HomeMy WebLinkAboutItem 4.11 Domingo & Nora Bonifacio Claim (2) CITY OF DUBLIN
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: May 14, 1990
SUBJECT: Claim submitted by Domingo & Nora Bonifacio (0055DU)
" (Prepared by: Paul S. Rankin, Assistant City Manager)
EXHIBITS ATTACHED: Copy of Claim
Copy of Sketch Illustrating Requirement for Zoning
rdinance Setback
RECOMMENDATION: ' 1 Deny the claim and direct Staff to notify the Claimant
and the City's insurance provider.
FINANCIAL STATEMENT: The claimant alleges $1 , 670 in damages.
DESCRIPTION: The City has received a claim submitted by Domingo and
Nora Bonifacio. The claim alleges improper permit approval in conjunction
with the construction of their swimming pool.
The claimant obtained a permit to construct a backyard swimming pool. The
Zoning Ordinance includes a requirement for a six foot separation between
the house and the pool. The claimant's house extends out from one of the
second floor rooms and encroaches on the six foot setback. Maintaining
this setback is important for access and to assure that the second floor
can be maintained. Attached is a sketch prepared by the Planning
Department, which illustrates the separation requirement. The claimants'
original site plan approved by the Planning Department did not show the
second floor encroachment. The building inspector who conducted the field
review prior to beginning construction did not note the encroachment.
The City's Building Inspection Services are provided under independent
contract with Taugher & Associates, Inc. The City's insurance provider
will be tendering this claim to Taugher & Associates as the City's contract
contains specific indemnification and insurance requirements.
The Planning Staff explained to the pool company representatives that they
had several options including: (1 ) appeal of the enforcement based on an
alleged error; (2) apply for a variance with facts to support findings; (3)
request a study to amend the Zoning Ordinance; or (4) work with their
client to revise the construction to meet the code requirements. The
claimants did not pursue any of the remedies available to appeal the
decision. They revised the pool design and submitted a liability claim.
The City' s insurance provider has recommended that the City Council deny
the claim and notify the claimants in order to protect the statutory period
for the claimants to pursue the claim.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
COPIES TO:
Terri Hodges, ABAG PLAN
ITEM N0.
!tc. CEiVED.
CLAIM AGAINST THE
CITY OF DUBLIN
Ci TY 0,,-- p,13LLIN. D SL-Du
DATE flECEIUED CLAIM NUMBER
(Office Use Only) (Office Use Only)
Name of Claimant Domingo & Nora Bonifaco
Address of Claimant 11227 Rolling Hills- Dr.
Dublin, California 94568
Telephone Number �41�551_0139
Send Notices To: same as above
Date of Occurrence: Feb. 201. 1990 Time of Occurrence:
Place of Occurrence: (Provide detailed diagram describing the exact location, including
physical landmarks or distinguishing land features, if appropriate)
Circumstances of Occurrence: (if an accident, describe physical conditions
surrounding occurrence such'as weather, road, and traffic conditions, etc.)
Improper permit approval.
List no addresses and phone numbers of any witnesses!
Anthony Pools 7286 San Ramon Rd. Dublin, California
(415) 828-9550 Ed McMully / Bob Schilling
Proulde a Description of.Damage or Loss: alh7n nn
Please see attached contract addendum.
Name and Department of InuolUed City Employee (if any)
Mr. Vic Taugher —' Building Dent Tel. -#833-6610
Briefly wipialn why you feel the City of Dublin is responsible:
The City on 02/20/90 approved and issued a permit and work
began. Upon completion of excavation, steel and plumbling
inspection was performed and original approval was found to
be in error.
Total Flmount Claimed: State 0 f)n ay claim it a dollar amount not shown
r10,000 or less must
be specified as described In Oovernm ent Code Section 9
indicate whether jurisdiction over the claim would rest in municipal or superior court.)
Breakdown of Amount Claimed:(if applicable)
Dated: 03-29-90 Signed:
Note: A Claim relating to a cause of action for death or for injury to person or to personal property
or growing of crops shall be presented not later than six (6)months after the cause of action. A claim
relating to of action (Government Code hSection 911.2) t e f h f
the cause
f the date occurrence was prior to January t,
1986, differenL filing deadlines would apply.
