Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 4.09 Universal Design Ord CITY CLERK File # D~~[Q]-~~ 1/1./0' t.J) AGENDA STATEMENT CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: October 2,2007 SUBJECT: Universal Design Ordinance 1\ Report prepared by Gregory Shreeve, Building Official Y' ATTACHMENTS: 1) Universal Design Ordinance RECOMMENDATI~. FINANCIAL ~2: 1) Waive reading and adopt Ordinance requiring Universal Design. An Ordinance on Universal Design will have a financial impact on the City due to the increased Staff time required to plan check, permit and inspect the dwellings. This impact will be offset when the City's valuation table in the City's Fee Schedule is amended to achieve cost recovery of plan check, permit and inspection costs. PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Background: The City of Dublin adopted the Housing Element of the General Plan in 2003. The Housing Element was certified by the State Department of Housing and Community Development, and contains a number of policies aimed at promoting equal housing opportunities for Dublin residents. Program E.2.1 of the Housing Element states that "the City will evaluate the feasibility of a Universal Design Ordinance that provides for greater adaptability and accessibility of housing for persons with disabilities." Universal Design is defined as the design of products and residential environments to be usable by all people, to the greatest extent possible, without the need for adaptation. or specialized modifications. Universal Design benefits persons of all ages and abilities, including seniors and persons with disabilities. The concept behind universal design is that, if desired, a new residence can be built with certain design features that will make living in that home easier for someone with limited mobility, strength, or functionality. Such features include door handles that are easier to grasp, doorways that are wider and easier to navigate through, electrical outlets that are located higher on the wall and easier to reach, and grab bars in baths and showers to provide stability and support. The guiding principles behind Universal Design are that the features should be useful to people with diverse abilities, easy to understand and utilize, require limited physical effort, and provide appropriate space and size regardless of the user's body size, posture, or mobility. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- COPY TO: Development Meeting Attendees Page 1 of2 ITEM NO. 1-. q G: IAgendas\2007\Universal Design\CCSR Universal Design Ordinance 10-2-07 2nd.DOC C-- In an effort to implement this program of the Housing Element, the City Council listed as a high priority goal in the 2006-2007 Goals and Objectives, the preparation of a Universal Design Ordinance for adoption as an amendment to the California Building Code requirements. Proposed Universal Design Ordinance The proposed Universal Design Ordinance requires projects in excess of 20 residential dwelling units (including duplex and triplex units) to meet the Universal Design Requirements. The Ordinance mandates that certain base universal design features be installed and mandates that other universal design features be offered. The mandatory-to-install items are as follows: . An accessible doorbell must be installed for an installed accessible entrance. . Grab bar reinforcements must be installed in powder rooms or bathrooms located on the primary entry level. . Faucets and handles not requiring tight grasping, pinching, or twisting of the wrist must be installed in powder rooms or bathrooms located on the primary entry level. . Sink controls not requiring tight grasping, pinching, or twisting of the wrist must installed when a kitchen is located on the primary entry level. . Hand-activated door hardware not requiring tight grasping, pinching, or twisting ofthe wrist. . Rocker light switches and controls or light switches and controls meeting ANSI A117.1 or the CBC chapter llA. · Receptacle outlets, lighting controls and environmental controls throughout the dwelling unit must comply with CBC Chapter 11 A or applicable provisions of the California Electrical Code. With regard to the mandatory-to-offer items, homebuyers would have the ability to purchase those items as an option from the developer/builder. This Ordinance will apply to 100% of the units in residential development projects in excess of 20 residential dwelling units. City Council Action of September 18, 2007 On September 18, 2007, the City Council introduced the Universal Design Ordinance requiring proj ects in excess of 20 single-family dwelling units (including duplex and triplex units) to meet certain Universal Design Requirements. This Ordinance will apply to 100% of the units in those projects. The Ordinance mandates that certain base universal design features be installed and mandates that other universal design features be offered. With regard to the mandatory-to-offer items, homebuyers would have the ability to purchase those items as an option from the developer/builder. In addition, the Ordinance has an "opt out clause". The "opt-out" clause permits the buyer of a unit to forgo any or all of the mandatory installation features. RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends that the City Council: 1) Waive reading and adopt Ordinance requiring Universal Design. Page 2 of2 'db'V ORDINANCE NO. XX-07 AN ORDINANCE OF THE CITY COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN ...................................................................................... ADDING CHAPTER 7.90 TO THE DUBLIN MUNICIPAL CODE RELATING TO UNIVERSAL DESIGN The City Council of the City of Dublin does hereby ordain as follows: Section 1. Addition of Chapter 7.90: Chapter 7.90 is hereby added to the Dublin Municipal Code to read as follows: CHAPTER 7.90 UNIVERSAL DESIGN 7.90.010 Purpose A. The purpose of the design guidelines established by this chapter is to enhance the full life cycle use of housing without regard to the physical abilities or disabilities of a home's occupants or guests in order to accommodate a wide range of individual preferences or physical abilities. B. The promotion and preservation ofthe public health, safety, and general welfare of the people of the City and the property situated therein have made necessary the adoption of a Universal Design Standard for dwellings in order to adequately safeguard life, health, property, and general welfare. C. The purpose of this 'chapter is not to create or otherwise establish or designate any particular class or groups of persons who will or should be especially protected or benefited by the terms ofthis chapter. 7.90.020 Findings. A. Pursuant to Health and Safety Code section 17959, the City Council of the City of Dublin hereby finds that the provisions of this Chapter are reasonably necessary because according to the City's Certified Housing Element, approximately 13 percent of the City's non-institutionalized residents have physical conditions that affect their abilities to live independently in conventional residential settings. Individuals with mobility difficulties may require special accommodations to their homes to allow for continued .independent living. B. The City Council ofthe City of Dublin hereby finds that the provisions of this Chapter are reasonably to enhance the full life cycle use of housing without regard to the physical abilities or disabilities of a home's occupants or guest in order to accommodate a wide range of individual preferences and functional abilities. C. Pursuant to Health and Safety Code section 17959, the City Council ofthe City of Dublin hereby finds that the provisions ofthis Chapter are substantially the same as the Model Universal Design Local Ordinance adopted by the Department of Housing and Community Development. Page 1 of 10 I Q-~-D7 if.i ~rvtU1+ /J.1f{) to 7.90.030 Definitions For the purpose of this Chapter, the following terms shall have the following definitions: Accessible: Consistent with or as defined by the California Building Code, Chapter11A. ANSI A1l7.1: The most current version of the "Standard on Accessible and Usable Buildings and Facilities", commonly known as "ICC/ANSI AI17.1", published by the International Code Council and American National Standards Institute, Inc. Bathroom: A room containing a water closet (toilet), lavatory(sink), and either a shower, bathtub, combination bathtub/shower, or both a shower and bathtub. It includes a compartmented bathroom in which the fixtures are distributed among interconnected rooms. CBC, Chapter llA: Chapter 11A of the California Building Code (located in Part 2, Title 24, California Code of Regulations), or its successor provisions. Common Use Room: A room commonly used by residents or guests to congregate. Condominium: As defined by the California Building Code. Custom-built home: A single family detached dwelling that is built to the owner's specifications and not part of a master plan check. Dwelling Unit: As defined by the California Building Code. Owner-Occupied: Any residential dwelling unit not intended, at the time of application for the building permit, to be occupied as a rental dwelling. Powder Room: A room containing a water closet (toilet) and lavatory (sink), but no bathtub or shower. It includes a compartmented powder room in which the fixtures are distributed among interconnected rooms. Primary Entry: The principal entrance used to enter a building or residential unit, as designated by the Building Official for purposes of compliance with this chapter. Rental: Any residential dwelling unit not intended, at the time of application for a building permit, to be occupied by the owner. Single-Family Residential Dwelling: Consistent with or as defined by the California Building Code. Substantial Rehabilitation: The reconstruction of the primary entry, hallway, or one bathroom or powder room on the route from the primary entry, when that reconstruction is required to be consistent with the most current version of the California Building Standards Code. Visit-able Residential Dwelling: A residential unit subject to the requirements ofthis chapter by virtue of being within the scope of this chapter a~ defined in section 7.90.040. Page 2 of 10 !; ofJ \0 7.90.040 Scope and Application A. Unit Coverage. All residential dwellings units that are a part of a residential development project in excess of 20 residential dwelling units for which an application for a new construction-building permit is submitted to the Building Division after the effective date ofthis chapter shall be Visit-able Residential Dwellings. B. Unit Types. New construction of all single-family, duplex, and triplex residential dwellings for which an application for a building permit is submitted to the Building Division after the effective date ofthis chapter, shall be subject to this chapter. C. Conditions of Approval. Any tentative map, conditional use permit, site development review or building permit master plan check subject to this chapter shall contain conditions sufficient to ensure compliance with the provisions of this chapter. 