HomeMy WebLinkAbout6.1 VarianceRequest7852StarwardDr
~
.
.
AGENDA STATEMENT
CITY COUNCIL MEETING DATE: May 9, 1994
SUBJECT: PUBLIC HEARING REQUEST FOR A VARIANCE TO SECTION 2516(m) OF
THE UNIFORM BUILDING CODE BY HEIRS OF THE
ESTATE OF JOHN YOUNG AT 7852 STARWARD DRIVE
Report by: victor Taugher, Building Official
EXHIBITS A~TACHED:
~1. Letter from heirs of the estate of John
~ -
"young
2~Section 2516(m) 1991 Uniform Building Code
3.~Section 2507(a) 1958 Uniform Building Code
4.~etter from Ron & Fawn Holman
5. ~etter from Mason McDuffie
6./Letter from city of Dublin Building
}nspection Department
7~Draft Resolution Denying the Variance
RECOMMENDATION:/'7J~ I.
f "Iv 2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
Open Public Hearing
Receive Staff Report
Receive Public Testimony
Close Public Hearing
Deliberate
Adopt Resolution Denying Variance Request
or provide staff with other direction
FINANCIAL STATEMENT:
No impact on city
DESCRIPTION: Prior to February 10, 1994, Ron and Fawn
Holman, prospective buyers of the property at 7852 starward Drive,
requested a Code Compliance Survey. Mrs. Holman is an employee in the
DUblin Planning Department. Code compliance surveys are available
upon request and with a paYment of a fee of $20.00 per 100 square
feet. At the time of the request the buyers, and their agent, were
verbally notified that if an inspection was made, any code violations
observed would have to be corrected. After being assured by the
buyers, and their agent, that the owners of the property were aware of
the consequences of an inspection and would make any necessary
corrections, the inspection was made on February 10, 11, and 16, 1994.
The results of the inspection were listed in a February 17, 1994
Building Inspection Department letter. A permit was secured by the
owners contractor on March 31, 1994. The stated valuation for the
work was $3,800.00. All of the items listed were corrected except for
securing the posts to the foundation.
By way of explanation, the floor of the building is supported by 4 x 6
girders spaced 4' apart. The girders are supported by 4 x 4 vertical
posts spaced between 4' to 6' apart. The 4 x 4 posts are supported by
a concrete pier foundation. Apparently, the 4 x 4's were not cut to
the proper length and as a result wedges were installed between the
J .
~ -----------------------------
--------- --- --------------------------
ITEM NO. COPIES TO: Nancy Cantrell
Ron & Fawn Holman
Fred DeGregoire
.
.
concrete pier and the 4 x 4 post. Consequently, the posts are not
fastened to the concrete pier. section 2516(m) requires a positive
connection between the post and the pier to prevent uplift and lateral
displacement. This requirement was in effect when the house was built
in 1960 (See Exhibit 3).
The oWner~are requesting a variance which would allow the floor
supports to remain as is. The rational for the variance is that the
owners believe this condition exists in the entire tract. We are not
able to verify this statement because we have not inspected the
underfloor space in any other houses in the tract. Also, they
indicate that they were not advised that any violations found during
the inspection would have to be corrected. Exhibit 4, indicates that
the buyers agent informed the sellers agent of this aspect of the
inspection. Apparently" there has been a lack of communication
between the owners agent and the owner.
The owners agent was on the premises along with the buyers agent when
the inspection was made on February 10, 1994. Thus, the inspection
was made at the invitation of both the agents of the buyer and owner.
In accordance with city Council pOlicy, the Building Department
requested all noted violations to be corrected.
It is important that the posts be anchored to the piers to prevent the
posts from shifting off the foundation in an earthquake. If the posts
shifted off the piers the floor could drop 6" to 24". This could also
cause the interior bearing walls to drop and this would damage the
ceiling and roof. This type of damage was observed in the recent
Northridge Earthquake.
In order to grant a variance the city council must make a finding that
the variance is consistent with the intent of the code and that the
granting of the variance will not lessen the protection to the people
of the City or the property situated therein. In the opinion of the
Building Official, this finding cannot be made and it is recommended
that the variance be denied.
2
.- ~
.
./B IE fa IE U W lE f{Jl
APR 22 1994 1J))
8 CITY o~
UILD!N"; INS DUBLIN
peer,,....,
'Av Of:PT,
YOUNG
:':':.
HEIRS OF THE ESTATE OF JOHN
7881 LANDALE DRIVE
DUBLIN CA 94568
CITY COUNCIL
DUBLIN, CALIFORNIA
REGARDING PROPERTY AT 7852 STARWARD DRIVE, DUBLIN,.CA
DEAR LADIES AND GENTLEMEN:
ON 2/2/94 MR & MRS RON HOLMAN MADE AN OFFER TO BUY THE ABOVE
PROPERTY. AS A CONTINGENCY OF THEIR PURCHASE, THEY REQUESTED A
HOME INSPECTION REPOR~ WHICH WAS TO BE PAID FOR AT THEIR OWN
EXPENSE. NORMALLY THIS REPORT IS PROVIDED BY A PRIVATE HOME
INSPECTION COMPANY AT A COST OF $400.00. SINCE MRS HOLMAN IS
EMPLOYED BY THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT J THEY REQUESTED THAT IT BE
COMPILED THROUGH THIS AGENCY AT THE COST OF ONLY $200.00, THUS
SAVING THE HOLMANS $200.00. SINCE THIS SEEMED COST EFFECTIVE AND
AN ADDITIONAL HELP IN GETTING THE HOLMANS INTO THE PROPERTY, WE
AGREED TO ALLOW THE BUILDING DEPARTMENT TO INSPECT THE PROPERTY.
AT NO TIME, WERE WE NOR OUR REALTOR, GARY SCHWAGERLE TOLD
ORALLY OR IN WRITING THAT ANY CODE VIOLATIONS FOUND WOULD HAVE TO
BE BROUGHT ,UP TO CODE AT OUR EXPENSE. THIS WAS TO BE ONLY A REPORT
TO ALLOW THE HOLMANS TO BE FULLY AWARE 'OF THE CONDITION OF THIS 35
+ YEAR OLD HOME. THE HOME-,WAS AND IS LISTED TO BE SOLD IN AN "AS
IS" CONDITION. WE FEEL WE WERE DECEIVED BY BOTH THE BUILDING
DEPARTMENT AND MR & MRS HOLMAN SO THEREFORE WOULD NEVER HAVE
ALLOWED THIS INSPECTION. IT'S NOT THAT WE ARE UNWILLING TO COMPLY,
BUT EXPENSES TO DATE HAVE BEEN IN EXCESS OF $10,000. NOT ONLY HAVE
WE LOST THIS MONEY SINCE OUR FATHER DIED, BUT DUE TO THE DECLINING
ECONOMY AND DECREASING PROPERTY VALUES, WE WILL HAVE LOST
APPROXIMATELY $30,000 IN RESALE VALUE.