When a claim is required to be presented not later than six (6) months after the accrual of the cause of
action, is not presented within such Lime: a written application may be made to the City Council for
leave to present such claim. The application shall be presented within a reasonable time not to exceed
one (1) year after the accrual of the cause of action and shall state the reason for the delay in
presenting the claim. The proposed claim shall be attached to the application.
Ciiy*ol Dublin-Building Inspection Dept. 100 CIVIC PLAZA,DUBLIN,CA 91568
THIS"APPLICATION,WHEN VALIDATED, IS A PERMIT. Expires ❑ 1 Year; ❑2 Years; ❑— INSPECTOR'S-ORIGINAL
s Inspection Request(415)890-6620
HERE
L BUILDING ADDRESS: ' t.J�L-(I �� ( H ( LCC, 0a �2
BETWEEN CROSS STS: —byz 1 T,��L--L—eus` AND s�L VE k-�l� Da-
J
WORK GC '
II. APPLICANT: ❑OWNER; (;(CONTR'ACTOR DRIVER UC NO._ PHONE CJ Z 311 SS
19. OWNER'S NAME: �J D•�N�A�FR /U �,J// PHONF .:5/-N2?
ADDRESS IJ ,yL,R�1 V UJ AJ t,1TY�•S �U/�J L/IV ZIPC
IV. CONTRACTOR'S NAME: —RAM
� (,RA/_'�1)Vk2-y/- 0 L 5 PHONE
ADORESS: �— esQ—+111A-9,0J?'2ZW-e-QITY PIVA5 L/A/ ZIP 7 !/ (�
V. ARCS�ITECT OR ENGINEER NAME: _ S[_7]�Cf!1LE![ E�Z_ / ,-1 CPHONE �Sl_• - STATE LIC jr,/?_�
,ADOFIESS: _�1-�—.:1"/V J . —CITY ` C - �266 ZIP--.
VI. LEGAL DESCRIPTION(Fill In one of the following):
A. TRACT _.___-- —BLOCK�1— 7_�_.-�.-_-'_---_LOT.---,---'--
1 B. BOOK_c y�BLOCKS[—�—PARCEL21 7MOIS RICAL SERVICE
f00 Votes or Less NO. FEE Over 600 Volts
C. PARCEL MAP PARCEL---- rc. FS Ea add 100 Over Inc. i-nu Ea.Add KVA
DO 600 200 KVA Vg. DESCRIPTION OF WORK TO BE DONE /�U U L u. SPA than 1 meter
/ B I MOTORS,GENERATORS,HEATERS,FURNACES, C ELECT.CIRCUIT AMP.CAP.
•i
Next_Addition Alleralion_—Repair_Moved—_Demolun Renawal - —. --
WELDERS, TRANSFORMERS,RECTIFIERS,AIR COND'RS OVERINC NO., FEE
A. DESCRIBE NEW BUILDING:Gross Area —. —Sq.Fl. -P kVA ORA —` NV aW ORr
OvE,I_Irrc NO. FEE pvEN-ING NO. FEE 0 20
No.Stories_ E■lenot Wall Covering —Y-- --
O 1 IS 50 21 00
S. DESCRIBE PRESENT BUILDING: Gross A,ea Sq.Ft. --
'1 2 50 100 71 e0
No.Stories Exterior Wan Covering —
2 5 100 — al SO
C. DESCRIBE ADDITION:'
S IS 51 70
Gross Area— _. Sq.Fl.No.Slates ----
7i 100
D. IS BUILUINGlAODITION: Heated.Yes No Cooled:Yeses FOR MOTOR GENERATOR SETS—NO ADD 50% 70 TOTAL 101 -
( VW.DESCRIBE ALTERATION OR REPAIR WORK OR ADDITIONi
ITEM NO, FEE ITEM NO. FEE ITEM NO. FEE
"y� �/� ,r^ 1 El.cvcr I•w.l«N.ur Il.lye Slr.lror —_
k." A/b u .LY—!'1 Nv.nc. 0•.a Gwl,c
�---•/ ] E�. Plu,ne,rq I!kxn.rnu 7x Dry Cn.n..:r/..