7.90.050 Exemptions A. When the applicant adequately demonstrates and the Building Official determines that compliance with any portion of any regulation under this chapter would create an undue hardship, or that equivalent facilitation is not available, an exception to that portion of the regulation may be granted. B. When the applicant adequately demonstrates and the Building Official determines that compliance with any portion of any regulation under this chapter would create an undue hardship due to topographical conditions ofthe site and/or due to the size ofthe site and/or other site constraints and/or legal constraints and that no equivalent facilitation is available, an exemption to that portion of the regulation may be granted. C. When the applicant adequately demonstrates and the Building Official determines that a residential dwelling unit is being reconstructed as a result of a disaster, an exemption to all or any portion of this chapter may be granted. D. This ordinance shall not be applicable to any residential structure constructed ifthe primary entry of that structure is above grade because the primary entry is located over subterranean or grade-level parking. 7.90.060 Standards: Primary Entrance: A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install: The following items for the accessible entrance on the primary entry level shall be installed. 1. Where at least one doorbell is provided for the accessible entry door, one that is between forty-two inches (42") and forty-eight inches (48") from the finished floor must be installed. B. New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: The following options for the accessible entrance on the primary entry level shall be offered and, if accepted, installed at the request and cost of the purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with section 7.90.140. 1. An exterior accessible route that is either: Consistent with the requirements ofCBC Chapter l1A; or not be less than forty inches (40") wide and not have a slope greater than one (1) uni~ vertical in twenty (20) units horizontal. Page 3 of 10 41J to 2. The accessible primary entrance that is consistent with the requirements ofCBC Chapter l1A. 3. The floor or landing at and on the exterior and interior side of the accessible entrance door that is either of the following: Consistent with the requirements ofCBC Chapter IIA; or the width of the level area on the side to which the accessible entrance door swings shall extend twenty-four inches (24") past the strike edge of the door. 4. The exterior accessible entry door that is either: Consistent with the requirements of CBC Chapter I1A, or has a thirty-four inch (34") net clear opening. 5. A second exterior door that is installed in a manner so that it is accessible as provided in this section with a thirty-two inch (32") net clear opening. 6. Where at least one eyehole is provided in the accessible entry door, one shall be at standard height and a second one that is between forty-two inches (42") and forty-four inches (44") from the finished floor. 7.90.070 Standards: Interior Routes: A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install: There are no mandatory installations related to Interior Routes in a Visit-able Residential Dwelling. B. New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: The following options for accessible interior routes on the primary entry level shall be offered and, if accepted, installed at the request and cost ofthe purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with section 7.90.140. 1. At least one accessible route through the hallways consistent with the requirements of CBC Chapter llA from the accessible entrance ofthe dwelling unit to the primary entry level powder room or bathroom, a common use room, and the kitchen iflocated on the primary entry level. 2. No sunken or raised area in the bathroom or powder room, the common use room, and the kitchen, if on the primary entry level, on an accessible route. 3. Handrails installed in a manner consistent with CBC Chapter llA on one or both sides of the accessible route, at the option of the purchaser/owner. 4. Handrail reinforcement installed on one or both sides ofthe accessible route. 