THE ONLY THING LEFT TO REPAIR, PER YOUR REPORT ARE THE
FOUNDATION PIERS. WE FEEL THIS IS UNDUE DISCRIMINATION BECAUSE THE
REST OF THE TRACT HAVING BEEN BUILT AT THE SAME TIME, IS IN THE
SAME CONDITION. WHERE WERE THE CITY AND THE BUILDING INSPECTORS AT
THE TIME OF CONSTRUCTION? OTHER HOUSES IN THE NEIGHBORHOOD HAVE
BEEN INSPECTED RECENTLY AND WERE FOUND TO ALL HAVE THE SAME
FOUNDATION STRUCTURE. IF EVERYONE ELSE IN THE TRACT HAS TO COMPLY
WITH THIS CODE THEN WE MAY UNDERSTAND THE REQUIREMENT OF FUTTING
ADDITIONAL FUNDS INTO THIS PROPERTY. AGAIN, FUNDS WE WILL NOT BE
ABLE TO RECOUP IN THE EVENT OF A SALE. '
ff
ExIiit.1
-2
.
.
IN ~EAKING WITH MR. TAUGHER, THE HEAD BUILDING INSPECTOR, WE
WERE TOLD THAT THIS WAS TO BE REPAIRED BECAUSE OF POTENTIAL
EARTHQUAKE DAMAGE. OBVIOUSLY THIS WAS OF NO CONCERN WHEN THE CITY
INSPECTED THIS TRACT AND SIGNED OFF ALL THE INSPECTIONS AT THE TIME
OF COMPLETION. WHY SHOULD WE BE SINGLED OUT NOW? IF THIS
PROPERTY IS REPAIRED, IT WILL BE THE ONLY ONE STANDING IN THE EVENT
OF A LARGE EARTHQUAKE. BY THE WAY, MR & MRS HOLMAN DIDN'T EVEN
PURCHASE THE PROPERTY. WE FEEL BOTH THE CITY AND THE HOLMANS
MISREPRESENTED THEIR INTENTIONS WITH THIS REPORT. WE ALSO FEEL THE
CITY SHOULD TAKE ANOTHER LOOK AT THIS INSPECTION, THE RESIDENCE AND
THE TRACT.
ALL CORRESPONDENCE CAN BE DIRECTED TO NANCY CANTRELL,
EXECUTRIX OF THE ESTATE OF JOHN YOUNG, AT THE ABOVE ADDRESS.
SINCERELY,
HEIRS OF THE ESTATE
OF JOHN YOUNG
CC: VICTOR T4UGHER
LARRY YOUNG
VSTAN YOUNG
NANCY CANTRELL
GARY SCHWAGERLE
.
.
~
2516-2517
1991 UNIFORM BUILDING CODE
tinuous spans may be designed on the basis oflhe full cross section using the simple
span moment coefficient.
Nail length shall not be less than two and one-halftimes the net thickness of each
lamination. When deck supports are 4 feet on center or less. side nails shall be
spaced not more than 30 inches on center and staggered one third of the spacing in
adjacent laminations. When supports are spaced more than 4 feet on center, side
nails shall be spaced not more than 18 inches on center alternately near top and bot-
tom edges, and also staggered one third of the spacing in adjacent laminations. Two
side nails shall be used at each end of butt-jointed pieces.
Laminations shall be toenailed to supports with 20d or larger common nails.
When the supports are 4 feet on center or less, altermltc laminations shall be toe-
nailed to alternate supports; when supports are spaced more than 4 feet on center,
alternate laminations shall be toenailed to every support.
A single-span deck shall have all laminations full length.
A continuous deck of two spans shall not have more than every fourth lamination
spliced within quarter points adjoining supports. ,
Joints shall be closely butted over supports or staggered across the deck but
within the adjoining quarter spans.
No lamination shall be spliced more than twice in any span.
7 (m) Post-beam Connections. Where post and beam or girder construction is
used. the design shall be in accordance with the provisions of this code. Positive
connection shall be provided to ensure against uplift and lateral displacement.
Conventional Construction ProvIsions
I Sec. 2517. (a) General. The requirements contained in this section are intended
for conventional, light-frame construction. Other methods may be used, provided
:~ a satisfactory design is submitted showing compliance with other provisions oflhis
~ code.
~ Appendix Chapter 25 provisions for conventional construction in high-wind
I areas shall apply when specifically adopted.
~ In Seismic Zones Nos. 2, 3 and 4, all buildings of unusual shape, size or split
] levels shall be designed to resist lateral forces in accordance with other provisions
~ of this code.
-=:~
(b) Foundation Plates or Sills. Foundations and footings shall be as specified in
Chapter 29. Foundation plates or sills resting on concrete or masonryfoundations
shall be bolted as required by Section 2907 (t).
(c) Girders. Girders shall be designed to support the loads specified in this code.
Girder end joints shall occur over supports. When a girder is spliced over a support.
an adequate tie shall be provided, The end of beams or girders supported on mason-
ry or concrete shall not have less than 3 inches of bearing.,
(d) Floor Joists. I. General. Spans for joists shall be in accordance with Table
No. 25-U-J-1.
282
ExhiIit
;z.
.v-".-"':'<"-- .",~., ,.-"'=-........,.n.J.-nT~
r0-
o
IC ...
N CI !
g "5f;i
=1 _.8e
..... 8 ~
4;1-
~:s~
.....
,o,o....,Il'J......'O ,gg
afo,o~go~ .5'::;
.... I':l 'E.'l'l ~ as ....
~ ~ g ~ >.'Ol!'E. =:3
S-"'o.!::.e1l~~ ;s'"
:I....... tn\lol......e:-
......cd(Jcum....,.c~ ..a.t
8ii"'lIl~a...'" c::aS
,1::"'", .sa "'c::
'0 .......e S cD Ql ,.C 0
g g'g:g s ~:S S =: !l: '0
~.5,g"'" as G)'O'ti ..;~
:d .....e:>-QlG) ....0
~$,g~.5.g1;~ ~~
o -... III ""
.;, '0 lQ ... '0 P...... Ql Ql
.;l1':l"'P.Ql.~'" ~,o.