... E.ry..,wp
A.y.rc.a Illwl a Ilan 51.] Sur«P,p,p E nn Aeel I pawl
/f /) a OWV P,yne Srm.m le Fur BuMp A40 W Lww ADUre- x!F..AWm Srwm�
IX.,P90POSED USE OF BUILDING (J V --- a
M,76 a Pr1 0l--
S. GAS P"SrrSy.— Denw•la: 5..i,rm O«,n1a.
., s. RAk". II E.n•.w F«I.
X. PRESENT USE OF BUILDING Pvrrq srr.m
le F•n.a A.Nu,Orrp UMI b•er,ci 77 Fur'61n.p.Ti,
�1•,.. 7 0„CI P'VrW$1'Mrn 1...n.n I nTl('..I
G•.kw«. .r.i.miJ 1.nnG FF.6a NuL.nc..
XI. ,VALUATION(Incly+di toots of all Labor and Materiel) U `fiTullp-
e n Gi,I.i V 6'..— la ora iM«+p a C Ca..a EI«,w,.A
.� t• LICENSED CONTRACTORS DECLARATION Id R.Vnm a
••"s' I nmoby All—that l am kcanSod urdut wovis—'s OFChAPlen 9 ici)—none 9 wAn t. 700010101vISKM
9 0l he Busrwss and Prolesswx/•mss Code.AId my kcanse Is In lull lace and allacl.IV-
F..�, 11 Fr.0-n .1•] 20 D.r Car —
L 3 � Lrn.m License Clasc♦ -�' LK.NunlDer7 rrrwy.C—,.L J/ _ � j _/_ v�_Oete. _ I lL Conlraaa J/{ — 22. v.na Cnmrr Fwc PeniA—,
I
OWNER-BUILDER DECLARA ION
I hereby enum trial I am exempt town the COnuacl0ls Llcanso Law for the follow ie ten(Sec. U9LS. e
BWlness and Prolasslons Code.Any city of counly which requires a permit 10 Orlshu:l,Auer,improve. �f /
demohill or lepae•any structure,prior 10 its issuance,also Inquires Ina appllca W/such pelml IO file a BLDG.AUDIt°SS:
y9ned slalemum that tie a licensed pursuant to ilia provisions of the Connatlw's License Law(Chaplin 9
(cannwrclrlg with Soctiexl 7000)of 81wlbn 9 of the Business snit Piolnssrons Code)a that nor is exnmpl ACV'D EXC.PERMI PERMIT FEE
Innreliom and Ina basis la Ilia aoo9n11 e■emphol.Any vrotatoon of Searon 7W 1.5 by any appllcanl fora a�FF -
pound suqucls Inc applicant 10 a civil penally of nor more Irian live hunalotZdl)PPOS(SSUO).1. GROUP //s OVER 60 CNEL ENERGY SURCHG /
Q has owner of Ina property.w my employees with wages as their solo compensation,wig do the work. I`� i
and Ira sbunuw Is nor enarded or offered for sate(Sec.704+,Busin°!s and Prolesswns Code:The TYPE _ SPRINKLED PLAN STORAGE
Conliaaorb Lleensb Law does not apply 10 an owner of pnopeny who truikls or Improves thereon,and who
dtws such work lvmsull or IMough his own Onlployens,piowlded[hill such Improvements are nor upended w WATER RECPT Ir PERMIT PROCESS
ollinod for sate. 11, however, the building or impnovumom Is sold within one year of completion, file
owlwr•bwldon will flaws the burden 01 prOving that he did not build or improve for ma purpose Of sale.). DSRSD SCHOOL AOCIL.PROCESS
(] 1,as O.A.of trio properly,am exUusivaly Conliacling with kcensad compactor►Ill construct the SUB TOTAL
piulect(Sec.7044.Busmuss and rolesmu0a Cole.The Cwenaclur'a License Law dons nor apply to an FIRE --
owners of piopuny who lwdds of improvas ilwneo.and who eonUaCls la Such P101ucts with a ewmaclw(s) PA a EO ART.
kcansad pursuant to the Contractor's License Law.).
