wage Earners and Clerical Workers). The resulting calculation for each fee shall be rounded down to the nearest whole dollar. Applicability This User Fee Cost Recovery Policy applies to all general user fees and charges for services established in accordance with an adopted Master Fee Schedule. Parks & Community Services shall establish its program related fees in accordance with the Parks & Community Services Pricing Policy as originally adopted September 21, 2010 and as may be subsequently amended. Impact Fees which fund capital improvements are not covered by this policy. Cost Recovery Levels Costs should not be the sole consideration in determining how much the City will charge for services it provides. However, absent reasons to the contrary,the City will set user fees at a level to recover the total cost of delivering the related services, including direct costs, departmental administration costs, and City-wide indirect costs. Offsetting revenues should be considered when determining the total cost. Revenue from each user fee should not exceed the related reasonable total cost of providing the related services. It is appropriate for certain user fees to be established at a level below the related total cost of delivering the related services. The following factors will be considered when determining the appropriate cost recovery level: Community-wide vs. special benefit- The use of general purpose revenue is appropriate for community-wide services while user fees are appropriate for services that are of special benefit to individuals or groups. Full cost recovery is not always appropriate for special benefits. Service recipient vs. service driver- Particularly for services associated with regulated activities (development review, code enforcement), from which the community primarily benefits, cost recovery from the"driver"of the need for the service (applicant, violator) is appropriate. City of Dublin User Fee Cost Recovery Policy Resolution— Exhibit A) Consistency with City public policies and objectives - City policies and Council goals focused on long term improvements to community quality of life may impact desired fee levels as fees can be used to change community behaviors, promote certain activities or provide funding for pursuit of specific community goals (e.g., health and safety, environmental stewardship, renewable energy, economic development). Impact on demand (elasticity) - Pricing of services can significantly impact demand. At full cost recovery, for example, the City is providing services for which there is a genuine market not over-stimulated by artificially low prices. Conversely, high cost recovery may negatively impact lower income groups and this can work against public policy outcomes if the services are specifically designed to serve particular groups. Discounted rates and surcharges - Rates may be discounted to accommodate lower income groups or groups who are the target of the service, such as senior citizens or residents. Higher rates are considered appropriate for non-residents to further reduce general fund subsidization of services. Feasibility of collection - It may be impractical or too costly to establish a system to appropriately identify and charge each user for the specific services received. The method of assessing and collecting fees should be as simple as possible in order to reduce the administrative cost of collection For fees that are established at a level less than full cost recovery, the City Council may desire to examine the rationale for these deviations, and direct Staff to explore the appropriateness. Contractor Hourly Rates When City contractors provide services to other governments, businesses or individuals, their time should be charged at direct labor cost, including benefits, plus a mark-up percentage representing City administrative overhead. The markup percentage(s) shall remain in effect until the next comprehensive fee study. Definitions Direct costs—those costs that can be specifically identified with a particular cost objective, such as street maintenance, police protection. Indirect costs—those costs not readily quantifiable with a direct operating program, but rather, are incurred for a joint purpose that benefits more than one cost objective. Common examples of indirect cost functions include accounting, purchasing, legal services, personnel administration and building maintenance. Although indirect costs are generally not directly linked with direct cost programs, their cost should be included as part of the total cost of providing specific services. Administration and Billing The method of assessing and collecting user fees should be as simple as possible in order to minimize inconvenience to the users and to minimize the City's administrative cost of collection. The cost recovery level established by the City for each fee should be sensitive to the "market" rate for such services provided by other governments, non-profit organizations, companies and individuals. Exhibit A— Page 2 City of Dublin User Fee Cost Recovery Policy Resolution—Exhibit A) However, the rates charged by others will not be the primary criteria for setting City user fees because there are many factors affecting how other communities and organizations set their rates, including: Planned cost recovery level What costs are included in calculated total cost The last time a comprehensive user fee study was