The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutItem 8.5 Streetscape Design CITY CLERK Fule # D[b][ll][~}[3J[3] AGIENDA STATIEMENT CITY COUNCIL MEIETING DATE December 18, 2007 SUBJECT Presentation of Proposed Streetscape Design and Alternatives for the East and West DublIn BART Stat10n Corndor Enhancement Projects Report Prepared by Melissa Morton Public Works Director ATTACHMENTS GraphIC Presentat10n of Proposed Design and Alternatives 3) Receive Staffs presentat10ll Select the preferred Identity Mmker and Gateway Feature alternatives and Approve the proposed streetscape deSIgn and dIrect Staff to proceed With final deSign RECOMMENDATION"" J f'/ \W 1) 2) FINANCIAL STATEMENT The East and West DublIn BART Station Corndor Enhancement Projects are beIng funded With federal transportatIOn dollars awarded to the City by the Metropohtan TransportatlOn Commlss1On In COllJunct1On WIth ItS Housmg IncentIVes Progran! A total of $3,376000 IS available for the deSIgn and constructIOn of these two projects DESCRIPTION On July 3 2007 the City CounClI approved a consultIng agreement With Royston Hanamoto Alley dnd Abbey (RHAA) to prepare the deSign of the East and West Dubhn BART StatIon Corndor Enhancement Projects These two projects w1l1 Improve a vanety of transportatIon modes mcludmg pede~tndll transit and bicycle faClhtIes located pnmanly on Dubllll Boulevard leadmg to the East and West Dublm BART StatIOns AddltlOndlly Dublm Boulevard Will be enhanced WIth new CIty entrance signs medmnlbndge rmlmg treatments a gateway feature at the mtersectlOn of Dublm Boulevard and Dougherty Road and IdentIty markers trom Hansen Dnve to TassaJara Road consistent With the City s Streets cape Master Plan These two projects are beIng funded With federal transportatlOn funds prmclpally to acknowledge DublIn s approval of high denSIty housmg near the East Dublm BART StatIOn ~__________________________________________________________WM__~W____________________________________________ COpy TO Royston Hanamoto Alley and Abbey Page I of3 ITEM NO ~ 5' G \CIPIFast Dubhn BART Corndor Fnhanccmcnt\AQ't Gateway realure Presentation 12 1807 doc IDENTITY MARKERS The proposed Identity Markers wlll be placed approximately 700 feet apart m the median of Dublm Boulevard from Hansen Dnve to TassaJara Road to highlIght thIS maJor artenal as the common feature that connects the entire City With the POSSlbll1ty of emphasIzmg mdIvldual neighborhoods and dlstncts Based on the Streetscapc Master Plan conceptual design approved by the City Councll m June 2005 RHAA has refined the design and prepared three alternatIves as shown on page SIX of the Attachment Option A represents a classIc design similar to the IdentIty Marker conceptual desIgn mcluded III the Streetscape Master Plan ThiS optIOn mcludes the offiCial logo of the City below the shamrock panel OptlOll B represents a modern form of the approved conceptual design With an enlarged SIngle shamrock and City sign located above the shan!rock panel OptIOn C also represents a modern appearance WIth an optIOn of attachIng a DIstrIct or Village nan!eplate m the mid sectIOn of the marker ThIS could be mcluded If the Council Wishes to deSignate certam dlstncts of Dublm Boulevard, such as "HIstone Dlstnct "Downtown "TranSIt Center etc The City Counctl Will be requested to select the preferred alternative (and fimsh) to be mstalled