~QlC::Ot:N II> ..0=
.., 1ll)....0.....c::'O'>. as
...G)-.; P.ll'JaSS" C::,I::
...i:",'OP.Ql :;::S""'lQ
o....'Oaiil'5~,o'" 1l'J";
"0,1:: s:: "'~==
c:....r.>c::Ql.....~...."" Sas
E ;so..o ,,"Ill ;s!l:
'01l'J:;:: goc::.....
= Q) _= ~.. boO 0 ~
~S'O~d+J~f~ tJo
Of p,iii:~p.~'O~
.........~ ='0 ~;l.s t; g~
z ~cDO-S::'" .,=!l:~
o .e=->.aS....'g..g ....
... . =-... as....;s '0'"
t: ro-..., ",.. as '" s:: '" as
~ :5"; 56bt):d:Oe;;p..
~ Nii,g~::;l:sg.~>.~e;>
co cSlIlc::IIl,",~llfIc::tl~Sai
10 ~ 1iJ !l: tl $ o'd Q/ '" P '" '"
=> 000~"'S::';.!:: ::1::!
,..( p''O P... 1:1. as ...'0 l';; III
P:'l
~
o
o
c:l
Z
...
9
s
~
S
o
r-
...
Z
~
III lI'l ",'0 "'=
-g~:d.3!i~
..as UJOu
UJ.....cn """"'w
. ~ -g >." u:l
llIl"l::'....-~c::
-=:l' Il'J ~...-
~.."':a...'C
:;: 0;:5 "'0 =-~
.....c cu__
.....,o2tJ:>-
r1,.C"'Ol~e
..... '0 P.
ai~~:..:i
o'O...=<;;as
= Q/ 1:1.~_ =
= tJ 112 1:1.$
.. - '"
1lS~s::'Oe,o.
=-c p,~ 0-
CP:: f~ Jo4
~.e t: Ol ~ s::
-.; >.al'O,o.:z
",,,,p.='d'"
~al-<Ol='"
",0112"''''
'tIS::_S::p.>.
5:3caS,g.e
_-~.E '0
-t: OG)Ql
:;Ol",tJ:>-t:
=: =-,1:: '" ~ 0
'tl'" Ol ~
'ga,gil:;~
;EQIIMIt~iQ)~
=~.... .caS
,....,cdfOllll:5!. ........
e!l: f ~:;:: ~~
.s~8~a~
'"
~
1j
;::
e-
~
""
"'=
z
o
::;;
::;;
o
U
l>:
o
X
o
~
'tl
o ~ 0
0- ....0-
...
~ o~
'C '0 'C '0 .....d 'C N 'tl 'C 'C
~o:lo:l~.o~~.o~~~
I I . I cP I I CD I , I
NNN<<r1N~r1NN~
~
o
~
UJ~
=~
~8
~~
~~
~o
eo
o!:i~
~....
,~
"'=cs
.Qt)
6i
Zo
~o
...
==
<
~
0:
=
.:
z
o
6
w
z
z
o
u
...
~
i:
I-'
<::l
o
.,~
N
=
.Sl
....
'"
'"
UJ
.
~~~.8-5.5~
al.!l.... S::lQp..
~ 1-<.><:;1''0 go
'OO~,l::Q""
:;:I .....1Il~1-<0
.... '" ... 0 ...
1Il2:l.c llIll-<~'::;
1-<:5~.s0_
o...._'tl ..... cD
- U2 I 'C::-'" t::5
~ "':;:1' 0
...o;s........""
~~,sIll><~1-<
...>.~~"',s
'O...."O..........c
Q/O.c ..--
:5! lQ r.> ..;.c.....
~1ll)c::"'~0'"
8.E'i'i:'i'S><
=-:g ~,g 5.8 ~
CD-~ G2 O-'~
",,g "'.... 0/
;;: c:: ~ .e.s;:
"'1-<"'1-<>'~tJ
~0.s;::5.e.s;:=
..c:~"" .c:+-J"'i'
.... 1l'J1Il.... "'0'"
0c:::0S::"';S
~ O-ltJ....-.~
d:;::... Ill)~'
+J'::::Oc~=>,
l:l,1-<S:::a.c><,c
QJ as '-1_......
~ 1:1.0"S c::~.c
~ Ill).....e as '"' r.>
=!l .c.c.E
Olli:~~""r.>b
~~o""gj~~ .
UJ.e:: ;,;.!:~":l
'''I:;I';;j'O lQ'd'!::
N s::.s;:.E~ >.=.8
al",lQc::,cdlll
~
o
.
'tl"l:;l'C'tl'C~
cOCOo:lICIlO'
........ .... 'tl
I . I I I CP
(l?MNNN....
· ..... s:: . -"1:;1 .s;:
~~:l~.E~
~~t:sla*
..... :t ce'--
cDQI,sI-<~1Il
..., G.l 't-I'V'
Ill.... .''d >< >.
g.S::~:;:I',o.
~$e~e.c
IllQlal""'.s::~
>>,c .... tJ-
.e ...'0/0 = 0'
- ><-
>.'iii 'g. l. ~
_.c....<<:;:I
g;mltl~O...
1-<.... .... 0
~.c.....c >.....
III ~M g,o.
~"ii~"'J::~
'tl.c. 5""~
~d)eo.S--
lootZ ...... 6,~
8."''5 >.Q/ '"
=-~s::..o~~
:=O.-.c.... .
1Il=.h""I-<>'ho
1Q1IlQ/=0....5
:l~l:'i'....fs
-3....0--~.,
8 S >.~ ~ .. .:::
~.el-<.....'tlo;:l
,.Jal.c0... C::;::l
.s::Eg::~Ol'ii
~ G) ~ ~ 1M t:.-.
<D .c 0 r1 c:: -.
=..~....."'.5CO
. ........~a><
(l?bt)""':<lal'
= 0 "'._ I-<N
_~....tQ't-oI'-'
l. 'g !! .5 '"
QI...:; .e
s;l,,,, .s:: ....
c~;~ 0
QI-9J: 0 l::
.=:;....IIM ......
.:;(o)-:~ c;
_..oallll ~
Cii ;l: III
~(:;f!0l
<D l:: "0 .
.!:: J:...'iii
~=- ;l:
1Il~1Il
<'i~ii
":'1:1~5
e 00 ~~
.. _:l' .S ';;j
:!~oo f!~
iC ....,..... ~ ~
f1l~:;:: '0
-"S::al .3.<::
~.....:al':l ...
00= '" "Z.~
... ~J: ...
c.5+J..., Cd I:IC
~d.,j.... 25
.stogO ~.~
.! ~8.....tt::~
::,g"'S::.Q~'"
... $ ",~.,... ..