performed The level of service provided Fees should be charged to all entities using City services including Federal, State and County jurisdictions unless exempt by law. The City Manager may exempt or reduce fees where it is in the City's best interest to do so, and in accordance with business need. When new fees become desired or necessary before the next comprehensive fee study, they will be established at a level based on estimated direct labor cost, including benefits, plus a markup representing City administrative overhead, which will be calculated as part of each comprehensive fee study and remain in effect until the next such fee study. The new fees shall be added to the City's Master Fee Schedule. The City Council will approve the Master Fee Schedule each year prior to its July 1 effective date. It will then be made available to the public on the City's website. Exhibit A— Page 3 Pricing Policy for Parks and Community Services Programs, Facilities, and Field Use 1. The City Council shall set Parks and Community Services programs, facilities and field use fees (“Parks and Community Services Fees”) annually as part of the adoption of the City’s Master Fee Schedule. 2. The City Council shall approve, by resolution, Parks and Community Services Fees, and shall approve, by resolution, cost sharing, when applicable, for programs offered via contract providers. 3. The Parks and Community Services Commission shall be given an opportunity to review the Parks and Community Services Department’s (“Department”) program fees annually prior to submission to City Council for approval. 4. The City Council will review and adopt cost recovery targets for the Department as part of annual budget process. 5. The Department Director, in his or her sole discretion, may adjust fees outside of the annual process by up to 20% in a fiscal year. Any revisions and/or changes shall be documented as part of the next Master Fee Schedule adoption. 6. The fees for non-residents for both programs and facility rentals shall be established at a minimum of 20% higher than fees for Dublin residents, unless an exception is made via the City Council adopted Master Fee Schedule. 7. The Director, in his or her sole discretion, may has establish rates for new classes (initiated after adoption of the annual Master Fee Schedule) and offer reduced fees such as introductory rates, early registration, family discounts and coupon discounts, to promote new recreation programs or resurrect existing ones. 8. Previously, the City Council adopted fee schedules with associated “use policies” as separate actions. Now, the City Council shall adopt Parks and Community Services Fees one time per year as part of the Master Fee Schedule. 2657409.1 ATTACHMENT 1 RESOLUTION NO. XX - 17 A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * AMENDING THE MASTER FEE SCHEDULE WHEREAS, the California Constitution authorizes local government to recover the reasonable costs of providing services; and WHEREAS, the City processes various permits, applications, and licenses, and offers various recreational program and facility rental opportunities; and WHEREAS, on September 4, 2012 the City Council approved Resolution 160-12 Establishing a User Fee Cost Recovery Policy that specifies annual adjustments to fees for services provided by the City; and WHEREAS, on June 20, 2017 the City Council reviewed the citywide FY 2017-18 Updated Master Fees Schedule; and WHEREAS, consideration of all revised Parks and Community Services fees were deferred until such time a thorough evaluation of the proposed policy changes reflected in the revised fees, including facility rental fee changes, could be conducted; and WHEREAS, Parks and Community Services has prepared amendments to the Master Fee Schedule, including updated pricing for programs and services for FY 2017 -18 while keeping facility use rates at the same rates they were for FY 2016-17. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, the City Council of the City of Dublin does hereby amend the Master Fee Schedule to include Parks and Community Services fees for FY 2017-18 as Exhibit A. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the new fees identified in said Master Fee Schedule for Parks and Community Services shall be effective immediately. PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 18th day of July 2017, by the following vote: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: ______________________________ Mayor ATTEST: _________________________________ City Clerk CITY OF DUBLIN PARKS AND COMMUNITY SERVICES MASTER FEE SCHEDULE, FY 2017-18 EXHIBIT A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 Section 10.1: Parks & Recreation Program Fees - Activity Fees** Family Programs FP1 After School Recreation/Middle School Union Full Session Resident $510 Non-Resident $612 Resident $663 Non-Resident $796 FP2 After School Recreation/Middle School Union Early Release Pass (formerly 20-day pass)Resident $280 Non-Resident $336 Resident $192 Non-Resident $230 FP3 After School Recreation/Middle School Union Late Fee (per minute)Resident $1 Non-Resident $1 Flat Fee $10 Plus $1 each minute FP4 Camp Dublin One week session Resident $212 Non-Resident $254 No Change FP5 Camp Sunrise, Camp Kolb, Camp Stager and Camp Dublin Sports Grounds One week session Resident $72 Non-Resident $86 No Change FP6 Glen the Guide Nature Camp One week session Resident $212 Non-Resident $254 No Change FP7 Camp Connector AM/PM Connector Resident $35 Non-Resident $42 Resident $40 Non-Resident $48 FP8 Camp Connector Lunch Connector Resident $20 Non-Resident $24 No Change FP9 Dublin L.E.A.D. Program Resident $99 Non-Resident $119 No Change Preschool Programs PP1 Dublin Preschool - 3-Year Old Classes 2 days per week Resident $437 Non-Resident $524 Resident $489 Non-Resident $587 PP2 Dublin Preschool - 4-Year Old Classes 2 days per week Resident $463 Non-Resident $556 Resident $519 Non-Resident $623 All Parks & Recreation Program Fees are subject to 20% increase based on the Parks & Community Services Pricing Policy. *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 1 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 PP3 Dublin Preschool - 3-Year Old Classes 3 days per week Resident $653 Non-Resident $784 Resident $731 Non-Resident $877 PP4 Dublin Preschool - 4-Year Old Classes 3 days per week Resident $686 Non-Resident $823 Resident $768 Non-Resident $922 PP5 Dublin Preschool - 4-Year Old Classes 4 days per week Resident $1,039 Non-Resident $1,246 Resident $1,164 Non-Resident $1,397 PP6 Little Lovies 8 classes Resident $176 Non-Resident $211 Resident $197 Non-Resident $236 PP7 Camp Shamrock 1 week session-(5 days)Resident $110 Non-Resident $132 Resident $123 Non-Resident $148 PP8 Dublin Preschool Non-Participation Daily rate Resident $65 Non-Resident $65 No Change Senior Center Programs SC1 Activity Fee Per activity Resident & Non-Resident $3-$15 No Change SC2 Special Luncheons Per Luncheon Resident $10-$20 Non-Resident $12-$24 No Change SC3 Dances Pre-Registrations Resident $10-$25 Non-Resident $13-$30 No Change SC4 Dances At the Door Resident & Non-Resident $15-$40 No Change SC5 Trips and Tours Local Trips (4-hour trip)Resident $20-$25 Non-Resident $24-$30 No Change SC6 Trips and Tours - Additional fee For each hour over 4-hr/person Resident & Non-Resident $3.50-$5 No Change SC7 Trips and Tours Local Trips (8-hour trip)Resident $35-$45 Non-Resident $42-$54 No Change SC8 Trips and Tours Distant Trips (8-10 hour trip)Resident $40-$50 Non-Resident $48-$60 No Change Sports Programs SP1 Basketball Adult League Resident $475-$640 Non-Resident $570-$768 Resident $499-699 Non-Resident $599-$839 SP2 Bocce Ball Adult Co-ed League Resident $155 Non-Resident $186 Resident $165-$175 Non-Resident $198-210 SP3 Softball Adult League Resident $475-$630 Non-Resident $570-$756 Resident $499-$699 Non-Resident $599-$839 SP4 Sports League Late Registration Fee Resident $25 Non-Resident $25 No Change Adult Sports *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 2 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 SP6 Junior Warriors Basketball League - Winter Season Resident $162 Non-Resident $194 Resident $183 Non-Resident $220 SP7 Junior Warriors Basketball League - Summer Season Resident $106 Non-Resident $127 Resident $127 Non-Resident $152 SP8 Teeball League Resident $109 Non-Resident $131 Resident $120 Non-Resident $144 SP9 Basketball Clinics Resident $51-$64 Non-Resident $61-$77 No Change Wave (Effective 12/21/16) WV1 Children under 2 N/A Resident and Non- Resident Fee $3 WV2 Recreational Swimming Under 40"Resident Fee $13 Non-Resident Fee $15 No Change WV3 Recreational Swimming Over 40"Resident Fee $15 Non-Resident Fee $17 No Change WV4 Group Resident & Non-Resident Fee $12 No Change WV5 Recreational Swimming Under 40"Resident Fee $11 Non-Resident $13 No Change WV6 Recreational Swimming Over 40"Resident Fee $13 Non-Resident Fee $15 No Change WV7 Group Resident & Non-Resident Fee $10 No Change WV8 Youth Swimming Lessons Per class rate $14 No Change WV9 Pre-School Swimming Lessons Per class rate $20 No Change WV10 Semi-Private Swimming Lessons Per class rate $35 No Change WV11 Private Swimming Lessons Per class rate $55 No Change WV12 Lap Swim/Water Walking $6 No Change WV13 Water Aerobics Per class rate N/A Resident and Non- Resident Fee $12 Contract Classes CF1 Interment Fees Cremation/Burial $330 No Change CF2 Interment Fees Earth Burial $1,533 No Change Section 10.3: Parks & Recreation Program Fees - Facility Rental Fees** Civic Center Rental (Council Chambers & Regional Meeting Room) FR1 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of meetings No Fee No Change Youth Sports Section 10.2: Parks & Recreation Program Fees - Cemetery Fees for Heritage & Cultural Arts Center** For all Contract Instructor Activities, Fees for Residents and for Non-Residents may vary. The fees are based on the contract agreements with each instructor and are subject to change at the discretion of the Parks & Community Services Director. Admission Fees (Partial Day) Admission Fees (Full Day) *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 3 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 FR2 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $68/hour No Change *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 4 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 FR3 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $90/hour Non-Resident $108/hour No Change FR4 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $120/hour Non Dublin-based Business $144/hour No Change Heritage Park & Museums Facility Rental - St. Raymond Church FR5 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations and Youth Sports Leagues Use during regular business hours for the purpose of meetings - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy) Setup/Takedown Fee Only of $14 per hour per Facility Attendant. Number of Attendants dependent on facilities used and the setup needs. No Change FR6 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations and Youth Sports Leagues Use During outside of business hours for the purpose of meetings - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy) $15/hour No Change FR7 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations and Youth Sports Leagues Used for the purpose of fundraising $45/hour No Change FR8 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $60/hour Non-Resident $72/hour No Change FR9 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $80/hour Non Dublin-based Business $96/hour No Change FR10 Individuals or Other Groups 6-Hour Package (includes Kolb Sunday School Barn)Resident $1,240 Non-Resident $1,488 No Change FR11 Individuals or Other Groups Each hour after 6-Hour Package (includes Kolb Sunday School Barn)Resident $230/hour Non-Resident $276/hour No Change Heritage Park & Museums Facility Rental - Kolb Sunday School Barn (Includes the use of the adjacent Picnic Area and a portion of the Park grounds) FR12 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations and Youth Sports Leagues Use during regular business hours for the purpose of meetings - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy) Setup/Takedown Fee Only of $14 per hour per Facility Attendant. Number of Attendants dependent on facilities used and the setup needs. No Change *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 5 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 FR13 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations and Youth Sports Leagues Use during outside of business hours for the purpose of meetings - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy) $43/hour No Change FR14 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations and Youth Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $128/hour No Change FR15 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $170/hour Non-Resident $204/hour No Change FR16 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $227/hour Non Dublin-based Business $272/hour No Change FR17 Individuals or Other Groups 6-Hour Package Resident $918 Non-Resident $1,101 No Change FR 18 Individuals or Other Groups After 6 hours Resident $170/hour Non-Resident $204/hour No Change Library Community and Program Room FR19 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of meetings No Fee No Change FR20 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $68/hour No Change FR21 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $90/hour Non-Resident $108/hour No Change FR22 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $120/hour Non Dublin-based Business $144/hour No Change Senior Center Facility Rental - Ballroom FR23 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of meetings $46/hour No Change FR24 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $139/hour No Change FR25 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $185/hour Non-Resident $222/hour No Change *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 6 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 FR26 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $246/hour Non Dublin-based Business $296/hour No Change Senior Center Facility Rental - Lounge FR27 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of meetings $12/hour No Change FR28 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $36/hour No Change FR29 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $48/hour Non-Resident $58/hour No Change FR30 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $64/hour Non Dublin-based Business $77/hour No Change Senior Center Facility Rental - Classroom A FR31 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of meeting $9/hour No Change FR32 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $28/hour No Change FR33 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $37/hour Non-Resident $44/hour No Change FR34 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $49/hour Non Dublin-based Business $59/hour No Change Senior Center Facility Rental - Meeting Room FR35 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of meeting $4/hour No Change FR36 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $13/hour No Change FR37 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $17/hour Non-Resident $20/hour No Change FR38 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $22/hour Non Dublin-based Business $27/hour No Change *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 7 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 Shannon Center Facility Rental - Ambrose Hall FR39 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use during regular business hours - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy) Setup/Takedown Fee Only of $14 per hour per Facility Attendant. Number of Attendants dependent on facilities used and the setup needs. No Change FR40 Ambrose HallPublic Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin- based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use Outside of Regular Business Hours - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy)$85/hour No Change FR41 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $188/hour No Change FR42 