HomeMy WebLinkAbout4.13 EmerGlenParkChangeOrd CITY CLERK
File # 600-35
AGENDA 'STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: December 21, 1999
SUBJECT:
ATTACHMENTS:
RECOMMENDATION:
· Contract Change Order- Contract 99-04 with Goodland Landscape
Construction, Inc for Emerald Glen Park, Phase I
Report by: Herma Lichtenstein,. t'arks & Facilities Development
Manager
1) Proposed Change Order #18
2) Exhibit "A" Change Order Form (Project Accounting Sheet)
Approve Change Order
FINANCIAL STATEMENT:
Original Contract
Change Orders #1 - #26
Change Order #27
Total
Available Budget
Balance
$ 4,011,800
110,336
48.070
$ 4,170,206
$ 4.412.980
$ 242,774
DESCRIPTION: In May 1999, the City Council awarded Contract 99-04, Emerald
Glen Park Phase I, to Goodland Landscape Construction, Inc. The original contract was for $4,011,800
and a 10% contingency was included bringing the total available budget to $4,412,980. Construction of
the park improvements began on May 17, 1999 and to date change orders for $110,336 have been
approved by the City Manager.
The children's play area in the park has a prehistoric theme and includes a buried "dinosaur," a granite
fossil wall and an artificial rock play mound. Several creative features in the play area include:
n
Intemctive water elements where children can use the water and sand to build sandcastles or unearth
the "dinosaur"
A fossil wall which relates to the theme of a paleontological dig where children can get a sense of the
fossil record by seeing the fossilized relief of water creatures, birds and plants. For example, one of
the plants represented is the Ginkgo tree that is planted in the park. This tree has remained consistent
from prehistoric times.
The artificial rock play mound continues the adventure. Children are allowed to climb, crawl and slide'
over the mound. They can see down on the found fossils in the play area or watch other children playing
on the adjacent swings, slides and bridges.
F:\emrldgle\phasel\cc 1221 co.doc.
COPIES TO:
Goodland Landscape Cgnstmction, Inc.
ITEM NO.
Goodland Landscape Construction has submitted a change order for $48,070 for additional costs
associated with the artificial rock play mound in the children's play area. The additional costs are bec,a~t~se
of increased structural requirements resulting from the soil conditions on the site as well as increases in
the load requirements of the rock.
The original Bid called for the play mound to be bid as a design build construction. The plans were based
on a similar structure that has already been built in another community. The anticipation was that the
design for the Emerald Glen site would not be significantly different from the existing play structure.
Once the area for the mound was graded and tested for structural requirements it became evident that the
soils would need a significant increase in structural engineering. Goodland's structural engineer
responded with a design that was approximately $100,000 over the original bid line item. The City
requested a review of the design and subsequent reductions in the size of the mound and clarification of
code requirements reduced the original change order by 50% to a cost of $48,070.
A comparison between the play mound as bid and the play mound as redesigned is shown below.
Footing
The original footing requirements were
12"x 24". This is a standard footing for
most soils in the area. It is easy to
excavate and does not require additional
forming.
The proposed footing has increased to 18"
x 24". The additional width as well as the
rebar ties in to the slab requires forming,
additional excavation, base rock and labor.
Structural slab
The original slab holding the artificial
rock boulders was 6" thick.
The proposed slab is 10" thick.
Rebar
The original rebar design had only rebar
reinforcing in the slab itself and a simple
two rod layout for the footings.
The proposed rebar includes J-hooks tied
into the slab at 12" on center to act as
anchors for the rock. The footings have
rebar going both ways acting as a "cage".
The proposed steelwork requires a
significant increase in labor to install.
Fossil
Retaining Wall
Excavation
The original fossil wall was a simple
masonry wail on a spread footing.
The proposed wall has a larger footing and
more complicated rebar system.
The increase in footing sizes and slab will
necessitate additional excavation and
removal / relocation of spoils.
Drainage
The original plan showed no drainage or
base rock.
The proposed plan shows base rock under
all concrete areas and drainage at the
fossil wall including 15' x 7' x 18" of
base rock.
Remobilization
Cost
Due to the redesign and value engineering
on this portion of the plans the contractor
will need to isolate the area from the
remaining park in order to secure a work
zone. Several sub-contractors will be
required to remobilize for the work.
The change order also provides for 80 additional working days. This will delay the completion of the
~hildsen's play area until mid-April. It should be noted that the construction of the artificial rock play
mound in the children's play area would be isolated from the rest of the park. In this way, opening of the
other areas of the park when they are complete (i.e. skate park, tennis courts and basketball courts) will
not be delayed.
As the amount of the change order exceeds the authorization limit ($25,000 per change order) granted to
the City Manager it is necessary for the City Council to approve the change order. Therefore, Staff
recommends that the City Council approve Change Order #27 for $48,070. Sufficient funds are available
to execute the change order.
CITY OF DUBLIN
CONTRACT CHANGE ORDER NO. 18
PROJECT:
TO:
DATE:
Emerald Glen Park, Phase I
Goodland Landscape Construction, Inc.