GATEWAY FEATURlE Also prepared for thIS presentatIOn are three conceptual deSIgn alternatIves for the Gateway Feature to be located at the southeast comer of the DublIn Boulevard/Dougherty Road mtersectlOn AdoptIng the goals and mtent of the CIty Streetscape Master Plan the gateway feature IS Intended to announce aITlval Into the City and create a sense of place and excitement ThiS IS a mam component of the project as It wIll be seen dally by at least 60000 motonsts passIng through the mtersectIon The followmg are descnptlOns of the alternatives The presentatIOn IS attached for reference Concept One The Wmd Forest Ammated by the wmd a forest ofwmd sculptures captures the natural energy of the site as well as the attentIon of passersby Each sculpture rangmg from 15 to 35 feet m height consists of a smgle mast sproutmg four branches each carrymg an anemometer-a common eastly mstalled and mamtaIned wmd measunng deVice The angled branches elevate thiS assembly of anemometers to create a plane of mOVIng objects a graceful wave that floats above the site and carnes wmd npples across ItS surface ThiS eye catchmg motIOn relates the sIte s natural forces to an audIence pnmanly protected from the elements WithIn their automobiles GroundIng the lofty sculptures a claSSIC stone wall spans the site armouncmg the entrance mto Dublm Estimated cost $622 000 Concept Two - The Flymg Harps Balancmg strength and elegance thiS deSign sends two shlmmenng towers skyward anchonng them to two correspondmg earth forms With a spread of cables msplred by the stnngs of traditIOnal Insh harps The 40 foot towers nse at an angle away from each other to create an mverted arch shape while their cables seem to embrace one another and the ground between them The two towers are carefully posItIoned to appear as one solId tower when approached from the Dougherty Road off ramp then fan out hke a bIrd s WIngs as the viewer approaches Dublm Boulevard Thousands of small hght-catchmg Page 2 of3 small alummum fans form the skms of the towers, gwmg them an almost transparent and constantly changmg surface that complements theIr grand scale These fans are sImilar to those used to cool automobile engInes referencmg the role that automobiles have played m shapmg Dublm EstImated cost $562000 Concept Three - The Eternal Ribbon A modern tWIst on the tradItIOnal gateway arch thIS deSign manifests constant motIon combmed With stablltty Inspired by the MoebIUS stnp a steel nbbon nses from two sweepmg earth mounds The arch s seemmgly flmd form changes dramatically when Viewed from dIfferent angles along DublIn Boulevard and Dougherty Road whlle lts textured metal skm captures the changIng light The shape of thiS 30 foot tall structure IS reflected m the earth by a curved path cut mto the mounds the relatIOnship between the rolllllg earth forms and graceful arch creates an mfimty symbol-a resonant Visual thdt speaks to the CIty's nch history and bnght future Estimated cost $580000 RECOMMENDATION The City Council s preferences for the Identify Markers and Gateway Features Will finahze the proposed streetscape deSIgn Staff therefore recommends that the CIty Council 1) receIve Staffs presentdhon 2) select the preferred IdentIty Marker and Gateway Feature alternatIves and 3) approve the proposed streetscape deSign and direct Staffto proceed WIth final deSign Page 3 of 3 z - ...J co ::>' ol u.. o >- I- - U II I ! I l J!..... L en o :ul- e U o UW C...... o 0 -- hj~ tj).:a. r- er::1- ~Z c W -- ...oJ: OW ~U V> (]) Z 5<1: o<SI: ~z ww z l:) - V> . LU o ...J <( :J ~ 0- LU u z o u l~Y~ <C <C :z: l:I: I~ I ;<~ '1~ ""t:J 1': C Q)'" ......... ~ u -- ..Q ... ~ c: c s::: '- l.. .... E ...... ~ ...Q s::: CJJ ~ '" J2 - ~ 0 C1J c (]) l.. '- <U '- E V) ~ ~ ~ ...... ...... Q) V) ~ ~ u ~- 0 c lJ <U ~ '- .c -- E ...... 