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $250/hour Non-Resident $300/hour No Change FR43 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $332/hour Non Dublin-based Business $400/hour No Change Shannon Center Facility Rental - Multipurpose Room FR44 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use during regular business hours - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy) Setup/Takedown Fee Only of $14 per hour per Facility Attendant. Number of Attendants dependent on facilities used and the setup needs. No Change FR45 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use outside of regular business hours - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy)$24/hour No Change FR46 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $53/hour No Change FR47 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $70/hour Non-Resident $84/hour No Change FR48 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $93/hour Non Dublin-based Business $112/hour No Change *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 8 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 Shannon Center Facility Rental - Classroom FR49 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use during regular business hours - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy) Setup/Takedown Fee Only of $14 per hour per Facility Attendant. Number of Attendants dependent on facilities used and the setup needs. No Change FR50 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use outside of regular business hours - (Please refer to the Facility Use Rental Policy)$14/hour No Change FR51 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Use for the purpose of fundraising $23/hour No Change FR52 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $30/hour Non-Resident $36/hour No Change FR53 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $40/hour Non Dublin-based Business $48/hour No Change Swim Center Pool Rentals SC1 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, and Sports Leagues Pool Use Fee $34/hour No Change SC2 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, and Sports Leagues Lifeguard Fee $12/hour/lifeguard No Change SC3 Individuals or Other Groups Pool Use Fee Resident $50/hour Non-Resident $60/hour No Change SC4 Individuals or Other Groups Lifeguard Fee Resident & Non-Resident $12/hour/lifeguard No Change SC5 Commercial Groups Pool Use Fee Resident $67/hour Non-Resident $80/hour No Change SC6 Commercial Groups Lifeguard Fee Resident & Non-Resident $12/hour/lifeguard No Change Stager Gym Facility Rental FR54 Dublin Sports League Organizations, Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations Resident Fee Only $40/hour No Change FR55 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $60/hour Non-Resident $72/hour No Change *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 9 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 FR56 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $80/hour Non Dublin-based Business $96/hour No Change Wave Rentals (Effective 12/21/16) WR1 Cabanas (3) 10'x10' structure with privacy screening, patio furniture & Cooler $60 No change WR2 Group Picnic Areas (5) shaded areas with picnic benches seating 50 $100 No change WR3 Luxury Lounges (10+) Portable shaded coverings with two lounges & cooler $40 No change WR4 Competition Pool, Natatorium, Children's Play Pool and Waterslide Tower Resident & Non-Profit $1,200 Non-Resident $1,440 Commercial $1,750 No change WR5 Children's Play Pool Resident & Non-Profit $330 Non-Resident $400 Commercial $500 No change WR6 Lower Level of Tower Resident & Non-Profit $380 Non-Resident $460 Commercial $560 No change WR7 Full Waterslide Tower Resident & Non-Profit $450 Non-Resident $540 Commercial $680 No change WR8 Natatorium Rental Resident & Non-Profit $280 Non-Resident $540 Commercial $680 No change WR9 Competition Pool Rental (during normal business hours) Resident & Non-Profit $280 Non-Residential $340 Commercial $410 No change WR10 Community Room Rental Resident & Non-Profit $170 Non-Resident $200 Commercial $260 No change WR11 Picnic Area Rental (added to other rental)Add-on Amenity, Flat $25/hr No change WR12 Additional Staff Add-on Staffing Charge where appropriate, Flat $30/hr No change Other Amenities & Services Pool/Amenity Rentals Shaded Space Rentals *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 10 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 WR13 Other Amenities & Services Amenity Charge/Additional Set-up Fee Add-on Facility Usee Fee where appropriate for use of amenities such as PA, Scoreboard, Water Polo Configuration, or other recreational amenities not included in standard rental fees No change *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 11 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 WR14 Wave Locker Fees Locker fees for the storage of guest items.Storage fee based on locker size $5-$15 No change Section 10.4: Parks & Recreation Program Fees - Picnic Area Rental Fees** Emerald Glen Park Picnic Area Rentals PR1 Emerald Glen Park - Area A (seats 56) $23/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $53/day No Change PR2 Emerald Glen Park - Area B (seats 48) $20/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $45/day No Change PR3 Emerald Glen Park - Area C (seats 96) $40/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $90/day No Change PR4 Emerald Glen Park - Areas ABC (seats 200) $83/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $188/day No Change PR5 Emerald Glen Park - Area D (seats 36) $15/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $34/day No Change PR6 Emerald Glen Park - Area E (seats 24) $10/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $23/day No Change PR7 Emerald Glen Park - Area A (seats 56)Resident $70/day Non-Resident $84/day No Change PR8 Emerald Glen Park - Area B (seats 48)Resident $60/day Non-Resident $72/day No Change PR9 Emerald Glen Park - Area C (seats 96)Resident $120/day Non-Resident $144/day No Change PR10 Emerald Glen Park - Areas ABC (seats 200)Resident $250/day Non-Resident $300/day No Change PR11 Emerald Glen Park - Area D (seats 36)Resident $45/day Non-Resident $54/day No Change PR12 Emerald Glen Park - Area E (seats 24)Resident $30/day Non-Resident $36/day No Change Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Individuals or Other Groups *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 12 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 PR13 Commercial Uses Emerald Glen Park - Area A (seats 56) Dublin-based Business $93/day Non Dublin-based Business $112/day No Change PR14 Emerald Glen Park - Area B (seats 48) Dublin-based Business $80/day Non Dublin-based Business $96/day No Change PR15 Emeral Glen Park - Area C (seats 96) Dublin-based Business $160/day Non Dublin-based Business $192/day No Change PR16 Emerald Glen Park - Areas ABC (seats 200) Dublin-based Business $333/day Non Dublin-based Business $400/day No Change PR17 Emerald Glen Park - Area D (seats 36) Dublin-based Business $60/day Non Dublin-based Business $72/day No Change PR18 Emerald Glen Park - Area E (seats 24) Dublin-based Business $40/day Non Dublin-based Business $48/day No Change Kolb Park Picnic Area Rentals PR19 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Kolb Park - Area A (seats 48) $20/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $45/day No Change PR20 Individuals or Other Groups Kolb Park - Area A (seats 48)Resident $60/day Non-Resident $72/day No Change PR21 Commercial Uses Kolb Park - Area A (seats 48) Dublin-based Business $80/day Non Dublin-based Business $96/day No Change Schaefer Ranch Park Picnic Area Rentals PR22 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues Schaefer Ranch Park - Area A (seats 64) $27/day Use for the Purpose of Fundraising $61/day No Change PR23 Individuals or Other Groups Schaefer Ranch Park - Area A (seats 64)Resident $80/day Non-Resident $96/day No Change PR24 Commercial Uses Schaefer Ranch Park - Area A (seats 64) Dublin-based Business $106/day Non Dublin-based Business $128/day No Change Commercial Uses Commercial Uses *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 13 of 14 Exhibit A #Item / Service Description / Unit Fees through 6/30/17 Fee Effective 7/1/17 Section 10.5: Parks & Recreation Program Fees - Sports Fields Rental Fees** SR1 Public Agencies, Dublin Youth Sports Leagues Sports Fields Rental - Turf Field $7/hour No Change SR2 Public Agencies, Dublin Youth Sports Leagues Sports Fields Rental - Synthetic Turf Field $25/hour No Change SR3 Public Agencies, Dublin Youth Sports Leagues Sports Fields Rental - Lighting Charge per hour $25.40/hour No Change SR4 Dublin Adult Sports Leagues, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations Sports Fields Rental - Turf Field $16.80/hour No Change SR5 Dublin Adult Sports Leagues, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations Sports Fields Rental - Synthetic Turf Field $50/hour No Change SR6 Dublin Adult Sports Leagues, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations Sports Fields Rental - Lighting Charge per hour $27.20/hour No Change SR7 Individual or Other Groups Sports Fields Rental - Turf Field Resident $21/hour Non-Resident $25.20/hour No Change SR8 Individual or Other Groups Sports Fields Rental - Synthetic Turf Field Resident $62.50/hour Non-Resident $104.70/hour No Change SR9 Individual or Other Groups Sports Fields Rental - Lighting Charge per hour Resident $34/hour Non-Resident $40.80/hour No Change SR10 Commercial Uses Sports Fields Rental - Turf Field Resident $33.60/hour Non-Resident $40.30/hour No Change SR11 Commercial Uses Sports Fields Rental - Synthetic Turf Field Resident $100/hour Non-Resident $250/hour No Change SR12 Commercial Uses Sports Fields Rental - Lighting Charge per hour Resident $54.40/hour Non-Resident $65.30/hour No Change Tennis Court Rentals TR1 Public Agencies, Dublin Chamber of Commerce, Dublin-based Charitable and Social Welfare Organizations, Homeowners Associations, and Sports Leagues $5/hour/Court No Change TR2 Individuals or Other Groups Resident $10/hour/Court Non-Resident $12/hour/Court No Change TR3 Commercial Uses Dublin-based Business $15/hour/Court Non Dublin-based Business $18/hour/Court No Change For all Facility Rentals, Picnic Area Rentals and the Sports Field Rentals a late charge and cancellation fees along with a security deposit will be charged in addition to the above fees. For Tournaments, an hourly Facility Attendant fee in addition to the rental fees will be charged. Please refer to the Sports Fields Use Policy for more information. *Local Fees and Charges not subject to annual adjustment based on Consumer Price Index (CPI) **Fees and Charges established by separate ordinance, State Law, or another agency and not subject to CPI adjustment Page 14 of 14 Exhibit A