5. An accessible route with a minimum width of forty-two inches (42"). A thirty-nine inch (39") hallway width may be provided when all doors leading to any bathroom, powder room, common use room, or kitchen, if on the primary entry level, that must be accessible have a minimum clear door opening of thirty- four inches (34"), and a thirty-six inch (36") hallway width may be provided when all doors leading to any bathroom, powder room, common use room, or kitchen on the primary entry level that must be accessible have a minimum clear door opening of thirty-six inches (36"). Page 4 of 10 5~\O 7.90.080 Standards: Primary Floor Powder RoomlBathroom Entry and Facilities A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install: When a powder room or bathroom is located on the primary entry level the following item(s) shall be installed in a Visit-able Residential Dwelling. 1. Grab bar reinforcement consistent with CBC Chapter llA for the water closet (toilet) and shower or bathtub. 2. Faucets and handles not requiring tight grasping, pinching, or twisting of the wrist and consistent with the requirements of CBC Chapter l1A. B. New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: The following options for the accessible bathroom or powder room on the route from the primary entrance shall be offered and, if accepted, installed at the request and cost ofthe purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with section 7.90.140. 1. At least one powder room or bathroom, at the option of the purchaser/owner, on the primary entry level of a Visit-able Residential Dwelling, which complies, with the requirements of CBC Chapter llA. 2. Clear space in the bathroom or powder room that is either: Consistent with the requirements of CBC Chapter l1A; or outside of the swing of the door and either a forty-eight inch circle, forty- eight-inches by sixty inches (48" x 60") or a sixty-inch (60") diameter circle, at the option of the purchaser/ owner. 3. A bathtub or shower meeting the requirements of ANSI AI17.1. 4. Grab bars installed in a manner consistent with CBC Chapter 11A for the water closet (toilet), shower/bath, or lavatory, or any combination thereof, at the option ofthe purchaser/owner. 5. A lavatory or sink installed consistent with CBC Chapter l1A. 6. A water closet (toilet) installed consistent with CBC Chapter l1A. 7. Removable cabinets under the lavatory/sink. 8. Where mirrors and towel fixtures are provided in the accessible bathroom or powder room, installation consistent with the requirements of CBC Chapter l1A. 7.90.090 Standards: Kitchen and Facilities A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install. When a kitchen is located on the primary entry level the following item(s) shall be installed in a Visit-able Residential Dwelling. 1. Sink controls not requiring tight grasping, pinching, or twisting of the wrist and consistent with the requirements of CBC Chapter llA B. New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: If there is a kitchen on the primary entry level, the following options shall be offered and, if accepted, installed at the request and cost of the purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with section 7.90.140. Page 5 of 10 &% \0 1. An accessible route to the kitchen, with a pathway through the kitchen to the stove, oven, or combination stove-oven consistent with the requirements ofCBC Chapter11A. 2. One or more ofthe following, at the purchaser/owner's option: At least a forty-eight inch by sixty-inch (48" x 60") clear space in front ofa stove at the base ofa U-shaped kitchen; or At least a thirty-inch by forty-eightinch (30" x 48") clear space in front ofthe sink (counting open access underneath, if available); or At least one eighteen-inch (18") wide breadboard and/or at least eighteen inches (18") in counter space at a thirty-four inch (34") height, or any combination thereof, at the option of the purchaser/owner. 3. Adjustable sink and/or removable under-sink cabinets consistent with Chapter l1A. 4. Hood fan controls at light switch level or lower level. 7.90.100 Standards: Common Use Room: A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install: There are no mandatory installations related to a common use room in a Visit-able Residential Dwelling B New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: The following options for the common use room on the primary entry level shall be offered and, if accepted, installed at the request and cost of the purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with section 7.90.140. 1. At least one common use room, such as a dining room or living room, on the accessible route. Sunken or raised areas not exceeding fifty percent (50%) ofthe area of the room's floor space shall be permitted as an option of the purchaser/owner in a common use room on the accessible route when an accessible route connects a usable portion ofthe common use room to the accessible bathroom or powder room and the accessible exterior entrance door. 2. No sunken areas in a common use room on an accessible route. 3. Standards related to access to and flatness of any other common area room on the primary entry level. 