G~~:!o-5~
";;;:i to:z "''1:1
lll~ ...",~~
.'Oal"':2z
NEo";;<':l :@
p....lQE-< .,
.
s:: .
., I>lI
= C:""":"
a;<> 'a:!='
,c QI .B ...
.5g'g=~
ioI01l~"'"
...
....
...
~.
.'~~~-~'-~ --~.~
.
'O~C::IQ"''-'l::''',!l:~'O''''tl' lIiJ"'''''''''''
.5",~.e. O;El::tJ ;::l.SlI':l~ s::i:..s::S:::;:l0
Il'J ",,$,0. >..... .........,!;E i:'" Ol Ol -'0.... e:d '"
bt) g,~ S as::. = Po.... ~ >. Il'J ~ ..... I-< p.. ho
.5lG lG ~ s...."- _.-. ~ ~"Z... S ",,s Ill).c:l
'0 a "" .....lQ :;. QI ;. '" - s:: '"
.......",.... crJ: '-'''C_.....c-l .,oIIfIIIIII.... c:: "';:::...... a,>""'" CJ cd
... ......... iQ) ~.,-4..... ..... ~ 4-11 All .... #'1. Co. =' ~.
::! ~ .c bt)'iii 'U "'.!:: .. r1 ~ < ~ Po .. - - III ....
- N....S ~ c:: II ;::l be'"' t: bt)'tl ; 1:1..c QI
,o.....~t: 'ZtJg'.51Q e..;",'g ~a:d.ce;;:S
ll.s:: 0 &'5;::l.5 I-< s1l ~= QI:>- -'0 '" "" "'...,
tJ5:lSp..::S...O..",OlO ",~.ee jS",tl;SS::-
as.::::slQ 3",...50"'=- C::SI-<IIl~S
Q;..'glQl-<>'o ....~ "'''I:;I'iiip.. 8"''''llIl1!~
'O::S ""- o,o....~ l=lca I-< "'s"c d Ill'::: p.o.C::_;s p.
o",as ..I':....~Ol.l': 0 III
>.... c. "" III tJ '" "" '" 1Il:5 s:: 0 l::.E lI'l !=!
l-ticQZS::cQ).... Q)g:t*""c:::..... Og2~=...,J-
o.:;>QlI-<S.-...."',Cc:: "'....o~ - ....1l'J
1iJ c::.e ~;sl. Q/~'C 0 "S:c"':;:: :E '" ~ C::o '0 11
,'" 'O;S;' C::'O s::,l.l:;::'O ....e._ .,.,~
~~:; gj "",s'l'l", '" s:: <= I-< 1l vi as::: llIltJ '" Clo
o .c"'IIls::c::~~d "'~..t=-"'Oc::5111
"'''''2Oldol.e-",.J: .,'O'tl.c....O
:5 ~ bt);S '0:5:5 S 8. S ~.: 'g J1 41 .3 III "'::! B1!
.....c.s I-< '" lQ "'~.... c:: 1'3 "'1iJ 1l'J:;:: UJ: "'t:!l d
.... ~ '0 '" ~ III ... M 0 III Ol ~ I-< d =-'0 Ill.o '0
Ct..'C..t.o'_aJO .....""'5:irtlc ._g,)p..P"""\oG,)
~ >..3 f :... 8 ~ ll:;:l ..0 III ~ ~.! p. i;l I-< :E
>< ~ '" ""'O"5..l:? gj 'd s:: t 11.2 -; I-< =-'" g;s
r:aaSS!C::"'C::oaS~~ =.2..~'" ~1l"'1l.llt1.g
I:1...O.......c::-c..... d~'=1-< ....0...'"
bi\fJ'ti-- d 0'0'" i-i(:; ..t: al,Cil .5! 0 '" "':5ll>
i "" ",' ~ '0 ') 0 ... = ... III a :::: I-< .c ,c
o IIlcO-::: ~ "" I-< 0 'A ~ P. >.Ol III o:SS: 0:=
;s.... w.. '" 0 _ c:. 'tl:a c:: cD d ~ '"
::1l:~ e ~ ~]~ ~ ~ a~::,. t~E bil~i
;s "'.c"'IIl~~"" lQll'Jo41 :;:l",=-1Il
. 0 >..c;,.J ~... ~ '" al . :::::;:: ... ~ . as '0 - III s::
....l-<aS'" o~",.c1llOdalS!:.; CO II> =:.9<:do
os.$.5tJc.r.>o", !l:~:;le;>' .c;::lI:1.I:1.:;l
'0
o
o
;l:
~C:::d1! :; "0 -
'" -:5 Ill) '" '" J: ... J!lQ
.I': ~ ~ _o:l Cd
:;:: !) ~.I': ~ 1.0 .c bC.
"'.... _ '" .:l .h c::~
ii~~-;~ c c ~.;
1Il"'~iiS ~ 0 =s::
=rn co 0 s:: 'alP
~"'1l....:a ... as lQ,.C
~+-J~ s.. 5 ~....,
~.5.<::"~~ .:l III f"O
;;:o.<>_';~ l':l'lI'l ;."
"'=-'<::0 ~s.!: ~Cd
S 1l ;l: z; . llIl~ "5 p..:S
s'" !)25il.5;: c:: .8 =
S ~... ~ '" ~ :;l ~ '" >>l!
8:;:.,;E-<lI'lo~"'.e ~...
. ~ ~ =,2 E' d)~:; = t
c:"'.--..."':5'O.c ~...
., ~ ~'O 0 ~ f:: '" ~ ca
~"';...~='-S'3: .=S
..tJ 0'-"" '" =e;>'""C::4111l
~.~ ~o.Qo~s:::.s~f.'II
~p..!2p. .,., ",...Q/",
~ '" 'C; '" c:: >''tl '" i: f!.; Q;
=-.c Z ....,g ~ 0:5:a.... ... 8
0:'" 0~i-i0 "'.'"
=:0 'C::I-< !i=C::'tlC::!l.-
Illj:; P;: "'~~ o~ f 8.oj'~
WI'- lQ ... =: cd...... s:: -
= c:: ~ c 8..2 'tl '" 'tl ill-< ....