1:: c s::: LU ::3 ~ ~ 0 "- 0 0 Q) 0 0- 0- "0 CO u \J U ~ oc '- "- U - 0 s::: ~+:,--- o- s:: :E u l.. s::: I- .-- '- Cl::: -- V) 0 0 -- - t"'l <( ...Q s::: ...... -e ..Q cO ::3 V) , - E ::3 '" W 0- l'\"l Q) Q :r: :::> Q ~ c... ...... tIq. - '" 0 . . . . . 0 -- C"-I t"I1 ~ Lr) LU U .f; :0 Vl :> 0 l- e( U - w CI: 0' - % 0:::: c.. a:: I z ::s a.. 0::: WlJ I-z Vl~ <(Vl :ECS W a.. <( U Vl I- W W 0:::0 I-~ VlO 00... 0:::0 <(8: > w -oJ ::J o co Z - -.J 'CO ::> o o t W 'j\' \ ' (/)0 i.''j,."t. '~,...: '~! .' \ 0... ", <, o :' a:::: 0... ' " " .... tI) .Q.. E '0 !a::: -e :3 j U -..-.-... I ~':.'-';;" .. '." ..s:: ...., o :';-" Q,. < ~ 3~ l.f3 '" !,Il ..... c Ul E Ul u c a .r:. c UJ ..... o u ~E o u I- 0::: -< c:a ..... !,Il Ul ~ ..... !,Il a UJ ,5; :0 :J o <t <I: Z a: I V) I- Z LlJ I: w > o a:: a.. L' LlJ C- <( U V) I- LlJ W a:: l- V) ~ c:::: ~ U - a:: o t- V) - :r: r. ~ ... '7' lOJ ..J ~ o tII ~ ~ ~ ,. ;. . - - i 1-;, !! .!. i d; . ~ 1 ii i .! i .; ~...- i H ~ i Ii! !., Q ...... j Ii Ii iH :J. .. ". o;.~ ~..@J.U~ -l , J "'. ~ 1 ~ , "~ I .' , 1 I... " I ..... , "'.;' <,'" , . : . G) C') a:s - - :; c: .- - .c j C o . ... .... o ! :s .., ::I U. G) J: ..... t- O .... c: o .- U) :; w ... .c ... .., IIIf III ... ~ - ctI :::s ..... c.. G> CJ s:: o U t..f "b tt~ V> W Z --J W o :) l.J Z l.J V> w o w l.J 5 --J > Z --J c:o :) o w U a::: :) o V> M '" +- C Q) E Q) u c o ..c c ll.J ..... o "'0 ";:: ..... o U I- a::: <( <:Cl +- '" ~ +- '" o ll.J .~ :0 :l o 4: C :z: a:: II '3>00 '+~ :, =1. ~'.' L :/. .. i.. I . :-7 i\l ~ t: Q) E ~ e .Q.. 1; no :>... c ~.~ ~ >- -t no'- _ ro.J:; 5: _CLCL""::':: ...2-o(3ro c: (j) V'1 5: o no -0 (j) o ~~ ~ . . . 'l" - V'1 ....::.:: ~ 3 .S: V'1 o V'1 .Q.. e u - o -0 .0 ~ Q) V'1 .Q.. +-' V) :J o ..t: ..6 .iooI ~ ~E o ,. ~ ?;' ?;' a: ~ 1i 5: 3: 6 'E ~ ~ c ~ (3 V)VlOa:u o c c t:S U~roO~ro IOV).p . . . . ~ c Q) E Q) u c o ..c c w .... o ....::.:: "'0 L .~ ro ... CL 0 u tI:: ~ ~ p ~ s::: -2 :;:: Q) 0 V> E +-' ~ ~ r= 1;; o (j) 0 10.. ~ UJ .Q..'~ .~ E c-o .~ ro 1i _-o~V'1V'1 :J '" (j) = 1: ki 0 ~ E 3 .Q:O L: .c:Q -0 (\) C ro c( _ [~ .~ E_ . ::: rU Vl ,::; >... _ u c ,^ ..f-' .." -0 en ~,.- ~ :3-oi!5~t:- o ia '3: [~ :I: w a.. <( U Vl I- UJ w r r- r r .'~..~ . . . . l:I:: II ~ II rI ! Ii I III ~ V') ~ z w I: w ....J W Z <( ...J a.. ~ w ~ V') <( I: w l:) <( z ~ - V') >- ~ - ~ Z LlJ o - z <( co ~ => >-.. _+--J U Vl ~ :~ o C 0- :J -0 Q) 1d E..c ...... +--J o ~ ~:J o 1d s.o~ 0- V) C ~o Ow E s::: E ~ 0 0- u -0 -0 <( . -- fj'"5 a:l) ~-ti QJ ..... ..... VI.Q..~ ...,. 0 QJ t.. o . ~ U . s::: :.x.e ~. 8 ~ . ~ . QJ " . ~ V') ~ s::: 0- V) V) e u ~ Q) Q) "- u ~ t (1j 0... (1j o o r---- ^ OJ to E 'x e Q.. 0... IT! "---' OJ ...... t)1) o OJ u f.I) b-O. - ~v 15 .:.::: - L _v 0- -D o OJ "- ..::L ~ ~ ~ U Ow L E u ~ o 0 ro ~ E -~ -0 ro Ul ::::<(~ S V) s::: -- . N "5 .... QJ ~ VI .... S" s::: 8 s::: ~ ~ * o ::E QJ .Q.. o \oJ ~ QJ ~ CI) Q) 0- .b M s::: c Q) ~ C .