December 15, 1999
Contract No. 99-04
You are hereby directed to make the herein described changes from the scope of services or do the following described work not included
in the scope &services on this contract.
NOTE: This chance order is not effective until aDOroved bv the City Mana.oer
Description of work to be done, estimate of quantities, and prices to be paid. Segregate between additional work at contract price, agreed
prices and force account. Unless otherwise stated, rates for rental of equipment cover only such time as equipment is actually used and no
allowance will be made for idle time.
Change requested by: Architect
The last percentage shown is the net accumulated increase or decrease from the original fee in the Agreement:
1. Mobilize, Supervision, Fencing site area.
Excavating & Grading per revised desig-n
Credit Excavation from original bid design
2. Furnish and Install labor and materials to build the Fossil Wall
Credit Fossil Wall Footing from original bid design
3. Furnish and Install Artificial Rock Area per revised design.
Credit Rockwork and Concrete from original bid design
TOTAL COST INCREASE:
11,891.00
6,725.00
-3,609.00
15,000.00
-I,500.00
50,575.00
-31,012.00
$48,070.0
BY REASON OF THIS ORDER, THE TIME OF COMPLETION FOR THIS AREA WILL BE ADJUSTED 80 WORKING DAYS.
APPROVAL RECOMMENDED BY: APPROVED BY: APPROVED BY:
Herma Lichtenstein Date Lee Thompson Date
Development Manager Public Works Director
Richard Ambrose
City Manager
Date
We, the undersigned contractor, have given careful consideration to the change proposed and hereby agree, if this proposal is approvect,
that we will provide all equipment,, furnish all materials, except as may otherwise be noted above, and perform all services necessary for
the work above specified, and will accept as full payment therefor the prices shown above.
Contractor: Accepted, Date:
By: Title:
ATTACHMENT 1
CITY OF DUBLIN
EXHIBIT 'A' CHAN(3C ORDER FORM
DATE;
PRO, ECT NAME:
CIP t.
CONTRACT NO:
CHANGE ORDER NO,
PERCENT COMPLETED:
CONTRACTOr.'
APPROVED latIIXiET AMT.:
CONYTRACT AMOUNT:
15-0ec-99
EMERALD GLEN PARK
750
18
$4,41 %980
$4,011.800
CONTRACT CHANGE
CHANGE ORDER
CHANGE ORDER 102
CHANGE ORDER
CHANGE ORDER
CHANGE ORDER
CHANGE ORDER ~
CHANGE ORDER IK)7
CHANGE ORDER 108.
CHANGE ORDER ~
CHANGE ORDER
CHANGE ORDFR #11
ORD!=R$,: AMOUNq'
Tree Removal 3.519.00
'VVirtd Ben~ 12,g68.00
48" Mm'tHole 7,442.00
Bench Anchoring I, 195.00
Copper Ftashing 2,260.00
Delete SS & Door Fit (10,488.00)
CatCh Basin Elevation 3,467.00
Grm::fing Taseajara 25,857.00
HC Ramps at Street 13,200.00
Revised ITTigatign (256.00)
Add 2' flu at Tennis Ct. 2,830.00
CON1/IACT CHANCE ORDERS: AMOUNT
CHANGE ORDER #12~ Set Amendments 23,308.00
CHANGE ORDER #13, 8reel Cope~ - Sk~ F 7,275.00
CHANCE ORDER #14, Bark Mulch 2.2S~.00
CHANGE ORDER #1S. PG&E Bo~ 1,706.00
CHANGE ORDER #f6, Elmc~cal Gemrator 13,770.00
CHANGE ORDE:R et 7, Frm'g ~ Cant-e--=
CHANGE ORDER #18, Playground Mound 48,070.00
CHANGE ORDER #19, Befithal tot Tenr~ C1 0.00
CHANGE ORDER #20. Main Shuf...off Valve Q,.00
CHANGE ORDER if'z1., Boltarcl~ for PG&E
CHANGE ORDER #2:2, Goodland RelQ~ Cost~ O.Q0
97,4C:~.00
TOTAL OP ALL CURRENT AND PRIOR CHANGE GRID ERe:
AD,KISTED CONTRACT AMOUNT:
PRO~REB,8 PAYMENT8 MADe:
PAYMENT ;01 142,801 .,¢4
PAYMENT iO2 :2~iQ,.407.47
PAYMENT ~ 134,108.62
PAYMENT lO4 1 oe,3o8,5~
PAYMENT 105 231.322.32
PAYMENT 106 252,38Q.4~
PAYMENT 107 389,483..40
PAYMENT Ilr06 49e,I 54.25
PAYMENT 10g 389,884.9Q
PAYMENT #I 0 353,1 g8.84
PAYMENT #11 381,362..97
PAYMENT #12 263,486.57
PAYMENT tl 3
PAYMENT #I 4 0.{30
PAYMENT tl 5 O.DO
3.405.510.73
'TOTAL P!~Xt~E88 PAYMENTS:
$3~leejlg.~3
REMAINING BALANCE ON CONTRACT:
APPROVED APPROVED APPROVED
DENIED DENIED DENIED
Sup.nnmng Heed
ATTACHMENT 2