C3,go~ ",g:;.::,so
Cl........::l,o........- ::l '0
l:lool""~,,,.e... ",e;>':~
UJ~2g.::~~~~~o!)
c.;S::,c- g.o~ C::r:a ,,,It.e
~~5~:; ~ Z ~
cD
1Il...~e;;
So;oc:: 'C
;:....~ :::=:j~ =
! ';'E ~ ll> '2::: ~'d
...C::'t". ",foal'" oBbll
8 OJ QI <>II QI ",'" p.... .... III s::
..c::~I-<~ .s~I....!! <D0,!::1Il
I~~o_==~~~~~ ~~~~
~ 0 l!i -E ! ! ~'C ~ Q :d e f! llIl.e ~
'C"'1~0.2 "'=~lQc..:l ,cs::o",
~..'O~.e~8"'0l0=-0~ ,.Cu....'C
1Il"".8 ... i.....1:l: It...,!....... ~ f! ho s::
I-<'OQI-<O lQ.aSlll :_,C=0l
o.,.,...o...",~lQ"'lIl Ol~ ~'"
:::::o~o.!~~II1D a ..5~"O
~~o~o~~m - ~~=~
III ~;s~p..l:1.~ ~ 06;::l.ctl
0~.elG200ol "';s"""
....-;s.c .......'S, bll I-<C::.c.s::~
..lll)lQ"",:l'O'tl ~ ,:l:;::""r.>C::
~~coC::al::S;sp.. ~ ~==s::...
~~~~~~w~ u ~8~~8
~ .
.<::'"
....Q/
tJ
.......
00
....
'0 :,~.~
"",c ;s
",,,,Ole;>'
.!:! o~ '"
"'~c::~
'0 --
s:: '1:1:5 ~
"'=......
..aloC.
"'....... 0
.e .......
Ea,:l'O
::l _.. ~
l::6s::=
",I-<:=ol
.cOoS::
E-<....s'"
od.e
rirQ4):=
.:l I-< J: ol
~","J:
=: .e c:: '"
=Scd",
::'Q,)J: =
~e~~
Q'O ~ ~
""= g.- s::
o:::;l:~ g
= I':lr.>
<II ~'" I-<,ci
....,_.ell....
rI.l c:;;:::~ bO
9'~t'jog
.. ,I:: ...
QCIll....;....
.Otn1t'-l
I-'''''''lQ....
-~=
. !. CJ . a,}
"".- = 0-
~ az ~
ExbiIit
lQ "1:;1 QI
S::s::,C
:30l>.
"" -d
",lIlc
2~ "
o _ 'C
OIllQl
..I-<
oQl
..c 1;
f""",
Q=
.s;:as",
r.> bll.~
C c::'"
....- ...
....a~
llIllll.c
c.to
51-<'"
ClOO
"1Il=
~1-<1Il
"'Ill)
0: Ill) c::
= =.-
illolS::
.1':'"
.... .
",..."''0
",,,,al,,,
"'-.... ~
bJ).g...... 0
2c::~~
t::o.-=-
c.C::d
...::l~",
"'lll)tJl-<
o="'~
"';aa~
bOf~'d
'"' c.J: '"
"'.... '"
'00:;:1
3
o
....
...
;::\
.
· /lJ) Il
IfU @lPP.1l
4p/? /!;: v ,- fil)
8UIl.D/ACtry o~ 7991 Li!l
k~ / DlJ
IV.)~I:;,.... 8l.lf /
.r,.....
" "'I/')_
. "'"",!'\?
April 18, 1994
~
victor Taugher, Building Official
Building Department
city of Dublin
100 civic Plaza
DUblin, CA 94568
RE: 7852 Starward Drive, Dublin
Code Compliance Survey
As requested by Building Inspector Robert White, my husband and I
would like to verify that on several occasions prior to the
building inspection of the above-mentioned address, we spoke with
our realtor, Fred DeGregoire of Mason-McDuffie in Pleasanton,
about our desire to have the Dublin Building Inspector do the
inspection. On those occasions, we were assured by Mr.
DeGregoire that having the inspection by the city Inspector was
within our rights.
After speaking with Mr. White regarding performing a building
inspection, he informed me that if he were invited into the house
as a city Inspector, any code violations would be required to be
fixed, regardless of whether or not the sale went through. After
being made aware of the requirement, I called our realtor, Fred
DeGregoire, and made him aware of the requirement and asked that
he also make the sellers and their realtor, Gary Schwagerle,
aware of the condition prior to the inspection. At that time,
Mr. DeGregoire assured me that he would do what was necessary.
The day before the inspection, I spoke with Mr. DeGregoire to
confirm the inspection plans. At that time, I again verified
that the sellers and the sellers' realtor had been informed of
the Building Department requirements. He confirmed my
verification.
On the day of the inspection I, my husband Ron, and Mr.
DeGregoire were present for the entire building inspection.
Before Mr. White entered the premises, he spoke with Mr.
DeGregoire about the city's requirement that all existing
violations be brought into compliance regardless of whether or
not the sale went through. Mr. DeGregoire again confirmed that
he understood the conditions and the sellers' agent and property
owners were also made aware of the City'S requirement.
Mr. DeGregoire then unlocked the lockbox and invited Mr. White
into the house.
During the inspection, the sellers' realtor, Gary schwagerle,
stopped by the house. Mr. White was introduced to him as the
city of Dublin Building ',Inspector. They spoke briefly about a
ExhIit1
.
.
couple of items (i.e., water heater non-conformity and
discoloration of furnace metal). Mr. schwagerle departed after
approxi~tely 10 minutes.
After coming to a stopping point in our negotiation, the
sellers', via their real estate agent, made it clear that they
there would be no further negotiation. We were asked, via our
agent, to make an immediate decision, since the sellers' wanted
to put the house back on the market as soon as possible if the
deal fell through. During this conversation, I made it extremely
clear to our realtor that the sellers would have to bring all the
building code violations into conformance if we did not purchase
the house. He insisted that he had made it clear to the sellers'
agent about all ramifications involved. After much
consideration, my husband and I declined to purchase the house
and arranged to meet with our realtor to sign the Release of
Liability form. At that meeting, I apologized to our agent for
being an anxious first-time homebuyer and for hounding him about
the Building Department requirements, but explained that I was
very concerned that the sellers' were aware of the ramifications
of allowing Mr. White into their home. He assured me, again,
that the proper procedures had been followed before the
inspection took place.
After a last minute attempt to re-negotiate, which we declined,
the sellers' signed the Release of Liability form, which released
our deposit from the escrow account.
I was shocked and concerned to learn that the property owners
contend that they had no knowledge of Mr. White's inspection of
their property. Although we had no direct contact with the
sellers' (all negotiation was via the agents, Mr. DeGregoire and
Mr. schwagerle) I was assured on several occasions by my realtor
that the proper procedures had been followed, and the presence of
the sellers' realtor during a portion of the inspection seemed to
verify that fact. Also, the sellers and their agent received a
copy of the inspection report during the negotiation proceedings.
The report was printed on city of Dublin letterhead with
Mr. White's signature block showing him as the person who
performed the building inspection.
sincerely,
~~\~~~.
