HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-22-2021 AGENDA PACKETApril 22, 2021 Dublin Community Task Force on Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Agenda 1
Regular Meeting of the
COMMUNITY TASK FORCE ON EQUITY,
DIVERSITY, AND INCLUSION
Thursday, April 22, 2021 Location: Electronic Methods
Meeting Procedure During Coronavirus (COVID-19) Outbreak:
In keeping with the guidelines provided by the State of California and Alameda County Department of Public Health regarding gatherings during the coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak, and recommendations to follow social distancing procedures, the following practices are adopted during the Community Task Force on Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Meeting.
• The meeting will be held remotely via Zoom Video Communications: https://dublinca.zoom.us/j/87966155633?pwd=a3IyZVk5Q2xmSDJicVpPQXlDUXFOZz09 Passcode: MXah40Ba For audio only, you can join the meeting by telephone: (669) 900-9128 Webinar ID: 879 6615 5633 Passcode: 84126282
• Individuals wanting to make public comment may email John.Stefanski@dublin.ca.gov starting at 1:00 p.m. on Thursday, April 22, 2021. Please provide your name and the agenda item you would like to speak on.
• When the agenda item upon which the individual would like to comment is addressed, the speaker will be announced in the meeting when it is his/her time to speak to the Community Task Force on Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion. The speaker will then be unmuted for comment.
1. CALL TO ORDER
2. PUBLIC COMMENT At this time, members of the public are encouraged to address the Task Force on any items of interest that is within the subject matter jurisdiction of the Task Force and not already included on the Agenda. Comments should not exceed three (3) minutes.
3. ACTION ITEMS
3.1 Approval of Minutes from April 8, 2021 Community Task Force Meeting The Task Force will consider the approval of the minutes from the April 8, 2021 Community Task Force meeting.
4. REPORTS
April 22, 2021 Dublin Community Task Force on Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion Agenda 2
4.1 Presentation by Assistant to the City Manager John Stefanski – Citywide DEI Initiatives Assistant to the City Manager Stefanski will present on Inclusive, Equitable, and Accessible Programming and Events, and Community Agency Funding and Support.
4.2 Task Force Discussion on City-wide DEI Presentations and Approach to Work. Seed Collaborative will facilitate a discussion where members of the Task Force will share their additional questions, thoughts and opinions in response to the presentations on citywide DEI initiatives. The Task Force will also discuss their preferred approach to this portion of the Task Force’s work.
4.3 Review and Comment on the Proposed Agenda Planning Calendar The Task Force will review and comment on the Proposed Agenda Planning Calendar.
5.OTHER BUSINESS
6.ADJOURNMENTNext Special Meeting: April 29, 2021 at 5:30pm
This AGENDA is posted in accordance with Government Code Section 54954.2(a). If requested,
pursuant to Government Code Section 54953.2, this agenda shall be made available in appropriate
alternative formats to persons with a disability, as required by Section 202 of the Americans with
Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Section 12132), and the federal rules and regulations adopted in
implementation thereof. To make a request for disability-related modification or accommodation, please
contact the City Clerk’s Office (925) 833-6650 at least 72 hours in advance of the meeting.
Mission The City of Dublin promotes and supports a high quality of life, ensures a safe and secure environment,
fosters new opportunities, provides equity across all programs, and champions a culture of diversity
and inclusion.
SUMMARY MINUTES OF THE COMMUNITY TASK FORCE ON
EQUITY, DIVERSITY & INCLUSION
REGULAR MEETING – April 8, 2021
A regular meeting of the Community Task Force on Equity, Diversity & Inclusion was held on
April 8th, 2021, via Zoom telecommunications. The meeting commenced at 5:32 PM.
Roll Call
PRESENT: Natasha Tripplett, Rameet Kohli, Isabella Helene David, Eman Tai, Clifford Brown
Jr., Matthew Aini, Beatriz Ballesteros-Kogan, Dyrell Foster, Kathy Avanzino, Martha Orozco
(alt.), John Stefanski, Paul Hudson, Rodas Hailu.
ABSENT: Brittany Jacobs (alt.)
1. Call to Order
Assistant to the City Manager, John Stefanski called the meeting to order at 5:3 2 PM.
2. Public Comment
Mr. Stefanski called for Public Comments. No comments were made.
3. Action Items
3.1 Approval of Minutes from March 25, 2021, Community Task Force Meeting
Motioned by Member Aini and Seconded Member Ballesteros-Kogan. The Task Force
Members unanimously approved the minutes.
4. Reports
4.1 Presentation by Assistant to the City Manager Stefanski – City-wide DEI
Initiatives
Mr. Hudson asked about public comments at City Council meetings. Mr. Stefanski
reiterated the process for members of the public to submit public comments.
Mr. Stefanski presented on City-wide DEI Initiatives pertaining to boards and
commission recruitments and City communications.