~ 0- U Q) ...... u o ~ V) Q) t:: ~ o~v CI) ro Q) 0 ~cr:. o c '- 0 t: E Q) (1j ~o::: 0- U c ::::: nj OUl ...... V) s::: - rwi la'fJ 4-~ .... .Q. 8 ~ \oJ s::: o 0: ~ ~ o ~ QJ .Q.. o u ~ QJ ~ ~ ~ 5: ~ Q) 5: C Q) "---' C "---' g;v -- cd L 0 00:::: (lj ro v L C (lj OJ -(ij"' U Vl (lj Vl I~ ...... o C) N " aJ .0 E Qj > o Z Lt) '" .- c Q) E Q) u c o .c c UJ (; '0 4E o u I- ~ -< cO .- '" ~ .- '" o UJ ,!;; :0 ::> o CI: CI: 2: I:C II ~ ! -: <.> Q.l :.c e a. ~ ~ r 1 ------d------i 1"1J Lot-=?=> '" '" a. e t> .~ C E '" ~'5: a.._ '" c ",'" ~ .. "'" tE'~ '!;la. <.> c - '" .~ ~ 2!~ ~.~ '" o o '" " Qj ..0 E <ll > o Z -n u c: o '- ...., :.Q.. o ,01 V> W > - ~ co c: Z 0 '- ...., 0:::. .Q., 0 '" W +- C ..... (1) E ....I (1) u <(I C " 0 ~ ..c ..... c ., UJ E a.. ., ... '" 0 .~ "0 W , (!; 'C ... U 0 u Z I- c;c ~ <: 0 c: a:l +- 0 '" U '+J ~ .Q., 0 ..... a::: '" 0 UJ W .~ ~ Ii :::J 0::: 0 <( <( I: - >- c - ~ z - t- el: Z II w 0 I L-- _ ~ DO tf"?;> ...... o o N r...:- ID .lJ l:: QJ > o z ...... W L ~ LL ...J W Z <( a.. OwU UJW- r-o:::I Zt=)a.. <(...J~ a..iLt=) OO...J wwUJ O:::r-w :)Zr- r- _ V') X<(O UJa..w r-~I ~ U Vl Z~:J ~a:l2 V') Z o - l- e.. o I l/') - Z ~.! ~ .~ \: .. " ~ '" ." ~ - LL ~ 0::: o -.J o U c::: UJ ~ c::: <( I: >- I- - I- Z w o <II - c <D E <D U C o .!:: C UJ ..... o "'0 0;;:: ..... o U I- 0:::: <( l:CI ...J W w L Z ~ ~ LLWU OW- wo:::I r-t=)a.. Z-<( ...J~ <(iLt=) a..ZW ~wN ul-Z ~~o cau~ .- <II ~ .- <II o UJ .~ Ii :J o ." .. ;,g j ~-gn ~.~~ ]'i~ ~~~ Q ~ &. ~~ ;~ '" ~ ~ :g ~: ~ ct :z a: II I - C1~Lf~1 "' o o N " Oi .l:l E <D > o Z 00 z' , 0 (J - ~ II ::J I I: V> I O. I ~ 1 VI .. +- C 0 ill E I ill U c a.. I 0 r:. ffil . c L.U "- 0 ~ l ~ '0 .;:: "- II 0 I u <( I I 1- Il::: -<( L co +- VI ill >- 'I :; +- I- VI II, 0 - , L.U ~ I .!; :0 Z :J 0 W 0 4 ~ <C - Z IZ: I z ~ - V') w o l- e.. w -u z o U <:J Z - ...J ~ w > - J- ~ o u w o Ii 1i "" ~ iE E " '" ~ "'..:: <: " <<1"2 "'" E .. .. '" :i'i ~ ii ~ ~ .~~ \ ...J ~ w t.:) o 0:: CO 10 on '-t-3 ...... o o N ....: Cii .0 E QJ > o z '" '" +- C ill E (j) u c 0 .!: C UJ I.- 0 -0 4;:: .... 0 U I- 0::: <( a::l +- '" ~ +- '" ...J 0 UJ ~ .S; :0 Z :J I':) <( 0 c w :r: - 4 - :I: a:: II ~ s s ~ ~ lo.., ~ QJ ~ o ~ ::- S S ~ .~ s:: :E s:: .b.O Vi ~. ...., a.5 .~ (j 00 II ~ 4-3 ..... o o N " Qi .Q E C\l > o z ~ on +- C Q) E Q) u c a .c c UJ .... o :g .... .... o U I- CI::: <( c::l +- on ~ +- on a UJ .~ :0 ::J o C <C :z a: II V') z o - I- <( U o ...J W l? <( Z l? - V') W Q.. <( U V') I- w w a:: l- V') IZOQ 4-"~ "- o o N " a.; .0 E Q) > ~ = '" +- C (]) E QJ U C 0 ..c c w ..... 0 '0 'C ..... 0 U I- b.o 0::: t: <( .- co - +- 0- 0 '" QJ 0::: 3i= <1J +- '" ~ :::.... 0 lo.., w <1J 0- ~ .S ~ lo.., c:Q CIJ :0 tJ tw :J :E ~ (5 0 0- tw >... tJ c: CI: ...., lo.., 0- .:.::: tw 0 - c: u ..Q c:r: <1J <1J ::J ." 0 0 - - Z 0 I 0 a:. I t ~% If-;, "- o o N ....: Qj ..Q E <ll > ~ ~ U') Z 0 - , ~ <1 <( <II ..... U C ill E 0 ill U ...J c 0 .c W c UJ t.? ..... 0 lJ <( 'C ..... 0 Z U l- t.? a::: <( I:C - ..... U') <II ill W tI ~ ..... a.. l... <II 0 <( QJ UJ OJ i:: .!;; U .io. 0 Ii ~ :> U') 0 J- .~ CI: LlJ .-:; c:: - LlJ ~ c:r: c::: - - J- 0 % U') a: II 1400~ '" a C) N r-.:: W .0 E <IJ > ~ ~ VI +- C Q) E Q) u c a .s::: c L.U ... 0 "'0 'C ... 0 U I- b.O a::: <:: ;;::.. c:: co S :.:: ;;::.. ..... -- VI S '=' S Q) 3: ~ IX S - !::'2 ~ ~ VI a L.U '- " ~ .~ Cl) -- ~ ~ :c CO -- VI ::J 0 Cl ~ ~ -- ...., <( ...., 1:: E LU - 0 C ct u Cl) 0 - Q :I: 0 I 0 a:: II ~r', ,'," ,_, "<, . " to \ ' ' ,~ ~ 't' ~-~., 'r.,~. : l . ISDb '+3 "- a 0 N " OJ .l:l E <ll > 0 :!: z V'I +- C III E III U ~ ~ c 0 .c s::: c QJ llJ ~ ... QJ E 0 1) 10.. ';:: LlJ :J ~ ... 