Fawn Holman
ATTEST:
1( GP? /~
Ron Holman
I,
.
· It(!)!f!P,?/t
4Pn 2- '-~-1jJ}
BUilD e,l'." 5 1991 ! If/
Itv,- Op 0 -~--
::> I~I lJt.
'''S:Je: vl.!tv
C.,.,
'0'1
!/r;{:J"!
~C)~'
. ~~~\
SINCE 1887
Mr. Robert C. White
Senior Building Inspector
City of Dublin
100 Civic Plaza
Dublin, CA 94568
April 21, 1994
Dear Mr. white:
RE: 7852 Starward Drive, Dublin; City of Dublin Building Inspection
Report.
As per your request, I've documented the following facts/events
regarding the sales transaction for the 7852 starward Dr. property.
I hope this helps clarify the matter.
1. signed contract acccepted by Buyer and Seller, 2/3/94.
2. 2/6/94, Buyer ordered Property Inspecti'on through City of
Dublin, Inspection completed 2/10 & 2/11/94.
3. 2/8/94, Buyer's agent ordered Pest Inspection from Frontier
Termite & Roof inspection from yorkshire Roofing; both inspections
completed 2/16/94. -
4. 2/8/94 Buyer's agent called and informed the seller's agent;
that the City of Dublin, Robert white was hired to do the property
inspection alid th=.t if the City finds any code violations the
sellers would have to repair or correct as per the city'S building
codes and regulations. Also, the buyer will request that the
seller repair or correct the items in the report that are hazardous
in nature, ie: electrical & plumbing code violations.
5. Buyer's agent received the property inspection report on 2/17/94
from the City of Dublin & faxed to the seller's agent.
6. Buyer's agent received the Pest Inspection from Frontier on
2/18/94.
.
.
"
Mason-McDuffie Real Estate Inc.
5870 Stoneridge Mall Road, Suite 150
Pleasanton. California 94588
Office (510) 463-1200 FAX (510) 463-9216
ExhIitS
.
.
7. Buyer~s agent received the Roof Inspection report from Yorkshire
Roofing on 2/21/94.
8. 2/21/94, Faxed to Seller's agent the signed Buyer's
contract/Addendum requesting seller to correct or repair items from
all (3) reports at seller's expense that are of a safety, hazardous
and in code violation. (please see attached Contract/Addendum,
signed by buyer's. 2/21/94)
9. 2/24/94, Received the signed contract/Addendum from Seller's
agent, as well as Addendum B. (please see attached Addendum B)
Addendum B stated that the Seller would agree to do Section 1
repairs as per the Frontier Pest Inspection report and the Seller's
would agree to repair the roof, as per Yorkshire's Roof Report, But
the sellers would not correct or repair any of the items in the
City's Property inspection report.
10. 2/26/94, The buyer's decided not to buy the property due to the
fact that the Seller's would not repair or correct any of the Code
violations, ie: Water Heater, Electrical, Plumbing and structural
items. The Buyer's signed a Release of Liability on 2/26/94 and
the Buyer's agent presented the document to the Seller's agent.
11. 3/3/94, The Seller's signed the Release of Liability.
Please call me if you require any additional information.
Best regards,
;{",(C\. ~/~
Fred A. DeGregoire
"
rt8-iJ.U 12:JJ
" , I
~o, 5]0 463 9216
p, 02
IIASON McDUFFIE RE
OIST~19U1ED In CALIfC'flHl" ~~.l.tl()"IOf' RFAl.lQRS""
FORM 05-14
~~., , :i';':'i~:"': ~ ';',',.' " :,~ "':"~'\ii\r~If!lii~VW!i";."UI"'iili~T~'M'ii:~~'jlt;i"flS:;ii~\f'lit..f~iii~PW;',~,;;:!'!.;~':~;;;"t';:;;:;';" ':;:,~;,~[7~:I,:!i'.. ~;~';:,:
. I ..' '~~\1;5'~'~'\'i';:\1: ".\, ,:~'."i~;' ,.\,.-'.::.f\<t;ONTRAGT,S P~~Ej 'ENTtAUDENOUM!:';~~1:(1\\,i;.~~:/.:'\~!:;',': '~,:...~..~~};:"'~;:,"'~ ~~:..t .'~;.''' ,'::.'".
;"", ' ," :t\l'i~is'\ili~~'b~llmil~Wiiili:J',iJ#it;j~t~ii~"i~,~Hoh'el"t~bll~~':':":' ','- ,',', , ' ',"
CALIFORNIA A!lsoci"Tloi, o~ ~~illP"~, (c.oi~) ST;'NOARO Foil;' ,'.,:
. "~i .
The following terms and conditions are hereby incorporated in and made a part of lhe; ~ Estate Purchase Contract and Receipt
for Deposit. 0 Mobile Home Purchase Contract and Receipt for Deposit. 0 Business Purchase Contract and Receipt for Deposit,
o~ 1
dated .2 /::;,:: . ~19 , on property kno~-~~~-""~s;.J", S...z::&e,\LIM..1 i... l./.I3urJ
n which I /lON + __ I4-!lLt.... (~ - Is referred to as Buyer
3nd :~rJQ.Y, aA..Jr.e~ is referred to as Seller.
'f. ... 'lr ;;;;-- t-L-VWI A.JG ~oA:t., :
L.l ;:)t..... 81=- '/'oJ .cO.&:.-
-Yi)u/\ p L f fH{C,ll R.. 'EI .u G:..-rIAJ ('
~~..s. c: .;:L ~
rJjJ{" t3uv~ fJF~ ~d€ AJ ~ iJlZDlet::rY /2.WJ +- F,\-lJJN F{e ~ AtJ
~~~~ ~_t-.LOW~L~~t:1.:>'I'L (~~ ~4-rA..~ A-T
t::lt::f.:L....5.. e1- L- ~ ~ ~f'::J,s.b.~,..._t'r ~ e~ (""l' .D.E"; _
_~ C; /EC-'T10,.j ,I. .,..h I BMs --~-C"""Ll.....~ ;}.J ~I-:-e ~td2/1'l /'liE'
Cn,.fl1l./J l.- z:; )J.s<P E"c.'?7 (:uJ ~()e..;r:,;, 7JkT"B1J~/-4I 'P ~
1. ~~~~~.;*~~v~
~ - <~~--'-:&l" :l ' "", ''*'" ,'. . I '.....JJ S
1;: 6/Z -~ .,.-_.''-~ (fr~ _ . -""~ ;!!;~i.N-A/{A
, ' ';r'r: ...~ J..~~L:f::.ey Of!... CJ oUt, ti.- =rL.'- wJ?:1 ~_7T:;J:ti:..,y,,~~Y:b_bLG u:<~,.