Member Ballesteros-Kogan asked about requirements for the YAC committee. Mr.
Stefanski elaborated on these requirements. Mr. Hudson asked about the process for
creating a commission. Mr. Stefanski discussed the process to create a commission ,
which requires an act by the City Council. Member Avanzino asked about the difference
between the Task Force’s creation and that of a permanent Commission/Committee . Mr.
Stefanski elaborated on the differences in criteria. Member Tai asked about
determination of the seats on a commission and geographic determination. Mr. Stefanski
discussed the process for determining seats on a commission , which takes place when
the commission is established.
Mr. Stefanski reviewed City communications.
Member David asked about PDF accessibility on the City’s website. Mr. Stefanski
discussed the background on PDF accessibility and how HTML content on the City
website is translatable by Google Translate.
Mr. Hudson asked about surveys. Mr. Stefanski elaborated on the resident satisfaction
survey. Member Orozco asked a clarifying question about survey distribution. Mr.
Stefanski elaborated on survey distribution throughout the City. Mr. Hudson asked about
community conversations and study sessions with the community. Mr. Stefanski
elaborated on community convers ations with smaller groups for virtual town hall events.
Member Tripplett asked about surveys and the sample size in representation of the
community. Mr. Stefanski discussed the randomization of the survey samples. Member
Tai asked for clarification around randomized sample of the surveys. Mr. Stefanski
elaborated on survey samples and reviewed the previous survey’s demographics of
respondents. Member David requested voter demographic information in Dublin.
Member Orozco asked about requesting information from the survey about participants.
Mr. Stefanski elaborated on requesting this information. Member Ballesteros-Kogan
asked about age demographics. Mr. Stefanski provided data from the 2019 American
Community Survey.
Mr. Hudson asked the Task Force their thoughts on how to develop the
recommendations for this section of the Task Force’s work. Member Tai discussed
Citizen participation and interaction with the City Council. Member Ballesteros -Kogan
discussed continuing ad-hoc meetings. Member Tripplett discussed reviewing all areas
before discussing commissions in ad-hoc groups. Mr. Stefanski discussed the remaining
two categories that will be covered in the upcoming meetings. Mr. Hudson asked about
the potential of ad-hoc groups. Member Kohli asked about the goal of the
recommendations. Mr. Stefanski clarified the goal of the Task Force, reiterating the
charge adopted by the City Council. Member Aini discussed moving forward with ad -hoc
groups. Mr. Hudson asked the Task Force to provide questions related to the four topics
and to pick an area of interest to make decisions in the next four meetings. Mr. Stefanski
reported on Member Foster’s question about providing information ahead of time to the
group.
Mr. Stefanski reported on Member Koh li’s question about reviewing recommendations at
the next meeting. Member Orozco asked about demographic surveys and whether cities
will conduct them annually. Member Tripplett asked about sharing information from the
schools. Mr. Stefanski clarified the access to this information.
4.2 Review and Comment on the Proposed Agenda Planning Calendar
Mr. Hudson and Mr. Stefanski reported on the proposed agenda planning calendar.
Member Tai asked about rescheduling the May 13 meeting. Member Kohli motioned and
seconded by Member Aini to move the May 13 date . Mr. Hudson asked the Task Force if
they have any problems with May 11 or 12.
Member Brown left the meeting at 6 :37 PM.
5. Other Business
Member Tripplett asked a clarifying question a round the Task Force goals in relation to
boards and commissions. Mr. Stefanski clarified about the goal with boards and
commissions. Member Kohli asked about possibly rescheduling for May 6 and
suggested May 6 as a makeup date. Member Ballesteros-Kogan motioned to move the
meeting to May 6 and seconded by Member David.
Member Foster shared about Member David’s speech at the event at Emerald Glen
Park.
6. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 6:50 PM.
Community Task Force
DEI:
Programming/Events
Community Agency Funding & Support
April 22, 2021
Task Force Charge
Reviewing and developing recommendations on
items within the City’s purview, specifically:
•Diversity, Racial Equity, and Inclusion
–Boards and Commission Recruitment
–Inclusive, Equitable, and Accessible
Programming/Events
–Community Agency Funding and Support
–Communications
Programming/Events Overview
•Parks and Community Services Department
offers year-round programming at various
facilities and parks.
–Preschoolers (Ages: infant-4)
–Elementary (Ages: 5-12)
–Teens (Ages: 13-17)
–Adults (Ages: 18+)
–Older Adults (Ages: 55+)
Programming/Events Overview, 2
•Programming offered covers many interests including:
–Arts
–Dance
–Theatre
–Enrichment
–Leisure
–Music
–Sports
–Fitness
–Aquatics
–Senior focused
•All events and programs are advertised via the City’s quarterly Rec Guides and DublinRecGuide.com.
Contract Instructors
•Programs are offered through Contract Instructors.
–City continuously recruits for new contract instructors to provide new activities to broaden programming.
