HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-23-2015 Approved HSC MinutesHUMAN SERVICES COMMISSION
REGULAR MEETING
e Minutes
CITY OF CITY OF DUBLIN
OUBLIN April 23, 2015
kill =07011W 1WA41;W*3ET
MINMIM41
ROLL CALL
Commissioners (Cm.) Present- Vc. Brown, McCormick, Sladden, Strah
Commissioners Absent: Chair Lockhart
ORAL COMMUNICATIONS
3.1 Public Comments — None
MINUTES OF PREVIOUS MEETINGS
4. January 22, 2015
On a motion by Cm. McCormick and seconde*
approved the minutes of the January 22, 2015
lang 4142. IW_j;Jlg rem -
by Cm. la den, on a vote of 4-0-1, the HSC
meeting.
NEW BUSINESS
8.1 Informational Presentation by Kidango, Inc. (Kidango)
Kimberly Sato, Director of Education, with Kidango presented information on Kidango's
services.
Vc. Brown asked how many of the eighty (80) students attending Kidango at the Emerald Vista
site reside in the Emerald Vista community.
Ms. Sato responded that eleven (11) students attending the program live in the Emerald Vista
development.
Cm. Strah as if the majority of students attending the Dublin Kidango site reside in Dublin.
Ms. Sato responded that one-half of the students in the program live in Dublin and the remaining
live in the Tri-Valley area.
Cm, Sladden asked if Kidango made commitments to the City of Dublin in order to secure the
space at Emerald Vista and if Kidango is in compliance with those obligations.
HSC Meeting Minutes, April 23, 2015 Page 1 of 7
Ms. Sato stated she is not aware of commitments made between the City of Dublin and
Kidgano. She did not work for Kidango when the program started at Emerald Vista.
Cm-. lad en asked if Dublin residents receive prioritization for program enrollment.
Ms. Sato stated that priority is given to income eligible students per state mandates. She
explained that Dublin residents do receive higher priority into the program over residents from
other cities.
Amy Cunningham, Assistant to the City Manager, explained that the City provided funding
through a loan to Eden Housing for the Emerald Vista development. The agreement requires
Eden Housing to provide onsite daycare. Eden currently contracts with Kidango to satisfy this
obligation.
Vc. Brown asked if any attendees in the program reside in Camp Parks.
Ms. Sato stated she is unaware of how many program participants reside at Camp Parks and
will obtain the information from Kidango's enrollment and development department.
Cm. McCormick asked how any private pay students are enrolled in the program.
Ms. Sato stated that the mission of the program is to support low income students and believes
private pay student enrollment is to She stated that she will follow up with the exact figures.
Cm. McCormick asked if the State requires a percentage of students admitted to be low-income.
Ms. Sato replied that the State does require a minimum, but she is unsure of the exact
percentage of student enrollment required to be low-income. She provided a document to the
HSC detailing the State subsidized funding eligibility and needs regulations.
Cm. Strap asked how much the monthly fee is for private pay,
Ms. Sato stated the monthly cost for a full day is approximately $900.
-701 F. I I ATM- mo
ff1s. Sato stated yes and explained that Kidango has a mental health department which
collaborates with special needs children and families using the Center on the Social arl'i
Emotional Foundations for Early Learning (CSEFEL) approach.
115
Ms. Sato stated that there is no waiting list, but all classrooms are at full capacity. She also
explained that they recently expanded classroom size from 24 to 32 children. She concluded by
stating that she would email Ms. Cunningham information in response to the outstanding
&,uestions from the Commission
-8.2 City of Dublin Below Market Rate (BMR) Rental Monitoring Program
Kim Obstfeld, Housing. Specialist, presented information on the results of Dublin's recent BMR
rental monitoring.
HSC Meeting Minutes, April 23, 2015 Page 2 ofs
I IN !!I I I I I I 741pqfi= I I I
M ffs"174 a 0 a 1 111111 r 11 ; i I I I 1;1111 1 � � �W
Ms. Obstfeld explained that the Affordable Housing Agreement defines the scope of BMR rental
monitoring for each project and it does not include tenant satisfaction as a component.