7.90.110 Standards: Bedroom A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install: There are no mandatory installations related to a bedroom in a Visit-able Residential Dwelling. B. New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: If there is a bedroom on the primary entry level, the following options shall be offered and, if accepted, installed at the request and cost of the purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with section 7.90.140: At least one bedroom on the accessible route of travel with all components meeting the requirements of section 7.90.130. A closet shall have at least a thirty-two inch (32") net opening and adjustable closet rods and shelving. A family room or den may satisfy this bedroom requirement if a sleeping structure (such as a bed, futon, hide-away, or Murphy bed) can be placed in the room and ifthe room complies with provisions for emergency escape and rescue and smoke alarms in the California Building Code. Page 6 of 10 1tJ \0 7.90.120 Standards: Miscellaneous Areas A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install: There are no mandatory installations related to miscellaneous areas of a Visit-able Residential Dwelling. B. New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: The following options shall be offered, and if accepted, installed at the request and cost of the purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with section 7.90.140. If on the primary entry level, miscellaneous areas or facilities (such as a patio or yard, laundry room, or storage area) for the dwelling must have an accessible route to and from the accessible entrance, either through the dwelling unit or around the dwelling unit. 7.90.130 Standards: General Components A. New Construction-Mandatory to Install. The following item(s) shall be installed in all Visit-able Residential Dwelling 1. Hand-activated door hardware not requiring tight grasping, pinching, or twisting of the wrist and consistent with the requirements of CBC Chapter llA. 2. Rocker light switches and controls or light switches and controls meeting the requirements of ANSI A 117.1 or the CBC Chapter l1A. 3. The installation of all receptacle outlets, lighting controls and environmental controls throughout the residential dwelling unit must comply with CBC Chapter llA or applicable provisions of the California Electrical Code. B. New Construction-Mandatory to Offer: The following options shall be offered, and if accepted, installed at the request and cost ofthe purchaser/owner, if requested when installation is consistent with 7.90.140. 1. 'An accessible route in an interior room or hallway, interior doors or openings for rooms and routes of travel required to be accessible consistent with CBC Chapter l1A. EXCEPTIONS: A thirty-four inch (34") clear doorway width may be requested from a hallway with a thirty-nine inch (39") width, and a thirty-six inch (36") clear doorway width may be requested from a hallway with a thirty-six inch (36") width. 2. The width ofthe level area on the side toward which an accessible door swings consistent with CBC Chapter l1A. 3. If the Building Official or owner/purchaser determines that the accessible route and doorway width options prescribed by Chapter l1A are not feasible and that a less wide accessible route is necessary, a functional alternative to ensure that all entries into rooms required to be accessible may be approved by the Building Official or purchaser/owner if it meets at least one of the following requirements and ifthe hallway is not less than thirty-six (36") inches in width: Page 7 of 10 BOb to a. The entry door to the room must be at the end of a hallway or passageway, or open directly from another room on an accessible route of travel, so that no turn of ninety degrees (900) or more is necessary to enter the room. b. The hallway wall opposite the room must be inset enough to allow an area of at least eight inches (8") deep with at least a sixty-inch (60") run centered on the center ofthe entry door opening [e.g., an 8" by 60" notch or alcove.] c. The hallway wall on the same side as the room must be inset enough to allow an area of at least eight inches (8") deep with at least a sixty-inch (60") run centered on the center ofthe entry door opening [e.g., an 8" by 60" notch or alcove.] d. The hallway wall directly opposite the room door must open to another room with at least a sixty-inch (60") opening on a level with the accessible passageway or hallway. NOTE: Doors or openings to the rooms required to be accessible may be wider and the notch or alcove smaller if equivalent access is not impeded. In addition, for a doorway at the end of a hallway or in other circumstances, the notch or alcove need not be centered on the doorway if equivalent access is not impeded. 4. Flooring throughout the residential dwelling unit consistent with CBC Chapter llA 5. Standards pertaining to residential structures from ANSI Al17.1 may be used throughout this chapter when CBC Chapter llA does not contain specific standards or when the ANSI Standards are equivalent to the Chapter l1A standards. 7.90.140 Standards: New Construction-Permissive Options A. The developer or builder of a Visit-able Residential Dwelling must offer an opportunity to select any the features listed in this chapter to an owner or prospective owner of a Visit-able Residential Dwelling at the earliest feasible time after the owner, purchaser, or prospective purchaser is identified. B. The developer or builder of a Visit-able Residential Dwelling shall construct or install any requested features identified in this chapter unless it would result in an unreasonable delay in the construction or significant un-reimbursable costs to the developer or builder. C. The developer or builder of a Visit-able Residential Dwelling, at his or her option, may offer or utilize standards for structural or design features, components or appliances and facilities, including but not limited ANSI Standards, which meet or exceed Chapter llA and which offer greater availability, access or usability, and these are deemed to be in compliance with this chapter. 