0 I- ...... u 0 0 I- <( a:: ~ 10.. <( .Q.. co l? .E .... ~ V'I III >- QJ - 3: boo .... QJ V'I I- 0 0 (lJ .Q.. llJ - ...... t: 0 ,!; U 0 .~ U :5 boo =' en en Cl Z .~ .~ ~ - t: 4 .....J U U 0 CO -J - 4 :J . - . . 0 -- N ,..., Z er: - ~ ~ c: ~ :::J .0 -C:l e ~ Q) ~ VI :::J ..... ..... Q) c ~ ..... Q) .5 E ""0 e Q) c: u 0 Q) c ~ ..c a g;o J:: C ~ 0 w 0 "- t:J 0 b.O ~ "'0 'C 0 "- +-0 ~ 0 ..... U t: -C:l Q) :::J I- U 0 c.::. .0 <: -5' '- cO 0 ..... 0 ... VI Q) ""0' Q) ~ ~ E ..... co 0 VI u a e ..... UJ (,I) ,!; Q) ~ -t: :0 ~ I :J -t: 0 0 t:: 0 0 s:::: E E 4 0 ~ e - I.;::" ct :t :t Q) - s: .Q) ::> Z AI:: II V) Z o - ~ - o z o u (j z - l- V) - X w . w. ..' ,- (1:.' I t ,,:.t:.~ .-- . u .~ 1lt>U{) tf~ Q) ~ ~ .5 ,.... 8 N ,....' a.> .0 E ill > o z ~ :S -C:l :::J o '- o ... Q) E 8 ..... (,I) 0: 0/ "E o s:::: E o ~ :t Q) s: ~ I I l__ r- JIll/] If;, " o o N " <i3 .0 E III > o '"' z - V'l ..... c <D E <D U C 0 J:: C W '- 0 "'. 0 1) '" ~ '" .C 0 '- '" 0 u U '" '" I- '" ~ :E 0-: '" <( LlJ a:::l ~ .... W V'l ct::~ <D I- ~ ~ct:: ~ .... <( V'l 0 ct::~ w l? "'0 ~~ .~ ~-g ffi c: :0 <( ct.1 Qli) :J 0 ct.1 a I- '-t:::..., 01 V> lJ.J LlJ<: UJ rn S-o I-t:: c( w <'- -J ~~ UJt3 - ~ (3 ~~ "'0 ct <( ~V) ~ ~1ti - V) ~6 '- ::::;W :I: L o.~ Cl C{ ~ V) o~ I- ~~ c: ~(JJ a: '- <( ~ .S II I I I I ~ I ... ... ... 0 ... 00 Ln 1..0 Vv "1"""'1 1 - .....-- . II 1/ , I l ~Db If'3 ri - J ;:: ~ · ----J i , i <II IJ ;;; +- C <D E <D ,2 ~.~ U I I ,w C ~L.U 0 I Vl .!: C UJ I .... 0 I 1) I ';:: .... 0 1 U lJ) I- Vl Cl::: (/') <: - <( cO Vl a.. +- >- cr: <II <D W 3: -J > +- <( 0 <II 0 ::E UJ Z .~ 0 , :0 <( c::: l :J u.. (~ 0 S i UJ w 4 -J I-i ... > 0 ... ... <{ L.(') 0 ... ... - 0 r-.... L.(') Ln 0 ct U "1"""'1 N ~ V') :z: a:: I I ' i II . I i 1.- I k~- _.iL T 1,-- I I I ...... o o N ,,' a; .Q E <L> > ~ ~ i 1 1 i j . I 1_- J i ; - J IJI ~ -...- tqUQ Lf~ o 0::: >- ~ 0::: LU I ~ :J o 01 I " I ; "- a o N " a; ..0 E OJ > ~ ~ .. '~- -. ',,- ~ ~ .. . ~ . '" . I' .1' # , f ., '/ I' J," ~p fit iE_,! O. 'L, $'f" t;>..' ~I~; . ~. ~ 9f ~ ~ <::;<() ~:}~ ~O~ 5 ~ ~ VI VI <( 19 Vl ..... c Ql E Ql U c o ..c c Ll.J ..... o "'0 ~E o U J- Ck:: <{ CO ..... Vl Ql ~ ------------- lilt '" w w 0: f- ..... Vl o Ll.J .!; :0 :> o (/) ~ l/') >- ...J <( Z <( w I- - l/') cc c( :z a: . II I- ~ :> 0 u '" I- .- c Q) l- E Q) W u --J c 0 ~ ..c c <( ll.J ..... 0 U "'0 .;:: ..... Vl 0 U l- a:::: <( a:l .- '" (/) Q) - ;: (,/') .- '" >- 0 ll.J -l ,!; <( :0 ::) 21 0 II( <:(1 - W DUBLIN BL VD ft --J I - <(I :z: U a: (/) II 20Vb$ o ex:: >- I- ~ w :r: t:) ::> o Q ..... 8 N " Qj ..a E Q) > .g ~ ,--- ~ j ) , . 1 . ~. ~:-;.; . . . I .. Vl LlJ -- ~ - Z :) ~ a:: o a.. a.. o LlJ ~ - Vl " _ \ 'J \_.'>..u ,I j I 1- ~. ~-::-- -m ,\ "'--:::S I . \:1 i ,j 2lFJb Lf? " 8 N ,....: Iii J.) E <ll > ~ 2 II'> ..... c <1.l E Q) u c o ..c c UJ o "'0 .;:: .... o U ...... 0:::: <( c:l ..... II'> Q) 3: ..... II'> o UJ .~ 15 ::J o C rC :z: II: II d.;llfb '+3 "- 8 N " lii ..a E III > o _ Z N ...., t:: (1) E t:: 0 "- 0- ~ t:: '" I- (1) ..- C ID (1) E Vl ...., ...., Q) t:: 0- u L1J (I') c <1J "- 0 0::: E (1) Q) ..c c ::3 -t:: UJ ~ ..... 0 t:r ...., 0 0- 0 l:J 0 t:: "C I- ~ ..... E ::s 0 a.. u.. u t- LU b.o s:: -t:: 0:: U , 0 -<( Q t:: ...., co .~ ..- 0- Q) '" Z -t:: Q) Z ~ oN 3: 0 ~ ~ ..- '" 0 0 0 UJ U - u ...., t:: .