Cm. Sladden asked if BMR communities are required to publicize themselves as income
restricted properties,
Ms. Obstfeld stated that affordable housing properties are required to execute a City approv
management and marketing plan, prior to occupancy. She explained that Staff is researching
ways to require periodic marketing plan updates for BMR communities. I
*JF V I A
Fas F
Ms. Obstfeld stated that the City's BMR and market rate apartment communities are also listed
on the City's website.
M r, TATTITIT. M-0
Ms. Obstfeld responded that the Housing Element, a component of the General Plan, is required
to be reviewed and certified by the Department of Housing and Community Development
(HCD). She explained that the Regional Housing Needs Assessment establishes a target
number of affordable units the jurisdiction is to provide and defines income limits from extremely
low to moderate. The Housing Element requires that zoning for affordable units is identified in
the plan.
Tc. Brown asked how many affordable properties in Dublin house extremely low income
families.
Ms. Obstfeld replied that the properties in Dublin accommodating extremely low income
categories are run by not -for -profit housing organizations; the properties are Camellia Place,
Wexford Way, Carlow Court, and Wicklow Square.
WIRIM11115111 T MIAMI 11111 11 1 11111 11
Ms. Obstfeld stated that the extremely low category is thirty -percent or less of the area mediar
'ncome. This is $28,050 or less per year for a four person household, using the 2014 state
:ncome Iiiiiits.
Vc. Brown asked if a household will qualify for affordable housing if the family is earning less
than the maximum for the extremely low income category.
Ms. Obstfeld explained that many families coming in below the extremely low income level have
a project or tenant -based Housing Choice Voucher, keeping the rent at 30% of their household
income.
Vc. Brown asked how households in the extremely low category are informed about available
BMR u-tits.
HSC Meeting Minutes, April 23, 2015 Page 3 of 7
Ms. Obstfeld explained that there are a variety of organizations providing this information
including: The City of Dublin, Housing Authority of the County of Alameda, Eden I&R inc.,
Valley Opportunity Center and other not -for -profit housing providers.
Cm. Strah asked how often Officer Rhodes frequents the properties who participate in the Crime
Free Multi -Housing Program.
Ms. Obstfeld stated he visits each site at least once a week, depending on the level of activity
the development. i
Cm. Strah asked about how many calls Officer Rhodes receives from the affordable housing
developments.
Ms. Cunningham explained that Officer Rhodes initiates these visits and is not necessarily
responding to calls for service. He provides a service in support of the local neighborhood watch
concept; he develops relationships with property managers and residents and in turn becomes
familiar with issues affecting the property.
Ms. Cunningham stated that crime statistics are categorized by geographical area and identify
calls for service and/or arrests for a specific area.
Cm. McCormick asked if there are waiting lists for affordable housing communities,
Ms. Obstfeld stated that not -for -profit properties that cater to lower income households' average
a two -to -three year wait period.
Vc. Brown asked where people live while waiting for affordable housing to become available.
Ms. Cunningham informed the Commission that not all the people on these waiting lists are
Dublin residents and that one family may be signed up on multiple waiting lists.
Vc. Brown asked if the City is requiring developers to provide more affordable housing in view of
the need.
Ms. Cunningham stated that the City requires twelve and one-half percent of affordable housing
per development project consisting of twenty or more residential units. She explained that the
Veterans housing project will provide sixty-five more affordable units and acknowledged the
City's investment of funds and efforts to provide more affordable housing.
il��111� Ill ;I;;1I IIIIIII 1�! 11 iiiii���l 11� r ��I1111;11 11 11 ;1 111 , I III Jilli I III
Ms. Obstfeld explained that the transit center project has already satisfied its affordable housing
requirement. She explained that Camellia Place fulfilled the very -low and low income category
and the other properties within the transit center offer moderate -income affordable units.
HSC Meeting Minutes, April 23, 2015 Page 4 of 7
Ms. Cunningham explained that the three (3) affordable senior communities are tied to income,
and the universal design guidelines ensure new construction can be adapted to a senior life
style.
Cm. Strah asked who the responsible party is for the maintenance of affordable housing
communities.
Ms. Cunningham stated that the City requires the property management company/owner 4
provide for the ongoing repair and maintenance of the affordable housing communities.