E] I am e■ampt under Set. B.BP.C.Ion this reason APPROVED Z ZD 7•
USE ZONE I ZONING APPROVAL _ _ Z OG
Date —Owner HEALTH DEPT.APPROVAL AL. DUE �j 3
WORKERS'COMPENSATION DECLARATION — -
I leraby aflum Ina)I have a eandicale of consent to fell•elsure,on a cunfificalo OI WO,kers'Compansalron Is] e s
Insurance,or a cenan cl copy Ihereol(Sec.9800,Let)
Polley No.//71, to 2b V Company v�r r�•1//_ — Q ,C,LJ �( � tf•.� C— lk.. { �T-2`
C.n,lied copy.*hereby furnlslad. pualion Dais
7Cerl,innj copy its hind with city building in ten deparinienl
Dale=_—L—=Applicant r.
CERTIFICATE OF E .rrON FROM W KERS'
COMP SATI INSURANCE
ITNs section need not be completed If I permit is for one hurdled dorlars(SI00)a less.)
I conity,that in the pedoinnarcs Of the it for which INS paimil is issued.I shall not employ any person in
any manna,so as 10 became"aa 10"Workels Componsanon Laws of California.
Data Applica^f
NOTICE TO APPLICANT: It,after making INS Cenifitate or Exemption,you should became Subject 10 the
Wakeni Corllpensulion provisions of Ilia Labor Code.you must lunhwdh comply with such P,OVISKMIS a Iles
r mA shall to UuemuJ nevWrd CONSTIIUCTION LENDING AGENCY
hunby enum Ibaf there is a owlsuuclrn tenurn9 agelwy for Ilia panloimulce of IM work for which Irms
..1 I'.m W'if 1'n, 1 1
COS
MEW Z� Rte' W A lL.
P � r e>uw W
• '.'r'!'���STIAI(.1 1' RtiZ WAl.1...—J Y _- z -
1�' m b'oEeP ro W 3
4'
i Rf Ihl GIB a , / k�. �� \.�• c -
POOL
JfiL 6
.,fir.
ARE
/ A ` AIMTH O IV J POOLS CONTRACT ADDENDUM
- a Division of Anthony Industries,Inc. Y 189250
Wos[d's Largest Pool CONTRACTOR
LICENSED SWIMMING POOL CONTRACTOR N
(LICENSE #190179-C 53)
ADDENDUM DATE
CONTRACT NO. yJ 3� DATED 4--/(/,
. 19—BETWEEN ANTHONY POOLS AND
OF—.//' -� %?� C.(/iL�� %�f % ; �/ DJ/1�i
NO.AND START CITT
-T 1TATC =Ir
IS HEREBY AMENDED AS FOLLOWS:
b rJ• 7�-t, S Gt_sL."l.,L_ %•-'J-�i.�' __/ /l�r-r-� ';� `��^ �^ ��'�� ���v. y
• L•� r9l,s :T..- //j.� .i G•--,� � G'i .1 ter) =�� W
N
V
FOR A TOTAL CONTRACT PRICE INCREASE OF $
( K)
DUE AT (PHASE) DECREASE OF $ ( ) (WILL BE DEDUCTED FROM FI NAL PAYM ENT)
THE REASON(S) FOR THE FOREGOING AMENDMENT(S) IS AS FOLLOWS:
WE AUTHORIZE THESE CHANGES IN TH WORK BEING PERFORMED UNDER THE
ABOVE-REFERENCED-CONTRACT FOR WORK
WE AGREE TO THE CONTRACT PRICE
INCREASE OR DECREASE SHOWN ABOVE."
ANTHONY POOLS
OW NERY
BY '' ✓/-r':._y�-c' OWNER--- .
' AP 9001 REV."3
i
NoT
SAFE usE A LLD0 Fb Fz
y�ppER To 5A U51: eF
LAODK TO
ZNDN.. 2"° Fi. . Z"'F�• g AC.a% 2"FL.
rw 0 a f�P DoT
�� �• .�-- 5HfD 6p-
POOL, dI'DC
l �
I �
44,- f- - -t�-
6 -f,-a 6 FT.
. CoMPu�S W tT�4 ?D�11�1 t ,, pDES Co►��LY
ORDtr,IW Rau 6R W cTt-f— ?��t N� D RDrrJ
fbP- 6 FT. WARA-'cod
C, ZT4
3Kf000T(A I AAW& OPPIPA &