~ 0- ~ I .Q.. 0 :a >- Q) ~ ~ \5 :J C <( ~ CC ~ LU <C ~ - :z: 19 a: I I ;) "3 "b tf.? ...... 8 N " CD ..Q E Q) > o N Z N I I ""0 rn I 0 I a:: .. ).... ., t OJ i ...c VI bO +- c ::J Q) 0 E 0 Q) u c b.() 0 .c C c 0 UJ .... .~ 0 "0 C .E 0 0 U 'tj I- 0::: <( > cc OJ +- VI LU ~ +- VI 0 .4-J UJ VI .~ OJ :0 !..... :> 0 0 LL ""0 4: c - .- <I: ~ ~ ..- % -- a:: II .'~ i \ \ ~ I' i -l~-;-;- . . . " I ' \ I \ \ I \ I I \ .1 I \ I \ \ '. I II I I I ~ I J I . J \ I I, \1 .. .1 " '1~,:..:r". ",..i,!.~_~ ,~i..'''':' ~. ,L .~ .. ..0,.,/ y....:~'lj .' " ~( , t.; ~ ~ ~, ...,~ ~ - ) .I' I . .1 I I! I ,,,", I I I I I I I ~ L I "2 yoo Lf3' ...... o o N ....:: OJ .Q E <ll > ~ ::: +J (I) cd Cl) b.O C 'v 0 0 -C s.... cd > Cl) :J VI C 0 Q) CO E Q) c u c .- 0 - ..0 .J:: C :J w 0 '- 0 1J .;:: E '- 0 0 U l- s.... et: I.f- <( ~ co +- '" CI) Q) >- ~ +- '" 0 w +J .!; V1 :0 CI) :l s.... 0 0 Ll- ce -0 - C .c .- ~ - :I: ..-- -- m: I , }' ( r I i .' j ; r K f . " " " ",~, " .o,r , . 'J",f ,. > ' .~ ~. ~ OL" .... I . i '{ l'r , , , ? S-l1b tf;, .... o o N " OJ ~ E <ll > ~ ~ +-J VJ CIJ ~ b.O c: .V 0 0 . '" -c - .~ 1# c > (]) E tf.~~~' co (]) ~-~ ~. U c: c 0 .- .c ...0 c UJ :J ... 0 0 -0 'C ... E 0 u 0 f- a::: ~ < '+- cO ~ - ..... (]) CIJ 3: :> - <II 0 UJ +-J .S :0 VJ ::> CIJ 0 ~ 0 C u.. - -C CI: c: - ~ % -.. ~ ~ - II .f-J -C b.O .- - 0. 0 ~ V) td . -0 a:: V'l ..... >-.. c .f-J <ll S- E OJ <ll U ..c: c b.O 0 :J .r; c 0 UJ ... 0 0 -0 .;:: E ... 0 0 ,U I- J:: ~ <C ~ cO ..... V'l Q) ID 3: > ..... V'l 0 UJ .f-J .S V) :0 Q) ::l -- - - S- O , I".'" ~~ 0 I U- C I -0 - J C ct . .. ~ - .~ ' ,~ Z .- "-' a: I 2l.P1fb tf? "- a o N ,...: OJ .Q E (I) > o LJl Z N ij' 1;1 I I :$,~.~ . !~ 'j . I ~ ~~M 'IY- ~~ f\" .. '~ ..;,.... . -~ ,:". ~: Q ^ 1 8 Nil 8 n Q \~> · . .... ~__~ a...~... ~ ., ,,',if.', -== 11 II ! ,.-.= i ~=~~ I I I I " , I ::1' ~- [ I l - --, -- I I : o I , , < I o I : il I 1 : j ! w J I :c I I I ~ I! :JI lot J f 01 I" ,I l- w ...J c:: <C U VI , I '9 111 . ,t I .f Ill. I' , II l H !~ 11 \ 'I. ') ! " .. .. '. "" 1 ~. " " ....- ] ~ I .. .. .~ li~~ --- n ~. ~ I Oi c "~ 11 IJ ....... ' , ., f- I . ...-.. ~, I' ! "'. I" I ::=.- ~ - ~ -~ -. j d-IUb 4'.3 l"- e> e> N " Qi .0 E Q) > o '" Z N <II +- C (1) E (1) u c o .c c UJ ... o "'0 'E o u l- e.:: <( cc +- <II ~ +- <II o LU .f; 15 ~ o 0 " Z '" <II ..... C Ul E Ul u C 0 - .c '~ c ill +J "- OJ 0 0 -0 .C "- 0 VJ u ro I- ~ 's... <C c::l OJ ..... .4J <II ro ~ I: ..... <II 0 ill .4J .!; VJ :0 OJ :> s... 0 ~ 0 (]) u. cI: tlJ -0 - E c <r: 0 ~ - E :c OJ c -- <( II: "-' I 2.01. UfJ 4'3 " o o N " /jj ..Q E <lJ > o 00 Z N s:: 0 u "- .... tJ "- - "- E ~ QJ VI U - 0 c s:: ill V) "+- tJ E ill 0 CI) w u a.. QJ CI) c "- 0 E s:: b:o ""0 ..c ~ 0 c s:: 0 l.U "- ..... w tJ <{ ~ 0 0 E "0 W =:: ';:: N ..... \J QJ 0 0 0 I .... u s:: .... -e- ~ l- I- t) C1J E 00:: \J < a... QJ 0 C ctl l? C1J s:: - W t-I ~ QJ VI - ~ s:: ~ U tJ "- QJ Z U ~ w CI) - s:: VI Z CI) QJ Cl CI) ~ l.U 0 - C1J ~ - ...Q .~ >- ::3 ~ ~ s:: :0 "- :J U t:r .Q.. >-.. 0 ...J "- ~ (3 s:: CI) "- >- u.. ::> s:: c c - <( - ~ cr - LlJ :I: J- a= <( II <..:> 30 i1.b Lt.? ...... a a N ,...: OJ D .~ "'....-: E Qj > 0 "" Z N '" ~ ~ .. Ii:I ~ P.l ~ 'I! ... '" ... .. ~ ": ... ... ... .. (;~ . "'" CI ..~...~ 1IIl~ II ~ ~~ 11'1 i:l'1:' .. .. .. 0.1 '" or; ... .. r:"'::! ~~~IO IrI ,..., .,..:0;. ... "'I III' i'!': - ~ ... "..",.- I.7t ~~.~~ ~ -- ..... ,. , -0 Cd 0 c::: >-.. t OJ ..c t>.Q VI ::::J +- C 0 Q) 0 E Q) u b.O c 0 C .c 0 c w (lj I- 0 C :g I- 0 0 .