8.3 Community Grants Program Modifications
Ms. Cunningham presented on Community Grants program modifications.
To. Brown asked if not -for -profit organizations are required to have a business license.
Ms. Cunningham explained that not -for -profit organizations serving Dublin residents in the City
are required to have a business license. The business license registration for not -for -profit
organizations is free.
Ms. Cunningham stated that General Fund and Housing Fund recipients can request funding
up -front in one disbursement. She explained Community Development Block Grant recipients
operate on a reimbursement basis per HUD guidelines,
Cm. Sladn asked when the mid -year grant recipient reporting would be due.
Ms. Cunningham stated mid -year reporting would be due in December. The goal is to have the
information prior to the Community Grants Program meeting. The information will allow the
Commission to review a funded organization's progress, prior to making recommendations for
future funding.
8.4 Human Services Priorities and Initiatives
Ms. Cunningham presented on Human Services priorities and initiatives.
Cm. trah asked if outreach for SeeDubWell includes recruiting doctors and/or nurses.
Ms. Cunningham responded that the school nurses are focusing on recruitment of doctors and
nurses for the event. Ms. Cunningham further stated that outreach is targeted at uninsured
participants who may be unaware of available services such as those through Axis Community
Health.
Cm. la den asked how close in proximity is August 22, 2015 to the start of the school year.
Ms. Cunningham stated the SeeDubWell event will be held a few days before school starts.
The goal is to prevent school registration delays resulting from a lack of student immunizations.
Vc. Brown asked if the planning committee for SeeDubWell is seeking pro-bono services from
health care workers.
HSC Meeting Minutes, April 23, 2015 Page 5 of 7
Ms. Cunningham explained that the planning committee is working with Axis Community Health,
Kaiser Permanente, ValleyCare, John Muir, and Alameda County Public Health Department to
provide collaborative services. They will assist with medical and health services as well as with
the needed medical record reporting and insurance requirements.
Ms. Cunningham stated the marketing materials will be available in about one -month. She then
asked for two volunteers from the Commission to be on the SeeDubWell subcommittee to assist
with participant outreach.
q11111111
Ms. Cunningham confirmed funding is needed and explained the joint dental clinic study will
identify needs, advantages and obstacles associated with providing a dental clinic,
Ms. Cunningham replied that a dental clinic study and implementation will cost between forty
,2nd sixty thousand dollars. She then asked for a volunteer to be on the Regional Human
Services subcommittee comprised of members from the three Tri-Valley Human Services
•
Ms. Cunningham suggested having not -for -profit organizations who focus on Commission
priorities present program services to the HSC at future meetings. She then suggested Senior
Support Program of the Tri-Valley (Senior Support) be the next presenter as senior services are
one of the HSC's identified priorities.
The HSC agreed they would like to have Senior Support present program services to the
Commission.
Ms. Cunningham explained that the proposal will need to be adopted as part ♦ the strategic
plan and budget process. The thought is that the HSC would meet every other month starting
sometime after July, perhaps beginning later than September due to staffing constraints during
the summer and early fall.
Ms. Cunningham then explained that there may be future volunteer opportunities through a
poverty awareness subcommittee and the SeeDubWell event. She stated that at each HSC
meeting one or two organizations of interest will present program services.
OTHER BUSINESS
9. Brief INFORMATION ONLY reports from the Human Services Commission and
or Staff related to meetings attended at City Expense (AB 1234).
Cm. Strah visited Tri-Valley Haven and was very impressed with the organization.
Cm. Sladden stated she recently joined the Board of Dublin Partners in Education.
Ms. Cunningham stated that the First Tee of the Tri -Valley asked for feedback about their grant
application and outreach opportunities for funding.
The HSC recommended potential private funding from local PFSO's (Parent, Faculty, Student
Organizations at the schools), local adult/youth sports associations, local services organizations
golf course for private business or other local resources involved with golf activities. They asked
staff to contact the organization and provide their suggestions.
ADJOURNMENT
Being no further business, the meeting adjourned at 8:38:57 PM .
Respectfully Submitted,
A astasia Nelson, Recording Secretary
APPROVE
ice Chairpe son, Alan Brown
HSC Meeting Minutes, April 23, 2015 Page 7 of 7