-f1..I. S-!::r0...6I./--J 2C.L1J -rz-fP.: 1r~.o!lll:T 0"" -r H'i),lo-_C-U:.....jhl,.~0~_.:;.:~
~$"TO d~ ~.QAL~ 7'ei-eL;f ~,'fr1J~~ V
n..., "'T"f-W 2{).O);::__-vJ:..l::t:;x;:'J-r Nf!7:::.-y) ~ ';(E ~_~.......:t::::k.~_e;h..,l'D$.&
<;-rt.....,pl.~ \ U-1:L'-c...J:t.:.-&~ +0 c ,S"'~t:J. _.___~...,_,
3': C lT~_lJ J- 1ll4&/-dJJ.-i,. -.J;AlS/llit:nofr Jie.pro~T;)tfiJ!1:i) .:?.J 1"'7 /tf'f':
A. ~AlA:c.:g ~.. t-
- - \.v!-,~c. ~ ':;r:-re..". (, A, - r .
, ,I ,
"-~-n A-i-L P1Jzt.r~ I~L WVI-K.:
- ~ ~rrc..m~ _; ~m~~~. COu.v~~
~Tnr .__j :eUiEne'i~A=L"-t/~ ~-
-- .____,__I1C J~5...~_..jM. ~ --~~
fhll undersigned aCknowledge receipt of a copy of this page, which constitutes Page / of ,I Pagell,
.stJB~ ,-0 fti)/)~f)<-I."'" E.
Date 2 - 2 'f - 7 "I
Seller c,{$1[f'./ 9 ~/1.~
Jale
z - 2. I ~ 9~
~,,~ ~~~~ ,
Seller
Juyer
uyer
. ..' " .!.,~ . '.
. '. . ","'-,""~;-
, ". . I
.,
.
.
o ZlpF..... ,. Compu,", AlIgnmonl
NCFlINQ Cmmn AQJII"ed)
h
ADDENDUM No.
In reference to the ~ PURCHASE AGREEMENT, D EXCHANGE AGREEMENT, CJ LEASE 0 COUNTER
OFFER - covering the J8Jreal property, 0 business, fJ premises - commonly-known as
7Jb?... ~w~ 'D-'!.tVW- ,])IA.BL---;;:T C.d 9'LS:.6o
dated ~-.2....... '17' ,between /UJ7'I/ q<- ,.c1"tw'N' HdL.,Lt,AyV,; B U-';j t,Nt.!'
and
:J tJH".J
:J~
~~
St!c~
/
the undersigned Partl~ hereby agree as follows:
J, S~ .:sH,If"t-'-- ~~ S~tnJ aNt: (~) Or ~s
~e-P p/ ~/~ ~ OA-1TD 2 -II, -'1'-1
:.L. ~ ~ .3H"tL1... f€'R.."e:~~ 1tJ02::.-() I::."() 'FPA-~ I'D te.trufT A-::S
{.ltff> b'tffIJ J j./
~-n6#'
f>..e.c)vl PIP 4
_~#I R~-J6-
(~ tJ"f--n:D
#~ 71J
J- -;Ll-'f If)
It D D<(l'>/ ~
J)Aff{J :<. - 2 I -Q'I
,+.vo A-s - /3
mA><! t..IlW+r
~
'3. .1>- I-L.
~' J.urL...i-
..sb~
sruFlZ- r/H"'"vS
lJr A-~
;]1-{41.L ~
~nso
J..../
(,I~ .t
13'1
UD
13 r.L,}i1SJL
Fwe.~
I?~}t- /fl..,B
/.$ ~ 71.
'1. I~ n1'5
I; Nn- AC~13 Ui Sfil.USY2- ~~ "1)U;'
IZ 16-1( r
'I
f1) Pu. r 1fi.lf )( ~r pAUL atl 1>iC ~T"" 'By S,4('lM!.P"'t-Y
.;-.: SfZ.L6Y2- IS I\I'2T1 ,gr;u...'-J'7r- 4't N~ /t~ I'V7he.. C8>V'" 7/f~tJ /11~
I r /lI'""eW ~ JU.../;V'?,- I r tv T1J A/tEW,;'f">VD lJ,e. G<< ~rJ ')
co PES .
(:"" '9€LL61t m~w:s r;le- A!U;1r ro fl/;tVC trJnt./t.. peeFb-ert..7J BIJ
WH ~ 7)(E';I SEU57:.:r ,
The herein agreement, upon Its execDtlon by both parties, Is herewith made an Integral part of the aforementioned Agreement of Sale.
DATED:
TIME:
DATED:
2-LY -9'1
TIME:
Buyer
Seller
Buyer
Seller
Agent
Witness
Agent
FOAM 101-8 (3-90)
L CA"oOit ("') 72"9fl.< ~ PROFESSIONAL
. . QiI PUBLISHING
COPyAIOHr 0 1990, BY PROFESSIOr.w. PUBlISt4If\1G CORP, 12:2PAUl.OR.
.
SALE 1/
NOTI':: Thi::;..Jc1rlll hilS llC!cn prcpnred hy Masnn-McDuffie Co. on the.> ndvicc of
itl; ll'g:ll cOllnsel in'respect to its position-in the matters involved. No
rcpn~sentation is made as to the legal validity or the adequacy of any
prnviRion in r(>~pcct to other parties. Each party should obtain any needed
Il.~,,1 ndvicl' from hbl own :Ittorney.
. RELEASE
;J fr.N C Y .:::I. C .J..i.JTILi:l-L--
PO/-.-) -t S"V~ ~~L. j'H AA.J
Sc H u..! A C:I::R.. L€ I 1<1:: f\-t- "/t)R. S
,
mA-sup.j.. rv\c..-.6 tJ~,'r::=, C R-,::::ta.- E~~~
SELLERS,
BUYERS,
BROKER, and
BROKER
hereby release each other from all obligations and from all liability for
claims and demands arising out of t~t certain Real Estate Purchase Contract
da ted
f)../a./q 4-
, ,
'7 &' S ;l. <;' 77t-2-vJ A.P-D
~ l1 g L--;,..J
,
concerning the property at
J
/)j2IU~
ql?...,b~
C ,A
_ (including any and all amendments to said Contract) on condition that the
deposit made in connection with said Contract be disbursed as follows:
":P'
. ;~..
t~~.<.
$ to Sellers
$. RIO.f22- to Buyers ~
$ to Broker
$ to Broker
and on the further condition that all of the above named persons agree to this
Re)ease.
..
Signed ,.j;;'~",-
->:-<, · -;-'-~~'~f.:~:~~:"!~~~:~~~::~~:?:~~(\
BUYERS:
~.