~ U I- a::: > <( OJ a) +- W VI Q) 3: +- VI V] 0 0.. w !... .!; Cd :0 I ::> 0 b.() C cE .- >.. - LL.. c( - -- ~ :z: -- a:: I 11- k.:~v~ - "",-o:-Ct ~.~~~. '-~. ~'~ ' L~ '':Ii f.~.~ <, ~ ~. .., (I) C':S Cl) b.O C 'v 0 0 -c L C':S > OJ '" +- ::J C 0 Q) E CO Q) u C c 0 .- .c. ..0 c UJ ::J .... 0 0 "0 'c .... E 0 . , u 0 l- ll:':: L <( '- c:::l ~ +- '" OJ ~ > +- '" 0 UJ .~ (I) :0 a.. ::l L 0 C':S I <I: b.O - C c:I: >-.. - LL :r: ...-.. M cc: -- II . '" , I , ~ f . I I V. j I " -\ J 1 f I ,I t ;r i , ~ 'I ,~ '" l .II .~ :1".1 ~" -. 'I .;'il -;J~ ..- - '" iP""- """" ,1'-,1-- ""G - ., -r- ..._~... ... -"'........,.. "3 i un Lf3 " o o N ,..; lii .0 E OJ > ~ ~ r~" ".,_a,~. ("i.~ '_,., ~':'.;. :~:.~ ' '. ...-'~c~.~ ' , .-.:- :i~' ' ~ \,.~....~ "I..~ ~,,_ , . ,-. " ';' '~t "'!~), ~,~..;' "1 ~ 'ft .l. . "'".. '("'1: '-li ,.,~~. ):~.....") . ....'.:t ~ p'... ' '."" . {\ ~.:~ ",:.~? 1:. -r.::, ".' .....~ ~ ..,. ~jI~(,:~:.-- ~"'I.:"~"- .."""- .... -~:~~, ~ ..~( ,-~~, '"'{. ..~ , '.o,.,;:..~ '" " .. ~... .4.'./;-:-_r. -.< . ~t., '.:--' Iir.. _:..,...~. .~ l' ~;;a, ~ ... "" " '- ,oJ (', \ '{ I c' ...., V) Q) ~ b.() c 32 o o ""'0 > CO c .- ..0 ::J o E o 1- "- ~ Q) >- V) a.. 1- cd :r: b.() c '>-. u.. ..- r--.I - 32Ob*3 " o C) '" " Cil .0 E Q) > ~ ;;:; Vl ..... c Q) E Q) u c o .c c UJ ... o "'0 'C ... o U l- (k: -<( co ..... VI ~ ..... VI a UJ .~ :0 :J o <C <I: Z II: I .4-J ..c: b.O 0- - 0... 0 .4-J V) ~ 0 "'U c::: ..... ..... c >.. w t E w OJ u c ..c: a b.O .c. c :J UJ 0 '- 0 0 "'0 ';:: '- E 0 u 0 I- l:l! ~ <C a) ..... ~ ..... w OJ 3: ..... :> ..... a UJ ,!; V) :0 0... ::J s- O ro I 4 b.O - --- 4 c 0>.. - - :z: LL.. - a: C"'I --- II a ~ ~.;;. ~- ~3 Vb if:? " g '" ,,' W .0 E <l> > o '" z '" { --::I . I 'I -, -: I -3 t , ~ t 1 I I I- 0 I 6 a: <: 0 i 0 a: '. ,,? Y: t1b 'f3 .,,'.,(1 .},:/ !"'u .' ., i r-.... 8 N r--: . Qj .n E Q) > ~ :::: 1 I · I! \ II · ! u Ii II I W I :c I ~ \ :) 'jl I ~ I I , ~. I , :I!~I\ }a@!~ taj ., ".12 ~.~'1 r \ , I I a ^ 1 a N I 1 '8 n a ~ \ \ ~_~~I . :~-.r. ~-- _ . ." ---.\ -IDJ \ \ _ .u, . \ \ I" ('J '~"""-~l. //~ / t_~JW~JJ :~Jil a" :> 5 I- II- a: I' I I 1 I -~ ~ .. ~, I . ") .~{.~.,._~~ ..~. ( ( (: ~ J ,~i;t. . ~.. ..:v~ D - '" \ --11111' u J J J r :n~f) (< '" +-- C Q) E Q) u c o .c c w '- o -0 .;:: '- o U r- !k:: -<( o:Q +-- '" Q) ~ +-- '" o UJ .~ :0 ::l o cr: ca: 2: a:: II V'J c m u.. E :::J C E :::J <C 3?OV t..f:3 ..... o o N .....' <Ii .0 E llJ > o .. Z M I I 3LPUO't7 "- g N " Qj ..0 E Q) > ~ iQ +-J ..t: ,b.o Z ...::: \:)..() c: 0 ,- b..o c: Vl ..... al 0 c (j) ..c E al +J U <D c: U c - (lJ C,I) 0 ~ E (lJ ..c "- c LLJ M ~ ::3 '- +J 0 ....J -- E \J ~ 0 0 .Q.. .;:: '- <( ...Q E 0 0 0- ~ ~ u u ~ LU a::: U Z \J (lJ ~ <( t: a:l -- ::3 ..... Z 0 ...Q Vl ~ +-J ~ <D t: 0 :?; 0 0 ~ "- ..... Vl LU c: .:.::: 0 +J 0 U UJ 0 0- E .~ I- ...Q \J >- C,I) .s <IJ O- n <IJ :s ::l LU ~ 0- 0 <( 0:: V") :::; ~ c( - LU c( I- 2: <( (j a: II .. , if ..- - \;.i ~t b ..- "" .; , ,.1' ~ if. . ~ ;l"-'ll. :~ ,. 1 ~i :i .~, ,', ~ ""'.... I.; ,," '" ,..,....,....-- ,.; ~J:,_~;.~ i~\ '~...~h#,1..~,.t.;t...,..,~~... 1I .~ - : ~ !,...\'!t;'!'1~- 'r." ~. "\ ,',' .1Cj', -. or , J ..n,' ;!.' \:):~'7 ~ 1;., ~-:-..\\=..~ .- " , . -I;. ~ '" "' ~ l7Xb ~b, ""- 8 N ...: Q; .Q E <l.l > 0 '" Z ""' -c cd o a::: >-. ~ CI) ..r::. t>.O :J o o t>.O C o r;j c o .- ~ > (]) W VI +- C Q) E Q) u c o ..c c UJ ... o -0 'C ... o U ...... 0::: <( c:::l ..- VI ~ c o ..0 ..0 .