–Proposals are reviewed and selected by Parks and Community Services (PCS) Staff.
•Priority is providing safe and quality programs.
•Proposals are evaluated to ensure that the classes are well organized,affordable, and that the instructor can demonstrate they have significant knowledge/training to teach the proposed course.
•Proposals may be denied if references do not check out. May also deny proposals if there is similar programming in place.
–Example: Do not necessarily need 10 karate instructors; however, if they offer classes at different times or for different age groups, then they may be considered.
•PCS will utilize surveys to determine community interests when recruiting for new instructors.
•Contracts are issued on an annual basis.
Financial Assistance
•Programming can range in costs anywhere between tens and hundreds of dollars.
•City offers fee assistance programs for youths and seniors.
–Must apply online and meet household income limits.
–Funding is limited to $200 per applicant, up to 75% subsidy of registration.
–“Qualified applicants will be considered without regard to race, color, ancestry, religion, national origin, sex, age, disability, medical condition or marital status.”
•Applications for fee assistance are accepted on a rolling basis, and funding must be used within 12-months.
Additional Information
•Special events for the entire family are held
seasonally and with holiday themes that bring
people together.
–Holiday Tree Lighting, Splatter, St. Pats Festivities.
•Recently opened the Imagine Playground at Dublin
Sports Grounds.
–First all-abilities playground in the region.
–Equipped with picnic area, street workout equipment,
and multi-functional features designed for all abilities to
climb, swing, and balance.
Questions and Comments?
Community Agency Funding and Support
•The City supports various community agencies
through Human Services Grant Funding.
–FY 2021-22 total funding requested: $397,767.00 for
21 total grant proposals.
•Funding is awarded to organizations that best
meet community’s needs, based on:
–14 Areas of Concern—2012 Tri -Valley Needs
Assessment
–City’s Mission and Vision Statement
Areas of Concern
•Behavioral Health (Mental
Health and Substance
Abuse)
•Affordable Housing
•Health Care
•Workforce Development
•Homelessness
•Transportation Services
and Access
•Domestic Violence and
Child Abuse
•Disabilities
•Food and Nutrition
•Senior Services
•Youth Services
•Child Care, Early
Childhood Development
and Education
•Changing Demographics
and Growing Diversity
•Financial Assistance
Grant Making Process
•Grant Application Process
–Proposals outline funding request, summary of project/program, and outcome measures/KPIs.
–Funding requested is either CDBG, General Fund, or Inclusionary Housing Fund.
•CDBG has more stringent reporting requirements.
•Human Services Commission provides initial funding recommendations to the City Council.
•City Council makes final funding appropriations.
–Examples of previously funded organizations sent out with the Agenda.
Grant Tracking Process
•Grant Recipients are required to submit timely
reports, handled through a web platform.
–CDBG recipients must submit quarterly reports, per
federal guidelines.
–General Fund recipients submit biannually.
Grant Tracking Process, 2
•Data tracked includes:
–Unduplicated Dublin Residents:
•CDBG: Disabled, Women/Female Headed Households,
Seniors, Youth, Homeless
–Race/Ethnicity
–Income Levels:
•Low Income (50-80% Area Median Income)
•Very Low Income (30%-50% Area Median Income)
•Extremely Low Income (<30% Area Median Income)
Questions and Comments?
Community Task Force on Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion
Proposed Agenda Planning Calendar
Page 1 of 1
Meeting Location: Electronic Methods (Zoom Telecommunications)
Meeting Time: 5:30-7:30 p.m.
Meeting Dates: The Community Task Force will meet on the 2 nd and 4th Thursday of each
month from January to June 2021.
Date Proposed Agenda Topics (subject to change)
April 22, 2021 Overview of City DEI initiatives and data
- Programming and Events
- Community Agency Funding and Support
Discuss citywide DEI initiatives as they pertain to Boards and commissions,
programming and events, community agency funding and support, and
communications.
Review Document and Data Requests.
April 29, 2021
Special Meeting
Discuss citywide DEI initiatives.
Review CAO Comments on Police Recommendations
May 13, 2021 Cancelled. Rescheduled to 4/29/2021.
May 27, 2021 Discuss preliminary citywide recommendations.
June 10, 2021 Discuss and finalize policing and citywide recommendations and review of
draft final report, findings, and recommendations.
June 24, 2021 Discuss and finalize policing and citywide recommendations and review of
final report, findings, and recommendations.
Community Task Force Charge
The Community Task Force is charged with reviewing and developing recommendations on items
within the City’s purview, specifically the following:
• Policing
o Training Curriculum
o Policies and Procedures
o Data Transparency and Context
o Communications
o Public Engagement and Community Relations
• Diversity, Racial Equity, and Inclusion
o Boards and Commissions Recruitment
o Inclusive, Equitable, and Accessible Programming and Events
o Community Agency Funding and Support
o Communications