7.90.150 Enforcement: A. It is unlawful for any person or entity to fail to comply with the requirements ofthis chapter. B. Violation of any provision of this chapter may be enforced by civil action including an action for injunctive relief. In any civil enforcement action, administrative or judicial, the city shall be entitled to recover its attorneys' fees and costs from a person who is determined by a court of competent jurisdiction to have violated this c1iapter. Page 8 of 10 q1JrD C. Any violation of the provisions of this chapter shall constitute a misdemeanor and shall be punished as such in accordance with Section 1.04.030. D. Enforcement pursuant to this section shall be undertaken by the city through its Community Development Director and the City Attorney. E. Remedies under this section are in addition to and do not supersede or limit any and all other remedies, civil, criminal, or administrative. The remedies provided herein shall be cumulative and not exclusive. F. Whenever the Building Official or designee re-inspects or otherwise takes any enforcement action against a residential dwelling unit, which is governed by this chapter to determine compliance with this chapter, the Building Official may assess fees against the owner to recover the costs to the city according to a fee schedule established by the city. The assessment and collection of these fees shall not preclude the imposition of any administrative or judicial penalty or fine for violations of this chapter or applicable state laws or regulations. 7.90.160 Purchaser op-out option. The purchaser(s) may file a letter with the City of Dublin and the Developer, their desire to forgo any or all of the mandatory installation features required under this ordnance. Such letter shall relieve the Developer of only those mandatory features listed in the purchaser(s) letter; all other mandatory items shall be installed. Section 2. Application of Ordinance to Existing and Approved Plans: This ordinance shall not apply to residential dwelling units for which a complete building plan check, application and applicable fees have been submitted to the Building Division as of the effective date of this ordinance. Section 3. Compliance with California Environmental Quality Act (HCEQA 'J: The City Council declares that this ordinance is exempt from CEQA based on the following findings: This ordinance is not a "project" within the meaning of Section 15378 of the State CEQA Guidelines, because it has no potential for resulting in physical change in the environment, directly or ultimately. The adoption of this ordinance does not, in itself, allow the construction of any building or structure. The adoption of this ordinance, therefore, has no potential for resulting in physical change in the environment, directly or ultimately. Notwithstanding the adoption ofthis ordinance, individual projects shall not be exempt from compliance with CEQA. Section 4. Severability: In the event, any section or portion ofthis ordinance shall be determined invalid or unconstitutional, such section or portion shall be deemed severable and all other sections or portions hereof shall remain in full force and effect. Section 5. Savings Clause: All code provisions, ordinances, and parts of ordinances in conflict with the provisions of this chapter are repealed. The provisions of this chapter, insofar as they are substantially the same as existing code provisions relating to the same subject matter shall be construed as restatements and continuations thereof and not as new enactments~ With respect, however, to violations, rights accrued, liabilities accrued, or appeals taken, prior to the effective date of this ordinance, under any chapter, ordinance, or part of an ordinance shall be deemed to remain in full force for the purpose of sustaining any proper suit, action, or other proceedings, with respect to any such violation, right, liability or appeal. Page 9 of 10 lDo/} 10 Section 6. Effective Date and Posting of Ordinance: This ordinance shall take effect and be in force thirty (30) days from and after the date of its passage, provided that a copy of the ordinance has first been filed with the California Department of Housing and Community Development in accordance with Health and Safety Code section 19759(b)(2). The City Clerk ofthe City of Dublin shall cause the Ordinance to be posted in at least three (3) public places in the City of Dublin in accordance with Section 36933 of the Government Code of the State of California. PASSED AND ADOPTED BY the City Council of the City of Dublin, on this 2nd day of October 2007, by the following votes: AYES: NOES: ABSENT: ABSTAIN: JanetLockhart,~ayor ATTEST: City Clerk 991969_1.DOC; 114.1001 Page 10 of 10