- a::: ~ c s.... CI) +-' W ..- VI o UJ .~ :n ::J o c( <l '2: a:: - M -- II i_ \ \ f J. MJ\:~:~" , '".k,'~Jc..' - ....'i',c r ' .i..;t~,'.r ! l;i" ,,, ib,'" , .. :'#': " i r' c.' C';~~.' .",l:-,: ", . , .,/ i , . ; 100 1 ). 40' ) . "- ~ 0 ~ 0 l C'l .. r..: 1 a; .0 E Q) > 0 f'. ,; Z "" j I It , . +-I V) cd OJ 0.0 C ~ 0 0 ""'0 !r... cd > OJ ::s 0 '" +- OJ C (]) c E .- m - u ..0 c ::s a .c: 0 c LU l- E 0 '0 4i:: 0 I- 0 !r... U "+- ....... ~ c.: <( OJ cc +- >- '" (]) 3: +- '" c: a LJ.J 0 .~ ..0 :0 ..0 ::J 0 a:: Cd C( c - !r... .c OJ - +-I :z: W ...-.. M a: "-' I --- f 1- .... ;:\;1; . ~',J'- 'u 1,1 , ,~ti. 'IW" , ' <;:',', ":.i" t. ' ~I",.",." " " ,-' , l'Ii,".;'>~,~.: ',"',',".",'..f.'.:'.::.',-:,,,: ; ~,\,.,,;~ .:. ~,~. . I 11""-:' "',' ",,:.\.-- ;... ,....' ",.:,' , /;~/;~j'} ,. -,,-:. ,.-' ...... 3ttao ~ I- I I I I , II " -+ ..; .. ...1'" - I, ,-r l t , I' .~ . If'" "'~;l:' ( to l" . , . 1';'1 ~' f. '_", , ,,' ,/<,i ~ .~ - ~ ,. " ., 8q 1Y() Lf3 " 8 N ,....: Cii .lJ E CI) > 0 00 z ,.., +J (/) Q) ~ b.() c: 'v 0 0 . "U "~-MJi > '" ai ..... c <ll &_1, C E <ll - u ..0 c ::s 0 ..c I 0 C I.lJ , ..... E 0 ] "'0 0 .E 0 S- U "+- I- ~ IJ<: <( Q) a:l. ..... >- III ~ CD ,,\, :s: - ..... '" C 0 I.lJ 0 .~ ..0 :0 ..0 ~ ~ 0 """@ ct: c - !.... cr: \. OJ - +J % \ LlJ '" ..- M a: --- II .~ ~.. ,~""",,.t<<~. '.,q-=..:..;;......., . ~. ..t~- ..Ii> .i" .:~' " ' " il'(il"~:wrr:< 6'''' .. A .:,Yi. ! .r" . ,..."./"0 ""~'~" ~. .~..:""""'!rl'.-..:\.'~... '" ll""'~ ,'~:-~ ~H ....-"".;'\t.~, 'i^.&\,t<!\''' ;,,' .. ... ' . .~'"'!,~' '\~.I-"... .....4'fi.. "".~. '''''',.''''''',''; '-'<<il.. ;:'j,,"'JJJ'..., " '1",." ~~'.+,:._~:<:'J~:~~.~<<)~r..W'~ ~. I......~..."'..';.......~..!,~.' ;.; 1> ',' ':i~-',~r', ~.\~;-~~~;~7r~' J, _,,~""'~t-' ~',1II '~~(.":'N' '. - -....... I Lff) Db ~ ...... 8 '" ......- 0 '" Z M .4-J ...c b.O - a. 0 .4-J V1 ~ . '"C ex:: ~ II'> +- l... c Q) lD ...c E lD :- b.O u :::J c 0 0 .c 0 c UJ '- E 0 1J 0 'E 0 l... U '+- I- ~ ~ <:( Q) /:0 +- II'> > lD 3= +- II'> C 0 UJ 0 .!; ..0 :0 ..0 :J 0 ---- - ex:: - ~ CI: c: - l... 4: Q) - ~ :z w -.. M a= -- II ~. ". LfJOb ~3 .~/ "/ I, /'t <~' ,J /. ----'J i J ~3 ~ [ 5 I.-I . I I --~- I I I o' 8 N " lii ..a E (j) > o 0 z ... ..... 6 a: :) . r 0 u ..... ..... I ~ J a:1 I 1;1 1 >j 1 ..... 'I 'a: W ~. '\ I I I 'i ~ J! . J: '" I 'I / < ' l u ~ "I . ,. I 'I~ 11ii.~JI . I ~,.. '"" I I~t; fi .::.'...."\:- ' · - , ' J:l :klj ') J 1 ,_ J'<;' '. i a~ ~! I~i .....,./ tifl' i/ .' ~'" 1-71 :/ . {jr, .' " ,J ~. :2. 1"\ ~. ~kr ..#,.,1 'lil'-: ""'''''''''::. '.''iI... I I ...-/' ~ ="p' \ \ ~ , :--:1 I I ~i a^1e Nllsna t .., \ I '\' ~...I .~ r==lg -.- - \ >-.. \ I ro ~ uti] _\, ~ '.~ _ l o I o I J '. I I \..~ . I VI ..... C <D E <D U c o .c c UJ o U .;:= '- o U l- n-:: -< .co '-, .." ~ . ~ ~ ?... .... J -,.., ~ -- ~-=... +- VI <D ~ +- VI o UJ .!;; :0 :J o D ""--- C \ ,:TIl(l : v ~ U l~ II( <C :z: l ,I II [) I If I , II 'J . ~ I L{ 2lJb t+) " o o N ,,' ill .D E q,l > :i: ;: ~ VI - C <1.l E <1.l rn u c .4-J 0 Q) ..c c 0 UJ '- 0 Vl "0 Q) ~ .;:: '- Q) .i: 0 U) U Q) I- ~ Q! -0 <( Q) a::i L - ~ VI <1.l ~ ~ >... - VI rn 0 Q) UJ 0.... ~ .s Q) :0 ~ ::l 0 (j II( b" - .- cs: c: <+= - c: Z a: ("I') II 4300 Lf? ' <( ~ L en cr 0 Z - -0 I- :z: .- - t: U l:J II: 0 U w - c .... V> 0 0 W .- 1d a:: 0 U1 a. ~ I- ....J 1 <( Z <( ,[ CO I C W :> .- - I: ...0 r- :J Z 0 w a.. - ...J ~ U CO W U) :J <J) Z U 0 ,5 <( u.. Z 0 ~ J: >- ~ z 0 U) ?- m - w w U U ! --