SELLERS:
l-1?AAU!Y '1 ~-;(;;i?n'V
t-BROKER:
. .</~~~f jJ7...;:....-.
li~~~€I>~:~~-::.~t'~~?~~\\
'1<)1 ~ ~.- -... ~)I
1.1 - I ~ ...-1
~". ~ /YJ);
..... ( >-f"'-~<\;"/
......0.. I rf~' "'\\.. ......... .......
....-...~..!..~/
CITY!F DUBLIN
.
Po. Box 2340, Dublin. California 94568
.
City Offices, 100 Civic Plaza, Dublin, California 94568
~
March 8, 1994
Nancy J. cantrell
c/o Fred A. DeGregoire
Mason-McDuffie Realtors
5870 stoneridge Mall Rd. suite 150
Pleasanton, CA 94588
RE: CODE COMPLIANCE INSPECTION AT 7852 STARWARD DRIVE, DUBLIN, CA
1~' 11
On ~~, 1994, a code compliance survey was done at 7852 starward
Drive, Dublin. There were numeroUS code violations found.
You are requested to obtain the necessary building permits to correct
the violations within 30 days and complete the corrections within 60
days.
If you have any questions regarding this matter, please feel free to
contact our office.
Thank you for your prompt attention concerning this matter.
~(d C. CJ}L-
Robert c. White
SENIOR BUILDING INSPECTOR
cf
Attachment: Survey letter
cc: street file
ExhIit6
Administration (510) 833-6650. City Council (510) 833-6605. Finance (510) 833-6640. Building Inspection (510) 833-6620
Code Enforcement (510) 833-6620 . Engineering (510) 833-6630 · Planning (510) 833-6610
Police (510) 833-6670 . Public Works (510) 833-6630 · Recreation (510) 833-6645
...
"
...:"~~"""
l;~~(~~~~~~~\\
11Q~ ~~l
-"\:~2~-
'," /J rrnO"':-';/ _.
~,....
.
.
.>
CITY OF DUBLIN
P.O. Box 2340, Dublin, California 94568
.
City Offices, 100 Civic Plaza. Dublin, California 94568
February 17, 1994
Ron & Fawn Holman
8617 Beverly Lane
DUblin, CA 94568
RE: 7852 STARWARD DRIVE, DUBLIN - CODE COMPLIANCE SURVEY
Listed below are the code violations found during the code compliance
survey at the above referenced address.
GARAGE AREA
1. Self-closer required on house to garage door; section 503 (d)
Table 5B occupancy separations, Uniform Building Code, Exception
#3.
2. Water heater -
A. Needs to be minimum 18" to firebox; Section 1310 Uniform
Plumbing Code.
B. Pressure temperature relief shall terminate exterior of
structure.
C. Water Heater required to be seismic strapped; Section
1310(e) Uniform plumbing Code.
D. Fuel gas piping; Section 1202(a) Appliance Fuel connector.
E. Accessible shut off required; section 1213(0) Uniform
Plumbing Code.
F. Venting hot water heater, single-wall connector transition
to double wall flue (Type B) at roof penetration or provide
611 clearance on single wall flue to combustibles; Section.
1323(B) Uniform plumbing Code.
3. Remove storage area in garage (ceiling) suspended from rafters -
Roof design section 2305(A) Table 23C Uniform Building Code and
section 1001 (c)7 Uniform Housing Code.
KITCHEN
Recommendation - GFIC on outlets within 6' of kitchen sink.
1. Vent over gas stove, section 30S-4(f) National Electrical Code,
Lamp Protection; no vent screen or lamp protection.
2. Outlet under counter, exposed Romex, no outlet cover; Section
305.4(H) National Electrical Code. outlet on garbage disposal
circuit; garbage disposal required to be on separate circuit;
section 220(16) National Electrical Code.
I
Administration (510) 833-6650. City Council (510) 833-6605. Finance (510) 833-6640. Building Inspection (510) 833-6620
Code Enforcement (510) 833-6620 . Engineering (510) 833-6630 · Planning (510) 833-6610
. _ 7 . Public WorKs (510) 833-6630 · Recreation (510) 833-6645
II"
.
.
Ron and Fawn Holman
February 17, 1994
Page 2
-
HALL BATHROOM
No permits on file for remodel of bathroom.
1. Toilet flange, rusted/loose; section 907 Uniform Plumbing Code.
2. smoke detector's required; section 1210 Uniform Building code,
state law requires smoke detectors in hallways be installed on
resale.
MASTER BATHROOM
1. Cabinet in bathroom installed does not have m~n~mum required
clearances from toilet; section 907 (E) Uniform Plumbing Code.
2. Handicap grab bars installed in shower (check for caulking around
flanges and screws) .
3. Skylight installed in bathrooms (no permits on file) show
evidence of leakage; section 1001-H, Faulty weather protection;
uniform Housing Code. No backing installed for nailing of
sheetrock edges; section 4704 Uniform Building code, Horizontal
Assemblies, Uniform Building Code.
ATTIC _ Electrical wire splices; required to be installed in junction
boxes; section 300-15(B) National Electrical Code.
FRONT PORCH _ outlet used as junction box; section 300-15(3) National
Electrical Code to be covered & accessible, wiring incased in stucco
stone.
ROOFING _ Leakage at valley, composition, two layers not installed per
manufacturers specifications - recommend licensed roofing contractor
inspection. Section 1001(h) Uniform Housing Code.
FOUNDATION - Pier and grade beam; section 2516(m) Post Beam
Connections, Uniform Building Code; foundation (piers) to post/beam
connection/shims between pier blocks and pier; no positive connection.
If you have any questions regarding this matter, please feel free to
contact our office.
l\~c~iL-
Robert C. White
SENIOR BUILDING INSPECTOR
cf
cc: site file ~
Fred A. DeGregoire
~
.
.
RESOLUTION NO.
- 94
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF DUBLIN
~
DENYING A VARIANCE TO SECTION 2516(m) OF DUBLIN BUILDING CODE
WHEREAS, The heirs of the Estate of John Young have
requested a variance to section 2516(m) of the Building Code in order
to allow the posts supporting the floor of the dwelling at 7852
Starward Drive to remain without a connection to the foundation pier;
and
WHEREAS, the city council of the city of Dublin did hold a
public hearing in this matter on May 9, 1994.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT THE Dublin City Council
does hereby deny said requested variance.
PASSED, APPROVED AND ADOPTED this 9th day of May 1994
AYES:
NOES:
ABSENT:
ABSTAIN:
Mayor
ATTEST:
city Clerk
~1